Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if parenting really was easier in the past?

343 replies

germanbight · 17/01/2023 19:46

My beloved grandma, who lived on a small farm and really ran it alone, always used to tut at toddlers/small children who were being naughty out and about and always told me that when she had her children it was all much simpler— especially in the baby phase.

Apparently routine kept all 4 children perfect from baby-hood. Baby fed every three hours until it slept through, all children off for an afternoon nap after dinner and bedtime a prompt 7:30 until they were 10. She always used to say that now parents adapt to fit the baby in their lives, but when she was having children they had to adapt to her life.

I just don’t see how it could’ve run on clockwork like that. Was it really that much easier? Just a case of endless CIO?

OP posts:
Lifelessordinary1 · 18/01/2023 15:50

I think it was much easier. Most mothers were at home until kids we're older. You wore clothes for longer so even without automatic washing machines you had a lot less washing. Everyone ate what was put in front of them so less cooking and washing up. Kids played out so you had plenty of time for housework, relaxing and seeing friends. And kids were in bed much earlier - I really do think routine helps with this. Kids went to school on their own and they had few other activities and little homework and schools made virtually no demands on parents in terms of uniform lunches special days etc etc. I think kids helped a lot more as well - I didn't wash up after my kids were 7 or 8 - ever. And they were expected to help with cleaning and laundry. Was it an idyllic utopia- no but was it easier and more relaxed for most people - yes.

Dotjones · 18/01/2023 15:12

It used to be easier because standards were different and essential things were more affordable.

For example:

  • housing was more affordable and people could realistically buy in their early 20s with one income and pay it off in their 40s
  • buying and running a car was cheaper than even public transport is today, in relative terms
  • families were more likely to have a stay at home mother so weren't juggling working as well
  • physical punishment was accepted as normal - even in the 50s a sound thrashing was perfectly acceptable (see the final scene in Cosh Boy (aka The Slasher in the US) where SPOILER ALERT the little thug gets his comeuppance because the police who've come to arrest him for attempted murder "pop out" for a few minutes so that his stepdad can give him a sound beating, the reasoning being that if his stepdad beats seven bells out of him the court will be more lenient with the sentence because they know his parents won't take any shit from him anymore)
  • there wouldn't be any intervention from the authorities for low- to mid-level abuse or neglect, so if parents didn't give a shit they probably wouldn't get into trouble over it
  • going back further, it was accepted that some kids would die young anyway, that's why they had large families, so it was less bothersome if your child got ill because that was just the way of the world
  • going back even further you could send your child into pseudo-slavery in the form of service to a family or being sent to serve a term of a few years as an apprentice, so there was money to be made out of your child.
realmsofglory · 18/01/2023 15:00

I honestly think things were better for children. They had to use their imagination and ingenuity to make their entertainment. They grew up (well most of them) learning how to manage risk, sort out problems and allowed to do more stuff. I remember as a child about 8 or 9 going to do 'campfires with a couple of friends in the counryside where e we would build a fire and fry bacon and sausages and egg. At 12 we were off 'wild camping' . Goff on a day lone bike ride-no adults Contrast that to nowadays where parents werent allowed to hold a y6 leavers barbeque because it was 'too dangerous'.
Kids left prinary school wth a good basic education because they didn't learn about so much bollocks in the primay curriculum today. Kids know they were te kids, and knew adults they were in charge

ancientgran · 18/01/2023 14:53

ivykaty44 · 18/01/2023 14:40

@ancientgran

my gran told me of her father coming back from the trenches in 1916 to find his baby, who was born while he was away fighting, had died before he got home. My gran said it was when she saw her dad cry at the table

we all know that a Childs death was just as hard then as it is now, less expected now but still as hard to deal with

That is so sad, the poor man and his poor wife. Just imagine she was worried about her husband, she had at least one other child to care for and lost her baby. Heartbreaking doesn't even begin to describe it does it.

ivykaty44 · 18/01/2023 14:40

@ancientgran

my gran told me of her father coming back from the trenches in 1916 to find his baby, who was born while he was away fighting, had died before he got home. My gran said it was when she saw her dad cry at the table

we all know that a Childs death was just as hard then as it is now, less expected now but still as hard to deal with

EffortlessDesmond · 18/01/2023 14:17

1950s born, with a younger sibling. Grew up in on the beach, and roamed fairly wild after the age of six. Every adult kept an eye on children, and they all felt free to tell you off for misbehaving. We knew we were loved, but we weren't indulged except occasionally by GPs who lived a long way away and whom we only saw in school holidays.

Most of that generation turned out self-reliant and competent by the time we went to work, university, into teacher training or nursing at 17/18. Certainly we were expected to be able to fend for ourselves more or less independently at 18 or 20. Which is not my DC's experience of new university students now.

hiredandsqueak · 18/01/2023 14:13

I paid £35 per child per week. I think I got a reduction for second child but it worked out at £70 for the two anyway. I supplied nappies and food (no snacks as they weren't a thing then) My two say they had a good childhood too despite money being tight and we remain close to this day.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 18/01/2023 13:45

WhatNoRaisins · 18/01/2023 11:28

Was childcare relatively cheaper a generation ago? I'm guessing without the ratios and Ofsted requirements of today you could do it on the cheap. Obviously not always good for the babies and children.

I paid £50 per week per child for my childminder in the 80's. I had 2 children, was a single parent and earned £9,500 per year. I got child benefit and £20 per week child support . I lived in a tiny 2 up 2 down and the rent was £160 per month.
Money was tight but my children didn't go without.
My children are now in their 30's and say they had a wonderful childhood

Dixiechickonhols · 18/01/2023 13:35

babsanderson · 18/01/2023 13:21

Look at that post about a stepmum who has a very young baby asking if she is unreasonable not to get out of bed in the morning to make her 14 year old stepson breakfast. Those saying she is BU will have a tougher time parenting than people did in the past. My grandparents were out in full time work at 14 years old.

Yes I was thinking of that thread. Lots of posters implying she’s being neglectful not making a 14 yr old his breakfast. Whereas I’m in the camp they should have been taught life skills to make own breakfast at that age.
Different styles of parenting. It’s still parental attention but in a different way.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 18/01/2023 13:34

hiredandsqueak · 17/01/2023 20:12

I think it was easier when I had my eldest two in the eighties because the dc were expected to fit in with your life rather than you fit your life around them.
Mine were fed by the clock, put up the garden for naps morning and afternoon, expected they would sleep through from twelve weeks or weighing twelve pounds whichever was first (mine slept through from six weeks).
I went back to work when ds was nine weeks old, childminder kept the same routine I'd pick him up bath bottle and bed by seven. I spent very little time playing with them, I gave them toys and expected them to entertain themselves tbh.
I do read posts where people say they haven't had time to shower and spend days nursing a baby and think to myself it would drive me potty tbh. Back then the midwife would visit and it was expected that you would be bathed and dressed for her visit and baby would have been fed, washed, dressed and asleep in the pram even if it was 9am.

My experience of having children in the 80's was the same as yours but I went back to work full time when both mine were 6 months. I was lucky that the only childminder in the village was a friend who lived at the end of our street. I became a single parent weeks after my 2nd was born so money was very, very tight until they were both in full time education. No financial help with childcare in those days.

babsanderson · 18/01/2023 13:21

Look at that post about a stepmum who has a very young baby asking if she is unreasonable not to get out of bed in the morning to make her 14 year old stepson breakfast. Those saying she is BU will have a tougher time parenting than people did in the past. My grandparents were out in full time work at 14 years old.

Twanky · 18/01/2023 13:17

ancientgran · 18/01/2023 05:53

I'm sitting here in tears, thinking of the mothers of the past being written off as callous as the death of a child not meaning as much to them as it would to anyone now.

I think this thread should be taken down because of that post. I'm truly horrified at the self satisfied nature if that is how modern women think.

Don't get upset by it, think of it as written by a smug idiot who thinks she's God's gift to being a parent and she most certainly isn't.

Twanky · 18/01/2023 13:13

magicthree · 18/01/2023 05:25

Also, regarding the "out all day" style of parenting in the past. None of the kids in my town just took off wherever they liked, their parents generally knew where they were. We used to play with our friends at their houses - outside generally - they would come to ours, we went to the park etc., went to the swimming pool in summer, roamed the cemetery (yes, that was a thing!), went to the shops. There was a lot more freedom to come and go, but we weren't randomly wandering around. However, we certainly weren't constantly taken to organised activities, and had to make our own fun.

We would wander miles away, in our heads, in reality we were probably not 500 yards from home!

babsanderson · 18/01/2023 13:12

Dixiechickonhols · 18/01/2023 12:59

Depends what you mean by attention though. I’m in a ‘nice’ area and parenting style is very hands on. So children driven everywhere, adult with them, lots of organised activities.

Example would be they don’t develop road sense - I was out with a group of 11/12 yr olds recently and it was really noticeable.

Children need attention but they also need space to develop and practice age appropriate life skills.

I notice this and I think this is why you get younger parents now saying things like well a child does not develop road sense/ability to do some task/etc until they are at least ?
It is because that is the case now for a lot of children because they are not learning those skills. Whereas those of us from other countries or who are much older know children can develop those skills much earlier, but it doesn't just happen by magic.

Blossomtoes · 18/01/2023 13:12

ancientgran · 18/01/2023 12:58

Mine went to nursery in the 70s then my mother retired and she had them. I had no choice, we couldn't live on one wage.

We struggled to so I did bar work two or three evenings a week. I think the availability of childcare depended very much on where you lived. We lived in the sort of area where the only mums of children under school age who worked had nannies.

Twanky · 18/01/2023 13:05

Thank fuck for devices tbh. I'd argue more active parenting has to happen now as there is no "out all day" option.

But surely devices, social media etc., etc. are the cause of so many problems that families experience today.
There 'll never be agreement about when 'parenting' was easier or harder, everypne has their own perspective, memories and opinions. I think we can assume that the vast majority of parents are doing/used to do what they think is right for that time. Today's parents need to remember that they'll be the ones being criticised in the future!

Dixiechickonhols · 18/01/2023 12:59

Depends what you mean by attention though. I’m in a ‘nice’ area and parenting style is very hands on. So children driven everywhere, adult with them, lots of organised activities.

Example would be they don’t develop road sense - I was out with a group of 11/12 yr olds recently and it was really noticeable.

Children need attention but they also need space to develop and practice age appropriate life skills.

ancientgran · 18/01/2023 12:58

Blossomtoes · 18/01/2023 11:27

Did private nurseries exist in the same way as they do now? For very young babies?

Not when I had mine in the mid 70s. The expectation was that you stopped work when your baby was born and went back when they started school. There was no maternity leave or pay either.

Mine went to nursery in the 70s then my mother retired and she had them. I had no choice, we couldn't live on one wage.

ancientgran · 18/01/2023 12:54

CallTheMobWife · 18/01/2023 11:24

We're not talking about housework aand convenience, we're talkong about parenting!Of course getting the washing done etc was harder, but on the other hand its easier to get it done if your children are out on the street for hours and you ignore them if they cry at night so you got a full nights sleep.

Parenting is obviously easier if you spend much of your time ignoring your children and you don't have any notion that you have to care about their emotional wellbeing or try and meet their needs.

Making sure children have healthy food, babies have enough nappies washed and clean when they need changing is parenting unless you want them running round with a wet bum all day and an empty belly. Maybe housework is so easy today that people don't see that.

ancientgran · 18/01/2023 12:50

creamwitheverything · 18/01/2023 10:03

This is such a lovely thread. I have 2 children and one was born in 1991 the other a mere 21 yrs later in 2011 ! Things are definately different this time round. The expectations on parents now are exhausting and whilst I am lucky enough not to have to work I think life is so fast these days,so many demands and however we may want to resist we can;t. We run just to stand still some times. I was thinking as I jumped into my car to take my dd to Guides last night,how could it only be tuesday? I always seem to be driving her somewhere to some club or other.I didnt do this with my son.He had no clubs,he went swimming with school and weekends with grandparents,holiday once a year and a club trip to Blackpool to see the lights! There was no expectations back then.Who dictated we should be occupied from morning to night when we drop exhaustedly in to bed to get on the treadmill of life again as soon as our eyes open,kids included,When did that happen?My own childhood was similar to others,mothers at home,cooking and cleaning us having all the freedoms we wanted,We used to go on bike rides with our friends,no adult supervision with a carrier full of jam sandwiches and a bottle of lemonade,Not one of us had a watch to know what time it was,we landed home when we did as soon as it was getting dark.We had no friends round for tea,it never happened,everyone seemed to go home to eat at the same time.We had no clothes like today,couple of pairs of jeans and t shirts ,couple of jumpers and that was it,one coat! New clothes at Easter and pyjamas at Christmas! My mum was always at home apart from weightwatchers on a wednesday with her mates! We had a best room no one was allowed in only on a sunday after lunch when dad would bring us pop and crisps home from the pub,what a treat that was.! Mum would cut our hair and next door would perm hers from a box even though she wasnt a hairdresser. My 11 yr old goes every 6 weeks for a trim at 40 quid!!! I think it may or may not have been easier back then but it was slower with less expectations and no envy,No envy cos no bugger had anything to be jealous of anyone else for!!! My world in the 70s was a happier place to grow up in compared to my dds experience now. I was thinking just now as I was driving home from the school run and my dd was telling me about this new flip phone she wanted how I used to sit on the stairs using the corded landline calling my nan but only after 6pm!! Now my dd rings me from her room to ask what time dinner is and i am only in the kitchen! Wonder what our kids will say about us when they have kids of their own?

Families vary. I had two children in the early70s, I had to work so although I read mother didn't need to work then I certainly did. Activities were less? Really I remember cubs, football, guitar, tennis, judo, cricket, art club, skating, probably some I've forgotten.

The luxury of getting into a car to get them there, I'd get home from work grab them and dash off to whatever/wherever it was.

All my friends did similar although if they had girls the list would include brownies and usually dancing. So yes in my experience there was an expectation to be "doing" stuff with kids long before the 90s. Maybe it varied round the country.

Blossomtoes · 18/01/2023 12:40

I don’t think that’s necessarily the case at all

If you’re referring to my comment on “more love” why did you say it? As I say, it’s going to be another 10 to 15 years before we’re able to judge the success of today’s parenting methods.

yorkshirepudsx · 18/01/2023 12:37

Getinajollymood · 18/01/2023 12:32

I don’t think that’s necessarily the case at all @Blossomtoes but people seem to be saying that children nowadays have more attention given to them and some see that as a bad thing; I don’t.

I agree @Getinajollymood , it's not a bad thing at all. X

Getinajollymood · 18/01/2023 12:32

I don’t think that’s necessarily the case at all @Blossomtoes but people seem to be saying that children nowadays have more attention given to them and some see that as a bad thing; I don’t.

Blossomtoes · 18/01/2023 12:24

I’m never sure why more time, more attention, more love, is seen as a bad thing

How presumptuous to think the children of the current generation of parents are more loved. As for more time and attention, the results of that seem to be coming through now In university entrants who can’t budget, do their own washing or cooking and frequently can’t even get themselves to lectures. Goodness only knows what’s going to happen when they start work.

Getinajollymood · 18/01/2023 11:45

I honestly don’t think the ills of society are being caused by children being taken to petting zoos, @Cuppasoupmonster