Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if parenting really was easier in the past?

343 replies

germanbight · 17/01/2023 19:46

My beloved grandma, who lived on a small farm and really ran it alone, always used to tut at toddlers/small children who were being naughty out and about and always told me that when she had her children it was all much simpler— especially in the baby phase.

Apparently routine kept all 4 children perfect from baby-hood. Baby fed every three hours until it slept through, all children off for an afternoon nap after dinner and bedtime a prompt 7:30 until they were 10. She always used to say that now parents adapt to fit the baby in their lives, but when she was having children they had to adapt to her life.

I just don’t see how it could’ve run on clockwork like that. Was it really that much easier? Just a case of endless CIO?

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 18/01/2023 10:36

Getinajollymood · 18/01/2023 10:26

But they weren’t, @Blossomtoes . Rates of illiteracy were very high. Special needs were not provided for.

It depends obviously when ‘in the past’ we are talking about, but for preschool children who are unlikely to be reading independently, their knowledge of the world is going to be extremely limited if they don’t get out in it.

I think children ‘just be’ plenty, to be honest - but spending most of the week in the same four walls is pretty miserable for everyone.

I want my children to see the seasons change and to be able to identify the different colours and rhythms of the year. I want them to know about nature and to be able to recognise birds, ducks, wildlife. I used to love pond dipping as a little girl. I want them to know about their immediate environment and also the world beyond it.

There is time for playing independently with toys but all the time? Really?

I want my children to see the seasons change and to be able to identify the different colours and rhythms of the year. I want them to know about nature and to be able to recognise birds, ducks, wildlife.

They’re not going to get that from soft play and petting farms. Children who live in rural or semi rural environments get all that anyway. Do you think nobody older than you loves nature? My son could identify all the garden birds before he started school from watching them on granny’s bird table.

The current parenting style is clearly something you believe in but it’s not the only way or inherently better than the way it was done in the past. It’s different and only time will tell if it’s better.

Yesthatismychildsigh · 18/01/2023 10:34

Smutty? *shitty parenting.

Yesthatismychildsigh · 18/01/2023 10:31

blubberball · 17/01/2023 19:54

@ifoundthebread That's true actually. I remember me and my friends not being allowed in parent's houses during the day. We were sent out to play, and told not to come in until lunch or tea time. The mum could then get jobs done in the house. This was the late 80s/early 90s

That certainly wasn’t the norm anywhere I lived. That’s just smutty parenting.

yorkshirepudsx · 18/01/2023 10:30

@knittingaddict really annoys me sometimes, I just posted in AIBU actually about something similar, but so many people overshare.

We all have good days and bad days and being a parent is no walk in the park (unless I decide to go for a walk in the park with the kids and even then it can be a shit show hahah)

But I never plaster it all on social media, I don't want people knowing what I'm doing and when, etc

But I will admit I've found myself guilty of looking on Facebook/Instagram, and seeing these 'perfect' mums, that have the house spotless, they have a full face of makeup, lovely hair, 100 things planned for the kids and every meal prepped until 2032, and for a split second I think "how do they do it & why can't I be like this " - then I have to remind myself that it won't always be like that for them and they only share the good parts. And I have to think to myself "Behind their camera is a massive pile of washing, their makeup is 50% from yesterday and 50% filters, that song on their video is to drown out their toddler having a meltdown it's okay, you've got this" 🙈🤣

ivykaty44 · 18/01/2023 10:29

WhatNoRaisins

i used to take myself to the park, I would have been around 7 years old and it was approximately just over quarter of a mile. It wasn’t unusual to go to the park with friends or on your own

knittingaddict · 18/01/2023 10:28

Dixiechickonhols · 18/01/2023 10:11

Definitely less pressure to do as much and less stuff.
Early 80s, nice suburban childhood.
But very much walk to local school, walk home. Have tea. Play and bed.
I went to brownies and had swimming lessons at one point but not lots of activities.
Tea very much of the it’s Monday it’s x, it’s Tuesday it’s y at same time each night at table.
Everyone had same striped buggy and sandals in summer.
Weekends. Cartoons in morning. Went shopping. Tea at grandparents. Sunday saw other grandparents, Roast dinner, Sunday school and toast for tea, bath and bed.
Yes we had trips but in holidays. There wasn’t pressure to be out constantly doing exciting things.
For a child it’s very comforting to have a very settled routine.
Lots of exercise. Walking everywhere. So walk to shops, walk older siblings to school.

That's interesting because I had my children in the 80's and our lives were very different to that.

No set weekly menus. Would eat out sometimes.

Went out at the weekends and did all sorts of activities - National Trust, fruit picking, animal and farm parks, visiting local attractions.

Our weekday routine was similar to yours, but not set in stone. The rest was very different.

WhatNoRaisins · 18/01/2023 10:27

I imagine these outings with small children wouldn't have been needed in the days when small children played out without their parents supervision. For me staying in all days with small children just doesn't work even with a lot of TV time. I prefer to do something free like the park if I can.

ivykaty44 · 18/01/2023 10:26

She always used to say that now parents adapt to fit the baby in their lives, but when she was having children they had to adapt to her life.

that’s how I remember life in the 1960s & 1970s

i think routine was the crux of the matter though , which today doesn’t seem to happen.

life was in some ways simpler

but even now my grandchildren seem to be harder work than my own D.C. for their mother. Im not sure why though? Did I have very easy babies and I had to be strict as I was a line parent

Getinajollymood · 18/01/2023 10:26

But they weren’t, @Blossomtoes . Rates of illiteracy were very high. Special needs were not provided for.

It depends obviously when ‘in the past’ we are talking about, but for preschool children who are unlikely to be reading independently, their knowledge of the world is going to be extremely limited if they don’t get out in it.

I think children ‘just be’ plenty, to be honest - but spending most of the week in the same four walls is pretty miserable for everyone.

I want my children to see the seasons change and to be able to identify the different colours and rhythms of the year. I want them to know about nature and to be able to recognise birds, ducks, wildlife. I used to love pond dipping as a little girl. I want them to know about their immediate environment and also the world beyond it.

There is time for playing independently with toys but all the time? Really?

Blossomtoes · 18/01/2023 10:20

I am surprised that this idea of parents taking children to farms or national trust or swimming is somehow being seen as a bad thing!

It’s not a bad thing although I think it’s sad that some children are never allowed to just be. But it’s by no means essential which is what you seemed to be saying in your original post. Yesteryear’s children were high achievers having had much less frenetic lives.

knittingaddict · 18/01/2023 10:20

yorkshirepudsx · 18/01/2023 10:16

But I do think expectations of parents have become a lot higher, which isn't necessarily a bad thing, but it can be exhausting.

Me and my mum often talk about all the differences between now and then and she says she's glad she had babies when she did. (I talk to her about so much she's the best to have discussions with lol)

But I feel like now, because of social media as somebody mentioned earlier, and the way in which adults interact with eachother, there's added pressure to be that perfect parent, everybody I know seems to plaster every little thing about their kids on Facebook (I don't simply because I think it's horrific to). People know when their kids are in trouble not because of a knock at the door, or word of mouth, but because Linda from the other side of town posted footage of it on the local Facebook group. I think you all know what I'm getting at haha.

People turn to strangers on the internet for advice before they turn to friends, family, etc.

Then celebrities are always sharing their 'mum hacks' and the rest of it.

And people don't post the shitty stuff, they don't openly say how crap their days been (unless it's one of those that check into the hospital at every visit and reply 'pm me Hun xxx' when people ask what's wrong) - but we constantly see a glorified version of everybody's lives and many people will subconsciously try to keep up.

My mum tells me stories of how she'd just 'crack on' with what needed to be done, then every week took me/my siblings (when we were babies) to the cafe to meet her friends who had babies and they'd discuss things there. Which I think is lovely.

I didn't see this before my post, but basically this. It's exactly how I feel about modern parenting.

Getinajollymood · 18/01/2023 10:20

I think my mum was very depressed when she had my brother and I. She wasn’t suited to staying at home with little children (neither am I; I work part time.) I’m glad that is now the norm.

knittingaddict · 18/01/2023 10:18

ancientgran · 17/01/2023 21:09

I had my first in 1971, no washing machine, no tumble dryer, no fridge, no central heating, no freezer, no car, no disposables, no money. I didn't find it very easy.

It was physically harder, but it seems emotionally and psychologically harder now. Trying to juggle work and home life, more rules about what you should and shouldn't do, less general acceptance of just muddling through.

I wouldn't want to be a parent to young children now because I think my mental health would suffer from the expectations others would have for me.

The other thread about not doing enough with your babies and how it's the mother's fault if the baby doesn't sleep because they aren't stimulating them 100% of their waking hours, is a case in point. I know not everyone is saying that, but a significant proportion are and those voices are loud in your head if you are at all underconfident as a new parent.

yorkshirepudsx · 18/01/2023 10:16

But I do think expectations of parents have become a lot higher, which isn't necessarily a bad thing, but it can be exhausting.

Me and my mum often talk about all the differences between now and then and she says she's glad she had babies when she did. (I talk to her about so much she's the best to have discussions with lol)

But I feel like now, because of social media as somebody mentioned earlier, and the way in which adults interact with eachother, there's added pressure to be that perfect parent, everybody I know seems to plaster every little thing about their kids on Facebook (I don't simply because I think it's horrific to). People know when their kids are in trouble not because of a knock at the door, or word of mouth, but because Linda from the other side of town posted footage of it on the local Facebook group. I think you all know what I'm getting at haha.

People turn to strangers on the internet for advice before they turn to friends, family, etc.

Then celebrities are always sharing their 'mum hacks' and the rest of it.

And people don't post the shitty stuff, they don't openly say how crap their days been (unless it's one of those that check into the hospital at every visit and reply 'pm me Hun xxx' when people ask what's wrong) - but we constantly see a glorified version of everybody's lives and many people will subconsciously try to keep up.

My mum tells me stories of how she'd just 'crack on' with what needed to be done, then every week took me/my siblings (when we were babies) to the cafe to meet her friends who had babies and they'd discuss things there. Which I think is lovely.

Getinajollymood · 18/01/2023 10:16

So, what, stay at home with them and just hope they turn out OK?

Because sure, we had Dickens. We also had a huge majority of illiterate children at the time he was writing.

What often gets missed is that most of us aren’t hugely talented individuals. I’m not, I don’t expect any children I have to be either. God given gifts aside, most of us do want our children to have opportunities and to see the world and enjoy being a part of it, in a way that wasn’t always possible in the past.

Until possibly the 1970s, I doubt my grandmother had been further than Blackpool. I don’t think for a moment that children need to be taken on foreign holidays or to exotic places but I am surprised that this idea of parents taking children to farms or national trust or swimming is somehow being seen as a bad thing!

Morestrangethings · 18/01/2023 10:14

I’m a grandma. I tend to remember my little kids as always being well behaved and easy to please. They were not. They were just as difficult - or not - as little kids today. It just seems like it was easier (1) because we forget, and (2) we really do remember, (there is no forgetting), the teenage years.

I lived in an area full of parks and beaches when my kids were little. Temperate weather most of the time too where I lived, too.. We tended to live outside more, doing very active things. I think that has changed - the areas I was able to bring my kids up in are now very gentrified and only for the wealthy. And population has increased so much that many of us have been pushed to live in high rise, or outer suburbs with amenities nowhere near as good as the ones available to me when my kids were small. If I was bringing up my children today, we’d spend more time indoors and in front of screens.

But much as a pp mentioned, less was known about many medical and mental health disorders.

Dixiechickonhols · 18/01/2023 10:11

Definitely less pressure to do as much and less stuff.
Early 80s, nice suburban childhood.
But very much walk to local school, walk home. Have tea. Play and bed.
I went to brownies and had swimming lessons at one point but not lots of activities.
Tea very much of the it’s Monday it’s x, it’s Tuesday it’s y at same time each night at table.
Everyone had same striped buggy and sandals in summer.
Weekends. Cartoons in morning. Went shopping. Tea at grandparents. Sunday saw other grandparents, Roast dinner, Sunday school and toast for tea, bath and bed.
Yes we had trips but in holidays. There wasn’t pressure to be out constantly doing exciting things.
For a child it’s very comforting to have a very settled routine.
Lots of exercise. Walking everywhere. So walk to shops, walk older siblings to school.

Blossomtoes · 18/01/2023 10:09

Interesting, because I think if you were to do a study of children who achieve the best at school and look at their early years, I doubt the high achievers spent most of their formative years at home.

Makes you wonder how we managed to have anyone who achieved academically in the past. Yet somehow we had doctors, professors, Nobel prize winning scientists, authors, playwrights. Perhaps Dickens’ writing would have been massively improved if he’d been taken to soft play and petting farms.

girlfriend44 · 18/01/2023 10:07

LizzieSiddal · 18/01/2023 09:40

I’m not saying she was happy to play quietly “for most of the day”. I’m saying she was happy to be at home for most of the day, she didn’t have the expectation of going to a farm park/soft play/music group etc etc every single day.

The expectation on parents that toddlers and Dc need to be doing some kind of activity, every single day is not good for the parent or the child! And to suggest if they don’t do these activities then they won’t be learning, is absurd!

Absolutely.

People expect so much more now. How many people have a house party for their children now on their birthday?
Never had to pay for playschemes in the holidays either.

EmptyWineGlass · 18/01/2023 10:07

Cuppasoupmonster · 17/01/2023 22:58

And also, parents aren’t happier - so many threads about ‘not being able to even shower because of the baby’. What?! Just put them in a bouncer on the bathroom floor and fucking shower! Why such a martyr?!

I think babies have different personalities.

Our daughter wouldn't even be put down without screaming purple in the face. She'd be absolutely distraught before I even got in the shower - because I'd stopped holding her to get undressed and turn the shower on, etc. I obviously sometimes tried having a quick shower anyway, but she would be in such a state by the end that, I swear, made her more liable to further upsets for the rest of the day. If I gave her what she needed (constant holding) she would be calmer for the day. Obviously, though, that meant I couldn't do much else! (Heat wave this year limited sling usage as well, so there was a lot of sitting and holding).

Now she's 6 months old and will let me have a shower, do some washing up, eat my lunch, etc. And she is a giggly, gorgeous, happy little girl - we think she was just a "high needs newborn". Thankfully NHS are quite clear that you can't spoil a newborn, so I'm hoping we did OK 🙂

creamwitheverything · 18/01/2023 10:03

This is such a lovely thread. I have 2 children and one was born in 1991 the other a mere 21 yrs later in 2011 ! Things are definately different this time round. The expectations on parents now are exhausting and whilst I am lucky enough not to have to work I think life is so fast these days,so many demands and however we may want to resist we can;t. We run just to stand still some times. I was thinking as I jumped into my car to take my dd to Guides last night,how could it only be tuesday? I always seem to be driving her somewhere to some club or other.I didnt do this with my son.He had no clubs,he went swimming with school and weekends with grandparents,holiday once a year and a club trip to Blackpool to see the lights! There was no expectations back then.Who dictated we should be occupied from morning to night when we drop exhaustedly in to bed to get on the treadmill of life again as soon as our eyes open,kids included,When did that happen?My own childhood was similar to others,mothers at home,cooking and cleaning us having all the freedoms we wanted,We used to go on bike rides with our friends,no adult supervision with a carrier full of jam sandwiches and a bottle of lemonade,Not one of us had a watch to know what time it was,we landed home when we did as soon as it was getting dark.We had no friends round for tea,it never happened,everyone seemed to go home to eat at the same time.We had no clothes like today,couple of pairs of jeans and t shirts ,couple of jumpers and that was it,one coat! New clothes at Easter and pyjamas at Christmas! My mum was always at home apart from weightwatchers on a wednesday with her mates! We had a best room no one was allowed in only on a sunday after lunch when dad would bring us pop and crisps home from the pub,what a treat that was.! Mum would cut our hair and next door would perm hers from a box even though she wasnt a hairdresser. My 11 yr old goes every 6 weeks for a trim at 40 quid!!! I think it may or may not have been easier back then but it was slower with less expectations and no envy,No envy cos no bugger had anything to be jealous of anyone else for!!! My world in the 70s was a happier place to grow up in compared to my dds experience now. I was thinking just now as I was driving home from the school run and my dd was telling me about this new flip phone she wanted how I used to sit on the stairs using the corded landline calling my nan but only after 6pm!! Now my dd rings me from her room to ask what time dinner is and i am only in the kitchen! Wonder what our kids will say about us when they have kids of their own?

cushioncovers · 18/01/2023 10:02

I was raised in the 70's and In my view babies and children were something parents/adults had control over and had to manage. Children had to fit in with the routine of adult life. 3 meals a day, bedtime set in stone. Both parents had defined roles. The man was often the head of the house and so you did as you were told. There were consequences if you didn't so out of fear you automatically tried to stay within the parameters your parents set otherwise you got punished. You didn't dare refuse a meal that was put on the table or kick off at having to stop playing and get in the bath for example. So yes the older generation probably think it was easier because they just made you too fearful to rebel. As well as just letting you out to play unsupervised for hours on end and older siblings told to keep an eye on the younger ones or else.

LivingMyBestAnxietyLife · 18/01/2023 09:59

I feel like it was easier back in day in some ways, as in nobody had social media back then, with silly memes like "your kids come first over anyone and anything and if you don't your shite" and i think parenting is a competition these days, who has this,that and the other Christmas/birthday so over the top, where as back in the day everyone was in the same boat and whatever, I was brought up in the 90s and I had to do everything my parents wanted ie sit the pub for hours on end, didn't dare play up when out and about as I knew what I would get if I did. I was basically brought up children should be seen and not heard, didn't dare scream in the house and defo not in the garden. I wouldn't have dreamed to go into the garden screaming and hollering disturbing the neighbours, never intrupted an adult when talking as I would be told its extremely rude! I was allowed to play out

I bring my children up to not intrupt adults when talking as it is rude not to scream and shout and disturb the neighbours but I would never hit them for it, it's said that children can't really play out anymore, all glued to tablets ipad ect ect!

I also think all generations have/had a low tolance for children tbh. Especially "disruptive" children.

LizzieSiddal · 18/01/2023 09:59

Interesting, because I think if you were to do a study of children who achieve the best at school and look at their early years, I doubt the high achievers spent most of their formative years at home.

Ok, well as most Dc nowadays seem to spend most of their day at “activities” , I’ll look forward to seeing a massive rise the number is children doing exceptionally well at school!

yorkshirepudsx · 18/01/2023 09:56

Getinajollymood · 18/01/2023 09:53

So modern parenting is going wrong by being out and about too much and children are better at home?

Interesting, because I think if you were to do a study of children who achieve the best at school and look at their early years, I doubt the high achievers spent most of their formative years at home.

I'm always out and about with my little one!! He will learn lots of valuable social skills & we're making memories to last a lifetime 🥰