Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That schools should not be telling children they are born in the wrong bodies?

485 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 08:44

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-11646881/I-asked-daughters-teachers-not-call-boy-reported-social-services.html?s=08

This is so alarming now - just how many children do we think are born in the wrong bodies?

Is this not now just science fiction?

YABU - Rainbows are magic

YANBU - It's brainwashing. No child is born in the wrong body and schools must be held to account.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
whereaw · 20/01/2023 11:39

I feel so sad about all this..

I remember being a kid at school and being told (and truly believing) that people are people are people. To just be yourself and love and accept people for who they are. I don't remember feeling like I had to be a certain way, to define myself, or others. The word was open and full of possibilities. I didn't have to think or consider if I was a girl, I simply was one. I went about my life, and learnt like all the other boys and girls. We knew we were boys and girls but in the same way that we know gravity keeps us on the ground. We didn't have to constantly consider it. It just was. It didn't really matter either way.

Now everything is so hard. So many boxes. So many questions.

Why can't we just accept our biology and do whatever the hell we want to do? Why does me refusing to deny reality impact how someone wants to live? Wear a dress, a wig, cut your hair, call yourself whatever you like.

Why is it that race, which is less definite or 'real' than sex, so all encompassing and not to be argued with, but sex suddenly so abstract or meaningless that I can be one, or the other, or none?

There are real safety reasons that sex matters.

Why should I need to shower or change beside a person with a penis so that they can feel like a real woman? I want to be only around biological females in intimate spaces because a biological female cannot rape me. That. is. it.

If I feel nervous when a man is walking close behind me late at night it is because there is a possibility he might attack or rape me. He probably won't. He's probably rushing home to see his wife. It isn't personal. I don't know him. I just know it is a possibility. That's all.

Children are children, just let them be children and stop sexualising them, stop grooming them.... just stop.

If you think you're being kind, you're not.

2023bebetter · 20/01/2023 11:04

It's incredibly scary when DC are so vulnerable and their bodies go through monumental changes. It's hard enough to cope with without adding this on top.

When they are 18 they are in a far better position to understand and decide how they truly feel.

I can't believe our vulnerable DC are being exposed and school a place of safety is allowing this.

WandaWomblesaurus · 20/01/2023 10:44

www.pressandjournal.co.uk/fp/politics/scottish-politics/5283763/gender-recognition-maggie-chapman/

Maggie Chapman wants 8 year olds to explore their gender.

I want Maggie Chapman to be kept away from children.

OP posts:
WandaWomblesaurus · 20/01/2023 09:58

www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/snp-handed-millions-lobbyist-who-28996720.amp

And the SNP had handed millions to them all to push through gender self ID - despite no one being able to define what gender identity means.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 20/01/2023 09:01

Teachers are being advised by lobby groups - they are acting way out of their remit.

Lobby groups that themselves have no medical expertise and a terrifying approach to safeguarding.

We're just handing the reins over to bunch of know nothing ideologues. How the actual fuck did we end up here?

WandaWomblesaurus · 20/01/2023 08:58

Teachers are being advised by lobby groups - they are acting way out of their remit. At my daughters school one of the teachers has big trans flags behind her desk and has been socially transitioning children without their parents permission. One of the children has been telling the other girls how transphobic her parents are. They are just normal people.

This girl has issues with her own hygiene, she's on the spectrum and can barely look after herself in practical ways. We personally know four or five other girls who are similar to this, not able to look after themselves well enough to deal with their own periods, yet pushing to go on puberty blockers and fantasising about having mastectomies.

These girls will not be able to cope with their own self care if they end up having life changing surgery that will have a high degree of post body trauma and medical attention needed. These girls are who Maggie Chapman, Nicola Sturgeon, Patrick Harvie, Emma Watson and all the trans activist gender zealots are sacrificing in the name of gender identity - which they cannot even provide a definition for.

These girls are going to be lifelong casualties of a war on children's bodies.

OP posts:
OP posts:
StephanieSuperpowers · 19/01/2023 19:05

I suppose I was thinking of the example upthread of the woman upthread who sounded like she had made her trans child into her identity and cause, and had bullied everyone she knew into compliance. How can a child withdraw from that?

My own child isn't a teen yet so I'll confess I haven't faced the reality that she will try to pull away and push me away later on!

NettleTea · 19/01/2023 19:03

StephanieSuperpowers · 19/01/2023 09:58

One thing that confuses me about the zealots is that they position this as so important that it must be acted on immediately or very serious consequences (even suicide) are likely, but also so trivial that it doesn't warrant any investigation.

ahh, the old suicide stats.

Those would be the ones that every trans campaigner, and every trans activist trots out. Despite the fact that suicide is NEVER supposed to be used as a campagning tool

What they dont 'trot out' are that those stats were taken from a self referring group of LGBT people with mental health problems. And of the 2000 people who filled in the survey, only 27 were trans (and not all of those were young) and I believe the 'nearly half' of those tiny number said, yes, they had thought about suicide

Transgender trend did a breakdown. (and Stephanie has British Empire medal for her work) www.transgendertrend.com/?s=suicide+statistics

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 19/01/2023 18:44

I do believe there's a lot to be said for gentle guidance, gentle interest, being available to explore at their pace and having absolute limits.

Ideally yes @StephanieSuperpowers ... but "explore at their own pace" is not easy if boys do the common teen boy thing - radio silence followed by "right mum now I want hormones". Shock and panic don't go with gentle interest and exploration.

How often do we mums really get to be the lovely adults gently guiding our teens? Family life with teens can be a battle. What I resent is people with agendas handing our kids weapons so our families can be their battleground.

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 19/01/2023 16:45

I encouraged them to challenge stereotypes and did so with toys and clothes I bought.

@Ofcourseshecan I don't think that does any harm. Challenge the stereotypes but reassure them they're still the same sex - a boy who wears pink, a girl who plays football, whatever. As long as you don't tell them it could mean they're a different gender, or sex.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 19/01/2023 16:42

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 19/01/2023 10:34

Back in the summer I watched one of the committee meetings about the Scottish Gender Recognition Reform ask whether worries about promoting trans identities to young people were not just another Section 28 (a shameful local goverment bill against "promoting" homosexuality in schools in the 1980s). The answer they got didn't hit the spot for me and I've been thinking about it ever since. Here is my answer:

Sexual orientation is very hard to influence. Who you fancy is who you fancy. What turns you in is what turns you on. if you're ashameed of your sexual orientation, if you try to hide it or change it, if other people tell you its uncool, if you believe its boring or shameful or scary - who you fancy is still who you fancy. At most society can change whether young people dare to admit it to themseves or to others, whether they want to explore or experiment, and whether they dare to act on their feelings. Society can't change what sex they feel attracted to.

But gender identity is a lot about body image. And young people's body image is very very influencable. Sure, there are always going to be a few people who are sure their body is "wrong" no matter what, and some people who are very happy in their body as it is. But the rest of us, we take what we get but we don't feel perfect. We're get embarrassed aboout our bodies, we compare ourselves to others and to ideals, and we want to improve. And if we keep picking up messages telling us, oh look how much bettter I'd feel about my body if I was slimmer, or had bigger boobs, or smaller boobs, or fuller lips, or was more athletic, or if I was the opposite sex...

And sure, some changes can make us happier and healthier. But then there's all the anorexics and the bulimics and over-exercisers and the serial cosmetic surgery candidates. The minority who do more and more and more, and are no happier, and end up harming themselves. It's only too easy for young people to believe that if only they had a different body they would be happy, and to talk themselves into, or be talked into, all sorts of dysphorias including gender dysphoria.

The Scottish govt has decided to validate one type of body image problem with a certificate for 16 year olds, one that declares "I know I would be happier as the other sex, forever". And the government agrees with me, says that's fine, just on my own say-so, no need for a professional to question whether I could be just as happy in some other less physically harmful way. What does that do to unhappy young people?

(And other bits of gender identity that aren't about body image are about social image - and that's obviously influencable too.)

I don't think that promoting dysphoria or physical transition in young people is what the Scottish govt intended. No-one who has a GRC is forced to have hormones or surgery. For a few people, especially older people who have considered and rejected these already, the GRC has no such effect, maybe even the opposite. But can we believe this validation wont affect very many vulnerable young people in this way?

Maybe the old rhetoric about Section 28 sounds the same as some of the rhetoric against promoting transition. Well, the rhetoric may be the same but the facts are different. So let's pay attention to the facts and not the rhetoric!

This is such a wise post that bears repeating. Thank you MumOfYoungTransAdult

Ofcourseshecan · 19/01/2023 16:35

Velvian · 18/01/2023 09:15

YANBU, it is scary to be a parent of a child that does 100% conform to gender stereotypes. When my DC were toddlers I encouraged them to challenge stereotypes and did so with toys and clothes I bought.

I had no idea at the time, the physical danger I was putting them in. I honestly think I would do things differently, had I known.

I strongly believe that gender stereotypes should be challenged, but I don't believe that it is safe to do so currently.

Velvian, I understand you and I sympathise. But what a terrifying state we’ve come to.

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 19/01/2023 16:06

And - to return to the article - schools are putting children on this pathway when a child says so, and moving them along it when a child says so too.

Closely related for people who don't like the DM, there is this in the Times from September - sorry I can't give a proper share token. It mainly summarises the content of a video made by a Scottish state school, shown at the Scottish Learning Festival and to be promoted to other schools.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/teachers-face-significant-challenges-to-avoid-outing-trans-pupils-to-their-parents-2fwhwrnpx

StephanieSuperpowers · 19/01/2023 16:00

Young people do move off the pathway, or stop where they are. Some. We just don't know how many, or who, or how.

I think, with everything, it's so important to give young people an easy way out without losing too much face. And that's why it's so important for parents and schools to not become overly invested in supporting young people in case they start to feel backed into a corner, like they may let people down or disappoint them if they don't want any of it anymore. Obviously, excessive opposition can have the same effect but I do believe there's a lot to be said for gentle guidance, gentle interest, being available to explore at their pace and having absolute limits. Not just for this issue either.

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 19/01/2023 15:41

it doesn’t seem like any one really spent the time to talk him through things.

Was he amenable to being talked through things? He seemed to treat every obstacle as another challenge, which is quite admirable in a way!

But too many of those who are willing to talk get affirmed - you're trans, you need to try this.

And on a more normal everyday scale, as a parent, it's easy to go along with it - oh it's only clothes, only pronouns, only a name, and then it's only hormones(!)..... and of course there's no point terrifying ourselves. Young people do move off the pathway, or stop where they are. Some. We just don't know how many, or who, or how.

Helleofabore · 19/01/2023 15:21

Yes. That is the issue. The stages he went through. He didn’t set out to have that much surgery. That he was trans was not even on his radar until recently according to him.

It was part of his need to change his body.

It is this way we are letting our young people down. He is certainly not a teenager, but it doesn’t seem like any one really spent the time to talk him through things.

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 19/01/2023 14:46

Oli London is interesting but very extreme, yes he did the Korean thing. I don't suppose he could have been stopped by anyone but himself! It's hard to relate to such an extreme.

One thing that does resonate with me is the repeated, step by step nature of what he did. It's not, first I decicde my end goal for my transition, then I decide all the steps I'll need to get there, one by one, then I figure out if they are worth it, and only then I do them all, one by one. It's much more "first i'll try this, how do I feel, then i'll try that, how do i feel..." and rinse and repeat. And every step you are further away from a normal healthy functioning body of either sex, and every small step makes it physically harder to go back to the start.

And you might take a lot of steps and not realise that the starting point was better than where you are now, and better than anywhere you can get to from where you are now, until you can't get back there.

One of the most scary things about the regret/detrans stories is when it takes the shock of surgery to make a young person realise it was all a "mistake". Sad

RichardBarrister · 19/01/2023 13:32

I've watched a lot of his stuff and he honestly is a very scary individual. And that has nothing to do with his trans status or his clothes or his make-up. His words are worrying.

He is terrifying. Encouraging children to communicate online with him, promising to be their ‘family’ if their parents aren’t immediately fully on board with a child’s self diagnosis of trans with all the life changing consequences that entails.

He calls himself their ‘auncle’ as he is ‘non binary’ and I think in the past has said he uses womens spaces and says that we can’t stop him.

He has also been paid to sell us tampons along with Dylan Mulvaney.

Boiledbeetle · 19/01/2023 13:16

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 19:29

Who needs parents when influencers like Jeffrey Marsh are your child's new glitter family?

I was determined to read all the parts before saying something. Then I got to the Jeffrey Marsh videos.

No parent in any other situation would let their child any where near this man. So why does he get a pass under the trans umbrella?

He is a very strange individual and if his videos were about anything else parents would be as aghast at his videos as they are of Andrew Tates.

I've watched a lot of his stuff and he honestly is a very scary individual. And that has nothing to do with his trans status or his clothes or his make-up. His words are worrying.

lifeturnsonadime · 19/01/2023 11:12

Oli London is a very very interesting character. Wasn't he claiming to be trans - Korean at one point, which is what led to the facial surgery?

TheKeatingFive · 19/01/2023 11:05

This is a really interesting read on the topic

ceriblack.substack.com/p/guest-post

Helleofabore · 19/01/2023 10:51

”But then there's all the anorexics and the bulimics and over-exercisers and the serial cosmetic surgery candidates. The minority who do more and more and more, and are no happier, and end up harming themselves. It's only too easy for young people to believe that if only they had a different body they would be happy,”

Yes. This.

This is an interview with Oli London who is very open about his addiction to cosmetic surgery and his identity issues. He is actually quite brave to do this interview and it is worth listening.

He was also about to undergo genital surgery as well when he stopped and thought some more.

Helleofabore · 19/01/2023 10:39

whereaw · 19/01/2023 09:51

I haven't done enough research (yet) but for some time now the thing that has worried me more than anything is the increasing acceptance and increasing ubiquity of pornography in society, and the untold damage that is doing to society and people (changing the way we think feel, experience pain and pleasure and understand who we are... the list goes on)... I am starting to think that the two things are not unrelated

It is not unrelated at all.

If you start looking at queer theory and where it seeks to destabilise society including language, you will find some of the reasons for your thinking there.

There was a thread here this week about two males walking through the IKEA restaurant in their dog gimp masks. (Pup play for those who don’t know) and the number of people who were unconcerned about being part of these two male’s sexual fetish and children included too was concerning.

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 19/01/2023 10:34

Back in the summer I watched one of the committee meetings about the Scottish Gender Recognition Reform ask whether worries about promoting trans identities to young people were not just another Section 28 (a shameful local goverment bill against "promoting" homosexuality in schools in the 1980s). The answer they got didn't hit the spot for me and I've been thinking about it ever since. Here is my answer:

Sexual orientation is very hard to influence. Who you fancy is who you fancy. What turns you in is what turns you on. if you're ashameed of your sexual orientation, if you try to hide it or change it, if other people tell you its uncool, if you believe its boring or shameful or scary - who you fancy is still who you fancy. At most society can change whether young people dare to admit it to themseves or to others, whether they want to explore or experiment, and whether they dare to act on their feelings. Society can't change what sex they feel attracted to.

But gender identity is a lot about body image. And young people's body image is very very influencable. Sure, there are always going to be a few people who are sure their body is "wrong" no matter what, and some people who are very happy in their body as it is. But the rest of us, we take what we get but we don't feel perfect. We're get embarrassed aboout our bodies, we compare ourselves to others and to ideals, and we want to improve. And if we keep picking up messages telling us, oh look how much bettter I'd feel about my body if I was slimmer, or had bigger boobs, or smaller boobs, or fuller lips, or was more athletic, or if I was the opposite sex...

And sure, some changes can make us happier and healthier. But then there's all the anorexics and the bulimics and over-exercisers and the serial cosmetic surgery candidates. The minority who do more and more and more, and are no happier, and end up harming themselves. It's only too easy for young people to believe that if only they had a different body they would be happy, and to talk themselves into, or be talked into, all sorts of dysphorias including gender dysphoria.

The Scottish govt has decided to validate one type of body image problem with a certificate for 16 year olds, one that declares "I know I would be happier as the other sex, forever". And the government agrees with me, says that's fine, just on my own say-so, no need for a professional to question whether I could be just as happy in some other less physically harmful way. What does that do to unhappy young people?

(And other bits of gender identity that aren't about body image are about social image - and that's obviously influencable too.)

I don't think that promoting dysphoria or physical transition in young people is what the Scottish govt intended. No-one who has a GRC is forced to have hormones or surgery. For a few people, especially older people who have considered and rejected these already, the GRC has no such effect, maybe even the opposite. But can we believe this validation wont affect very many vulnerable young people in this way?

Maybe the old rhetoric about Section 28 sounds the same as some of the rhetoric against promoting transition. Well, the rhetoric may be the same but the facts are different. So let's pay attention to the facts and not the rhetoric!

Swipe left for the next trending thread