Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lying on a dating profile.

62 replies

TheCatIsOnMyFoot · 18/01/2023 00:43

So I've read a few threads recently about how people have lied about there on line dating profiles. It's got me thinking, one of the most recent threads was about a guy who lied about having a child. The overall consensus was that he was wrong and lied. I agree.

Therefore, would i be unreasonable not to tell a date/someone ive dated for 6 months that I have a significant disability (mentioned in the equalities act) that they might not currently see, but could mean in a years time could mean I can not see/hear/walk/swallow.

What do you think?

OP posts:
BelleMarionette · 18/01/2023 08:47

Is this a hypothetical, or have you dated someone for 6 months without telling them?

If you are looking for a long term relationship, you need to be upfront and honest. After all, you wouldn't want to waste time on someone who wouldn't be happy staying if you had worsening symptoms. It's not fair on them either.

Lialou · 18/01/2023 08:33

I dont think you need to declare it on your profile, but you need to tell him. Its both of your decision how invested you want to be, with transparency.

Titoti · 18/01/2023 08:24

That diagnosis must have been really tough, I'm sorry you're going through this.

No, I don't think it needs to be on your profile. But I think talking about it early on can only be a positive, say date 3 or 4. To not say anything for 6 months would be terrible.

ClangingBell · 18/01/2023 08:17

6 months in I think your partner should know all really significant pieces of information about you. That includes any significant medical information that might affect them (and yes I would absolutely include depression and anxiety in that). Six months is really the stage where you’re deciding whether it’s a long term thing or not and people need full information to do that. If he decides he doesn’t want to deal with it, then you don’t want both of you to have wasted a load of time on a relationship that was never going to last.

If you’ve been dating seriously though, I wouldn’t be surprised if even someone who would be fine with the MS had massive doubts about you because of not having told them earlier. That would bother me quite a lot.

Hankunamatata · 18/01/2023 08:07

6 months in you have to tell him.

I think you are in an incredibly difficult position. However you want to find a person who is going to stick with you and see you for you. If telling them about your MS scares them away then they are not the person for you.

SnowyPetals · 18/01/2023 07:43

OLD is really just a way of meeting people. It's a shame that because it's computerised, it's become more like shopping than meeting people, and a way of "saving time" by being able to rule out people who don't match your criteria. Things like health conditions to me should be discussed once you have initially met, as otherwise people's profiles would turn into massive laundry lists of features and attitudes.

Avastmehearties · 18/01/2023 07:13

Sorry about your diagnosis, it is all a lot to come to terms with.

I don't agree that health conditions need disclosing online although i believe that they should be brought up early. Well before real feelings have had the chance to develop.

I have a neuro condition too, and if that put someone off, I would much rather know that early about them, as well as not put them in the position of having already developed feelings, or even having to be the bad guy if it does put them off. If it was on an early date then they could just bow out gracefully but after this long it would be 'that's my previous boyfriend over there. He dumped me after 6 months for having (whatever condition)'.

I'm sorry to say it but i think that omitting or massively minimising anything that has or could have a huge impact on your lives together is quite manipulative. Better to give people a clear picture and let them decide for themselves.

I wish you the best but think you should let your partner know if you're serious about them long term.

Planesmistakenforstars · 18/01/2023 06:56

I don't think you should have to share private health information on your dating profile. I think it's something to bring up face to face on a first or second date. It gives them a chance to get to know you a little better as a person and make an informed choice about whether they want to take things further with you, and gives them a chance to ask questions about something which might be an intimidating issue, but at the same time no one is getting too invested at that point.

LlynTegid · 18/01/2023 06:47

I wonder if dating websites will come within the scope of the legislation on social media? So that someone saying they have no children when they have one or more, the onus being on the dating website to act, perhaps by removing them from the site?

In the OPs case, no don't lie. Don't stoop down to other people's level.

menareallthesame · 18/01/2023 06:41

I also have it and it is a bit of a dilemma. I don’t tell people before I meet them but do make sure I’ve told them within the first couple of dates. I’m a gym fanatic so I don’t want it to define me and kind of want them to see at the moment I’m totally fine. No one has been out off.

BensonStabler · 18/01/2023 06:07

Great advice from @Bbdm1984 and a wonderful example of how it can work out.

Sorry to hear of you having MS too. It is heartwarming to hear that he stood by you through one of your toughest relapses, and come out the other side stronger and happier, then even nicer to hear of your pregnancy and love still growing 🥰 Congratulations and best of luck.

Here is hoping OP that your bf will be understanding and in it for the long run too.

Zanatdy · 18/01/2023 05:51

Re previous message I don’t think it needs to be on your profile, but maybe by date 3 or 4, if it seems like it’s getting to be exclusive etc I’d let them know. I didn’t mention my illness to my new bf but I was aware he might know we used to work in the same area. When I did mention it (date 4) he already knew, and it wasn’t a big deal. I’ve not gone into detail about it apart from giving a bit of history, largely to explain big scar across my stomach. He isn’t bothered but then I guess none of us know what the future holds, but if someone’s got a diagnosed illness they should let someone know before it’s too serious

BensonStabler · 18/01/2023 05:50

Is your diagnosis fairly recent op?

It sounds like you may still, understandably, be coming to terms with this condition and it’s effects on you and in the future.

I was diagnosed with a similar serious condition, it took me at least a year to accept it, (and by accepting I mean just not breaking down with the fear and unfairness of it all - every moment of every day!) but even then, not totally, I have had many years of good times and bad times coping and not coping with the emotional effects, the fears, the what if’s, and letting go of all your dreams you had up until then about what your life and future could be. As I am sure you will know you have to go through a grieving process.

I agree about speaking honestly to them when you feel that you and your dating partner are getting to be in a more emotional and committed direction, but only so much so that you know that you both aren’t just looking for a casual fling. So that they have a choice, but feelings aren’t too far gone, and so he’s not tricked or manipulated, and then in a position of feeling too attached or guilty to walk away.

There’s no need to say to casual shorter term flings at this moment in time.

I was already in a relationship 12 years by the time I was diagnosed, and even still, over and over again I kept offering my partner a guilt free “out” so he could truly think about wether he wanted to choose to share the burdens and care of all the tough things that come with it. Let me clarify that and say that I mean the situation and the problems are the burden part. Not you, nor anyone else with a serious life limiting illness who didn’t ask for or deserve this. The upside is at this point almost ten years later from diagnosis, is that I am no where near as bad at this point in time than I thought I would be, I am losing more of myself each year, but still hanging on and making the absolute most of my time and relationships.

I hope that you tell your bf now that you have had your eyes open to his feelings and choices in all of this, at 6 months it’s not fair. I do however understand the emotional inner turmoil and perhaps burying your head in the sand to avoid dealing with it. That’s not to say it’s right though. Good luck, and I hope you find someone who will love, accept and take on you in the totality you and of your condition.

Zanatdy · 18/01/2023 05:45

Massively unreasonable to hide. You say they could just walk away but that’s not as easy when you’re in love with someone. You owe it to them to inform them of something so significant

Bbdm1984 · 18/01/2023 05:19

I met my fiance through online dating 5 years ago, I also have MS. I did not put this in my dating profile at the time however when I got talking to fiance told him very early on before we met in person so that he had the choice, I told him it may not ever affect me physically badly but the pssibility is always there. Turns out 2 years into our relationship i had a massive relapse and could not walk for 3 months, he was my rock. We are now 6 months pregnant and i love him more everyday. Rip the plaster early is my advice

JudgeRudy · 18/01/2023 04:54

AlwaysAReason · 18/01/2023 01:15

I don't think anything health wise needs to be discussed on profiles etc. I do think it would need to be discussed face to face is the relationship is becoming more than a casual relationship.

I agree, if we had to 'disclose' everything on our profiles they would be soooooo long. I'd also expect conditions such as depression to come up early on.

JudgeRudy · 18/01/2023 04:48

MintJulia · 18/01/2023 00:54

OP, it isn't about whether you are happy for them to walk away. By then they may be emotionally attached, and it isn't fair to put them in that position.

Tell them upfront.

This!

JudgeRudy · 18/01/2023 04:45

What? You've been dating SIX months and not told him this massive piece of information. Have you actually done this?Yes you're being very unreasonable and this level of deception would be a bigger red flag than your condition. I'd dump you.
Whilst I can imagine several reasons why you would want to do this, this is yours to bare and its just wrong to trick someone. Does he love you? Do you plan on telling him anytime soon? I just can't getvmy head round how you could possibly think this is acceptable.

Anotherparkingthread · 18/01/2023 02:16

I think it's unreasonable for a few reasons...

Obviously private medical information shouldn't be put on a dating profile, that would be ridiculous. I think it should be brought up early in to the dating process though. Certainly before 6 months imo. I'd expect it to be mentioned even if not discussed at length by the the 5th date or so, enough to trust them and decide its worth telling them but not at the point where we were so involved it may be very hard to find out or change how they feel. Any later feels like a rug pull.

I would be hesitant to build plans for a secure financial future with somebody who may be unable to work at some point. As shallow as this sounds I would want to be able to consider it.

I would want to do my own research into the condition before I could decide if I could commit or become more emotionally involved as I am nota naturally caring or nurturing person and I don't know if I'd want to end up a carer.

If the condition could be passed on to potential children (assuming nothing parties want that and it's an option) then it would be highly irresponsible to proceed without letting them make the judgement on that.

I'd want to find out before walking away
would break my heart. Telling somebody only after they have fallen in love is bordering on emotional manipulation, it could make it very hard for somebody to leave. It would feel deceitful to me. I wouldn't leave my partner if they became disabled but hiding it would be wrong. It removes the choice and their ability to read the information and consent to the risk.

If its just a casual fling I wouldn't bother saying a word. If it staryed as just that but became more serious you should hopefully know when it's time to say something.

TheCatIsOnMyFoot · 18/01/2023 01:46

Notatallanamechange · 18/01/2023 01:31

I assumed you were talking about MND or something similar. I’m on the fence with MS. Generally life expectancy isn’t drastically cut with it, the symptoms you listed are the ‘worst case’scenario, sorry I honestly don’t know how to put that better. Basically I mean it’s a managed condition and I can see why you might have wanted to withhold your diagnosis until you feel ready to share it.

That's the thing though. Who knows what will happen. Less serious, pretty much nothing. Serious, no speech, mobility, bodily function.

End of the day. The 'serious' could happen to anyone is a serious car accident tomorrow.

OP posts:
Christmaspyjamas · 18/01/2023 01:36

TheCatIsOnMyFoot · 18/01/2023 01:12

I don't want a short term relationship.

Sorry. My general point was that you could allude to your health and future possibilities without going into detail.

Notatallanamechange · 18/01/2023 01:31

I assumed you were talking about MND or something similar. I’m on the fence with MS. Generally life expectancy isn’t drastically cut with it, the symptoms you listed are the ‘worst case’scenario, sorry I honestly don’t know how to put that better. Basically I mean it’s a managed condition and I can see why you might have wanted to withhold your diagnosis until you feel ready to share it.

AlwaysAReason · 18/01/2023 01:15

I don't think anything health wise needs to be discussed on profiles etc. I do think it would need to be discussed face to face is the relationship is becoming more than a casual relationship.

TheCatIsOnMyFoot · 18/01/2023 01:14

WeAreAllLionesses · 18/01/2023 01:11

could mean in a years time could mean I can not see/hear/walk/swallow

Forgive the bluntness, is it definitely going to happen but you don't know when?

It's Multiple Sclerosis ~ so who knows. Currently I'm working full time. No massive impact on my life. Potential had it for 18 years though it can't be pinpointed.

OP posts:
TheCatIsOnMyFoot · 18/01/2023 01:12

Christmaspyjamas · 18/01/2023 00:52

I think on your profile you could say something like "looking for a short term relationship as I have health conditions that don't trouble me greatly now but mean I like to live in the moment" then go into more details on an early date.

Sorry if I have not accurately written about how you feel but I was just trying to give an example of how you could address it honestly but without giving away personal information that could attract negative and hurtful responses.

I don't want a short term relationship.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread