Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if parenting really was easier in the past?

343 replies

germanbight · 17/01/2023 19:46

My beloved grandma, who lived on a small farm and really ran it alone, always used to tut at toddlers/small children who were being naughty out and about and always told me that when she had her children it was all much simpler— especially in the baby phase.

Apparently routine kept all 4 children perfect from baby-hood. Baby fed every three hours until it slept through, all children off for an afternoon nap after dinner and bedtime a prompt 7:30 until they were 10. She always used to say that now parents adapt to fit the baby in their lives, but when she was having children they had to adapt to her life.

I just don’t see how it could’ve run on clockwork like that. Was it really that much easier? Just a case of endless CIO?

OP posts:
Museya15 · 18/01/2023 07:54

Back then if you got hit by a teacher, my mum would always say, "what did YOU do to deserve that!!"

Nottodaty · 18/01/2023 07:50

Both my parents talk of being hit as a way of controlling children - both have very different upbringings as well, but seemingly was the norm.

The stay at home mum again - seemingly an again a control thing. But if you where poor you worked as did both my Granny’s and my Great Granny.

I asked my Granny was it easier - she says no it was different. Children had more freedom younger, but also meant in a more vulnerable position. She remembers going out to work leaving her eldest at 9 to look after the other 4 younger children - but she knew any issues the neighbours would help rather than judge. Living in London she was worried her boys would join a gang (this is the 50/60) she wanted to keep them safe - but even she says it’s hard to know what they were up to!

WhatNoRaisins · 18/01/2023 07:44

Nowadays we're more aware of the psychology of children and the amount we need to invest in their development. The problem is that many of us don't have the village to make it manageable and it's mums mental health that suffers.

KatieB55 · 18/01/2023 07:32

My mother didn't drive so we walked to the shops every other day with one in the pram, one on pram seat and one walking. She didn't have a washing machine so hand washed & soaked terry nappies. I think it was pretty hard work. I don't ever remember her walking me to/from school and my brother (1 year older) just went off with his friends. My other brother (1 year younger) got hit by a car crossing the road on the walk home from school when he was far too young to be crossing a road by himself! Different times.
I think parents today have different challenges with phones/internet/drugs etc

Lilyhatesjaz · 18/01/2023 07:22

I was born in the 60s We were out and about on our own a lot but it felt safe we were normally in a group of kids and although parents were working we knew where to go in an emergency.
My parents had a lot of time for us my Dad worked long hours but always had time for a bedtime story.
My mum used to take us to the beach in the summer often with neighbours kids tagging along.
I have lots of memories of family board games and card games.
Sunday walks with my Dad chasing us and throwing fir cones.
Helping my Mum on the allotment or collecting fire wood. Baking together.
Our home was full of love.
My Gran also played a huge part in my life.
This thread has been good for me as after losing both parents it's been good to think of my childhood rather than remembering my poor Mum with dementia,which is so often in my mind.

watchfulwishes · 18/01/2023 06:49

@DifficultBloodyWoman Many children were hit, and plenty were genuinely beaten, in a way/to an extent we would consider abuse now.

Hitting/beating children was of no interest to the authorities until relatively recently.

Newuser82 · 18/01/2023 06:48

blubberball · 17/01/2023 19:54

@ifoundthebread That's true actually. I remember me and my friends not being allowed in parent's houses during the day. We were sent out to play, and told not to come in until lunch or tea time. The mum could then get jobs done in the house. This was the late 80s/early 90s

Yes! That's what we did!

bloodyeverlastinghell · 18/01/2023 06:46

blubberball · 17/01/2023 19:54

@ifoundthebread That's true actually. I remember me and my friends not being allowed in parent's houses during the day. We were sent out to play, and told not to come in until lunch or tea time. The mum could then get jobs done in the house. This was the late 80s/early 90s

I’d agree with this. Completely normal to be booted out and return for meals. Lots of children about, no parental supervision. In cold weather we’d walk to local library ( a mile) or to local pool ( a mile and a half) if we were given money. Primary school aged.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 18/01/2023 06:36

I find it interesting that several posters have used the phrase ‘beaten into submission’ and more have echoed that sentiment.

Whether you are using it literally or figuratively, do you really believe that most/the majority of children fitted into or around their parents’ lives by force?

In my, albeit fuzzy, recollection of my childhood, I fitted around my parents but it wasn’t a hardship in any way. It was just an adult centred life. And it was perfectly normal. When I misbehaved, there would be consequences such as having to leave the shop or restaurant but then I would learn not to repeat that behaviour. So my behaviour was pretty good and also improved with time.

I really don’t consider that being beaten into submission.

TheLastDreamOfTheOak · 18/01/2023 06:35

Don't know if it was easier-certainly much more manual Labour. But different and maybe a bit more simple. Less to think about in terms of invisible threats to children (the insidious parts of the internet, more freely available harmful things in society. Granny wasn't worrying about county lines, online grooming, pro-ana content and vapes etc). Less comparing yourself to other parents. Less pressure to look 'hot' and have a meaningful hobby and all the stuff we judge ourselves on now. Less expectation or need to 'have it all' or to Work and run a home. On balance at this point in my life I think jd take it!

Bumpitybumper · 18/01/2023 06:31

It depends on what you classify as 'parenting' as to whether you think it was easier or harder in the past. Also it depends on what era we are talking about.

The domestic aspects of everyday life would have been undoubtedly harder in the past and adding more people to the mix would have made it harder still. Basic things like washing clothes, cooking absolutely everything from scratch, getting groceries etc would have been more more challenging than today. There was also a greater emphasis on keeping an immaculate house and women were routinely shamed for not having a clean front door step or windows etc.

The actually 'looking after the child' element of parenting does seem easier. Expectations were lower and things like enrichment, safety and education were often valued less. Parents weren't expected to cart the children around to numerous extracurricular activities or help them with mounds of homework. Tummy time etc wasn't a thing and children were really expected to just get on with it without hassling parents too much.

I think overall that actual parenting is much harder today. The practical aspects of keeping a house were harder back then but generally this was considered the vocation of the woman. Now domestic chores aren't really factored into life at all and women are expected to work outside the home, be totally involved parents and keep on top of domestic chores. I do though think there was a very easy era for some mothers in the 80s/90s (when I was born) when the modern domestic appliances were common place but societal expectations of parenting were rooted in the past and intensive parenting was less of a thing. I think being a SAHM in that era was generally pretty easy.

Quinoawoman · 18/01/2023 06:24

She probably just got lucky and had easy kids. Mine have always been quite routined from about 6 months onwards, just naturally. Not all kids are like that.

I do think parenting in general might have been easier in the past.

  • more of a village around as people didn't typically move really far away from parents/family as much (especially pre industrial revolution
  • no social media to make you fear using your intuition to parent
  • kids just weren't expected to be in adult spaces as much so the standards of good behaviour was different
  • fewer safety concerns so kids just went out to play for hours and hours
  • not as much pressure to drag them to a million different clubs, activities and playdates and entertain them for hours on end

But also

  • higher infant mortality
  • more labour intensive to complete domestic tasks
  • no guidance on parentig apart from how your own parents did it
  • more interference from objectionable mothers in law
ancientgran · 18/01/2023 06:21

WandaWonder · 18/01/2023 06:17

I do agree with you, to a point, but I do find this a little dramatic

No one knows how people felt in the past and I will not try and guess how people felt back then to now

It might seem dramatic but as I said I remember my poor aunt when her baby died and my gran who cut herself off from everyone for a week a Christmas because of over 40 years of mourning her dead child so to be told "they" didn't feel like us is painful.

WandaWonder · 18/01/2023 06:17

ancientgran · 18/01/2023 05:53

I'm sitting here in tears, thinking of the mothers of the past being written off as callous as the death of a child not meaning as much to them as it would to anyone now.

I think this thread should be taken down because of that post. I'm truly horrified at the self satisfied nature if that is how modern women think.

I do agree with you, to a point, but I do find this a little dramatic

No one knows how people felt in the past and I will not try and guess how people felt back then to now

ancientgran · 18/01/2023 05:53

I'm sitting here in tears, thinking of the mothers of the past being written off as callous as the death of a child not meaning as much to them as it would to anyone now.

I think this thread should be taken down because of that post. I'm truly horrified at the self satisfied nature if that is how modern women think.

Stunningscreamer · 18/01/2023 05:53

MrsHughesPinny · 17/01/2023 20:26

When I was under 10 (1980s) Mums (mine or friends/family) never really interacted with children like we’re expected to now. We were told to go away and play and that’s what we did! If we said we were bored we were told “only boring people get bored, find something to do!” That really stuck with me! 😂

My Mum used to tell me repeatedly when DS was small that I was spoiling him by answering him immediately when he interrupted or asked me something. She’d just say “adults are talking now, unless you’re bleeding it can wait!”

Just a different time and set of expectations.

That's true.

Also there were more people around to help. So we would go to grandparents, aunts, family friends. There were lots of people who would look after us, so you didn't need to have babysitters or childminders as much. We used to play in each other's houses or gardens so they never had to entertain us, and just wouldn't have expected to have to, either.

Another thing was that adults were more scary and intimidating. Everyone used to tell you off all the time from people in shops, friends of parents, the park keeper, teachers, everyone. So there was an idea of a certain standard of behaviour which made it easier to discipline children, I think. Not saying this is a good thing though. I hated being scared all the time, and it meant if you didn't have loving parents you didn't get affection or attention from anyone.

ancientgran · 18/01/2023 05:51

JoonT · 17/01/2023 22:03

Possibly, but only because people were more callous. They had lots of kids and, when they weren’t at school, kicked them out the house and told them not to come home until dinner. OK, bit of a stereotype, but not far off the mark. Children frequently died in accidents. It was really common. Brian Blessed, in his (brilliant) autobiography about growing up in 1930s Yorkshire, recalls several little friends who were killed. One drowned in a village pond, another was hit by a car. My grandfather (who grew up in Norfolk in the 1930s) used to talk about this as well - how brutal people were to children, and how common it was for children to be killed. He could remember several little friends who died - one fell out of a tree and broke his neck, another drowned, etc. I don’t mean that people were indifferent, or that they didn’t love their children, but they were less sentimental and less patient. Maybe parenting is harder today because we invest so much in our kids.

I remember my aunt having a still birth in the 50s. I remember her and my uncle and how heart broken they were, I remember the whole family in shock and my baby brother being held very close to my mum as she was frightened to put him down. I remember my gran, who had 13 kids, being in shock.

I don't think people were brutal, I don't think people took the death of a child any easier than they do today. I can remember my gran telling me about a woman in her village in Ireland, her baby died in the 1930s and the mother committed suicide. My gran had a toddler die in the 30s, it was Christmas and she never celebrated Christmas again in her life, even in her late 70s Christmas was unbearable because of the memories.

I think your view is horrible to be honest.

ancientgran · 18/01/2023 05:42

Blossomtoes · 17/01/2023 23:30

The nappies weren’t that bad. I was a very, very sad person as I took great pleasure in a line full of snowy white nappies flapping in the wind.

Yes it was lovely on a nice sunny day, unfortunately in the UK not all days are like that. On the rainy day if you were living in a small flat surrounded by wet nappies it wasn't much fun. Particularly if you didn't have a spin dryer, I could never squeeze them enough so you didn't end up with them dripping.

LlynTegid · 18/01/2023 05:33

Children at any age did not have the internet and mobile phones and so were escaping any bad things from school etc, and probably this made parenting easier. Less bad influences I think.

magicthree · 18/01/2023 05:25

Also, regarding the "out all day" style of parenting in the past. None of the kids in my town just took off wherever they liked, their parents generally knew where they were. We used to play with our friends at their houses - outside generally - they would come to ours, we went to the park etc., went to the swimming pool in summer, roamed the cemetery (yes, that was a thing!), went to the shops. There was a lot more freedom to come and go, but we weren't randomly wandering around. However, we certainly weren't constantly taken to organised activities, and had to make our own fun.

magicthree · 18/01/2023 05:18

Devices are definitely the lesser of evils, I just notice a difference in my child's behaviour. I'd prefer it if toys, trampolines, skipping ropes, etc. were played with and preferred more. Independent play is important too.

I had children living over the back fence from me a few years ago - the youngest is probably 18/19 now - and they were always outside, winter and summer. They had a trampoline, a pool, they played football, they climbed trees (and had a tree house), they had a couple of dogs, and I loved listening to them. It reminded me so much of my childhood, but sadly it seems to be the exception rather than the rule.

Yoppi · 18/01/2023 03:07

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 17/01/2023 23:06

With devices, on demand, etc, children don't know how to be bored and find stuff to do within the home or garden themselves

Children's worlds are a lot smaller now. It's easy to say "in my day we went out the house at 8am and came home at 6pm from 4 years old"

Do that now and social services would be at the door. Schools would log safeguarding concerns and, most likely, the kids would be at risk of being run over, exposed to by the many perverts that roam the streets or stumble upon people on Spice in the street.

It's simply not possible for them to be out and about as much as kids in the 70s or whenever were.

Thank fuck for devices tbh. I'd argue more active parenting has to happen now as there is no "out all day" option.

I don't disagree with you. Whilst that's how it was when I was growing up, my mother never chucked me out. I think I was probably about 10 before I walked to the end of the road alone.

Devices are definitely the lesser of evils, I just notice a difference in my child's behaviour. I'd prefer it if toys, trampolines, skipping ropes, etc. were played with and preferred more. Independent play is important too.

PuzzleMonster · 18/01/2023 03:03

Iam4eels · 17/01/2023 20:47

RE: child deaths.

Mortality rate for children age 1yr-15yrs now is around 789 a year (infant mortality is recorded separately). In 1981 it averaged over 3000 a year.

Yep. And given population growth in the intervening period the percentage difference is huge.

I remember three children I knew when I was younger who died tragically. Each death was totally preventable and wouldn't have happened if their parents had been looking after them.

PuzzleMonster · 18/01/2023 02:50

germanbight · 17/01/2023 19:46

My beloved grandma, who lived on a small farm and really ran it alone, always used to tut at toddlers/small children who were being naughty out and about and always told me that when she had her children it was all much simpler— especially in the baby phase.

Apparently routine kept all 4 children perfect from baby-hood. Baby fed every three hours until it slept through, all children off for an afternoon nap after dinner and bedtime a prompt 7:30 until they were 10. She always used to say that now parents adapt to fit the baby in their lives, but when she was having children they had to adapt to her life.

I just don’t see how it could’ve run on clockwork like that. Was it really that much easier? Just a case of endless CIO?

And what happened if the babies were hungry and crying before the three-hourly scheduled feed? Or did not want to nap at the scheduled time? Or did not in fact sleep through and woke up and cried?

Were they just ignored?

Basically her complaint is that it's now frowned upon to be abusive to children and that parents are expected to meet their children's needs. This kind of "criticism" hopefully comes from a place of shame for the neglect and abuse of children in previous generations.

Mamaneedsadrink · 18/01/2023 02:42

I doubt it with no modern appliances or conveniences and the mothers expected to do everything. I'm sure everyone was alot more judgemental too