Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not know if this offensive?

315 replies

Catnary · 17/01/2023 22:49

Colleague in canteen queue today, I comment that the food looks tasty. She makes a face, points to the label and says “Yeah but look, I’m not eating that!”

Label says “Halal beef casserole”.

I say “but it’s just a different way of slaughtering the cow”

”Yeah I know, that’s what I mean, it’s SO cruel. I can’t have that on my conscience.”

This was all very loud and other people overheard. Neither colleague nor I are Muslim but many other colleagues are. I felt very uncomfortable, didn’t engage, and ordered the beef.

Is this just no different to a vegetarian declaring loudly that they couldn’t possibly be so cruel as to eat meat, or is it a slur on Muslims? It felt inappropriate, especially at work.

OP posts:
LastOfTheChristmasWine · 18/01/2023 11:54

SchoolTripDrama · 18/01/2023 11:49

You do realise that if livestock wasn't killed for meat that the planet would be utterly & completely overrun with cattle, pigs & sheep?! It would be like an apocalypse

Do you think they just pop into existence magically and in a way that we have no control over? No.

They are bred, deliberately, by farmers. If there's no demand for beef, pork or lamb then they will send the remaining animals to slaughter and stop breeding them. They're not going to turn their animals loose in the local park and let them breed at will now, are they?

You could make this argument for wild British venison because they live in the wild and have no natural predators after we hunted wolves, bears etc to extinction a few centuries ago. But not for pheasants and other game birds (mostly raised by gamekeepers and released for the purposes of shooting) and certainly not for pigs, sheep, cattle and poultry.

Kanaloa · 18/01/2023 11:49

Ponoka7 · 18/01/2023 07:36

So what conditions we keep animals in wasn't worth campaigning for? We should go back to the long distance transportation of live animals? There should be no farm animal welfare legalisation? Free range etc doesn't matter?

I mean that’s not really what I said. I said that you can’t stand loudly talking about how meany pants others are who kill animals to eat because you kill animals in a nice way. You can feel better that you buy chickens that get to go out for an hour a day before they’re killed, but if you really cared about animal suffering then you wouldn’t want to to eat any animals. But if you do want to eat animals you can’t exactly look down at others.

SchoolTripDrama · 18/01/2023 11:49

AnneLovesGilbert · 17/01/2023 22:53

You seem sure it is offensive. I’m a lifelong vegetarian and think eating meat is unnecessary so I don’t really care how the animal that’s been killed so you can eat it died. None of it’s okay.

But cultural sensitivities aren’t a reason not to object to inhumane practices and there are plenty of things done in the name of religion I object to and would do so out loud.

You do realise that if livestock wasn't killed for meat that the planet would be utterly & completely overrun with cattle, pigs & sheep?! It would be like an apocalypse

AnuSTart · 18/01/2023 11:00

Mark19735 · 17/01/2023 23:34

If your colleague would say the same about kosher meat, or lobster, or factory-farmed chickens and eggs, then perhaps it's fair enough. But I suspect your colleague is less vocal about this.

So actually, it's just like Tommy Robinson raging about nine Asian paedophiles in Rochdale, but saying absolutely nothing at all about the 1,323 white people convicted of sex offences against minors that same year. It's not about the crimes against women and children - it's about the ethnicity of the perpetrator. That's what makes him racist. And using the same logic, so is your colleague.

This I reckon. In a nutshell.

Fullsomefrenchie · 18/01/2023 10:54

Is this serious? She’s not allowed an opinion on the cruelty of halal slaughter purposes or it’s deemed offensive.

how ludicrous

LakieLady · 18/01/2023 10:49

Mark19735 · 17/01/2023 23:34

If your colleague would say the same about kosher meat, or lobster, or factory-farmed chickens and eggs, then perhaps it's fair enough. But I suspect your colleague is less vocal about this.

So actually, it's just like Tommy Robinson raging about nine Asian paedophiles in Rochdale, but saying absolutely nothing at all about the 1,323 white people convicted of sex offences against minors that same year. It's not about the crimes against women and children - it's about the ethnicity of the perpetrator. That's what makes him racist. And using the same logic, so is your colleague.

That's pretty much the way I see it.

And there was no need to say any more than "I don't eat halal for animal welfare reasons".

OneTC · 18/01/2023 10:48

BananaBlue · 18/01/2023 10:34

I was questioning this too - I’ve always assumed that Organic animals are slaughtered in the same manner as non-organic?

Or are there special abattoirs for them?

TBH, I’m not fussed about what my meat is listening to before slaughter (Imam CD or Now 25).

I do care that they are stunned and treated humanely.

The same slaughterhouses can handle both. My (small up market) butcher can show you the audit trail on his meat from farm to counter and it goes through the same large commercial abattoir that spoilt pig bacon goes through, which whilst a higher welfare product is also very mass market

There's definitely lesser slaughterhouses though and I guess they get less or none of the higher welfare trade.

Mark19735 · 18/01/2023 10:44

Isn't it funny how this thread divides into those who want to discuss animal welfare (who think the racism angle is infringing on their right to prioritise the issue that they care about more), and those who interpreted the OP post as being about racism (who may or may not also have a view on animal welfare, but who fundamentally prioritise the racism angle).

The choice people exercise to frame this one way or the other is very revealing - it really reveals their particular privilege.

SleeplessInEngland · 18/01/2023 10:41

By definition if you eat meat your concern about animal welfare is limited. (Yes, I eat meat before anyone asks.)

Verybritishproblems101 · 18/01/2023 10:38

Halal is vile. End of.

BananaBlue · 18/01/2023 10:34

OneTC · 18/01/2023 10:30

Organic free range meat is cuddled to death, surely everyone knows this 😅

I was questioning this too - I’ve always assumed that Organic animals are slaughtered in the same manner as non-organic?

Or are there special abattoirs for them?

TBH, I’m not fussed about what my meat is listening to before slaughter (Imam CD or Now 25).

I do care that they are stunned and treated humanely.

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/01/2023 10:34

Simonjt · 18/01/2023 09:31

Stunning is perfectly fine for halal slaughter, around 95% in the UK are stunned as animals have to be alive at ‘slaughter’/bloody draining, they do not need to be conscious. In Kosher a stunned animal would be considered injured, which is why stunning isn’t permitted for kosher slaughter.

Thank you - I appreciate your clarifying this.

smileladiesplease · 18/01/2023 10:33

No it's fact it is a cruel way to kill

OneTC · 18/01/2023 10:30

Simonjt · 18/01/2023 06:01

I’m not sure why you think organic/free range meat can’t be halal.

Organic free range meat is cuddled to death, surely everyone knows this 😅

Testingprof · 18/01/2023 10:29

Nimbostratus100 · 18/01/2023 10:23

  1. I often hear people complain that kosher slaughter is inhumane
  2. There are several orders of magnitude more Halal meat than Kosher

I have literally never heard of someone in real life complain about kosher meat. It matters not how many animals are killed using these methods. If you find the method inhumane that’s fine but there is a reason that halal meat is called out more and it’s Islamophobia. That’s the massive dog whistle.

The fact they’ll eat meat and dairy products in this type of venue but complain about halal meat shows that animal welfare is not at the forefront of their mind.

Vallmo47 · 18/01/2023 10:27

@Fifteenicecreams What your son said was so cute!! 😂♥️

I personally think you’re entitled to have an opinion. Maybe your colleague could have been a bit more tactful, but I’m sure the catering staff didn’t mind- they’ve been told to offer this option, doesn’t mean they would buy it themselves or heavily promote it.

Jazzy21 · 18/01/2023 10:27

It is a cruel way to kill an animal, and I don’t think having that opinion in isolation makes someone anti-Muslim. However I probably wouldn’t mention this in a work based setting, just as I’d steer away from any conversation that could be taken to heart or cause upset with a work colleague. I don’t have time for that!

Nimbostratus100 · 18/01/2023 10:24

I did not know that most UK Halal meat was stunned, and I am glad to hear it if so - I think a lot of my Muslim friends are of the belief that it is not stunned

Nimbostratus100 · 18/01/2023 10:23

Testingprof · 18/01/2023 10:19

Exactly. That’s the point the slaughter methods are similar except 95% of animals slaughtered for halal meat is stunned prior to being slaughter in comparison to 0% of animals for kosher meat. I’ve never heard of people complaining about kosher meat being inhumane. Why do you think that people complain about halal meat and not kosher?

  1. I often hear people complain that kosher slaughter is inhumane
  2. There are several orders of magnitude more Halal meat than Kosher
Testingprof · 18/01/2023 10:19

Nimbostratus100 · 18/01/2023 08:52

What are you talking about? The slaughter methods are similar, and they are normally spoken of together, the only difference being the amount of halal meat is many orders of magnitude greater than the amount of kosher meat

I have no idea what "disingenuous" means or "dog whistle"

Exactly. That’s the point the slaughter methods are similar except 95% of animals slaughtered for halal meat is stunned prior to being slaughter in comparison to 0% of animals for kosher meat. I’ve never heard of people complaining about kosher meat being inhumane. Why do you think that people complain about halal meat and not kosher?

Nimbostratus100 · 18/01/2023 10:17

Catnary · 18/01/2023 10:10

There was never any prospect of you saying that you were anything other than completely fine about it. But you’re missing my fundamental point. This is not about whether Brenda should or should not express this opinion. It is about her saying this loudly, in the workplace, when nobody asked her for her opinion and it was not relevant to her job.

And you may be quite happy to speak for all members of your religion, but I think I will continue to go about my professional life erring on the side of caution and pausing before making strident public criticisms of religious practices.

How do you feel about people criticising female genital mutilation, which happens in some fundamentally Christian communities.

Presumably you would hush up anyone criticising this, call them "strident" and say they shouldn't publicly criticise religious practices?

Your argument is that no "religious practice" can be discussed, or have an opinion expressed about it in public - that makes you in favour of keeping quiet about FGM?

Nimbostratus100 · 18/01/2023 10:13

Catnary · 18/01/2023 10:10

There was never any prospect of you saying that you were anything other than completely fine about it. But you’re missing my fundamental point. This is not about whether Brenda should or should not express this opinion. It is about her saying this loudly, in the workplace, when nobody asked her for her opinion and it was not relevant to her job.

And you may be quite happy to speak for all members of your religion, but I think I will continue to go about my professional life erring on the side of caution and pausing before making strident public criticisms of religious practices.

what are you talking about? You asked me if I would be OK about it, I told you I am, you say there was never any prospect of me saying I wasn't?

I am not speaking for all members of Judaism, and I never said I was, and if someone Jewish disagrees with me then we would have to agree to disagree.

You are not "erring on the side of caution" though, you are calling people offensive for having a point of view about a practice they think is cruel - that is very much NOT erring on the side of caution

Catnary · 18/01/2023 10:10

Nimbostratus100 · 18/01/2023 10:01

YES! absolutely 100% completely and totally fine

What I would find offensive is someone deciding on my behalf that someone else freely express that they find a particularly practice cruel

I just cant emphasise this enough

There is more than enough discrimination in the world that NEEDS calling out, and tackling, without muddying the waters and making people feel upset and defensive for being in trouble expressing completely fair and relevant points of view about a practice they find cruel.

That sort of thought policing just causes all sorts of issues.

Brenda is upset about something that is happening to her nephew, and she has every right to be upset and to say so. The fact that this is happening becasue he is Jewish is irrelevant, she would be equally upset if it was happening becasue it is normal practice for an American baby, or whatever,

To be honest, I think the most offensive thing hear is that you seem to think I am too delicate and easily bruised to hear this

Lots of Jews would agree with Brenda, by the way

There was never any prospect of you saying that you were anything other than completely fine about it. But you’re missing my fundamental point. This is not about whether Brenda should or should not express this opinion. It is about her saying this loudly, in the workplace, when nobody asked her for her opinion and it was not relevant to her job.

And you may be quite happy to speak for all members of your religion, but I think I will continue to go about my professional life erring on the side of caution and pausing before making strident public criticisms of religious practices.

OP posts:
saraclara · 18/01/2023 10:09

Assuming that her comment was only to you, not aimed at any Muslims nearby, and was purely about the slaughtering method, she wasn't being offensive.

I'm sure that I eat halal meat 'accidentally' fairly often. But I don't consciously buy it. Yes, eating meat at all is questionable, but the halal method crosses a line for me.

GerundTheBehemoth · 18/01/2023 10:01

TheLadyofShalott1 · 18/01/2023 02:45

I tried to be a vegetarian many years ago, I lasted 6 months. I have never, and can't ever, imagine me becoming a vegan. I don't think that any other type of "milk" on my cornflakes, or in my cup of tea, tastes acceptable, never mind nice. I also love cow and buffalow milk made cheeses.

But I do hate that calves are often taken away from their mums when they are less than a day old, I find that barbaric, so I wish that milk based products had to have printed on them whether they were left with their mums until normal weaning ages for cows, or taken straight away.

When I am shopping for eggs or poultry, I will usually only buy free range options, or barn bred ones, if temporarily needed while bird flu is around, and if apart from being in a barn, the birds are treated as well as is possible. However, on the rare occasions that I eat out at a restaurant, where you can't usuall tell where the meat has come from, I admit to just trying not to think about it.

I have very little spare money, but when I can give to any charities, it will usually be to ones concerned with the welfare of farmed animals (oh, and dog charities - except for the RSPCA). I don't go to Curry Houses any more, because I refuse to eat halal meat, and if anywhere else also admits to using halal meat, then I won't eat there either. My choices have nothing to do with any religion, and yes, if asked, I would be vocal about them.

If I ever knew anyone who is involved in feeding chicks into those awful crushing machines, I would be very tempted to tip them into it.

Here's a directory of UK dairies where calves stay with their mothers. There are not very many of them. This is important to me too. Most don't offer delivery but Old Hall Farm in Norfolk does so I buy milk from there. It's expensive but I use v little (and buy it in bulk and freeze it): www.cowcalfdairies.co.uk/