Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not know if this offensive?

315 replies

Catnary · 17/01/2023 22:49

Colleague in canteen queue today, I comment that the food looks tasty. She makes a face, points to the label and says “Yeah but look, I’m not eating that!”

Label says “Halal beef casserole”.

I say “but it’s just a different way of slaughtering the cow”

”Yeah I know, that’s what I mean, it’s SO cruel. I can’t have that on my conscience.”

This was all very loud and other people overheard. Neither colleague nor I are Muslim but many other colleagues are. I felt very uncomfortable, didn’t engage, and ordered the beef.

Is this just no different to a vegetarian declaring loudly that they couldn’t possibly be so cruel as to eat meat, or is it a slur on Muslims? It felt inappropriate, especially at work.

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 18/01/2023 10:01

Catnary · 18/01/2023 09:53

OK @Nimbostratus. Let’s imagine that you are at work and a chat goes like this:

Nice weekend Brenda?
Yeah, great thanks. My brother just had a baby boy actually!
Oh congratulations.
Yeah he’s gorgeous. Thing is though, my SIL is Jewish and she wants him to be circumcised. It’s so cruel and unnecessary, I can’t believe she’d do that to a child.

You are either in the chat or it’s loud and you overhear it. Would that be fine by you (and yes, the fact it is at work is relevant)?

YES! absolutely 100% completely and totally fine

What I would find offensive is someone deciding on my behalf that someone else freely express that they find a particularly practice cruel

I just cant emphasise this enough

There is more than enough discrimination in the world that NEEDS calling out, and tackling, without muddying the waters and making people feel upset and defensive for being in trouble expressing completely fair and relevant points of view about a practice they find cruel.

That sort of thought policing just causes all sorts of issues.

Brenda is upset about something that is happening to her nephew, and she has every right to be upset and to say so. The fact that this is happening becasue he is Jewish is irrelevant, she would be equally upset if it was happening becasue it is normal practice for an American baby, or whatever,

To be honest, I think the most offensive thing hear is that you seem to think I am too delicate and easily bruised to hear this

Lots of Jews would agree with Brenda, by the way

CountZacular · 18/01/2023 09:53

If you're not a muslim why on earth would you eat something that has had an islamic prayer said over it? Makes no sense, you believe that islam is wrong/inaccurate therefore eating something that has been slaughtered in a manner specifically and solely designed for people of that religion seems wrong.

I understand the misconceptions around halal meat in the UK but this is batshit. What’s supposedly happened to the meat because it’s been prayed over? I’m atheist, and find all religions problematic. When I’m at my Christmas dinner and a prayer is said over the meal by family is it wrong for me to then eat it?

Catnary · 18/01/2023 09:53

OK @Nimbostratus. Let’s imagine that you are at work and a chat goes like this:

Nice weekend Brenda?
Yeah, great thanks. My brother just had a baby boy actually!
Oh congratulations.
Yeah he’s gorgeous. Thing is though, my SIL is Jewish and she wants him to be circumcised. It’s so cruel and unnecessary, I can’t believe she’d do that to a child.

You are either in the chat or it’s loud and you overhear it. Would that be fine by you (and yes, the fact it is at work is relevant)?

OP posts:
Willyoujustbequiet · 18/01/2023 09:52

larchforest · 18/01/2023 00:11

If the practices of any faith or tradition causes unnecessary suffering to any living creature, then I am not in favour of that practice, and will say so.

Method of slaughter, bullfighting, Palio of Siena, rodeos, none of them are necessary in a modern society.

This.

I agree with the colleague.

CountZacular · 18/01/2023 09:48

It’s ignorance. As PP stated, the vast, vast majority of halal meat in the UK is stunned before slaughter. The only key difference is the prayer.

In slaughterhouses in general, conditions can be poor and animals suffer needlessly. There’s also the poor treatment of workers too. The whole process is ‘inhumane’. But it seems it’s easier to ignore that and direct it at halal meat.

And as an aside, I do think there’s a time and place for some comments. Work is rarely a place to be political, and especially making moral judgments as people nearby are tucking into that food.

WineDup · 18/01/2023 09:46

Dotjones · 18/01/2023 09:27

No it's not offensive, it's just a statement that the person would not want to eat meat that has been slaughtered in a particular way - throat slit to drain blood and being prayed over.

If you're not a muslim why on earth would you eat something that has had an islamic prayer said over it? Makes no sense, you believe that islam is wrong/inaccurate therefore eating something that has been slaughtered in a manner specifically and solely designed for people of that religion seems wrong.

I mean you could wear a t-shirt with allah written on it but why would you if you weren't a muslim? You don't believe in it, so why would you promote or support it?

One, as a vegetarian I believe that all animal slaughter is unethical, which includes halal or kosher.

However, I literally couldn’t care less if the cow listened to a Muslim prayer as it was dying. what could the possible harm be? The meat tastes the exact same. Do you eat out at all? Coz if so, we need to have words.

Nimbostratus100 · 18/01/2023 09:38

Noob2022 · 18/01/2023 09:19

As a Muslim (and inclusion champion in my workplace) yes the comment is offensive given the implied meaning.

Yes you can’t be sure what she actually meant but you're in the workplace not a social setting. she can have her opinions which she is entitled to, but she also needs to be mindful and respectful of others that work with and their beliefs/ religion. Ultimately the animals is dead if she doesn’t want to eat it that’s her choice but no need to make unnecessary comments.

i also expect halal food is presented as an option due to demand in the workplace from the number of Muslim colleagues you have. So like any inclusive employer your company is catering for these staff as well as others.

unless people like this are called out on this behaviour, it’ll just continue. And like many on the post and this thread will continue to think it’s ok.

There is a thin line between banter and discrimination, and open conversations without judgement is how we can educate others.

personally I would sit her down and let her know that her comment made you/ or could make others uncomfortable and why.

I completely disagree with you, this is neither "banter" or "discrimination" it is someone expressing that they feel a particular practice is cruel. They are totally within their rights to do so, and no one gets to try and strong arm them into keeping quiet, or gaslight others by trying to twist this into something that is morally wrong and needs to be "called out"

You carry on being offended if you want to - that is your right

I'm Jewish and 100% back up anyone who feels these methods of slaughter are cruel, and feels strongly enough to say so in public.

Hiding behind an ethnic origin or faith and saying people cant criticise an aspect of culture because of a blanket ban on speaking out against any aspect of that culture or faith is just an attempt to gag people and stifle free speech and slap down perfectly respectable points of view

I dont know what an "inclusion champion" is supposed to do, but surely not bully and divide people like this

Catnary · 18/01/2023 09:36

If you're not a muslim why on earth would you eat something that has had an islamic prayer said over it? Makes no sense, you believe that islam is wrong/inaccurate therefore eating something that has been slaughtered in a manner specifically and solely designed for people of that religion seems wrong.

I think you are on very dodgy ground saying that if someone is not Muslim they believe that Islam is wrong. And, personally, if I like the look of some food I will eat it without a second thought as to whether it bears religious significance for people who follow a particular religion. I can’t think of any religions that actively discourage non-believers from eating their food?

OP posts:
Simonjt · 18/01/2023 09:32

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/01/2023 09:29

I understood thane of the requirements of Halal slaughter was that the animal was aware.

However, if I'm wrong, I'm wrong.

You’re wrong, around 95% of halal animals slaughter in the UK are stunned, they have to be alive when drained, not aware, stunning won’t kill an animal.

Simonjt · 18/01/2023 09:31

Nimbostratus100 · 18/01/2023 09:26

really? I didnt know that

Stunning is perfectly fine for halal slaughter, around 95% in the UK are stunned as animals have to be alive at ‘slaughter’/bloody draining, they do not need to be conscious. In Kosher a stunned animal would be considered injured, which is why stunning isn’t permitted for kosher slaughter.

BananaBlue · 18/01/2023 09:30

@DeFacto Thanks for the explanation by this ‘I used to run a catering company. All meat was organic or free-range, so wouldn't have been halal.’ I thought you meant organic = not halal.

Do organic places not use slaughter houses?

NB I just googled organic halal and there’s good availability.

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/01/2023 09:29

Simonjt · 18/01/2023 09:25

Almost all animals killed via halal slaughter in the UK are stunned.

I understood thane of the requirements of Halal slaughter was that the animal was aware.

However, if I'm wrong, I'm wrong.

Dotjones · 18/01/2023 09:27

No it's not offensive, it's just a statement that the person would not want to eat meat that has been slaughtered in a particular way - throat slit to drain blood and being prayed over.

If you're not a muslim why on earth would you eat something that has had an islamic prayer said over it? Makes no sense, you believe that islam is wrong/inaccurate therefore eating something that has been slaughtered in a manner specifically and solely designed for people of that religion seems wrong.

I mean you could wear a t-shirt with allah written on it but why would you if you weren't a muslim? You don't believe in it, so why would you promote or support it?

Nimbostratus100 · 18/01/2023 09:26

Simonjt · 18/01/2023 09:25

Almost all animals killed via halal slaughter in the UK are stunned.

really? I didnt know that

Simonjt · 18/01/2023 09:25

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/01/2023 08:53

I would agree - there is no "good" death for the animals we eat, but Halal (and, I understand, Kosher) meat is killed without stunning, with the animals fully conscious and aware. This is particularly cruel.

Cruelty is built into the system, though whatever the killing method, especially since small local slaughterhouses were closed and the large "production line" ones instituted so that only a few serve the country. This means that many animals are crowded into trucks, often for a couple of days at a time, deprived of food, often deprived of water, and shut up in horrible crowded conditions, frightened and distressed.

For the record, I used to be vegetarian but am not now, though am trying to work back towards it.

Almost all animals killed via halal slaughter in the UK are stunned.

Noob2022 · 18/01/2023 09:19

As a Muslim (and inclusion champion in my workplace) yes the comment is offensive given the implied meaning.

Yes you can’t be sure what she actually meant but you're in the workplace not a social setting. she can have her opinions which she is entitled to, but she also needs to be mindful and respectful of others that work with and their beliefs/ religion. Ultimately the animals is dead if she doesn’t want to eat it that’s her choice but no need to make unnecessary comments.

i also expect halal food is presented as an option due to demand in the workplace from the number of Muslim colleagues you have. So like any inclusive employer your company is catering for these staff as well as others.

unless people like this are called out on this behaviour, it’ll just continue. And like many on the post and this thread will continue to think it’s ok.

There is a thin line between banter and discrimination, and open conversations without judgement is how we can educate others.

personally I would sit her down and let her know that her comment made you/ or could make others uncomfortable and why.

Nimbostratus100 · 18/01/2023 09:16

DeFacto · 18/01/2023 08:58

I only eat locally produced meat from small suppliers. I would argue that a local, seasonal and ethical omnivorous diet it the most sustainable and kind to the planet.

I live in an area of the UK entirely unsuited to arable crops. I am surrounded by sheep who happily graze uplands. Unfortunately, due to regulations, livestock has to be transported for slaughter, I wish that it were not so but I do not have the time to raise my own livestock. I have shot wild game, caught fish and slaughtered a chicken for personal consumption, but that was 20 years ago when I had a brief 'living off the land' phase. I don't have time for that now so am comfortable eating the best meat I can.

I'd quite happily argue that almonds, avocados, and unseasonal fruit are more problematic from both an environmental and human point of view than eating local sheep in an Northern European uplands winter.

very interesting post

DeFacto · 18/01/2023 09:12

@BananaBlue, sorry, you misunderstand me, maybe I wasn't clear.

It's entirely possible for halal meat to be free-range or organic. It's just that it's not widely available in this country as most organic suppliers have a market that they cater to, it's a premium product and to also be halal would make it very niche. There are suppliers that produce halal organic meat but they are few and far between and it is an expensive product as it's not widely sought after.

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/01/2023 09:11

Nimbostratus100 · 18/01/2023 08:55

@Emotionalsupportviper

I am the same as you, ideally would be vegetarian, but dont acheive that ideal wholly. Still, every time we make a decision on the side of vegetarianism, it is a plus, it doesn't have to be 100% to have an effect

I really think that meat is addictive, @Nimbostratus100 .

I was veggie for years, then was very unwell and had to eat meat again (it was complex, and also related also to a bereavement -I have no physical or mental energy). Anyhow, I fully intended to go back to vegetarianism when I was sorted, but have found it very difficult. (And, I'll be honest - as the rest of the family eat meat, it is just easier. Which is an appalling "reason".)

BananaBlue · 18/01/2023 09:04

@DeFacto

sorry for my ignorance but what stops organic food from being halal?

I thought:

  1. Organic food meant free from pesticides, allowed to roam free.
  2. Surely an organic animal can be stunned then slaughtered with a prayer over a rabbit making it halal?

Can you explain why most organic cannot be halal?

DeFacto · 18/01/2023 08:58

Fixyourself · 18/01/2023 08:44

Please someone tell me what type of slaughter isn't cruel?
lf you don't like the thought of halal but eat meat then you are a huge hypocrite!

I only eat locally produced meat from small suppliers. I would argue that a local, seasonal and ethical omnivorous diet it the most sustainable and kind to the planet.

I live in an area of the UK entirely unsuited to arable crops. I am surrounded by sheep who happily graze uplands. Unfortunately, due to regulations, livestock has to be transported for slaughter, I wish that it were not so but I do not have the time to raise my own livestock. I have shot wild game, caught fish and slaughtered a chicken for personal consumption, but that was 20 years ago when I had a brief 'living off the land' phase. I don't have time for that now so am comfortable eating the best meat I can.

I'd quite happily argue that almonds, avocados, and unseasonal fruit are more problematic from both an environmental and human point of view than eating local sheep in an Northern European uplands winter.

Nimbostratus100 · 18/01/2023 08:55

@Emotionalsupportviper

I am the same as you, ideally would be vegetarian, but dont acheive that ideal wholly. Still, every time we make a decision on the side of vegetarianism, it is a plus, it doesn't have to be 100% to have an effect

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/01/2023 08:53

KrisAkabusi · 17/01/2023 22:56

I do think it's a particularly cruel method of slaughter. Normal processes aren't great, but I do think this is worse. My opinion on this has nothing to do with religion.

I would agree - there is no "good" death for the animals we eat, but Halal (and, I understand, Kosher) meat is killed without stunning, with the animals fully conscious and aware. This is particularly cruel.

Cruelty is built into the system, though whatever the killing method, especially since small local slaughterhouses were closed and the large "production line" ones instituted so that only a few serve the country. This means that many animals are crowded into trucks, often for a couple of days at a time, deprived of food, often deprived of water, and shut up in horrible crowded conditions, frightened and distressed.

For the record, I used to be vegetarian but am not now, though am trying to work back towards it.

Nimbostratus100 · 18/01/2023 08:52

Testingprof · 18/01/2023 08:28

You are being disingenuous. The issue is people boycott halal and make a massive song and dance about it but you don’t have the same people complaining about Kosher meat where they never stun the animal.

I’m a meat eater and I’m happy to talk about humane meat eating but not when the dog whistles are going off. Some people who moan about halal meat are also happy to eat battery hens/eggs where they debeak them to stop them pecking each other to death.

What are you talking about? The slaughter methods are similar, and they are normally spoken of together, the only difference being the amount of halal meat is many orders of magnitude greater than the amount of kosher meat

I have no idea what "disingenuous" means or "dog whistle"

Pr1mr0se · 18/01/2023 08:48

Would the same apply to commenting on not wanting to eat pork (including bacon for those who have read that thread!)?

I don't think your colleague was out of order, she made an informed choice not to eat the beef just as you did to eat it.

There is a petition here:
www.rspca.org.uk/getinvolved/campaign/slaughter

Swipe left for the next trending thread