Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not know if this offensive?

315 replies

Catnary · 17/01/2023 22:49

Colleague in canteen queue today, I comment that the food looks tasty. She makes a face, points to the label and says “Yeah but look, I’m not eating that!”

Label says “Halal beef casserole”.

I say “but it’s just a different way of slaughtering the cow”

”Yeah I know, that’s what I mean, it’s SO cruel. I can’t have that on my conscience.”

This was all very loud and other people overheard. Neither colleague nor I are Muslim but many other colleagues are. I felt very uncomfortable, didn’t engage, and ordered the beef.

Is this just no different to a vegetarian declaring loudly that they couldn’t possibly be so cruel as to eat meat, or is it a slur on Muslims? It felt inappropriate, especially at work.

OP posts:
Catnary · 18/01/2023 00:11

Patertater · 17/01/2023 23:57

Your colleague has a right to air her opinion. Whether it's welcome or not is another thing. Whether she's right or not is up for debate. If your Muslim colleagues heard that, then I'm guessing it might've caused offense so it was tackless and insensitive to say that. However, I believe no-one has a right not to be offended so people should be allowed to say what they want. It's just that there are many people out there who don't know when to be quiet, just as much as many people nowadays who are afraid of expressing themselves because they're worried about not being politically correct or upsetting the woke brigade.

Ha , yes, I think that is about right actually (but knowing when to be quiet). It was mostly rude, in a professional environment, I suppose, rather than offensive.

OP posts:
larchforest · 18/01/2023 00:11

If the practices of any faith or tradition causes unnecessary suffering to any living creature, then I am not in favour of that practice, and will say so.

Method of slaughter, bullfighting, Palio of Siena, rodeos, none of them are necessary in a modern society.

AlwaysAReason · 18/01/2023 00:09

TrickorTreacle · 17/01/2023 23:55

I find veganism more offensive tbh, due to how militant the cohort is. It's pushes the politics and cult of it more so than the health benefits of it.

I have a relative who is vegan and they are very hard work... for instance if anyone (of the family) dares say anything like "I love dogs!" around them they will jump on them and ask if they eat meat and if not, how they can claim to love any animals...
I think it's just we only hear the vocal militant ones talking about it. Im sure the majority of vegans just keep quiet and eat their choice of food without telling everybody they should be vegan too!

ANonnyMouse1 · 18/01/2023 00:05

TrickorTreacle · 17/01/2023 23:55

I find veganism more offensive tbh, due to how militant the cohort is. It's pushes the politics and cult of it more so than the health benefits of it.

Most vegans aren’t vegan for health reasons though.

Mamaneedsadrink · 18/01/2023 00:00

As a meateater myself, I feel anyone criticising a way of killing meat that eats meat themselves is a bit of a hypocrite. I also feel vegans are hypocrites who wear leather etc.

Patertater · 17/01/2023 23:57

Your colleague has a right to air her opinion. Whether it's welcome or not is another thing. Whether she's right or not is up for debate. If your Muslim colleagues heard that, then I'm guessing it might've caused offense so it was tackless and insensitive to say that. However, I believe no-one has a right not to be offended so people should be allowed to say what they want. It's just that there are many people out there who don't know when to be quiet, just as much as many people nowadays who are afraid of expressing themselves because they're worried about not being politically correct or upsetting the woke brigade.

henrilechat · 17/01/2023 23:57

Francisca459 · 17/01/2023 23:43

It's a horrific method of slaughter and most people who try to be politically correct about it wouldn't even dare to see a video of it. It would literally sicken them. So yes, YABU, and it is not your job to be offended on behalf of other people!

Most methods of slaughter are horrific though aren't they. Most people would struggle to watch any footage from a slaughterhouse, halal or otherwise. If you only speak out about the cruelty of halal slaughter, it does seem more like the religion that's the issue, rather than animal rights.
It was either intended to offend or to show he bigotry. It's a bit of a dog whistle isn't it?

StalkedByASpider · 17/01/2023 23:55

I've always avoided halal meat because there's no guarantee of a humane slaughter.

It's not hypocritical to eat meat, yet still want to avoid an animal suffering unnecessarily.

@Mark19735 gave some examples above and I avoid all of those too. I couldn't eat a lobster that's been boiled alive, or crab. I just couldn't. I always buy free range eggs. And if my understanding is correct then kosher meat is worse than halal in terms of cruelty, so I avoid that too.

It's not a comment on the religion whatsoever. I just don't agree with the slaughter methods. But people will jump to conclusions....

TrickorTreacle · 17/01/2023 23:55

I find veganism more offensive tbh, due to how militant the cohort is. It's pushes the politics and cult of it more so than the health benefits of it.

AlwaysAReason · 17/01/2023 23:46

Most Halal meat in the UK that you buy from supermarkets etc is killed in the same manner as all other meat with a tape playing of prayers.
The whole meat industry is cruel, so I think she is being a bit picky over it.

Francisca459 · 17/01/2023 23:43

It's a horrific method of slaughter and most people who try to be politically correct about it wouldn't even dare to see a video of it. It would literally sicken them. So yes, YABU, and it is not your job to be offended on behalf of other people!

DuplicateUserName · 17/01/2023 23:42

*not know

DiddyHeck · 17/01/2023 23:42

Catnary · 17/01/2023 23:21

And would you state that loudly in public? That’s my question, not about whether her opinion was valid or not.

Your question was 'AIBU to no know if this is offensive'.

And there's no single answer really. What offends one person won't offend another.

This thread has been done to death over the years and the opinions are always a mix of 'it's cruel', 'all meat eating is cruel', 'it's no more cruel than other methods of slaughter' and 'it's anti muslim to dislike halal slaughter'.

Blueberrywitch · 17/01/2023 23:38

It is cruel on an industrial scale, I think it was actually less cruel historically. I think your opinion that she shouldn’t be free to say it’s cruel in public is an example of “cancel culture” and word policing that’s wrong with today.

She didn’t say anything about Muslim people but rather about a particular method of animal slaughter. I think that’s fine, she can have an opinion and speak it loudly if she wants. Free speech and all that!

But I can see why you were stressed as we are pretty primed to be offended/worry about people being offended these days.

Mark19735 · 17/01/2023 23:34

If your colleague would say the same about kosher meat, or lobster, or factory-farmed chickens and eggs, then perhaps it's fair enough. But I suspect your colleague is less vocal about this.

So actually, it's just like Tommy Robinson raging about nine Asian paedophiles in Rochdale, but saying absolutely nothing at all about the 1,323 white people convicted of sex offences against minors that same year. It's not about the crimes against women and children - it's about the ethnicity of the perpetrator. That's what makes him racist. And using the same logic, so is your colleague.

Catnary · 17/01/2023 23:33

henrilechat · 17/01/2023 23:29

Is your colleague vegetarian? Or only eats organic meat or something? If she's quite happy to eat battery farmed chicken, then it seems likely to me she was being islamophobic. If she's an animal rights activist or something, then that's different.

I have worked with her for about 10 years and seen her eat all sorts of meat, never heard her express a view on animal cruelty before.

OP posts:
Daisybuttercup12345 · 17/01/2023 23:31

Disgusting anyway. Very cruel.
Stop looking for things to be offended about!!

henrilechat · 17/01/2023 23:29

Is your colleague vegetarian? Or only eats organic meat or something? If she's quite happy to eat battery farmed chicken, then it seems likely to me she was being islamophobic. If she's an animal rights activist or something, then that's different.

Catnary · 17/01/2023 23:21

And would you state that loudly in public? That’s my question, not about whether her opinion was valid or not.

OP posts:
1994girl · 17/01/2023 23:19

I agree with the other woman.

Kanaloa · 17/01/2023 23:12

I think it’s a bit rich to be queuing up to eat meat then loudly denigrate other people for eating meat that was killed ‘cruelly.’ If you’re happy for animals to be killed for you to eat I don’t think you can really take the high ground if I’m honest.

Fifteenicecreams · 17/01/2023 23:09

When my son was in year 1 we had the option for the Xmas lunch of halal or non halal. We aren’t Muslim so chose non halal. For the next year he told us every week that he always made sure the dinner ladies have him a non halal jacket potato !!! He knew there was something important about some food being halal or non halal but thought it extended to potatoes as well 😂

RoseslnTheHospital · 17/01/2023 23:08

It's an ignorant comment that specifically targets one religion. The very large majority of animals killed for halal meat are stunned before being killed. For kosher meat, which is a smaller number, the animals are not stunned. So it makes little sense to object to halal meat in general. And it makes the assumption that all other slaughter processes are carried out correctly, which they often are not, causing distress to animals. And either way, the animal is still being killed in a slaughterhouse, which is distressing in itself for the animals and, you know, they're killed.

Catnary · 17/01/2023 23:07

I think I also read that most schools now serve halal meat as standard, most non-Muslims have no issue with that. And non-Muslims eat halal every time they go for a curry!

OP posts:
MiaMoor · 17/01/2023 23:07

I believe over 95% of halal meat is stunned before slaughter.

Swipe left for the next trending thread