Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if parenting really was easier in the past?

343 replies

germanbight · 17/01/2023 19:46

My beloved grandma, who lived on a small farm and really ran it alone, always used to tut at toddlers/small children who were being naughty out and about and always told me that when she had her children it was all much simpler— especially in the baby phase.

Apparently routine kept all 4 children perfect from baby-hood. Baby fed every three hours until it slept through, all children off for an afternoon nap after dinner and bedtime a prompt 7:30 until they were 10. She always used to say that now parents adapt to fit the baby in their lives, but when she was having children they had to adapt to her life.

I just don’t see how it could’ve run on clockwork like that. Was it really that much easier? Just a case of endless CIO?

OP posts:
Sausagenbacon · 19/01/2023 08:22

I think social media has made us aware you just can't trust folk now though. Horror stories
One of the problems with Social Media and life today.
Because I think you can trust people. The women on the group were all mums that you knew, and you knew their children. Because, as a SAHM , you had time to get to know them.
Yes, being a SAHM was often boring, but you did build up a support network (my family didn't live nearby).

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 19/01/2023 08:16

Sausagenbacon · 19/01/2023 07:59

My children are in their 30s, so I did my childbearing in the past.
The big difference I notice is that parents don't seem to allow themselves downtime.
I belonged in a babysitting group, which was common, so you could easily go out together without children, knowing that they were being cared for by another mum.
Unless we were on holiday, we didn't eat out with our children.
I think it's a shame that parents haven't got that safety valve anymore.

I think social media has made us aware you just can't trust folk now though. Horror stories

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 19/01/2023 08:15

I think parents back in the day just ignored their kids crying. My granny me tions this as a "just had to get the work done" type thing.
Kids had to fit into adult lives and I think it's the opposite now.
My mum said she and dad were 26 when they had my brother and then 27 when they had me so they were still young and wanted to go out. I know we were left to cry it out.
We were left in the car for an age whilst they went to the bank and god knows what else.
She thinks because me and DH were older we had all our partying days out of our system which is probably true.
But also I don't want to leave my kids to cry...
They were much harsher on me and my brother than what I am with my children.

Iam4eels · 19/01/2023 08:09

For those who felt it was easier, once you have more than one DC how much help did you have/expect from your elder DC?

I was expected to mind younger siblings, heat up my dad's tea when my mam was working (and do those dishes), put youngest sibling to bed while dad ate, and generally do various bits of housework when she was at work. From the age of 11 I became the family babysitterbecause I was considered sensible and would look after my siblings and younger cousins while the adults were out. At that point my aunt had five children ranging from six months old to seven years old and I was regularly looking after them from 6pm to after midnight every weekend. My cousins of similar age to me were also family babysitters.

My parents and aunts all think parenting was easier but they seem to forget they were all reliant on their first-born daughters to grease the wheels and keep it all running.

Sausagenbacon · 19/01/2023 07:59

My children are in their 30s, so I did my childbearing in the past.
The big difference I notice is that parents don't seem to allow themselves downtime.
I belonged in a babysitting group, which was common, so you could easily go out together without children, knowing that they were being cared for by another mum.
Unless we were on holiday, we didn't eat out with our children.
I think it's a shame that parents haven't got that safety valve anymore.

Cuppasoupmonster · 19/01/2023 07:44

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 19/01/2023 07:31

How much free time would you have if you had no school runs, no helping with homework/reading, not having to spend time with your child playing,talking etc, no clubs , no school involvement and so on?

If basically all you had to do for them was feed them and keep them clean and they were out of your way most of the day.

Sounds ideal to me.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 19/01/2023 07:31

PennythePenguin · 19/01/2023 06:56

I've decided to have no more kids as it's too hard but I wonder how I would cope years ago. Would it be easier as I could send the kids out all day or worse as I'd be quite housebound doing cleaning etc ?

How much free time would you have if you had no school runs, no helping with homework/reading, not having to spend time with your child playing,talking etc, no clubs , no school involvement and so on?

If basically all you had to do for them was feed them and keep them clean and they were out of your way most of the day.

PennythePenguin · 19/01/2023 06:56

I've decided to have no more kids as it's too hard but I wonder how I would cope years ago. Would it be easier as I could send the kids out all day or worse as I'd be quite housebound doing cleaning etc ?

BMrs · 19/01/2023 06:54

I think life has evolved sand we as parents have evolved with it. Similarly to your Gran though, I've always had a strict regime with nap times and bed time etc. and worked around this.

A few posters have said they feel pressure to parent a certain way. I don't feel that pressure but do what comes naturally and I make an effort to try to meet the needs of my children that weren't met for me as a child. E.g. 1 of 4 kids so got very little attention and 1:1 time. Was given too much responsibility too young and spoken to as though I was an adult.

I just believe in knowing better and doing better. I would prefer more family support but we moved away from our families 6 years ago for career.

ballroompink · 19/01/2023 06:47

garlictwist · 19/01/2023 04:51

I agree. I was born early eighties and I don't know any mums that didn't work. I don't think it's ever been normal to have widespread stay at home mums in the way people assume. Most women work. My grandma worked full time too and she was parenting in the 1940s/50s.

Same - also early 80s. I think mums tended to stay at home while they had children under school age but then work once children were at school. I grew up in a small rural town so people's mums didn't have big careers etc. but friends' mums worked as teachers/TAs/lunchtime supervisors, in the school office, in retail, in local offices etc.

Kitkatcatflap · 19/01/2023 06:38

MrsHughesPinny · 17/01/2023 20:26

When I was under 10 (1980s) Mums (mine or friends/family) never really interacted with children like we’re expected to now. We were told to go away and play and that’s what we did! If we said we were bored we were told “only boring people get bored, find something to do!” That really stuck with me! 😂

My Mum used to tell me repeatedly when DS was small that I was spoiling him by answering him immediately when he interrupted or asked me something. She’d just say “adults are talking now, unless you’re bleeding it can wait!”

Just a different time and set of expectations.

I grew up in the 70s and so relate to hearing 'only boring people get bored'. I remember having books, but not my mother reading to me. I remember having craft kits but not my mother doing them with me. I had toys but it was up to me to play with them. Dressing up clothes were my mum's old clothes and a mad great Aunty who send play clothes for the kids. I never felt neglected, it was up to me to find something to do.

But looking back she was busy - cooking from scratch. Top loader washing machine with sopping wet clothes at the end of it. WASHING NAPPIES. Lots of hand washing - tons of ironing. Who irons nowaday? Children started school later back them. I was five, no nursery. Children being dragged around the shops being told to hold onto the pram.

I had my children later and loved all the baby groups, children's activities, I never saw children's parties as a chore. There is so much paraphernalia around babies and young children - remember the wet wipes warmer from a few years ago? I did all the reading with my kids, crafts, there own size dress up clothes. So many activities - definitely so much around entertaining kids as opposed to just letting them run free outside. Looking back I think it was okay for me to be bored and be told to go and find something to do because I did find something. But I think it's easier now

garlictwist · 19/01/2023 04:51

Getinajollymood · 17/01/2023 20:38

@Iam4eels is right.

Posters referring to having a mum at home are referring to a very specific post war - 1980s period, and it really wasn’t representative of history as a whole or a particularly golden era in respect of bringing up children (hence the radical feminist movement in the latter part of the twentieth century.)

I agree. I was born early eighties and I don't know any mums that didn't work. I don't think it's ever been normal to have widespread stay at home mums in the way people assume. Most women work. My grandma worked full time too and she was parenting in the 1940s/50s.

PuzzleMonster · 19/01/2023 04:43

ivykaty44 · 19/01/2023 04:30

Absolutely agree. So many people just suffered with no help or support. A lot of the generation brought up in the 50s and 60s even still have this attitude sadly. Not all obviously but a lot, they do not want to hear about mental health and won't discuss things they did that caused huge damage.

asylums we’re places that people were scared of, and that is where you would end up with no escape if you were mentally ill. It’s no surprise people kept quiet and didn’t seek support in the 1950s/1950s

Indeed. Although you'd hope those people might have learned from that and welcome a soceity which is moving towards treating vulnerable people more humanely, rather than defending how things used to be.

PuzzleMonster · 19/01/2023 04:42

HamBone · 19/01/2023 03:18

II think we can safely ignore any parenting advice from anybody who thinks such times were "better". Might have been easier for the parents, but certainly not better for children.

@PuzzleMonster i take your points, but I think it’s also v. subjective depending on our personal experiences. Both my DH and I were born in the ‘70’s and we were lucky to have loving parents so less oversight didn’t really hurt us, plus we’re both NT. I agree that the stigma attached to MH was an issue in the 1980’s and 90’s. I didn’t receive any counseling when my family experienced some very difficult times and it would’ve made a huge difference if I’d had some support as I started suffering from anxiety. Nowadays we accept that trauma affects children and we’re encouraged to ask for help.

Yes. So be healthy, neurotypical and lucky and then that childhood is great. So much freedom! If you get ill or have mental health issues or happen to be neurodiverse or have abusive parents then sorry, bad luck, no help for you. And even if you happen to have loving parents but are one of the unlicky ones who dies in an horrific way that was totally avoidable then I guess you're just collateral damage, too.

It may have been ok for some, but there are very good reasons that parenting has changed.

ivykaty44 · 19/01/2023 04:30

Absolutely agree. So many people just suffered with no help or support. A lot of the generation brought up in the 50s and 60s even still have this attitude sadly. Not all obviously but a lot, they do not want to hear about mental health and won't discuss things they did that caused huge damage.

asylums we’re places that people were scared of, and that is where you would end up with no escape if you were mentally ill. It’s no surprise people kept quiet and didn’t seek support in the 1950s/1950s

HamBone · 19/01/2023 03:18

II think we can safely ignore any parenting advice from anybody who thinks such times were "better". Might have been easier for the parents, but certainly not better for children.

@PuzzleMonster i take your points, but I think it’s also v. subjective depending on our personal experiences. Both my DH and I were born in the ‘70’s and we were lucky to have loving parents so less oversight didn’t really hurt us, plus we’re both NT. I agree that the stigma attached to MH was an issue in the 1980’s and 90’s. I didn’t receive any counseling when my family experienced some very difficult times and it would’ve made a huge difference if I’d had some support as I started suffering from anxiety. Nowadays we accept that trauma affects children and we’re encouraged to ask for help.

PuzzleMonster · 19/01/2023 01:45

The childhood friends I had in the 80s who died tragically when even basic parenting (i.e. an adult being present with small children) wouod have prevented it were a 4 year old drowning in a pond, a 6 year old falling out of a tree that was not suitable for climbing at all and smashing his head on concrete and an unsupervised 7 year old being hit by a car.

I think we can safely ignore any parenting advice from anybody who thinks such times were "better". Might have been easier for the parents, but certainly not better for children.

PuzzleMonster · 19/01/2023 01:12

Actually, when I think about it, a person who was born in 1900 lived through during WW1, then lived through the influenza pandemic, then the Depression, was 45 when WW2 ended, had every reason to be anxious, depressed, suffer ptsd etc.

I was born around 1960, and remember that a mentally unwell person was seen as being weak - having some sort of character failing, a coward who just needed to ‘pull up their socks, get their heads on straight, and get on with it’ So a lot of people would have just suffered quietly.

Absolutely agree. So many people just suffered with no help or support. A lot of the generation brought up in the 50s and 60s even still have this attitude sadly. Not all obviously but a lot, they do not want to hear about mental health and won't discuss things they did that caused huge damage. Things are still not good, but we're at least moving in the right direction towards actually caring for how people feel and realising that physical needs are not all that matters. And that's true with children more than anybody else as they cannot get help for themselves.

It is their parents' job to give them an environment to grow up in that fosters good mental health, and to help them and get them the support they need when they are struggling. This simply did not happen in many cases even when I was a child in the 80s and 90s. As an ealier poster admitted, some parents saw simply clothing and feeding their children as sufficient parenting. It isn't.

HamBone · 19/01/2023 00:43

I agree, @Morestrangethings . At least we recognize and are willing to talk about MH issues now. A few decades ago, someone might be described as “having nerves” and their problems would be swept under the carpet. Taking sick leave for stress or anxiety-related reasons would be unthinkable- I imagine many people struggled on and/or ended up physically ill as well.

Morestrangethings · 19/01/2023 00:35

rightsaidfreddie · 18/01/2023 23:35

Someone recently spoke to me about the following. I don't know if eh is so true or not:

Years ago our grandparents weren't always so materialistic as we are now (me included).

They didn't seem to need en-suites and separate bedrooms for all the kids, expensive clothes, holidays, big TVs and a car each etc. So the wife often stayed at home whilst the husband worked, or the wife just worked part time.

Although money was tight, there was generally a parent at home with the kids so they had more time to concentrate on home life, which made things more simple.

Nowadays we are generally all working and rushed off our feet to pay the bills for the nicer things, so effectively we've all made it harder on ourselves!

I think that some of what you say is true but it was often very hard for the women at home. It was expected that nearly everything to do with home life, including children, was her responsibility. But their work had no value in the eyes of society in general. With a lack of ‘value,’ comes powerlessness. There was nowhere to turn if you were regularly being beaten up by your husband. It was very much, ‘ you made your bed, now you lie in it.’

A man often did carry the burden of being the sole provider (money-wise) for his family. This was a more powerful position than that of his wife. While there were many decent, honourable men, there was also a lot of bullying bastards. If you married a man that turned out to be a bullying bastard, where did you go? And if you had somewhere to go, it’s still hard to leave for many women - even now when there is more social encouragement to do so. How much harder would it have been when there was absolutely no safety nets.

Morestrangethings · 19/01/2023 00:20

Cuppasoupmonster · 18/01/2023 23:29

There aren’t any fewer messed up young people now though, even with all this knowledge and better safety etc 🤷🏼‍♀️ MH issues in young people are rife and more common than ever

I think it’s unlikely that MH issues are ‘more common than ever,’ now. I think MH issues are now more commonly recognised. Perhaps the pandemic has seen an increase, but this would also be true of global events in the past - WW2, The Great Depression, the Flu pandemic and WW1 etc..

Actually, when I think about it, a person who was born in 1900 lived through during WW1, then lived through the influenza pandemic, then the Depression, was 45 when WW2 ended, had every reason to be anxious, depressed, suffer ptsd etc.

I was born around 1960, and remember that a mentally unwell person was seen as being weak - having some sort of character failing, a coward who just needed to ‘pull up their socks, get their heads on straight, and get on with it’ So a lot of people would have just suffered quietly.

Twanky · 19/01/2023 00:05

Blossomtoes · 18/01/2023 23:29

Lots of things have changed. We were taught to put our babies down on their tummies, breast feeding wasn’t encouraged the way it is now and we started weaning at three months wit baby rice and purées. It will all be different again in ten or 20 years.

In the mid and late 70s when I had our two we were encouraged to breastfeed, they both settled to a more or less 4 hour schedule but would be topped up if necessary. The advice from somewhere apparently was for front sleeping, I don't recall getting any input from outsiders though, SSAFA popped in the day I came home with No 1, saw things were OK and we drank sherry for an hour, don't recall anyone coming after No 2. Maybe if new parents trusted themselves a bit more they may be happier. One thing I never did and really don't understand is this constantly having a baby strapped to you then wondering why s/he can't be put down!

PuzzleMonster · 18/01/2023 23:44

rightsaidfreddie · 18/01/2023 23:35

Someone recently spoke to me about the following. I don't know if eh is so true or not:

Years ago our grandparents weren't always so materialistic as we are now (me included).

They didn't seem to need en-suites and separate bedrooms for all the kids, expensive clothes, holidays, big TVs and a car each etc. So the wife often stayed at home whilst the husband worked, or the wife just worked part time.

Although money was tight, there was generally a parent at home with the kids so they had more time to concentrate on home life, which made things more simple.

Nowadays we are generally all working and rushed off our feet to pay the bills for the nicer things, so effectively we've all made it harder on ourselves!

This is utter rubbish as economic data demonstrates that most people now need two incomes to main the average standard of living. What they had was a luxury of maintaining an average standard of living with just one income of 1.5.

As a lone parent who works full time I still look after my children with far more care than was the average way of parenting when I was a child and many more families proportionately could afford a stay at home mother, than can now.

I had a stay at home mother myself and my own childhood was neglectful and abusive.

There is no correlation demonstrated anywhere in any research about stay at home mothers or fathers leading to better child outcomes.

The problems in the past were driven by awful attitudes to parenting and very poor understanding of child development and safeguarding. This caused huge damage to children's mental health, as well as many avoidable deaths.

Sure, not putting much effort into parenting was easier for parents. But that doesn't make it ok. And it's a good thing that these days social services would get involved in many of these cases and prevent what many used to consider acceptable - bullying children, shouting at them and emotionally abusing them, hitting them, putting them in dangerous situations with no supervision - and stop this happening.

Twanky · 18/01/2023 23:42

Blossomtoes · 18/01/2023 09:55

I know. It’s incredibly callous. My great grandma had 15 children, seven of them survived to adulthood with most of them dying as babies. It broke my heart, how could anyone survive that? My dad’s sister died of meningitis in the 1930s, she was 12. My grandparents never got over it.

I transcribe old registers for an on-line genealogy site and sometimes it's heart breaking, families in the late 1800s/early 1900s where a father would be burying his wife and newborn babies on the same day, where families were burying three or more children within the space of a couple of weeks. My mother and father lost a child at almost 7 just after the war, I was the 'replacement' for him, and my mother especially never really got over that loss. Apparently she walked up to the Churchyard every day during the awful winter of 1947 for weeks, it took the Vicar to persuade her not to put her health at risk and stop going so often. There was nothing callous about her behaviour nor I'm sure about the behaviours of those who records I transcribed.

rightsaidfreddie · 18/01/2023 23:35

Someone recently spoke to me about the following. I don't know if eh is so true or not:

Years ago our grandparents weren't always so materialistic as we are now (me included).

They didn't seem to need en-suites and separate bedrooms for all the kids, expensive clothes, holidays, big TVs and a car each etc. So the wife often stayed at home whilst the husband worked, or the wife just worked part time.

Although money was tight, there was generally a parent at home with the kids so they had more time to concentrate on home life, which made things more simple.

Nowadays we are generally all working and rushed off our feet to pay the bills for the nicer things, so effectively we've all made it harder on ourselves!