Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mortgages

62 replies

Icanflyhigh · 18/01/2023 00:26

Bear with me on this, might be long and I'm ranty.

DH and I applied for mortgage, jumped through all the usual hoops to be told there is a deal available IF we can increase our deposit to 20%

We currently have just over 5.5% deposit for the property we want to buy. We can't raise another 15% in a month of Sundays.

On paper, it all works. Joint income of almost 70k, but my income comes from 5 different employers and most lenders will only take 2 salaries from one person into account. I also had an IVA which finished successfully in 2021, but again, most lenders want 3 years clear of IVA before committing.

I signed up with credit ladder over 4 years ago and it has recorded every rent payment, on time, in full.

There are no missed payments anywhere and we are in credit on all of our utilities. We don't have credit card debt or loans and have worked hard to save a decent deposit, which we are adding to.

My biggest issue is that the mortgage we would be paying is LESS than our current rent, and we've offered to pay a higher mortgage repayment.

Why is it so damned difficult to buy a house?

Feel so jaded tonight. Had our hearts set on a house we both love and the dream is over.

OP posts:
Kinnorafron · 18/01/2023 13:37

Mark19735 · 18/01/2023 13:17

Well, we'll just have to disagree.

Better tell my entire IT department that an angry keyboard warrior doesn't think their situation can possibly exist.

You are being ridiculous - an entire IT department of contractors doesn't make your advice to the OP correct.
I have 30+ years in IT including 2 periods of being a Limited Company contractor so I know exactly how this works, thanks.

We don't knwo what the OP does - but as a PP said, it's entirely possible (and legit) that they work for 5 different supermarkets on the till. That is increasingly common with zero hours contracts and it doesn't mean that all five can't be legitimate PAYE employment. The idea that the OP could simply waltz into each job and say " don't send me a payslip, I'll invoice you from now on" (your suggestion) is from the realms of fantasy.
But feel free to keep on claiming you know better and embarrassing yourself if you prefer.

Mark19735 · 18/01/2023 13:35

Ginmonkeyagain · 18/01/2023 13:24

They will be contractors though. The OP doesn't say she is a contractor, she says she has five jobs.

They are contractors now ... but they were employees before that. The OP didn't say she is a contractor now ... but if she makes some changes, maybe she could be.

Mark19735 · 18/01/2023 13:34

Kinnorafron · 18/01/2023 12:52

I wouldn’t consider the self-employed Ltd company route as that’s bonkers and providers would normally want about 3 years worth of accounts, so you’d have an even longer wait. To suggest that when we don’t know what you do is also very misleading. Having multiple jobs doesn’t mean you can be self employed. You could work on the checkouts one day a week across, Tesco, Sainsbury, Asda, Waitrose and Lidl. I’d love to see the look on their faces if you followed a PP advice and told them you’d set up a limited company and would like to be self employed as you have multiple jobs!
Exactly - no way that would fly - it is extremely bad advice.

And yet the gardener who waters the plants in the car park at Tesco, Sainsbury, Asda, Waitrose and Lidl almost certainly does have a Ltd company. As does the HVAC engineer who repairs all their fridges. As does the manual handling instructor who provides all their staff training. As does their industrial access person who operates the cherry pickers to get up into their roof voids. As does the electrician who comes and does all their PAT testing. As do, quite literally, tens of thousands of people up and down the country.

The decision whether to have an in-house versus outsourced capability is one that is discussed by management teams in boardrooms every single day. There is no reason why any services provided in house by employees couldn't be redefined as being provided under a managed services contract. Just requires flexibility of mind and a creative problem-solving approach.

How do I know this is correct? Because I have done exactly this, only last week, for an employee who was previously an in-house maintenance worker doing 0.4FTE for us, with the balance of his time shared with two other employers. As of this week, he is off payroll and invoicing us for his time instead.

So keep up with the "don't know what you're talking about" posts ... it's you who is embarrassing yourself.

Ginmonkeyagain · 18/01/2023 13:24

They will be contractors though. The OP doesn't say she is a contractor, she says she has five jobs.

Mark19735 · 18/01/2023 13:17

Well, we'll just have to disagree.

Better tell my entire IT department that an angry keyboard warrior doesn't think their situation can possibly exist.

Kinnorafron · 18/01/2023 12:52

I wouldn’t consider the self-employed Ltd company route as that’s bonkers and providers would normally want about 3 years worth of accounts, so you’d have an even longer wait. To suggest that when we don’t know what you do is also very misleading. Having multiple jobs doesn’t mean you can be self employed. You could work on the checkouts one day a week across, Tesco, Sainsbury, Asda, Waitrose and Lidl. I’d love to see the look on their faces if you followed a PP advice and told them you’d set up a limited company and would like to be self employed as you have multiple jobs!
Exactly - no way that would fly - it is extremely bad advice.

Kinnorafron · 18/01/2023 12:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You're just embarrassing yourself. There are categorically not tens of thousands of people who have converted five jobs into a limited company that invoices their former employer - that is absolute total bunkum.

Gingersay · 18/01/2023 12:44

Now is not the time to be taking out a new mortgage you would be better waiting until the economy has stabilised, the lenders are not willing to take on any risks just now, whereas a year or so ago you wouldn't have any issues. Wait a year and keep saving or an option might be to look at new builds where they are offering boosts to your deposit.

Ginmonkeyagain · 18/01/2023 12:28

God, ain't that the truth. I have had to find over £1000 this month to replace the washing machine and fix the plumbing issue that contributed the the demise of the previous washing machine. 😣

MidnightMeltdown · 18/01/2023 12:02

As others have said, I wouldn't even consider buying with 5%, especially with interest rates the way they are.

If you can't afford to save more, then you can't afford to be a homeowner. It's not just the mortgage, paying for all the insurance, maintenance etc is expensive. You need to have a decent chunk of surplus money in your budget each month.

Ginmonkeyagain · 18/01/2023 11:53

Indeed, also with interest rates going the way they are a 5% deposit is a bit risky.

Christmasbaubleswithtinselon · 18/01/2023 11:53

Yep, from experience you need to demonstrate a longer period of time out of the IVA. It’s disappointing I get it but it’s not personal for them.

Either you have a better history of credit management, or you have to put down a bigger deposit to share the perceived risk.

I feels worse when you are the reason for not being able to move. Try and get a positive savings plan in place. Start putting away the difference you would have paid on any new mortgage and you’ll soon find yourself in a stronger position.

Babyclb · 18/01/2023 11:52

NewYearNewName2023 · 18/01/2023 11:24

I'm not surprised you can't get approved for a mortgage with only a 5% deposit!
Deposits that low have been incredibly rare since about '08, unless it is government backed by a HTB loan or something.

That's completely untrue. We bought with a 95% LTV in 2016 and there were loads of similar options in the market.

They will have been removed again recently because of interest rate rises and the general state of the economy making lending more risky

It's not untrue. Of course 5% mortgages exist, I didn't deny that, but lenders are incredibly strict with who then lend to hence 5% mortgages as a product are actually quite rare.
The number of people getting a 5% mortgage is very low.

They are pulled on and off the market like the wind, in the last 3 years lots of banks removed their offering twice; once for the pandemic and again with the rise in interest rates.

TallulahBetty · 18/01/2023 11:49

Debt Advisor here. It's the IVA. Now that might well have been the best solution at the time, and well done for taking a decision to deal with your debts productively. However, the downside is that such a solution has to be recorded and visible to potential lenders, which you would have been made aware of at the time. It's annoying, but that's the way it goes if you want debts written off.

Therefore, they want a bigger deposit as you are more of a risk factor.

Ginmonkeyagain · 18/01/2023 11:42

Low deposit

Recent IVA

Income for a lot of different employers

You are not a desirable borrower. The best rates always go to low risk borrowers. On paper you are not a low risk borrower.

With interest rates increasing I would take some more time to save a bigger deposit and let that IVA settle. 2021 wasn't that long ago.

bowlingalleyblues · 18/01/2023 11:31

Remember that while a mortgage is cheaper than rent, it doesn't include the cost of repairs and maintenance which can be thousands a year.

A 95% mortgage means you will be paying a higher rate of interest, and could go into negative equity if prices fall by 5%. This could mean that you can't remortgage, or would struggle to pay if interest rates go up.

Those things together would suggest that you can't afford the house you're trying to buy, and it might not be a good idea.

NewYearNewName2023 · 18/01/2023 11:24

I'm not surprised you can't get approved for a mortgage with only a 5% deposit!
Deposits that low have been incredibly rare since about '08, unless it is government backed by a HTB loan or something.

That's completely untrue. We bought with a 95% LTV in 2016 and there were loads of similar options in the market.

They will have been removed again recently because of interest rate rises and the general state of the economy making lending more risky

Chocolatelabradorsarethebest · 18/01/2023 11:22

I feel for you OP, but as others have said it’ll be the IVA and relatively low deposit that will be flagging. I’d wait until the IVA has fully run its course and continue to save in the mean time.

I wouldn’t consider the self-employed Ltd company route as that’s bonkers and providers would normally want about 3 years worth of accounts, so you’d have an even longer wait. To suggest that when we don’t know what you do is also very misleading. Having multiple jobs doesn’t mean you can be self employed. You could work on the checkouts one day a week across, Tesco, Sainsbury, Asda, Waitrose and Lidl. I’d love to see the look on their faces if you followed a PP advice and told them you’d set up a limited company and would like to be self employed as you have multiple jobs!

Try not to get disheartened and I’m sure you’ll be in your own home soon.

Jimboscott0115 · 18/01/2023 11:19

Unfortunately OP, it's the IVA that's the issue. As you've sort of seen, there's still plenty of 5% deposit deals out there but in the current market, they're pretty tight in terms of lending criteria and will be looking for not only no debts, but a stable reliable income and no blemishes on your credit report.

The challenge is, an IVA is one of the biggest blemishes you can have on your report and it'll show for 6 years from the date it was set up I believe. Now, I don't know how long your IVA was for (5 years is fairly standard), but ultimately you may have struggles until it's dropped off your report. If it's been there for more than 6 years and hasn't dropped off I'd recommend contacting the credit reference agencies to get it removed because to the bank, it's irrelevant how long it's completed for, they simply won't know it existed if it drops off your file which would be a huge win.

In the meantime I do think holding off until the 3 years is up as per what your bank said (or it drops off your file) because prices will reduce over this year anyway so late 2024 or early 2024 is likely to be a good time for those in a position to buy.

Jarstastic · 18/01/2023 11:11

It is frustrating when you're paying rent which is higher than your mortgage, but it's an overall risk scenario and with a 5% deposit, you're not leaving the bank much room. If you had a higher deposit if you defaulted and they had costs associated with repossession etc they would be covered.

In your place, I wouldn't go down a LTD company or self employed. That will just open up a new can of worms of having to show 2 or 3 years accounts. Is there any way you can get a 1 new job you'll only need 3-6 months pay slips and will be seen much lower risk. Alternatively, go up your hours on 2 jobs as a PP suggested.

Looks like 3 years since your IVA was settled will be next year? Just keep saving and hopefully things will look rosier for you next year.

Having your utilities in credit won't help your credit record. I'd suggest using YNAB for budgeting. Cut back on your payments to utilities (and if you have large balances on them, consider requesting payment from them) just make sure you are putting enough away in the appropriate accounts in YNAB so you know not to spend it, but your bank balances are showing higher amounts.

housemaus · 18/01/2023 10:59

The problem for you is that both the low deposit and the recent IVA are sticking points, even for specialist lenders.

There are a small handful of lenders who'll look at IVAs more recent than 3 years, but (from a quick search) none of them have product ranges up to 95%.

And any lender who'll do a 95% mortgage right now is very unlikely to do so with a less-than-3-year-old IVA.

I might be wrong (I work in the industry but not as a mortgage adviser) and you could speak to a good broker who specialises in trickier cases to get an idea of whether they know someone who will accept it - some of the smaller lenders really are super flexible if the underwriter can see the credit file as a whole makes sense. I can recommend someone if you DM me - if anyone could place this mortgage, it'd be them.

But really I think your options are:

  1. Wait til IVA is 3 years old
  2. Look at much cheaper properties to give you a bigger deposit % (although I know this is impossible in some areas)
blebbleb · 18/01/2023 10:54

Babyclb · 18/01/2023 10:14

I'm not surprised you can't get approved for a mortgage with only a 5% deposit!
Deposits that low have been incredibly rare since about '08, unless it is government backed by a HTB loan or something.

Plus your very recent IVA is obviously not going in your favour.

Save for the next 3 years while waiting for the minimum time post IVA and hopefully you will have a larger deposit.

Not true. There were plenty of mortgages like that in 2019 when we were first time buyers.

Flamingogirl08 · 18/01/2023 10:42

Babyclb · 18/01/2023 10:14

I'm not surprised you can't get approved for a mortgage with only a 5% deposit!
Deposits that low have been incredibly rare since about '08, unless it is government backed by a HTB loan or something.

Plus your very recent IVA is obviously not going in your favour.

Save for the next 3 years while waiting for the minimum time post IVA and hopefully you will have a larger deposit.

There's loads of 5% deposit mortgages but it's the IVA that's the problem

Mark19735 · 18/01/2023 10:31

Well, there we are. Your assumptions are just that. Might be correct - might be wrong. Assuming you can up your hours might be just as flawed. It's for the OP to reflect on all suggestions and decide what best suits their circumstances.

Whether or not a situation is classed as employment is complex, and there are many factors to consider. It's not simply a choice the individual makes, but neither is it a decision the organisation makes either. It is a negotiation, and a judgment call with many consequences to consider. But it is legal, commonplace and has helped many, many people fulfil their career and life ambitions.

Everyone firing off abuse and putdowns based purely on their own experience or assumptions is not being particularly helpful. Might make you feel clever and wise, but that's not what the OP needs (and it doesn't actually make anyone else on these thread think you particularly clever or wise).

Aprilx · 18/01/2023 10:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Having more than one job does not mean you are not an employee, you can be an employee of more than one organisation. As OP is already considered an employee of these five places, then I would assume that this is what she is.

A more realistic suggestion for overcoming the problem of five employments for mortgage purposes, is probably to up her hours in a couple of places and resign from the others.

Swipe left for the next trending thread