Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lying on a dating profile.

62 replies

TheCatIsOnMyFoot · 18/01/2023 00:43

So I've read a few threads recently about how people have lied about there on line dating profiles. It's got me thinking, one of the most recent threads was about a guy who lied about having a child. The overall consensus was that he was wrong and lied. I agree.

Therefore, would i be unreasonable not to tell a date/someone ive dated for 6 months that I have a significant disability (mentioned in the equalities act) that they might not currently see, but could mean in a years time could mean I can not see/hear/walk/swallow.

What do you think?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cronkywonkycrinkywinky · 18/01/2023 20:30

I would dump you immediately if you waited six months to tell me this.

10HailMarys · 18/01/2023 16:00

Thanks. But what if that disability might not happen? What if the disability did happen and the disabled person was okay if the other person walked away ?

As you say, your MS might never get to the point where you're severely disabled - but if you don't want a short-term relationship, you need to be upfront with people about the condition and explain that there's a chance it could have a bigger impact on your life one day, even though it's only a possibility and not a certainty.

If someone says on your first date 'Sorry, I don't want to risk dating someone who might one day need me to be their carer' when you tell them you have MS, then you've lost nothing except an evening of your time. But if you were to get that same reaction from someone upon telling them you have MS after you'd been together for months and were planning a future with them, you've lost the love of your life.

Generally speaking, it's better to be upfront about the big stuff from the start if you're looking for something long-term - which you say you are. And this is in the 'big stuff' category.

WisherWood · 18/01/2023 15:14

MaryMcCarthy · 18/01/2023 14:33

have been accused of any sexual offences

So it's the accusation that's important to you? How come?

Look up Ian Huntley, the Soham murders and the Bichard inquiry. Accusations alone can be important.

TheCatIsOnMyFoot · 18/01/2023 15:05

StrawberryAnnie · 18/01/2023 14:41

I don’t see any dishonesty in the OP?

It’s explained that a thread about dating profiles got her thinking. She was then wondering if it would be unreasonable to wait 6mths before discussing her diagnosis.

OP since confirmed and clarified this is a hypothetical situation.

Perhaps you could be a little less defensive. You have misunderstood the intention of the post.

I know this is AIBU, but there is no need to throw accusations around when someone is seeking perspectives about how to approach a very personal matter.

Thank you. I wasn't being dishonest. This poster explained my reasoning perfectly.

OP posts:
LaLuz7 · 18/01/2023 14:45

MaryMcCarthy · 18/01/2023 14:33

have been accused of any sexual offences

So it's the accusation that's important to you? How come?

Don't be obtuse. Given the tiny tiny percentage of rapes and sexual offenses which end up with a conviction, it's smart to treat any accusation/investigation as a huge red flag.

The number of men who commited the act but were not convincted due to lack of evidence/the victim not reporting is significantly larger than the number of men who were falsely accused.

StrawberryAnnie · 18/01/2023 14:41

DismantledKing · 18/01/2023 13:58

Perhaps you should have been more honest in your OP?

I don’t see any dishonesty in the OP?

It’s explained that a thread about dating profiles got her thinking. She was then wondering if it would be unreasonable to wait 6mths before discussing her diagnosis.

OP since confirmed and clarified this is a hypothetical situation.

Perhaps you could be a little less defensive. You have misunderstood the intention of the post.

I know this is AIBU, but there is no need to throw accusations around when someone is seeking perspectives about how to approach a very personal matter.

FunnyWorldWeLiveIn · 18/01/2023 14:33

This you must disclose

MaryMcCarthy · 18/01/2023 14:33

have been accused of any sexual offences

So it's the accusation that's important to you? How come?

LimeTwists · 18/01/2023 14:32

I think there are number of significant potential factors that you need to make the people you are dating aware of fairly quickly - ie within a few months or so. Otherwise, you are either going to find yourself lying, being deliberately evasive to avoid the topic coming up, or letting someone get emotionally involved with you when you know something could well be a deal breaker.

My personal list of things I want to know would sooner rather than later is: known infertility, the existence of a child, been married before, have a chronic or terminal illness, carry a gene for a significant health condition, have been in prison or have a criminal record, have been accused of any sexual offences.

Not all are deal breakers - particularly health issues, being divorced or already having children - but I’d want to be able to a least consider the impact on our future relationship. Hiding any of these things would make me wonder what else they’d lie about so I wouldn’t trust them if I suddenly found out any of these things six months in.

MaryMcCarthy · 18/01/2023 14:32

I think you know fine well that you've been unreasonable.

This isn't about lying on a dating profile, it's about lying to someone you're dating. Did you expect people on here would defend you?

Reugny · 18/01/2023 14:31

My DP has a disability. He told me on the first date. It didn't freak me out.

I've dated other guys with different disabilities. Some of them would have had a major impact on my lifestyle later on as I know other people with the disability, and so after one/two dates I took it no further.

Oysterbabe · 18/01/2023 14:28

Yabu.
I agree, not on profile but disclosed early.
I went on a date with someone who it transpired had a serious and progressive condition that would kill him in the next 10 years. He should have told me before the date. I was clear that marriage and kids is what I wanted. He was a lovely guy, but not a suitable match for me.

EBearhug · 18/01/2023 14:27

I would not put it in my profile. I would mention it early on.

I had a first date at the weekend. He is partially sighted. His profile does not say so. He said he mentioned it when chatting to one woman he matched, and she just blocked him. But if that's how someone reacts, would you want to be with them anyway?

I needed to know, because it means he can't drive, and that affects where we can meet. If we end up together, it means I accept I will be the only driver. I don't know the long term prognosis; it was the result of an accident. He could end up with much less sight than he has now. But I could also find out he's a complete bastard, it's too soon to know how it will end up, but at least I'm going in with my eyes open (even if he's got a white stick for crowds!)

Trust is hugely important and being told something like that further down the line might make me reconsider the whole thing, even if it doesn't affect you now.

If you're just going for a quick fling with no long term, then you probably don't need to mention it, unless it would affect you being able to get to a date.

StrawberryAnnie · 18/01/2023 14:25

You will probably know when the right time is to talk about it. There is no arbitrary month or number of dates.

A conversation about health might naturally come up on say, a second date. It might never come up, so after a period of time you might feel like talking about it.

Personally I don’t think it needs to be on a dating profile, but it would be deceptive to withhold it from someone you are entering into a serious relationship with.

Autoimmune conditions are common enough, not a taboo subject. And like a pp has said, nobody knows with any certainty what life will throw at them.

LaLuz7 · 18/01/2023 14:23

Yes, majorly wrong to keep it from them for months. It should be discussed by date 3-4.

WalkthisWayUK · 18/01/2023 14:21

No I don’t think everything should have to listed on a profile. It’s like meeting someone in a pub etiquette, for the first drink, first dates, it’s perfectly OK not to disclose everything yet.

However once you are starting to realize that there is a connection, then you mention things like kids. And once you are in a relationship, early in such as a couple of months, then you disclose personal stuff such as disabilities. That’s my take anyway!

latetotheinterview · 18/01/2023 14:14

I think in dating it's best to be up front and honest and anything you know that they don't is keeping something from them, and you have to ask yourself are you keeping it from them in case they leave?

If the answer is yes then they have a right to now because they have a right to leave.

I really think that's the long and short of it.

WisherWood · 18/01/2023 14:12

What if the disability did happen and the disabled person was okay if the other person walked away ?

It's not just about that. You're asking someone to build a relationship on a lie. They will build up an attachment to you. What if they're not OK with then leaving you, but also not OK with your diagnosis? Plus I would just be wondering what else you might not be telling me.

I told my DP I have depression after a couple of dates. By then it was clear that we had potential as a couple, but we hadn't got attached to each other. I knew my MH could affect him and felt it fair that he should know. I know this is not the same as MS by any means, but it is something you mentioned.

And yes, anyone could have an accident at any time. But that's rather different from knowingly excluding information about something that will happen to some degree.

Whatevergetsyouthroughthenight · 18/01/2023 14:10

Sorry about your diagnosis. I would tell some on the second or third date if you have ‘clicked’. Have a spiel ready about how long you have had it and best and worst case scenario, uncertainty etc and maybe a website that is balanced on the subject.

My DP has a health condition that is incurable and may or may not significantly shorten his life. My late DH was as far as anyone knew very fit and healthy and died young suddenly and unexpectedly. Who knows what is going to happen?

meetmeatmidnights · 18/01/2023 14:02

I think yes it should be up there, but I also think anything health wise (mental or physical!) should definitely come out early on in the getting to know them stage. It's unfair on both parties to keep things that could impact a relationship health wise from the other person, the other person might not want to deal with that sort of thing, or get involved with someone with any health issues due to their own personal experiences.

DismantledKing · 18/01/2023 13:58

Perhaps you should have been more honest in your OP?

TheCatIsOnMyFoot · 18/01/2023 13:55

Sorry to miss lead. 6 months was an arbitrary number. I'm currently single. Last LTP knew about it before we got together and was fine with it.

I was just musing really.

I've been diagnosed for a few years now and at peace with it.

OP posts:
Whataretheodds · 18/01/2023 09:20

AlwaysAReason · 18/01/2023 00:56

I think around 6 months is UR.
I don't think mentioning it on any profiles is necessary- the first few dates are about finding out if you even want to see each other again/getting to know each other. By the time you have committed to someone, I think they should know.

The referenced thread was different because the OP had specifically said in their profile that she wasn't interested in people with children, and yet the guy just ignored that and didn't mention it.

This.

Uninterestedfamily · 18/01/2023 09:10

I'd be fine with dating someone with MS.

I would not be fine dating someone who did not tell me for 6 months. Lying by omission, and I'd find it very manipulative to wait until presumably I'd be in love, or be at least developing feelings.

If you are looking for a long term relationship, you should both be open and honest about any factors that could impact your lives - health, family, financial, work, future plans, time-consuming hobbies etc. Not on date 1, but I think after a few dates.

Merryoldgoat · 18/01/2023 08:50

As PP said, it doesn’t need to go on a dating profile but I’d expect to know about something so serious early on.

After 6 weeks or so I think you generally know if you want to keep going or if it’s not working so at that point I’d tell.

My Dr told me conceiving would be likely problematic (in my early 20s) so I told (now)DH that very early on and that was a very vague maybe.

A significant illness or disability and I would certainly disclose that and expect it to be disclosed.