Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not know if this offensive?

315 replies

Catnary · 17/01/2023 22:49

Colleague in canteen queue today, I comment that the food looks tasty. She makes a face, points to the label and says “Yeah but look, I’m not eating that!”

Label says “Halal beef casserole”.

I say “but it’s just a different way of slaughtering the cow”

”Yeah I know, that’s what I mean, it’s SO cruel. I can’t have that on my conscience.”

This was all very loud and other people overheard. Neither colleague nor I are Muslim but many other colleagues are. I felt very uncomfortable, didn’t engage, and ordered the beef.

Is this just no different to a vegetarian declaring loudly that they couldn’t possibly be so cruel as to eat meat, or is it a slur on Muslims? It felt inappropriate, especially at work.

OP posts:
FamilyFunAdventure · 18/01/2023 06:40

My response would have been that all meat comes from a slaughter, no method is particularly pleasant and if it upsets her that much become vegetarian.

youshouldnthaveasked · 18/01/2023 06:39

It’s not offensive. She can have an opinion on how meat is slaughtered. Is she generally very outspoken?

Testingprof · 18/01/2023 06:34

Babyclb · 18/01/2023 06:17

It’s not anti Muslim, I know vets who eat meat but will not eat halal due to the practice being particularly cruel.

Do they also refuse to eat kosher meat?

QuinkWashable · 18/01/2023 06:21

I think even if it wasn't about cruelty (and obviously there are differences in cruelty of slaughter - although I don't know enough, and I'm sure there's plenty of places where regs aren't followed anyway) - I wouldn't want to eat meat that had been intentionally slow-killed vs. killed quickly, and I don't think there's anything wrong with that, nor do I think it's moralising to say it.

But also, if I were religious, I can see that I might not want to eat food blessed for another religion - I can see that that could be offensive.

Babyclb · 18/01/2023 06:17

It’s not anti Muslim, I know vets who eat meat but will not eat halal due to the practice being particularly cruel.

HandsOffMyCarrierBags · 18/01/2023 06:14

It’s perfectly reasonable for her to hold an opinion and make menu choices based on how the animals were killed. She thinks it’s cruel, possibly she’s muddling halal with Khoser

Quinoawoman · 18/01/2023 06:09

Personally I don't think a humane way to slaughter an animal exists. I find it very odd when people who eat meat try to impose morality on the different levels of cruelty involved in slaughter or animal farming. You can't be an animal lover and eat them - it's just cognitive dissonance.

DarkNecessities · 18/01/2023 06:05

In answer to your post OP I don’t think she was being offensive towards Muslims.

Some people feel the same about other meats such as veal. Or don’t like the potentially dodgy content of burgers or sausages

Simonjt · 18/01/2023 06:01

DeFacto · 18/01/2023 01:53

@Catnary, that seems fair enough-ish.

I used to run a catering company. All meat was organic or free-range, so wouldn't have been halal. I couldn't do Kosher either because I couldn't provide the religiously correct separation of various food-stuffs.

Essentially, people who required certain religious requirements around food would never have come to me.

I think in mass-catering situations religion shouldn't be a concern. The vegetarian option is there for people who wish to believe that God cares about what they eat.

I’m not sure why you think organic/free range meat can’t be halal.

DarkNecessities · 18/01/2023 05:58

LINABE · 18/01/2023 05:53

Yes this. Halal meat is now served in so many places in the UK by the back door and we don't even realise it. We should know before we eat if the meat is halal or not and then make our choice.
A well known high street Pizza chain serves halal for example. (I asked them)
I find it abhorrent that this has crept in the way that it has.
I thought I still lived in a predominantly christian country where the Animal is not slaughtered according to the muslim religion.
I would like to have a choice.

Yes, pizza express serves halal chicken but non of their dishes are halal which makes me wonder what they’re trying to achieve here.

LINABE · 18/01/2023 05:53

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Yes this. Halal meat is now served in so many places in the UK by the back door and we don't even realise it. We should know before we eat if the meat is halal or not and then make our choice.
A well known high street Pizza chain serves halal for example. (I asked them)
I find it abhorrent that this has crept in the way that it has.
I thought I still lived in a predominantly christian country where the Animal is not slaughtered according to the muslim religion.
I would like to have a choice.

DarkNecessities · 18/01/2023 05:53

DeFacto · 18/01/2023 02:33

Guaranteed she will be off to her local Indian restaurant for her chicken bhuna with rice at the weekend.

It’s not halal meat that irks her, it’s Muslims being catered for that pisses her off.

Let's be fair, her local 'Indian' wouldn't be halal or Muslim run. If it was 'Indian' it would be Hindu or Sikh.

What you perceive to be 'Indian' is most likely Bangladesh which is more aligned to Pakistan than India, most curry houses in the UK are Bangladeshi. Who are more Pakistani than Indian.

we frequently use 4 Indian restaurants and they’re all run by Muslims

Ineedtosleep79 · 18/01/2023 05:22

Catnary · 18/01/2023 01:31

Hmm, she started by pointing out the sign to me in a way that suggested she thought I had missed it and she was doing me a favour by warning me, followed by the loud performative “oh no I couldn’t POSSIBLY have that on my conscience”. Come to think of it, it was also rude to the catering staff.

Well she's just spitting straight facts tbf. Maybe she has more of a conscience than you 🤷

Fuck Halal meat.

Judgyjudgy · 18/01/2023 05:14

Suzi888 · 18/01/2023 04:20

Of course it’s cruel, should be banned. If I wanted to express it then yes I would. It’s called freedom of speech.

Curious. What are you basing this on? Why is this so cruel and should be banned? What are you comparing this to? Do you eat meat? Wear leather shoes?

KinkyMom · 18/01/2023 05:06

I don't think it offensive but I would find her personality annoying as she sounds very self righteous and opinionated so I might be weary of her....

Coffeecreme · 18/01/2023 04:52

she was tactless

WiddlinDiddlin · 18/01/2023 04:50

Almost all the halal meat slaughtered in the UK is stunned first - the risk comes in buying imported halal meat.

Truly halal meat, as the relevant religions really intended... an animal quietly and swiftly slaughtered in the field it lived in, away from the others but in a familiar place, by a quiet, respectful and calm person, I have no issue with at all.. but that isn't possible in a slaughterhouse.

However the issues with slaughterhouses are pretty much the same regardless of halal or stunning - you're moving animals long distances, to unfamiliar places, which is stressful. They can smell each others fear and distress, they can smell blood, they will pick up on distress cries and fearful behaviour from one another.

So, long story short, she's ignorant and rude.

Suzi888 · 18/01/2023 04:20

KrisAkabusi · 17/01/2023 22:56

I do think it's a particularly cruel method of slaughter. Normal processes aren't great, but I do think this is worse. My opinion on this has nothing to do with religion.

Of course it’s cruel, should be banned. If I wanted to express it then yes I would. It’s called freedom of speech.

Silverbook · 18/01/2023 04:14

Her comment was about the slaughter process, not the religion. It would be comparable to somebody saying they would never wear a kilt and you wondering if that was offensive to Scottish people.

Aprilx · 18/01/2023 03:35

Catnary · 18/01/2023 00:11

Ha , yes, I think that is about right actually (but knowing when to be quiet). It was mostly rude, in a professional environment, I suppose, rather than offensive.

I really don’t understand why you think this was rude. Rude to who exactly? She was expressing an opinion on a process that is quite controversial. I am not commenting on it myself as I don’t have specific knowledge but I know it is controversial and I think your colleague is allowed to have an opinion on something she sees in the canteen. I might express a preference for free range eggs, is that rude too in your mind?

Ladyinpuce · 18/01/2023 03:33

@MyLittleToe www.bva.co.uk/take-action/our-policies/non-stun-slaughter/

MyLittleToe · 18/01/2023 03:31

I was under the impression that in the UK all animals have to be stunned before slaughter. I'm pretty sure there was objection to this by the Islamic community a while ago but I may have gotten my wires crossed.

PoIIyPandemonium · 18/01/2023 03:30

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Dontsayfuckorbugger · 18/01/2023 03:23

Farmers daughter here. All slaughter houses, halal or not, are government regulated. Animals will/should not suffer either way they are killed or it would not be allowed. Your only problem lies if a slaughterhouse ignores these regulatory rules (those that do include halal and non halal slaughter). Most farmers go to extreme lengths to find the best slaughterhouse for their animals and farmers also believe animal killed should not be wasted. If it is then that is also awful in itself too. Educate yourself on the slaughter process of good slaughter of both halal and traditional then you can make an inform decision for the future. There are many horror stories regarding slaughterhouses but there is also a very high amount that would not stand for any animal suffering. No one should allow an animal to be slaughtered and the meat etc to go to waste

Ladyinpuce · 18/01/2023 02:58

OP, Your question was “AIBU to not know if this was offensive”?
IMO, yes, you are.
If you work/live in a multicultural environment it behoves you to learn about other cultures in order to understand others' values/customs etc. Maybe you could do a bit of research on Halal meat production so you can be better informed?
In any event you aren't responsible for what your colleague says/thinks/eats.

Swipe left for the next trending thread