Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That schools should not be telling children they are born in the wrong bodies?

485 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 08:44

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-11646881/I-asked-daughters-teachers-not-call-boy-reported-social-services.html?s=08

This is so alarming now - just how many children do we think are born in the wrong bodies?

Is this not now just science fiction?

YABU - Rainbows are magic

YANBU - It's brainwashing. No child is born in the wrong body and schools must be held to account.

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 18/01/2023 11:13

So it's easy to define homosexuality because it's tangible, you are either same sex attracted or you are not.

Surely it's also easy to define what being trans is?

Especially given that laws are being written to give trans people additional rights over those who are not trans and given that being trans will lead some children to go on to harm their otherwise healthy bodies.

TeaKlaxon · 18/01/2023 11:11

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 18/01/2023 11:03

Have you never heard of social contagion in other circumstances before?

It's well known that eating disorders and issues like self-harm spread through friendship groups, why would trans be any different?

Kids follow what their friends do to stay in the group, anyone with children is aware of this.
Has your kid never done anything just because their friends do? They are suggestible and rather than the adults in the room patting them on the head and saying 'of course you're non-binary, now run along to maths', they are complicit in telling them they are the opposite sex and letting them know about puberty blockers.

Except there is zero evidence that this is what's happening.

The numbers don't support it - given what we know about the adult trans population, it follows since all trans adults were once children that a similar proportion of children are trans. So why are we shocked that more of them are realising that at a time when there is much more visibility of trans issues?

The evidence doesn't support it - given that the only study claiming this phenomenon is absolute nonsense that relies entirely on parents self-reporting that their child's gender dysphoria came out of the blue (as if parents of queer kids haven't been unaware of their children's struggles for centuries).

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 18/01/2023 11:09

TeaKlaxon · 18/01/2023 11:05

Honestly, this notion that any gay child looks at the experience of trans people and thinks 'you know what, that looks like an easier route for me' is for the birds.

How about if that gay child is uncomfortable with being gay?
Instead of being a gay boy, they can now be a straight girl.
All problems solved.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 18/01/2023 11:08

TeaKlaxon · 18/01/2023 10:52

It's almost like that is an entirely made up concept popularised by homophobes over many decades who imagined that gay people coming out at younger ages must be because of 'contagion' and now co-opted, as with so many other arguments, by transphobes.

Social contagion is well documented occurrence and nothing to do with being gay.

Like the new fads of kids claiming to have tourettes and multiple personalities and 'alters' because they've seen it on tiktok.

The constant stream of gender batshit from all angles is the problem.

You also keep avoiding the question what exactly is trans if it's not a mental health issues that requires drugs and surgery?

How can it be innate if it can only exist with drugs, surgery and constant external validation and affirmation?

SleeplessInEngland · 18/01/2023 11:08

The school shouldn't be telling them that, and going by this article it hasn't. That's lucky, eh?

Toomanywaterwipes · 18/01/2023 11:08

LemonBounce · 18/01/2023 10:53

I've read the article in detail and the substance of it does not match your alarmist claims:

  • the school is simply respecting the young person's choice it's not the school transitioning young people off their own bat
-one person at CAHMS said there was some young people with autism who were also trans there is no reference to evidence showing any link, this is anecdotal. This is the daily mail somehow if there was any evidence of a real link I think they would have splashed that on the front page! There is clearly not

It's the kind of attitudes expressed here on this board which presumably the school is trying to guard against - is it the schools role to force young people to come out to their parents - who may hold anti trans views, that could put their child at risk?
A young person comes out as trans to their parents and is told it's 'self-harm' or 'a safeguarding issue' just to be themselves?
There is a much higher rate of depression, anxiety and mental health issues for trans young people - they have a right to their identity, equal treatment and an end to discrimination. When is discrimination more damaging than from your own parents?

But should the school respect the young person's choice in this regard without contacting parents? That's the question. Should a child who is experiencing difficulties be allowed to socially transition and thus adopt a position that may be very difficult to retreat from?

You other point is incorrect. There is indeed evidence showing overlap between autism and transitioning. It's just referred to indirectly in the article.

InstaJam · 18/01/2023 11:07

LemonBounce · 18/01/2023 10:53

I've read the article in detail and the substance of it does not match your alarmist claims:

  • the school is simply respecting the young person's choice it's not the school transitioning young people off their own bat
-one person at CAHMS said there was some young people with autism who were also trans there is no reference to evidence showing any link, this is anecdotal. This is the daily mail somehow if there was any evidence of a real link I think they would have splashed that on the front page! There is clearly not

It's the kind of attitudes expressed here on this board which presumably the school is trying to guard against - is it the schools role to force young people to come out to their parents - who may hold anti trans views, that could put their child at risk?
A young person comes out as trans to their parents and is told it's 'self-harm' or 'a safeguarding issue' just to be themselves?
There is a much higher rate of depression, anxiety and mental health issues for trans young people - they have a right to their identity, equal treatment and an end to discrimination. When is discrimination more damaging than from your own parents?

one person at CAHMS said there was some young people with autism who were also trans there is no reference to evidence showing any link, this is anecdotal.

1 person at camhs. 1 person. And yet the multiple medical professionals who were whistle blowers at the Tavistock, a facility specializing in trans children, said the opposite thing.

NoWrecksToday · 18/01/2023 11:07

is it the schools role to force young people to come out to their parents - who may hold anti trans views, that could put their child at risk?

Interesting use of emotive language from Lemon and is exactly the type of attitude that undermines safeguarding.

Having open conversations in school about respecting difference is fine. Having appropriate risk assessments and action for children who might be at risk of abuse is essential.

Positive affirmations of an ideology, without understanding any of the reasons why a child is struggling, while encouraging them to keep secrets is not fine.

TeaKlaxon · 18/01/2023 11:07

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 11:05

This is of course precisely why the Daily Mail can't be trusted. What precisely do you think the process is for a child to be prescribed puberty blockers?

The actual process for obtaining puberty blockers is not relevant (although we do know that a particular online private GP was in court for prescribing them to 9 yr olds after a 20 zoom call. This company is signposted by trans charity Mermaids that is also currently under investigation although still signposted by many schools).

The issue here is that the school nurse was talking to an autistic child who understandably didn’t like the idea of puberty and suggesting to him that there were drugs he could take to stop it.

Can you not see the issue with that?

The process is massively relevant.

The article claims the child was given paperwork on'how to register' for puberty blockers.

But no one can 'register for puberty blockers'.

So either the article is lying about what the parent said, or the parent was lying to the Daily Mail.

lifeturnsonadime · 18/01/2023 11:07

Ok @TeaKlaxon you've declined to define 'Trans' , can you please define 'Trans Person' instead if that's easier?

What is a trans person?

When we are dealing with vulnerable children who may go on to make life changing and harmful decisions about their bodies it would be extremely useful to have clear definitions of terms.

TeaKlaxon · 18/01/2023 11:05

LemonBounce · 18/01/2023 10:58

Woah! There is quite a few assumptions in here. That's quite a stretch....

Honestly, this notion that any gay child looks at the experience of trans people and thinks 'you know what, that looks like an easier route for me' is for the birds.

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 11:05

This is of course precisely why the Daily Mail can't be trusted. What precisely do you think the process is for a child to be prescribed puberty blockers?

The actual process for obtaining puberty blockers is not relevant (although we do know that a particular online private GP was in court for prescribing them to 9 yr olds after a 20 zoom call. This company is signposted by trans charity Mermaids that is also currently under investigation although still signposted by many schools).

The issue here is that the school nurse was talking to an autistic child who understandably didn’t like the idea of puberty and suggesting to him that there were drugs he could take to stop it.

Can you not see the issue with that?

TeaKlaxon · 18/01/2023 11:04

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Because for some trans people, the most appropriate treatment for some of the common mental health challenges that go along side being trans for many is surgical intervention.

Of course in reality for many trans people, surgery isn't chosen or appropriate (and I've seen plenty of transphobes claiming that those trans people who don't go down the surgical route must not really be trans, and those who do are mentally ill - so trans people just can't win regardless of how they deal with being trans).

SleeplessInEngland · 18/01/2023 11:03

I knew the thread title would be bollocks.

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 18/01/2023 11:03

TeaKlaxon · 18/01/2023 10:52

It's almost like that is an entirely made up concept popularised by homophobes over many decades who imagined that gay people coming out at younger ages must be because of 'contagion' and now co-opted, as with so many other arguments, by transphobes.

Have you never heard of social contagion in other circumstances before?

It's well known that eating disorders and issues like self-harm spread through friendship groups, why would trans be any different?

Kids follow what their friends do to stay in the group, anyone with children is aware of this.
Has your kid never done anything just because their friends do? They are suggestible and rather than the adults in the room patting them on the head and saying 'of course you're non-binary, now run along to maths', they are complicit in telling them they are the opposite sex and letting them know about puberty blockers.

rockymountains · 18/01/2023 11:02

Actually think it's wrong on every level. What do kids know about this nonsense and even worse that schools/ parents try to push it it on them also. Let kids be kids! It feels like a trend nowadays & they want to jump on the bandwagon. Delusional thinking in my opinion.

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 18/01/2023 11:02

Re:Cass review. she also states that 'doing nothing' is also not a neutral action. Point 5.20 (see image)

Indeed, which is why this must be handled very delicately and with everyone informed and consulted - including parents and psychological professionals. Social transition is outside the competence of teachers to decide and it's not something schools should do in secret just on their own authority.

It is very dangerous for schools to make a default assumption that parents should not be consulted when a school changes how their child is treated in school. This secrecy fuels children's alienation from their parents and makes children vulnerable. Secrecy should be used when there may be abuse, but not a first go-to when a chld starts to question their identity.

MickeyMouseShithouse · 18/01/2023 11:01

I agree.

although I feel like I was born in the wrong body.

I should have definitely have been given a skinner, taller body than the one I have.

VickyEadieofThigh · 18/01/2023 11:00

AlisonDonut · 18/01/2023 09:06

This is how we got here. People who can't answer questions wanting the 'feminists' to chit chat about the promotion of this ideology, which results in the sterilisation of kids who are mainly gay, autistic, in care or are non conformist until it is too late.

Meanwhile kids are fed this utter baloney and taking strong drugs previously used to castrate rapists and everyone rainbow washes it in 'inclusivity'.

Correct.

In my 30-odd years of teaching, I never met a child who showed any inclination of being "trans". There were kids who knew they were, or showed signs of being, gay, however.

Trans is a monster created and spread to children by social media, and fed by organisations telling schools they 'must' adopt specific policies. It's fuelled by fear of that word 'transphobia' (which is flung out willy nilly and means the sum total of fuck all) and the cult of identity - the latter which appeals massively to kids, who have always sought 'tribes' to attach themselves to. It's entrenched by the deployment of lies and fake statistics about suicide.

It is having its worst impact on autistic kids - and the pressure not to allow talk therapy (or even to remotely challenge the notion that the kid is trans) for them is sending them down rabbit holes that can result in shockingly life-changing decisions.

LemonBounce · 18/01/2023 10:58

InstaJam · 18/01/2023 10:38

Potentially that child could be saying they are trans precisely because their parents are homophobic and changing their gender seems an easier way out than accepting that they are gay. So simply because they are gay you want to be complicit in removing their body parts and subjecting them to a life of dependency on drugs amd medical procedures. I think that's a very concerning position for you to be taking.

Woah! There is quite a few assumptions in here. That's quite a stretch....

TeaKlaxon · 18/01/2023 10:58

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 10:14

Maybe you could actually read the article and consider testimonies from parents like this:

But when a nurse at school had a chat with Harry about puberty, he came skipping home through the door with paperwork about how to register for puberty blockers. I was shocked. He was only 14.

Please ask yourself why it is appropriate for the school to give this child information that bypasses any psychological evaluation or actual diagnosis of gender dysphoria and jumps straight to medication as a solution for his distress?

Most children experiencing distress with puberty or their identity will settle down once the huge brain development that occurs has kicked in. Encouraging a child to jump straight to a self diagnosis of trans and need for heavy lifelong medication is extremely harmful.

Let's unpack this 'paperwork about registering for puberty blockers' claim.

This is of course precisely why the Daily Mail can't be trusted. What precisely do you think the process is for a child to be prescribed puberty blockers?

What percentage of children do you think are prescribed them and just how easy do you think it is for them to access them?

TheKeatingFive · 18/01/2023 10:56

one person at CAHMS said there was some young people with autism who were also trans there is no reference to evidence showing any link, this is anecdotal

This did not take me very long to find.

www.spectrumnews.org/news/largest-study-to-date-confirms-overlap-between-autism-and-gender-diversity/

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 18/01/2023 10:56

LemonBounce · 18/01/2023 10:53

I've read the article in detail and the substance of it does not match your alarmist claims:

  • the school is simply respecting the young person's choice it's not the school transitioning young people off their own bat
-one person at CAHMS said there was some young people with autism who were also trans there is no reference to evidence showing any link, this is anecdotal. This is the daily mail somehow if there was any evidence of a real link I think they would have splashed that on the front page! There is clearly not

It's the kind of attitudes expressed here on this board which presumably the school is trying to guard against - is it the schools role to force young people to come out to their parents - who may hold anti trans views, that could put their child at risk?
A young person comes out as trans to their parents and is told it's 'self-harm' or 'a safeguarding issue' just to be themselves?
There is a much higher rate of depression, anxiety and mental health issues for trans young people - they have a right to their identity, equal treatment and an end to discrimination. When is discrimination more damaging than from your own parents?

Well, I completely disagree with you but let's go with it.

I imagine you believe that kids who believe they are trans also have a high suicide rate, do you think parents should know about this? Or is this OK to be kept secret? Can you see any problems with this?

lifeturnsonadime · 18/01/2023 10:55

Another parent of an autistic daughter here. She doesn't conform to gendered expectations of how girls should look and what they should wear because of sensory issues associated with autism. She doesn't communicated in ways that are normally expected of girls because she has a social communication disorder.

She has been asked if she's really trans or a boy by many people including CAMHS.

Luckily for me she hasn't fallen for this gender religion and she is comfortable that being a girl isn't a set of stereotypes.

But other autistic girls are being led down this path.

This is from a support group for autistic children on social media, this was posted yesterday -

I’m looking for advice from parents that have a young child who is transgender, 9 years old around that mark please 🙂 (our now boy was born with female parts)
This is very new to us in the sense of not having dealt / helped with this before however it is not new to us that he is clearly a boy! That has been obvious since he was born!

How is it clear to anyone that a girl is a boy?

It's just nonsense. This girl will end up sterilised for the 'be kind' brigade.

PoIIyPandemonium · 18/01/2023 10:53

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.