Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not know if this offensive?

315 replies

Catnary · 17/01/2023 22:49

Colleague in canteen queue today, I comment that the food looks tasty. She makes a face, points to the label and says “Yeah but look, I’m not eating that!”

Label says “Halal beef casserole”.

I say “but it’s just a different way of slaughtering the cow”

”Yeah I know, that’s what I mean, it’s SO cruel. I can’t have that on my conscience.”

This was all very loud and other people overheard. Neither colleague nor I are Muslim but many other colleagues are. I felt very uncomfortable, didn’t engage, and ordered the beef.

Is this just no different to a vegetarian declaring loudly that they couldn’t possibly be so cruel as to eat meat, or is it a slur on Muslims? It felt inappropriate, especially at work.

OP posts:
LastOfTheChristmasWine · 20/01/2023 01:11

I'm sure halal slaughter methods were the most humane option 1500 years ago when Mohammed was around.

The prohibition on pork is also very practical - in a hot climate it will go off more quickly (likewise shellfish for kosher laws - same principle). With modern refrigerators, it's less of a practicality and more of a tradition.

But things have moved on in the last 1500 years. If Mohammed was around today, he'd probably still be after the most humane solution and would be mandating stunning.

BrokenBonesStixStones · 20/01/2023 01:00

I’m a vegetarian and I wouldn’t comment on what anybody else eats or try to force my opinion.

Halal slaughter does seem even more cruel than other methods though

SedatePixie · 20/01/2023 00:49

SallyWD · 19/01/2023 08:56

I assume you feel equally outraged about the treatment of NON-halal farm animals? Because I certainly do.

Well, that's good but if you're trying to say that killing an animal while still conscious and aware is as bad as killing a stunned animal who doesn't feel any pain, then you're way off beam!

Killing an animal in such a way as to cause maximum pain is fucking barbaric.

If you can't see the difference, next time you go in for an operation, tell them you'll have it without the anesthetic-you'll soon appreciate the difference.

PoIIyPandemonium · 19/01/2023 14:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

thedancingbear · 19/01/2023 14:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Fine, whatevs. Had to put up with people like you all my life. Thanks for outing yourself.

PoIIyPandemonium · 19/01/2023 13:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

thedancingbear · 19/01/2023 13:29

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

And if we think she's a bigot because of her views, tough shit.

You happy with that? Or does it only work in one direction?

Zebedee55 · 19/01/2023 09:15

I wouldn't eat Halal or Kosher meat, because I don't like the methods of slaughter. The methods are virtually the same, other than the prayer.

"One differentiation between Halal and Kosher is that before slaughter, Halal requires the praying to Allah. Kosher does not require a prayer to God before slaughtering."

I've got nothing against Muslims or Jews though.😗

SallyWD · 19/01/2023 08:56

SedatePixie · 18/01/2023 23:11

She is absolutely right and if people are offended by that-tough shit.

I'm guessing hey;re not as offended as the animal.

I assume you feel equally outraged about the treatment of NON-halal farm animals? Because I certainly do.

PoIIyPandemonium · 19/01/2023 08:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

SedatePixie · 18/01/2023 23:11

Catnary · 17/01/2023 22:49

Colleague in canteen queue today, I comment that the food looks tasty. She makes a face, points to the label and says “Yeah but look, I’m not eating that!”

Label says “Halal beef casserole”.

I say “but it’s just a different way of slaughtering the cow”

”Yeah I know, that’s what I mean, it’s SO cruel. I can’t have that on my conscience.”

This was all very loud and other people overheard. Neither colleague nor I are Muslim but many other colleagues are. I felt very uncomfortable, didn’t engage, and ordered the beef.

Is this just no different to a vegetarian declaring loudly that they couldn’t possibly be so cruel as to eat meat, or is it a slur on Muslims? It felt inappropriate, especially at work.

She is absolutely right and if people are offended by that-tough shit.

I'm guessing hey;re not as offended as the animal.

Pizzamyamour · 18/01/2023 20:23

Of course it’s offensive, I’d have reported to HR in your shoes.

Don’t forget AIBU (and MN in general) has a bit of a race issue so the vote won’t be representative of ‘normal’ views

Cronkywonkycrinkywinky · 18/01/2023 20:22

From The Guardian newspaper website

The Arabic word halal means permissible, and the rules of slaughter are based on Islamic law. The animal has to be alive and healthy, a Muslim has to perform the slaughter in the appropriate ritual manner, and the animal's throat must be cut by a sharp knife severing the carotid artery, jugular vein and windpipe in a single swipe. Blood must be drained out of the carcass.

About 40m cattle, sheep, pigs and calves and 900m poultry birds are killed in British abattoirs each year, according to a Food Standards Agency (FSA) report two years ago, and one estimate has suggested that 114m of these animals, including poultry, are killed using the halal method. The value of the market could be £2bn a year or more.

But contrary to what many assume, most animals killed by halal methods are stunned before slaughter. FSA estimates suggest that 88% of animals in the UK killed by halal methods were stunned beforehand in a way that many Muslims find religiously acceptable

Testingprof · 18/01/2023 20:07

MistyLuna · 18/01/2023 18:20

You say “It’s arguable that they do if they are not pre-stunned”

How do you know this? And how do you know that stunning doesn’t hurt them more?

Putting aside how animals feel when killed, how do you know that one method of slaughter isn’t healthier than the other?

People love throwing around a lot of second-hand unsubstantiated statements they read on FB & Twitter about how sunning animals is kinder than bleeding to death (personally, I’d rather bleed to death as I heard it’s just like passing out. I’d rather not be stunned, but that’s just a personal choice). But I’m left scratching my head how these people could possibly be so certain that stunning hurts less, or being vegan is healthier, etc.

The saying running around like a headless chicken exists for a reason, blood loss is not a quick death. If we’re talking about preferable deaths, apparently drowning is euphoric…

I said arguable, I never said with certainty one is better than the other, like I said though the death is a tiny part of animal welfare, what about the conditions they live in?

PenanceAdair · 18/01/2023 18:43

I find it hypocritical to condemn another method of meat eating/slaughtering when one also eats meat (not really knowing exactly how these animals lived and died). She was being ignorant, to say the least.

shrubgreen · 18/01/2023 18:27

DeFacto · 18/01/2023 02:33

Guaranteed she will be off to her local Indian restaurant for her chicken bhuna with rice at the weekend.

It’s not halal meat that irks her, it’s Muslims being catered for that pisses her off.

Let's be fair, her local 'Indian' wouldn't be halal or Muslim run. If it was 'Indian' it would be Hindu or Sikh.

What you perceive to be 'Indian' is most likely Bangladesh which is more aligned to Pakistan than India, most curry houses in the UK are Bangladeshi. Who are more Pakistani than Indian.

What twaddle. There are Indian Muslims and Bangladeshi Hindus.

Honestly, the confidence of some people spouting stuff on a subject they know pityingly little about...

NumberTheory · 18/01/2023 18:25

10HailMarys · 18/01/2023 15:08

I don't think her objection to halal slaughter is offensive in itself, but I do think it's offensive if halal slaughter is the ONLY animal welfare issue she cares about. If someone boycotts halal meat but doesn't boycott, for example, battery chickens, then there's definitely an agenda there that isn't really connected to animal welfare at all.

The agenda could simply be that she is offended by things she doesn’t like that have been brought to her attention. The sort of person who is incensed at news stories of unwanted kittens being drowned but doesn’t think about kittens being put down at an animal shelter, or of them starving to death if left in the wild, etc.

It’s not an informed position, but that doesn’t mean her motivation is Islamophobia.

Jedsnewstar · 18/01/2023 18:25

Patertater · 17/01/2023 23:57

Your colleague has a right to air her opinion. Whether it's welcome or not is another thing. Whether she's right or not is up for debate. If your Muslim colleagues heard that, then I'm guessing it might've caused offense so it was tackless and insensitive to say that. However, I believe no-one has a right not to be offended so people should be allowed to say what they want. It's just that there are many people out there who don't know when to be quiet, just as much as many people nowadays who are afraid of expressing themselves because they're worried about not being politically correct or upsetting the woke brigade.

So only people doing the offending have any rights? What a ridiculous idea.

For the record I find ‘Halal’ a horrific method and will avoid it as much as possible. Although I don’t eat much meat anyway.

The woman in question could have used basic tact. A simple ‘I don’t want to eat Halal’ quietly to respond to the op’s question would have been fine although even that was not necessary unless the op pushed. I also don’t agree with it being the standard option in schools etc. Stuff like this causes division needlessly.

Also terms like ‘woke brigade’ are used as a weapon to by the right wing media to shut down people who have thoughts and ideas that don’t align with their own ideology. I can’t take anyone seriously who used them like original thoughts.

MistyLuna · 18/01/2023 18:20

Testingprof · 18/01/2023 17:59

It’s arguable that they do if they are not pre-stunned. Which 100% of kosher meat is not pre-stunned. Tbh though the choice of slaughter is small fry when you look at how some (most) of these animals are kept. Shouldn’t we care more about the whole meat industry rather than just one religions practices for death?

You say “It’s arguable that they do if they are not pre-stunned”

How do you know this? And how do you know that stunning doesn’t hurt them more?

Putting aside how animals feel when killed, how do you know that one method of slaughter isn’t healthier than the other?

People love throwing around a lot of second-hand unsubstantiated statements they read on FB & Twitter about how sunning animals is kinder than bleeding to death (personally, I’d rather bleed to death as I heard it’s just like passing out. I’d rather not be stunned, but that’s just a personal choice). But I’m left scratching my head how these people could possibly be so certain that stunning hurts less, or being vegan is healthier, etc.

TheLadyofShalott1 · 18/01/2023 18:18

Very well said @QuinkWashable, thank you for wording it much better than I could!

Testingprof · 18/01/2023 18:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

This link has been incredibly helpful as I have been looking for raw milk for a little while and there is a small holding relatively close to me. Thanks @GerundTheBehemoth

Testingprof · 18/01/2023 17:59

VanillaSnap · 18/01/2023 17:45

It's more ignorance than hate. Animals do not suffer when slaughtered in the Jewish/Muslim manner. At least not any more than in the mainstream way.

It’s arguable that they do if they are not pre-stunned. Which 100% of kosher meat is not pre-stunned. Tbh though the choice of slaughter is small fry when you look at how some (most) of these animals are kept. Shouldn’t we care more about the whole meat industry rather than just one religions practices for death?

FairylightsandHygge · 18/01/2023 17:53

henrilechat · 17/01/2023 23:29

Is your colleague vegetarian? Or only eats organic meat or something? If she's quite happy to eat battery farmed chicken, then it seems likely to me she was being islamophobic. If she's an animal rights activist or something, then that's different.

Agree with this. There is so much ignorance about halal meat and most people just jump on the bandwagon of what our tabloids feed us regarding it, often a load of nonsense but great at getting people to squabble amongst themselves.
I bet the woman moaning about halal meat happily eats eggs from caged hens. It is bigoted it.

VanillaSnap · 18/01/2023 17:45

It's more ignorance than hate. Animals do not suffer when slaughtered in the Jewish/Muslim manner. At least not any more than in the mainstream way.

MistyLuna · 18/01/2023 17:45

AnneLovesGilbert · 17/01/2023 22:53

You seem sure it is offensive. I’m a lifelong vegetarian and think eating meat is unnecessary so I don’t really care how the animal that’s been killed so you can eat it died. None of it’s okay.

But cultural sensitivities aren’t a reason not to object to inhumane practices and there are plenty of things done in the name of religion I object to and would do so out loud.

P.S. Hitler was not religious, but he was a vegetarian.

Hitler did lots of terrible, inhumane things, including gassing millions of children to death and torturing millions of others to death.

Communism has nothing to do with religion. It’s a political ideology. It caused A LOT of suffering and pain. Under Stalin, hundreds of thousands were killed in cold blood because he was merely suspicious that they may oppose him. Stalin was anything but religious.

Slavery was something that went on for hundreds of years, it involved many cruel inhumane practices. The people and countries that enslaved Africans did it for money, not religion.

I can go on, but you get the picture, I hope. Anything — political ideology, philosophy, religion, etc. — can twisted by someone and used to do terrible things. Religion is no exception.

Second, there’s a holier-than-thou attitude among certain individuals in society who like to point the finger at others and yet fail to see their own flaws. I have never hung myself, allowed myself to be stunned to death, or known anyone to have bled to death and come back to say how it feels. I don’t know of any scientists who’ve done reliable studies that can show whether passing out due to blood loss is worse or whether being stunned hurts more. A scientist worth his/or her salt will NOT tell you they know the answer because the scientific method is based on something called falsification, and testing for wether “stunning will hurt more than bleeding to death” will involve doing it and then asking the person how painful it was — something that’s not going to happen if the person is dead!

Third, I’ve looked at supermarket shelves and seen the explosion of new “vegan” products. They are all super processed. I wonder how much oil, gas & CO2 was wasted to deliver that nice vegan sausage on someone’s plate. Just because someone’s vegetarian it does t mean they’re a nice or good person (again, the Hitler example).

So the point of my rant is that it’s very fashionable these days for people to go “Halal meat is cruel” or “vegetarians are saving the planet”. The truth is, these people are both hypocrites and ignorant. They’re probably not the brightest nor the kindest of people.

@Catnary YANUB — this girl is a bit dim and mean. Sorry if she’s a friend.