Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if parenting really was easier in the past?

343 replies

germanbight · 17/01/2023 19:46

My beloved grandma, who lived on a small farm and really ran it alone, always used to tut at toddlers/small children who were being naughty out and about and always told me that when she had her children it was all much simpler— especially in the baby phase.

Apparently routine kept all 4 children perfect from baby-hood. Baby fed every three hours until it slept through, all children off for an afternoon nap after dinner and bedtime a prompt 7:30 until they were 10. She always used to say that now parents adapt to fit the baby in their lives, but when she was having children they had to adapt to her life.

I just don’t see how it could’ve run on clockwork like that. Was it really that much easier? Just a case of endless CIO?

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 18/01/2023 11:36

WhatNoRaisins · 18/01/2023 11:28

Was childcare relatively cheaper a generation ago? I'm guessing without the ratios and Ofsted requirements of today you could do it on the cheap. Obviously not always good for the babies and children.

It could still be half your wage. Women in clothing factories in the 80's could be on about £1.50 an hour, childcare if using a local woman could be between £3-£5 a day. The better quality the more expensive unless you touched lucky. There were kind retired women who just wanted to supplement their pension.

Clarabellawilliamson · 18/01/2023 11:36

My Nan makes child rearing in the 1950s sound idyllic- she goes all misty eyed when she remembers how much of a 'good baby' my uncle was because she could just leave him in his pram under the apple tree all day and he never cried....

Dixiechickonhols · 18/01/2023 11:33

WhatNoRaisins · 18/01/2023 11:28

Was childcare relatively cheaper a generation ago? I'm guessing without the ratios and Ofsted requirements of today you could do it on the cheap. Obviously not always good for the babies and children.

I think far more informal childcare. Neighbour 2 doors down walked us home from school for a while (mum paid her cash) now she’d need to be ofsted registered I think.
Sunday school - we were dropped off and picked up parents didn’t stay. Would be no dbs check, ratios etc.
Teens babysitting or young girls taking babies out in prams. When I was 1 a girl age 10 ish from down street came to ‘play’ with me. Obviously my mum was there but could get on with jobs. Christine had just seen me and knocked on door and asked.

Cuppasoupmonster · 18/01/2023 11:33

I’m never sure why more time, more attention, more love, is seen as a bad thing.

Because unlimited love/attention equals a spoilt child. It also limits their independence and confidence, if mum/dad is always there to hover and pick up the pieces. It’s about balance. Plus the main job of parents is to prepare their child for adulthood - there certainly won’t be a source of unlimited love and attention then!

Ponoka7 · 18/01/2023 11:31

@Clarabellawilliamson, I grew up in a deprived bit of Liverpool. My Mum worked for Littlewoods pools, a lot of other Mum's worked in the Meccano, Jacobs biscuit factory and other factories. Family childcare was usual, as was the older teenage girl of a local family, or a Mum with just one/two. It was a good earning opportunity for older women. Sally Webster was a childminder on Coronation Street, she gave up when the regulations came in. Over summer we'd (a big group of children) be looked after my friend's sisters who were 12 and 14. We lived on jam sandwiches. There were similar set ups all over the neighbourhood.

Getinajollymood · 18/01/2023 11:30

Problem is, we’re talking about ‘the past’ and some of us mean Victorian times, some mean 1980s!

As always, there’s going to be huge differences amongst different cultures and social classes and even within those cultures and classes huge variations. There are general trends, but we’d need to identify which era we are specifically referring to.

Certainly it’s only very recently smacking has been socially frowned upon. And abuse of children in plain sight was a thing. ‘Streetwise’ children was a synonym for a troublemaker and not a vulnerable child.

Helen Forrester’s books are a good read for an insight to 1930s attitudes. And it was less than a hundred years ago children were evacuated to an unknown family which is unthinkable now. So attitudes have changed dramatically in that time, but I’m never sure why more time, more attention, more love, is seen as a bad thing.

Dixiechickonhols · 18/01/2023 11:29

Some workplaces had nurseries. Relatives in cotton mills and their dc in 50s went to nursery.

WhatNoRaisins · 18/01/2023 11:28

Was childcare relatively cheaper a generation ago? I'm guessing without the ratios and Ofsted requirements of today you could do it on the cheap. Obviously not always good for the babies and children.

Blossomtoes · 18/01/2023 11:27

Did private nurseries exist in the same way as they do now? For very young babies?

Not when I had mine in the mid 70s. The expectation was that you stopped work when your baby was born and went back when they started school. There was no maternity leave or pay either.

CallTheMobWife · 18/01/2023 11:24

mooongooose · 17/01/2023 21:17

Exactly- why on earth would it have been more convenient without modern technology?!

We're not talking about housework aand convenience, we're talkong about parenting!Of course getting the washing done etc was harder, but on the other hand its easier to get it done if your children are out on the street for hours and you ignore them if they cry at night so you got a full nights sleep.

Parenting is obviously easier if you spend much of your time ignoring your children and you don't have any notion that you have to care about their emotional wellbeing or try and meet their needs.

Ponoka7 · 18/01/2023 11:24

DifficultBloodyWoman · 18/01/2023 08:32

I recognize that but how widespread do you think that was? Every family? Most? Some?

With modern values, that it happened (still happens) in any family is shameful . But how many suffered or would have to suffer for it to have an effect on children’s behavior at a societal level?

I was born in the 60's. You'd see children constantly getting smacked legs. You'd see other children being hit, in school, at clubs etc so it would be enough of a threat to make you behave. Children's bruises were ignored as was their mother's black eyes. DV and child abuse was practically legal. To keep the workforce moving along, things were deemed "to not do any harm", so damaging practices carried on.

"Rome for example had mourning that started at one month for a very young child and then it increased based on age. Who would spend a month in mourning for someone inconsequential?"

When a Roman woman gave birth the baby would be taken to the father, or male head of the house, who would decide if it lived. Those mourned were the children wanted by the men.

I agree that the Mother's pain wouldn't have necessarily been any less. There was just an acceptance of death and so many died you were expected to carry on. The letters and writings found from Catherine of Aragon showed that Henry V111 felt the loss of his children on a personal level.

People believe what they are taught and in generations or cultures were they are told not to question their elders etc what we now know as neglect carries on. It was all about freeing the women up to service the men, so they could go to work.

Dixiechickonhols · 18/01/2023 11:23

Clarabellawilliamson · 18/01/2023 11:14

The thing is, we can talk about trends at a societal level, or we can talk about anecdotes from your own experience, both are valid but they won't necessarily match up.

It is true to say that people tend to live further away from their own families now, and there are fewer multigenerational households compared to say the 1950s. If granny can hold the baby while mum cleans the house and dad is out at work that's a very different experience to most modern day parenting!

Lots of people saying their mums worked full time when they were little, just interested in who looked after them (pre school age). I went to a childminder, my own children went to a day nursery.Did private nurseries exist in the same way as they do now? For very young babies?

Late 70s, early 80s there was no private nursery or after school where we lived.
Brother went to a childminder when mum worked for a few months. She’d enquired at council run nursery and was told no it was only for single mums, neglected children etc.
School nursery half days from age 3. This was brand new I was first intake.
After school a neighbour walked us home. I disliked her daughter so persuaded mum to let me walk alone from age 7 ish.

Dixiechickonhols · 18/01/2023 11:17

But children at home would still get out. Being at home doesn’t mean inside 4 walls all day.

No mums had access to a car where I grew up. Tiny fridges so shopping frequently. Lots more in person bill paying. Mum went to post office to get family allowance weekly. Where mum went pre schooler went.

We seem to have shifted to in house. Get in car. Go to paid activity. Parents feel pressured to do an activity daily.

Things like walk to pond and feed ducks were the activity not a paid one.

Not saying don’t do activities and farms, stately homes but there’s a lot of enjoyment and learning for small children in everyday life.

I’m a girlguiding volunteer now. I did brownies as a child but it was my only evening activity. Now our girls do multiple a week sometimes more than one a night.

We are all guilty of it. There’s a pressure to do exciting activities, go on lots of trips. One of best nights we’ve had recently at Guides was just colouring and chatting. I’m trying to remember that as we plan sessions.

Fuwari · 18/01/2023 11:15

I’d say I maybe hit the “sweet spot” in terms of timing. I had mine late 80’s/early 90s. Still in the times when a baby was meant to fit into your life and not vice versa, but late enough for modern conveniences like washing machines!

I had two 18 months apart and I kept the house clean, dinner on the table etc, with time to spare. They both went on solids from 12 weeks and slept through from around the same age. And I certainly never got up at 5am with them as toddlers, they’d have been told in no uncertain terms to go back to bed!

We did ok financially with just my partner working. But I also got into a career quite easily towards the late 90s. Whereas now women are cautioned on taking more than a year out. I guess the job market is also tougher now. We got a PC around the mid/late 90s but the internet wasn’t like it is now, so less of a concern. Overall I’m glad I had them when I did.

Clarabellawilliamson · 18/01/2023 11:14

The thing is, we can talk about trends at a societal level, or we can talk about anecdotes from your own experience, both are valid but they won't necessarily match up.

It is true to say that people tend to live further away from their own families now, and there are fewer multigenerational households compared to say the 1950s. If granny can hold the baby while mum cleans the house and dad is out at work that's a very different experience to most modern day parenting!

Lots of people saying their mums worked full time when they were little, just interested in who looked after them (pre school age). I went to a childminder, my own children went to a day nursery.Did private nurseries exist in the same way as they do now? For very young babies?

WhatNoRaisins · 18/01/2023 11:13

I could but without something like an essential errand or the park at the other end to motivate myself it's just tedious as fuck.

Cuppasoupmonster · 18/01/2023 11:12

I agree @Lilyhatesjaz Dd loves joining me on my errands. She loves being given little jobs to ‘help’ (like asking her to let me know when she sees the dog food and then I’ll deliberately walk past it looking the other way!), I feel a constant timetable of organised ‘activities’ just raises their expectations as to what constitutes fun and makes them less patient and well behaved when it comes to ‘boring’ days or helping with regular household tasks. DD also loves helping me unpack food shopping, sorting through laundry (‘put all the pants in a pile here’) and dusting (she just follows me around with a duster)

I’m not surprised parental satisfaction is so low and stress levels are so high if I’m honest, it seems all people do with their kids are high-energy, high-spend or tech based things.

Blossomtoes · 18/01/2023 10:57

WhatNoRaisins · 18/01/2023 10:49

It's also the walk to these places (I don't drive much with them, bonus is that they find the car exciting in of itself) and we look at trees, look for snowdrops, see if we can spot birds nests.

You could just take them for a walk.

Lilyhatesjaz · 18/01/2023 10:50

My mum 60s and 70s spent lots of time with us but not playing as such as a small child I remember helping her a lot with the hoover and dusting, drying the dishes, helping on the allotment. All the time we would be talking to each other and I would be learning.
From working with small children I have noticed quite a few with language delays and I think some of this is because modern technology means less talking to small children.
I think that it doesn't really matter what the activity is it's the interaction with an adult that matters. Paid activities are great if you can afford them but a walk and a chat or cooking dinner together are just as good.

WhatNoRaisins · 18/01/2023 10:49

It's also the walk to these places (I don't drive much with them, bonus is that they find the car exciting in of itself) and we look at trees, look for snowdrops, see if we can spot birds nests.

Getinajollymood · 18/01/2023 10:44

Why on earth wouldn’t they get it from soft play and petting farms?

Soft play provides skills like movement, climbing, navigating, motor skills (fine and gross) as well as good exercise, which never harms anyone.

Petting farms provide the opportunity to see animals and to understand the world around them. See a sheep in a book or television a toddler will learn it’s a sheep and says baa. Touch a sheep and learn words like woolly, soft. Opportunities to learn about colour (black, brown, white.) A lamb is a sheep’s baby, and so on.

I honestly don’t understand why anyone would have a problem with either of those things!

QueenSmartypants · 18/01/2023 10:43

Child accident and death rates from things like scalds were much higher though, too.

For balance, some of the reasons for this will be improved medical care and clinical response times.

FriedEggChocolate · 18/01/2023 10:42

If your idea of parenting is, at best, benign neglect, then yes, you'll have time to do things around your kids. To be fair, if clothes washing took half a day, you could see why you'd chuck your kids out the door. In urban areas, other adults would also keep an eye out but kids were left to roam much further and just find their way back. Child accident and death rates from things like scalds were much higher though, too.

WhatNoRaisins · 18/01/2023 10:40

I think I was thinking more like pre schoolers. Keeping them in all day is like not taking your dog for a walk.

Dixiechickonhols · 18/01/2023 10:37

knittingaddict · 18/01/2023 10:28

That's interesting because I had my children in the 80's and our lives were very different to that.

No set weekly menus. Would eat out sometimes.

Went out at the weekends and did all sorts of activities - National Trust, fruit picking, animal and farm parks, visiting local attractions.

Our weekday routine was similar to yours, but not set in stone. The rest was very different.

Eating out only happened once or twice. Really was rare event (Bernie inn)
We definitely had trips and outings but not weekly. Went on Sunday school trips, zoo, Blackpool illuminations but wasn’t a weekly expectation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread