Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if parenting really was easier in the past?

343 replies

germanbight · 17/01/2023 19:46

My beloved grandma, who lived on a small farm and really ran it alone, always used to tut at toddlers/small children who were being naughty out and about and always told me that when she had her children it was all much simpler— especially in the baby phase.

Apparently routine kept all 4 children perfect from baby-hood. Baby fed every three hours until it slept through, all children off for an afternoon nap after dinner and bedtime a prompt 7:30 until they were 10. She always used to say that now parents adapt to fit the baby in their lives, but when she was having children they had to adapt to her life.

I just don’t see how it could’ve run on clockwork like that. Was it really that much easier? Just a case of endless CIO?

OP posts:
QueenSmartypants · 18/01/2023 20:58

PermanentTemporary · 18/01/2023 20:19

I really liked reading that when Anne Boleyn was about to give birth, 3 maids were employed just to rock the cradle. Baby care has always been tough.

'Ealth & safety.

Cradle rocking is a killer for RSI

PermanentTemporary · 18/01/2023 20:19

I really liked reading that when Anne Boleyn was about to give birth, 3 maids were employed just to rock the cradle. Baby care has always been tough.

ivykaty44 · 18/01/2023 20:14

We were encouraged to get children into a 3 or 4 hour feeding regime from birth. Most of the day the babies were outside in the pram.

do you think this was a better way of doing things? And how did this work with breast feeding opposed to bottle feeding.

thise babies I remember being feed every 4 hrs were bottle feed, not breast

CoalCraft · 18/01/2023 19:36

Apparently my dad was a screamy baby (colic I guess) so Gran would just shut him in a drawer for a few hours 😬

babsanderson · 18/01/2023 19:34

Hongkongsuey · 18/01/2023 19:21

Speaking as someone whose own children are adults and who remembers that era very well, I think it was easier. Contrary to a previous poster, abuse and neglect were not rife in my WC neighbourhood-but children were allowed a lot more freedom. Indeed, it was expected they would entertain themselves-and we would play out all day doing hopscotch, French skipping, Elastics(who remembers that!) and on the local playground. Parents didn’t seem to helicopter around their kids, constantly anxious. We had firmer boundaries around what was expected of children.In most of the families I knew, there was always one parent at home-not great for career development but less stress with time management. In some ways things are easier-better,Labour saving appliances mean less time is spent on drudgery. There is more acceptance now of children who don’t fit in the majority mould-children who didn’t fit in in my youth had to carry a lot of shame around. There is more informality in parent child relationships which can improve relations as kids grow up. So good things and bad things really!

In my working class neighbourhood all the mums worked, although usually part time. Cleaners, dinner ladies, factory work - not careers but they needed the money.
But I agree about kids going out to play and not having to entertain them all the time.

florentina1 · 18/01/2023 19:24

I am in my 70s, I definitely think it was easier physically for our generation. The main reason because most of us only needed one income. There was fairly reasonable rented accommodation as well as LA housing which was rent controlled.

We never had much money, labour saving devices or husbands who helped with childcare or housework. The majority of girls were not educated to a high standard or expected to earn a living after marriage. The ambition was limited to getting a husband and having children.

We were encouraged to get children into a 3 or 4 hour feeding regime from birth. Most of the day the babies were outside in the pram.

Hongkongsuey · 18/01/2023 19:21

Speaking as someone whose own children are adults and who remembers that era very well, I think it was easier. Contrary to a previous poster, abuse and neglect were not rife in my WC neighbourhood-but children were allowed a lot more freedom. Indeed, it was expected they would entertain themselves-and we would play out all day doing hopscotch, French skipping, Elastics(who remembers that!) and on the local playground. Parents didn’t seem to helicopter around their kids, constantly anxious. We had firmer boundaries around what was expected of children.In most of the families I knew, there was always one parent at home-not great for career development but less stress with time management. In some ways things are easier-better,Labour saving appliances mean less time is spent on drudgery. There is more acceptance now of children who don’t fit in the majority mould-children who didn’t fit in in my youth had to carry a lot of shame around. There is more informality in parent child relationships which can improve relations as kids grow up. So good things and bad things really!

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 18/01/2023 19:14

realmsofglory · 18/01/2023 15:00

I honestly think things were better for children. They had to use their imagination and ingenuity to make their entertainment. They grew up (well most of them) learning how to manage risk, sort out problems and allowed to do more stuff. I remember as a child about 8 or 9 going to do 'campfires with a couple of friends in the counryside where e we would build a fire and fry bacon and sausages and egg. At 12 we were off 'wild camping' . Goff on a day lone bike ride-no adults Contrast that to nowadays where parents werent allowed to hold a y6 leavers barbeque because it was 'too dangerous'.
Kids left prinary school wth a good basic education because they didn't learn about so much bollocks in the primay curriculum today. Kids know they were te kids, and knew adults they were in charge

Except a lot of parents were only in charge when and how it suited them.

And let's not pretend the free roaming was a parenting choice or even a conscious decision for the benefit of the children. It was socially acceptable ,the easy way out and it suited them/their lifestyle.

Blossomtoes · 18/01/2023 19:08

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 18/01/2023 18:55

Can't or won't?

It amounts to the same thing. Either way it’s hardly indicative of effective parenting.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 18/01/2023 18:55

Blossomtoes · 18/01/2023 12:24

I’m never sure why more time, more attention, more love, is seen as a bad thing

How presumptuous to think the children of the current generation of parents are more loved. As for more time and attention, the results of that seem to be coming through now In university entrants who can’t budget, do their own washing or cooking and frequently can’t even get themselves to lectures. Goodness only knows what’s going to happen when they start work.

Can't or won't?

magicthree · 18/01/2023 18:42

going back further, it was accepted that some kids would die young anyway, that's why they had large families, so it was less bothersome if your child got ill because that was just the way of the world

It couldn't have been they had large families because birth control wasn't as available or effective as it is now could it? Honestly, I have never read such rubbish. Incidentally, my DF was one of three and my DM an only child!

magicthree · 18/01/2023 18:38

Wow really! I work with so many elderly people who say the had a lovely childhood, running around, more free play and how no one died, yet on mumsnet and someone is saying so many accidents yes likely happens now ! but a number of people die to accident, they may still happen now but no increase in number statistically.There are still accidents now but bubble wrapping which is very unhealthy which isn't allowing children to navigate the world as it should. I have never spoken to an elder generation who has said times are better now and i work with many and have for years. Big topic of conversation takes gone by and being chilsren.

Another sensible post. I'm heading towards elderly myself and don't recall childen dying like flies in my childhood. In fact only two children died in my town in my youth - one from cancer and the other drowned, and children still drown here every year. My parents both had enjoyable childhoods - now in their 90s. I feel sorry for children these days, they don't have the carefree time I and my friends did.

magicthree · 18/01/2023 18:31

ancientgran · 18/01/2023 05:53

I'm sitting here in tears, thinking of the mothers of the past being written off as callous as the death of a child not meaning as much to them as it would to anyone now.

I think this thread should be taken down because of that post. I'm truly horrified at the self satisfied nature if that is how modern women think.

Well said @ancientgran

This idea that today's parents are the only ones who care about their children really irritates me. My grandmother lost her first baby not long after his birth and was still sad about it right to the end of her life. Some posters on MN are far more callous in my opinion. People have always loved and cared for their children and wanted the best for them. Yes, there were neglectful/cruel parents in the past - and there are still plenty of those today.

Blueflag22 · 18/01/2023 17:22

Newnamenewname109870 · 17/01/2023 20:18

I mean there was very little understanding about child’s psychological development ans child abuse was pretty normalised.

My gran let my dad run around the streets as a toddler. The accidents, omg. She even said she knew a number of people who lost babies due to accidents. Horrific.
Oh and she tied him into bed to get him to sleep at nap times.

So yeah, pretty awful. You’ve got to look at all the messed up people out there.

There was also much less grass is greener and am I doing the right thing/AIBU like now where you go on the internet and constantly worry and feel judged.

Wow really! I work with so many elderly people who say the had a lovely childhood, running around, more free play and how no one died, yet on mumsnet and someone is saying so many accidents yes likely happens now ! but a number of people die to accident, they may still happen now but no increase in number statistically.There are still accidents now but bubble wrapping which is very unhealthy which isn't allowing children to navigate the world as it should. I have never spoken to an elder generation who has said times are better now and i work with many and have for years. Big topic of conversation takes gone by and being chilsren.

ancientgran · 18/01/2023 17:07

Twanky · 18/01/2023 13:17

Don't get upset by it, think of it as written by a smug idiot who thinks she's God's gift to being a parent and she most certainly isn't.

That did make me smile. I just think it is hurtful to think of people like my gran and their heartbreak just being dismissed by someone who hasn't got a clue. I remember my mother saying that when she was a child in the 1920s and money was very short my gran would have a slice of bread and butter while the children had their dinner. She would tell them she had eaten earlier but she hadn't, she had given the food she had to the children. No one can tell me she didn't love her children as much as any 21st century mother.

QueenSmartypants · 18/01/2023 16:59

going back further, it was accepted that some kids would die young anyway, that's why they had large families, so it was less bothersome if your child got ill because that was just the way of the world

That just isn't true. Knowing your child might not survive did stop you loving them just much. The evidence of how brokenhearted parents were is everywhere.

Blossomtoes · 18/01/2023 16:56

going back further, it was accepted that some kids would die young anyway, that's why they had large families, so it was less bothersome if your child got ill because that was just the way of the world

If anyone is tempted to believe this nonsense, read the account of a child’s death here. I defy you not be be moved.

www.theguardian.com/society/2014/jun/04/coalition-attacks-nhs-return-britain-age-workhouse

ivykaty44 · 18/01/2023 16:34

www.goodwood.com/grr/road/news/2020/4/1955-vs.-2020--how-uk-roads-have-changed-in-65-years/

how life was back in the 1950s compared to now

lockdown saw the level of car journeys as there was in the 1950s

ivykaty44 · 18/01/2023 16:30

housing was more affordable and people could realistically buy in their early 20s with one income and pay it off in their 40s

1920s. At the end of the first world war, Britain was a nation in which almost 80% of people rented their homes, almost all from private landlords.

buying and running a car was cheaper than even public transport is today, in relative terms
In 1923 there were 383,525 cars on the roads of Great Britain

going back further, it was accepted that some kids would die young anyway, that's why they had large families, so it was less bothersome if your child got ill because that was just the way of the world

It wasn't accepted that children died, it was as painful then as it is now

Stunningscreamer · 18/01/2023 16:26

DifficultBloodyWoman · 18/01/2023 06:36

I find it interesting that several posters have used the phrase ‘beaten into submission’ and more have echoed that sentiment.

Whether you are using it literally or figuratively, do you really believe that most/the majority of children fitted into or around their parents’ lives by force?

In my, albeit fuzzy, recollection of my childhood, I fitted around my parents but it wasn’t a hardship in any way. It was just an adult centred life. And it was perfectly normal. When I misbehaved, there would be consequences such as having to leave the shop or restaurant but then I would learn not to repeat that behaviour. So my behaviour was pretty good and also improved with time.

I really don’t consider that being beaten into submission.

I guess we can only talk about our own experiences, as we don't know everyone else's but, yes, my parents did use hitting and shouting more than explaining and modelling good behaviour. Also we had things thrown at us (chalk, books) at my primary school, the slipper and cane were used, people were led round by their ears and we were screamed at in senior school by some of the teachers.

As I say I was regularly told off by adults for things that wouldn't even be noticed now, as I was a pretty good child anyway.

ancientgran · 18/01/2023 16:23

CallTheMobWife · 18/01/2023 16:02

I think everyone is imagining different time periods and specific set ups and pontificating as if they are some kind of widespread reality. We have thoughts wandering from somewhere around the late 18th century right up to the 1990's.

Most of it is utter nonsense

Amen to that.

ancientgran · 18/01/2023 16:22

People's ideas of the past are funny. I worked in the 70s as we couldn't afford a mortgage on an old two up two down on one wage. Children didn't all eat what was put in front of them, my sister would have died as she would starve rather than eat most things. Kids didn't all go to bed earlier, parents loved their children and grieved if they died. I went to a Catholic primary school in the inner city, they certainly did enforce the uniform, I remember a boy who insisted on wearing long trousers as he didn't like shorts, one day he was stood on a desk and his trousers were turned into shorts. My kids did lots of activities in the 70s and they weren't all by themselves, there were even waiting lists for things like brownies/cubs and swimming lessons. My parents never had a car, we got our first car in the 80s, definitely couldn't afford one in the 70s.

I'm not sure if I should laugh or cry.

cptartapp · 18/01/2023 16:20

Many families of years gone by had a lot more extended family help. We spent many days and nights at my GP when I was young. When my DC came along my DM could easily go a month without seeing us. She was working at first and then when retired had the disposable income to lead a full life including lots of shopping and many foreign holidays.
My DC may have had more material things and wider experiences than I did as a child, but DH and I as parents had far far less hands on help that we didn't have to pay a small fortune for over the years.

CallTheMobWife · 18/01/2023 16:02

I think everyone is imagining different time periods and specific set ups and pontificating as if they are some kind of widespread reality. We have thoughts wandering from somewhere around the late 18th century right up to the 1990's.

Most of it is utter nonsense

Blossomtoes · 18/01/2023 15:58

going back even further you could send your child into pseudo-slavery in the form of service to a family or being sent to serve a term of a few years as an apprentice, so there was money to be made out of your child.

You do know what apprentices and servants were paid in the period you’re referring to? There was no money to be made. Some apprenticeships actually cost money as a premium had to be paid upfront.

Swipe left for the next trending thread