Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not know if this offensive?

315 replies

Catnary · 17/01/2023 22:49

Colleague in canteen queue today, I comment that the food looks tasty. She makes a face, points to the label and says “Yeah but look, I’m not eating that!”

Label says “Halal beef casserole”.

I say “but it’s just a different way of slaughtering the cow”

”Yeah I know, that’s what I mean, it’s SO cruel. I can’t have that on my conscience.”

This was all very loud and other people overheard. Neither colleague nor I are Muslim but many other colleagues are. I felt very uncomfortable, didn’t engage, and ordered the beef.

Is this just no different to a vegetarian declaring loudly that they couldn’t possibly be so cruel as to eat meat, or is it a slur on Muslims? It felt inappropriate, especially at work.

OP posts:
Emmamoo89 · 18/01/2023 17:23

Quinoawoman · 18/01/2023 06:09

Personally I don't think a humane way to slaughter an animal exists. I find it very odd when people who eat meat try to impose morality on the different levels of cruelty involved in slaughter or animal farming. You can't be an animal lover and eat them - it's just cognitive dissonance.

You can be an animal lover and eat meat

PoIIyPandemonium · 18/01/2023 16:58

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Cronkywonkycrinkywinky · 18/01/2023 16:42

CarolDunne · 17/01/2023 22:57

Halal slaughter is horrific

How so? What does it involve?

TheLadyofShalott1 · 18/01/2023 16:31

GerundTheBehemoth · 18/01/2023 10:01

Here's a directory of UK dairies where calves stay with their mothers. There are not very many of them. This is important to me too. Most don't offer delivery but Old Hall Farm in Norfolk does so I buy milk from there. It's expensive but I use v little (and buy it in bulk and freeze it): www.cowcalfdairies.co.uk/

Thank you so much for that Gerund, I will look them up straight away!

PassionateLady · 18/01/2023 15:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

veggiegirl9 · 18/01/2023 15:24

Out of interest how do you justify eating meat if you care about animal welfare? Have you seen how animals are killed or just oblivious.

LastOfTheChristmasWine · 18/01/2023 15:22

mamacattiva · 18/01/2023 15:04

I get my meat from here, their website answers a couple of questions on this thread:

www.willowbrookfarm.co.uk/halal-standard

That's an interesting link, and confirms my prior understanding that the farm welfare standards of halal meat is no higher than that of non halal meat (which is piss poor, especially for poultry) unlike what @SallyWD was saying.

"Halal monitoring bodies do not look at the animal's life, which means an animal can be raised in appalling factory conditions but still get halal certification. Furthermore even in the slaughter, both the HMC and the HFA, do not stipulate requirements to mitigate the litany of welfare abuses during the transportation and mass slaughter of the animals and they approve large scale abattoir slaughter processes. As a result we do not seek their certification."

If I were in the market for chicken breast (as a vegetarian, I'm.not) then I'd be just as happy to eat the Willowbrook halal free range chicken as any other free range chicken.

10HailMarys · 18/01/2023 15:08

I don't think her objection to halal slaughter is offensive in itself, but I do think it's offensive if halal slaughter is the ONLY animal welfare issue she cares about. If someone boycotts halal meat but doesn't boycott, for example, battery chickens, then there's definitely an agenda there that isn't really connected to animal welfare at all.

mamacattiva · 18/01/2023 15:04

I get my meat from here, their website answers a couple of questions on this thread:

www.willowbrookfarm.co.uk/halal-standard

LimeTwists · 18/01/2023 14:50

YABVU. How is her view on the meat any less valid than that of the Muslim who insists upon eating it? One thinks it’s cruel, the other thinks it’s necessary. You can’t allow all of the freedom of expression to only be exercised by the religious!

LastOfTheChristmasWine · 18/01/2023 14:34

SallyWD · 18/01/2023 14:10

I assume halal meat isn't labelled as "free range" because that's the whole point of it. It's a prerequisite of halal meat. For Muslims it's taken for granted that animals will have been raised this way.
I live in an area of Leeds which is home to a large number of Muslims. I have many Muslim colleagues, neighbours etc. Looking back I do now remember conversations about the animals being raised humanely with space to roam etc.

Like all private businesses, they're out to make as much money as possible. Free range designation would widen the appeal to welfare minded non Muslim meat eaters (if stunned)

However, the price is a really big hint. All prices taken from the Asda website

  • Shazaan Halal chicken breast £8.56 per kg
  • Asda own brand chicken breast £8.98 per kg (no specific welfare claims made, so it'll be low welfare)
  • Asda free range chicken breast £15 per kg
  • Asda organic free range chicken breast £18.80 per kg

The halal chicken breast is the cheapest of the lot; on a purely economic scalebhow on earth would they be producing free range halal chicken at those prices when regular free range chicken is so much more? The sums just don't add up.

SallyWD · 18/01/2023 14:10

LastOfTheChristmasWine · 18/01/2023 13:52

It's a US source, and worth knowing that in the UK & EU growth hormones are outright banned and antibiotics are only allowed if the animal is actually ill, not just as a daily prophylactic.

I strongly suspect that definitions around a "pure and natural" life has been stretched thin over time; I can't remember ever seeing halal meat labelled as "free range" (why wouldn't you give it that premium label if it conformed to those standards? I'm sure there are specialist suppliers doing it but certainly the halal butchers in my local Asda aren't advertising it, and nor are the local independent halal butcher) and it's often sold at prices so low that they are only achievable by intensive farming.

Cows and sheep are naturally herbivores, but chickens and other poultry are omnivores - they will eat insects and even occasionally catch and kill small mammals up to the size of mice. Any chicken living a free-range lifestyle will inevitably have an omnivorous diet.

I assume halal meat isn't labelled as "free range" because that's the whole point of it. It's a prerequisite of halal meat. For Muslims it's taken for granted that animals will have been raised this way.
I live in an area of Leeds which is home to a large number of Muslims. I have many Muslim colleagues, neighbours etc. Looking back I do now remember conversations about the animals being raised humanely with space to roam etc.

RoseslnTheHospital · 18/01/2023 13:59

@DogsDryWineAndCheese the aim of slaughtering animals is to make profit within the guidelines and laws they have to follow. Let's not pretend that humane treatment is the top priority.

The kind of halal meat provided by mass caterers is going to be from animals that were pre-stunned. If that's what you care about in terms of the "humane" treatment of animals then it makes no sense to object to the halal beef in this canteen meal.

LastOfTheChristmasWine · 18/01/2023 13:52

SallyWD · 18/01/2023 13:41

It certainly made me rethink halal meat too! There are loads of different websites that talk about it. Here's one example: wehalal.co/blog/halal-meat/

It's a US source, and worth knowing that in the UK & EU growth hormones are outright banned and antibiotics are only allowed if the animal is actually ill, not just as a daily prophylactic.

I strongly suspect that definitions around a "pure and natural" life has been stretched thin over time; I can't remember ever seeing halal meat labelled as "free range" (why wouldn't you give it that premium label if it conformed to those standards? I'm sure there are specialist suppliers doing it but certainly the halal butchers in my local Asda aren't advertising it, and nor are the local independent halal butcher) and it's often sold at prices so low that they are only achievable by intensive farming.

Cows and sheep are naturally herbivores, but chickens and other poultry are omnivores - they will eat insects and even occasionally catch and kill small mammals up to the size of mice. Any chicken living a free-range lifestyle will inevitably have an omnivorous diet.

SallyWD · 18/01/2023 13:41

saraclara · 18/01/2023 13:19

Also just read that there are strict rules for how animals are raised for halal meat. They are to live a "pure and natural" life, roaming freely and eating a vegetarian diet (as they would naturally). They can't be given antibiotics and growth hormones. They must be treated humanely.

That's really interesting @Sally090807 , and would certainly make me rethink my attitude towards buying halal meat. Do you have a link?

It certainly made me rethink halal meat too! There are loads of different websites that talk about it. Here's one example: wehalal.co/blog/halal-meat/

saraclara · 18/01/2023 13:19

Also just read that there are strict rules for how animals are raised for halal meat. They are to live a "pure and natural" life, roaming freely and eating a vegetarian diet (as they would naturally). They can't be given antibiotics and growth hormones. They must be treated humanely.

That's really interesting @Sally090807 , and would certainly make me rethink my attitude towards buying halal meat. Do you have a link?

Nebula277 · 18/01/2023 13:18

The latest Food Standards Agency figures show an estimate of 24.5 million animals are slaughtered without pre-stunning in 2022:

22 million meat chickens (2.3% of total slaughtered)

2.5 million sheep (23% of total slaughtered)

20 thousand cattle (1% of total slaughtered)

DogsDryWineAndCheese · 18/01/2023 13:13

RoseslnTheHospital · 18/01/2023 13:06

It's an incorrect opinion though. As has been repeatedly stated!

Even if we were to pretend that 95% were stunned beforehand, that leaves 5% unstunned…
I stand by Halal being cruel. Further to that, I don’t require my meat to have a religious based end. Be it an Islamic one, a Christian one, a Hindu one etc etc. and neither do the majority of the country. The importance is to be as humane as possible.
I stand completely by it being cruel (even if only 5% were killed unstunned).

Mark19735 · 18/01/2023 13:11

The other big divide, apart from the "is this thread about animal welfare or is it about racism" one, is almost more of a grammatical one.

There are people asking and opining on whether particular actions or words are, in themselves, offensive. There can be no offence given unless there is someone else who takes offence. Offensiveness is a subjective measure of upset or hurt as experienced by an observer, recipient or third party - it bears absolutely no relationship to the intent or motives or morality of the person making the comment or taking the action.

Intent is only relevant if those actions require an exploration of legal culpability for giving offence, and having done so unknowingly or unintentionally will be treated more leniently than, say, persistent and vindictive harassment. But this exploration does not negate or mitigate or qualify the offense that is taken. It is entirely up to the offended party to describe, explain, quantify and complain about how those actions made them feel. A second strand of the legal perspective is to ask whether it was reasonable for the offended party to be as upset as they were, and that too provides a potential defence against any criminal charges. But the words and actions remain offensive, regardless whether they are also criminal. Not all instances of racism are unlawful. But they remain instances of racism nonetheless.

So for all you racists out there - no one care what your intentions are. It's not always about you. You are, and continue to be, recognised as racists. Own it. If it bothers you that people think this about you, change the way you talk and act. If it doesn't ... well that sort of proves our point, doesn't it?

RoseslnTheHospital · 18/01/2023 13:06

DogsDryWineAndCheese · 18/01/2023 12:45

I’m offended that you’d be offended by her having her non-offensive (and completely correct!) opinion.
Life isn’t about being competitively offended - perhaps she was offended that the meat was halal?

It's an incorrect opinion though. As has been repeatedly stated!

Simonjt · 18/01/2023 12:59

SherbetDips · 18/01/2023 12:29

It’s not offensive, its her opinion and one she is allowed to have. I won’t eat halal meat because of how it’s slaughtered. British farming standards stun the animal before its death.

halal slits the animals throat and lets it beed out in agony. …

Are you aware that 95% of animals halal slaughtered in the UK are slaughtered to the british standards?

LadyKenya · 18/01/2023 12:49

Mark19735 · 18/01/2023 12:34

When the racists get called out for their racism, to them it feels like oppression.

The colleague was almost certainly racist. The only element of doubt would be if they were genuinely misinformed and mistakenly believed that halal = cruel and not halal = humane. That's clearly not true, but there is a very slight chance that the colleague was merely misinformed and did not therefore have any ill intentions in respect of racism or cultural insensitivity.

But them's your choices. Racist or Stupid. Take your pick.

(Oh, and also - the colleague is clearly not in a minority, either. This thread is evidence enough that both racism and stupidity are fairly commonplace and widespread)

This. I agree.

5128gap · 18/01/2023 12:48

The problem with consuming animal products of any type is the huge amount of cognitive dissonance required by 'animal lovers' to participate in the cruelty and exploitation it requires.
Many people cope with this by comparing down.
The non halal eater likes to consider themselves less cruel than the halal eater, the vegetarian less cruel than the meat eater....when in truth unless a person is vegan in diet and lifestyle, they have simply chosen the place on the cruelty continuem they can live with (or be in denial about) so no one is in a position to be judging anyone else.

DogsDryWineAndCheese · 18/01/2023 12:45

I’m offended that you’d be offended by her having her non-offensive (and completely correct!) opinion.
Life isn’t about being competitively offended - perhaps she was offended that the meat was halal?

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 18/01/2023 12:41

I don't think it's offensive.....no different from a veggie saying "no I'm not eating that it's got meat in it"

Swipe left for the next trending thread