Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mortgages

62 replies

Icanflyhigh · 18/01/2023 00:26

Bear with me on this, might be long and I'm ranty.

DH and I applied for mortgage, jumped through all the usual hoops to be told there is a deal available IF we can increase our deposit to 20%

We currently have just over 5.5% deposit for the property we want to buy. We can't raise another 15% in a month of Sundays.

On paper, it all works. Joint income of almost 70k, but my income comes from 5 different employers and most lenders will only take 2 salaries from one person into account. I also had an IVA which finished successfully in 2021, but again, most lenders want 3 years clear of IVA before committing.

I signed up with credit ladder over 4 years ago and it has recorded every rent payment, on time, in full.

There are no missed payments anywhere and we are in credit on all of our utilities. We don't have credit card debt or loans and have worked hard to save a decent deposit, which we are adding to.

My biggest issue is that the mortgage we would be paying is LESS than our current rent, and we've offered to pay a higher mortgage repayment.

Why is it so damned difficult to buy a house?

Feel so jaded tonight. Had our hearts set on a house we both love and the dream is over.

OP posts:
Babyclb · 18/01/2023 10:14

I'm not surprised you can't get approved for a mortgage with only a 5% deposit!
Deposits that low have been incredibly rare since about '08, unless it is government backed by a HTB loan or something.

Plus your very recent IVA is obviously not going in your favour.

Save for the next 3 years while waiting for the minimum time post IVA and hopefully you will have a larger deposit.

Margarita45 · 18/01/2023 10:13

Even if you could go self employed, you’d be restarting the clock as you’d need 3 years books to be considered for a mortgage.

Mark19735 · 18/01/2023 10:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

BMW6 · 18/01/2023 08:27

mark19735

Please don't make suggestions about which you know the total of Fuck All.

BMW6 · 18/01/2023 08:24

Sorry OP but you can't simply set yourself up as a company and invoice your various employers. There's a big clue - you are an employee, not self employed.

The status "employed" or "self employed " isn't a matter of your choice. It's a matter of fact. Look up on UKGov or take my word for it (33 years working in HMRC)

Kinnorafron · 18/01/2023 08:19

Could you set up a company and invoice your employers, instead of being paid through payroll? You'd then "pay" yourself and would only have one salary to account for?

I have seen some ridiculous ideas on MN but that is really daft - this isn't possible, OP it's a batshit idea that would lead to all kinds of legal and tax issues, please don't consider it.

SweetSakura · 18/01/2023 07:31

I don't think it is particularly unfair, a recent IVA is going to mean you are seen as high risk, and then the current market means it is a high risk lending environment too

Rebel2023 · 18/01/2023 01:04

It won't be the best rate but if you need a mortgage broker then simply adverse are one I can recommend
They got me a mortgage when several other brokers couldn't

Icanflyhigh · 18/01/2023 00:59

Mark19735 · 18/01/2023 00:43

"there is a deal available IF we can increase our deposit to 20%"

That's more to do with the state of the current housing market than any reflection on you or your budgeting. It basically means the banks think house prices could drop by 20% and they want to be sure they won't lose their investment.

"My income comes from 5 different employers and most lenders will only take 2 salaries from one person into account."

Could you set up a company and invoice your employers, instead of being paid through payroll? You'd then "pay" yourself and would only have one salary to account for?

"The mortgage we would be paying is LESS than our current rent"

Yes, but a mortgage is a commitment over 25 years, rent is just a commitment for whatever the tenancy agreement says. And in the mortgage scenario, there is a risk of negative equity. In a rental scenario, the only risk is that you'll leave the place untidy and lose your deposit. It's the same principle as renting a car for a day (cost per day is high ... paperwork needed at car rental desk is basically a credit card and a license), versus leasing a car for 4 years (cost per day is much lower, but paperwork needed is more involved and includes credit checks etc.)

Final thought - have you thought about asking the seller to drop their price by 15%? In the current market ... they just might?

Thank you - I know you're being the voice of reason and I need to hear that right now.

It all feels very unfair even though I know we are in a good position compared to some.

I'm being mardy basically because I can't get my own way.

OP posts:
SweetSakura · 18/01/2023 00:55

Keep saving, get those 3 years clear of your IVA and your risk profile will be much better

MintJulia · 18/01/2023 00:45

Because your past history indicates risk.

There is always 'a deal available' and there will be in the future. Given your history, I think I'd wait until next year when you will have three clear years from your IVA and you will have saved a larger deposit.

I don't think house prices will rise (and may well fall) given the economic situation. And when you do buy, the difference between rent payments & mortgage payments will be even larger and more enjoyable, Either way, good luck.

Mark19735 · 18/01/2023 00:43

"there is a deal available IF we can increase our deposit to 20%"

That's more to do with the state of the current housing market than any reflection on you or your budgeting. It basically means the banks think house prices could drop by 20% and they want to be sure they won't lose their investment.

"My income comes from 5 different employers and most lenders will only take 2 salaries from one person into account."

Could you set up a company and invoice your employers, instead of being paid through payroll? You'd then "pay" yourself and would only have one salary to account for?

"The mortgage we would be paying is LESS than our current rent"

Yes, but a mortgage is a commitment over 25 years, rent is just a commitment for whatever the tenancy agreement says. And in the mortgage scenario, there is a risk of negative equity. In a rental scenario, the only risk is that you'll leave the place untidy and lose your deposit. It's the same principle as renting a car for a day (cost per day is high ... paperwork needed at car rental desk is basically a credit card and a license), versus leasing a car for 4 years (cost per day is much lower, but paperwork needed is more involved and includes credit checks etc.)

Final thought - have you thought about asking the seller to drop their price by 15%? In the current market ... they just might?

Swipe left for the next trending thread