Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if parenting really was easier in the past?

343 replies

germanbight · 17/01/2023 19:46

My beloved grandma, who lived on a small farm and really ran it alone, always used to tut at toddlers/small children who were being naughty out and about and always told me that when she had her children it was all much simpler— especially in the baby phase.

Apparently routine kept all 4 children perfect from baby-hood. Baby fed every three hours until it slept through, all children off for an afternoon nap after dinner and bedtime a prompt 7:30 until they were 10. She always used to say that now parents adapt to fit the baby in their lives, but when she was having children they had to adapt to her life.

I just don’t see how it could’ve run on clockwork like that. Was it really that much easier? Just a case of endless CIO?

OP posts:
junebirthdaygirl · 17/01/2023 21:43

I was a child in 60s/ 70s. My dm had a big lrish family. She said herself it was easier because she didn't go out to work like all her dds. There was no rushing around in the morning stressing to be in time for work. No coming home exhausted trying to get dinner/ clubs etc.
She was super organised having learned in school how to be a good housewife!! She kept a very steady routine which l feel looking back was the most security building aspect of my childhood. We lived in the countryside so no being let off to do our own thing. My dm had a big bunch of siblings. She was a young dm and had a lot of social interaction with them which would have been supportive. My dad was pretty involved and hands on and we spent a lot of time with him outdoors. My dm had the capacity to run a tight ship around bed times/ chores etc without seeming to be stressed around it or cross.

I wouldn't have wanted her life but she said she wouldn't have wanted our lives. I expected my life to be easier with holidays/ catch up with friends/ gym etc. She expected none of that .
She was prepared to work far harder than me. Always busy always productive.

girlfriend44 · 17/01/2023 21:39

There was not the pressures that there are now like wanting the latest phones and designer gear. It wasn't around.
Children were generally better behaved and more respectful.

Ishouldgodostuff · 17/01/2023 21:35

I remember my 1st Mum in law telling me that routine was the key to keep in mind - while expecting my first child in the early 1980s. She was a Mum to 9 children & said all things could be managed by staying organised. Apparently her 4 older kids would each have a younger sibling to be in charge of, leaving her with the baby for their (infrequent) car rides, trips out visiting etc.
Each of their children too had specific chores around the house & yard so helping with milking the cows, dishes, laundry etc based on the age & sex of each. She had worked part time as a cleaner from when the youngest was a toddler.
When my eldest was tiny in 1982 even the HV stressed the importance of 4 hourly feeding routines & CIO's - I was super stressed though with it all & prob had PND but can remember him screaming his wee lungs out while I bottled fruit for preserving & my Mum & MIL both telling me to leave him or he'd be spoiled.
As a child though in the early 1960s we were often outdoors & away from the house all day, I can remember friends werent allowed in their bedrooms at all except for sleeping & if my Mum was tired/grumpy we would be made to take a nap so she could rest (aged then maybe 10 or 12 - seriously uncool).
I think routines & what the neighbours thought of your house/well behaved children mattered more than playing games with them, spending time with your kids in the era I grew up in - a real shame in hindsight but as others have mentioned societal pressure was intense even without social media platforms.

Babycakes6 · 17/01/2023 21:23

Yes, it was easier for sure, there was no internet! Thanks to the internet, kids know too much and want too much. (Especially the toys they see on YouTube!)

And this one thing for sure: we were not getting so much homework. I feel like I am actually attending the school all over again, so involved in DD’s homework! It’s taking away most of my evenings and I’m already working full time, cleaning, cooking etc

In my days, we learnt everything at school but these days they seem to play at school and leave the actual schooling to parents 🙈

Caramia23 · 17/01/2023 21:19

I think it was easier in the sense that societal expectations of parents were much lower. As a pp has said, in the (even not so distant) past kids slotted into parents lives but nowadays kids are front and centre of every single thing and parents lives are expected to revolve around kids to their own detriment.
I'm not saying the way I was reared in the 80's was perfect (it wasn't) but I think the pendulum has now swung too far the other way resulting in a lot of stressed, exhausted parents who constantly feel like they're failing & also a lot of stressed, exhausted kids who have no tolerance of boredom & who are often way too over stimulated.

MissWings · 17/01/2023 21:18

I had 3 close together and genuinely found baby and toddlerhood easy. I did have a good routine which was rather militant but I also took 10 years off work. I suspect the latter making it a whole lot easier.

mooongooose · 17/01/2023 21:17

ancientgran · 17/01/2023 21:09

I had my first in 1971, no washing machine, no tumble dryer, no fridge, no central heating, no freezer, no car, no disposables, no money. I didn't find it very easy.

Exactly- why on earth would it have been more convenient without modern technology?!

Ihatethenewlook · 17/01/2023 21:16

VestaTilley · 17/01/2023 19:57

It was a time of wide spread child abuse and neglect. Beatings were common, corporal punishment in schools was perfectly legal.

I don’t believe it’s ever been easy - but if children were quieter in the past it’s because they were beaten in to submission. Not a past I think we want to return to.

This. I was the youngest of 2, I was my sisters responsibility when I was born, she was 6. When she was 9 and I was 3 we were left from morning til late at night. Both my parents worked all day. My dad did a day shift, my mum did split shifts at a pub and my dad used to leave us to go drinking there every evening. We were alone almost all of the time. I’d catch the public bus to nursery on my own from age 4. The discipline was completely normal for the rural village we were brought up in, I think we had it good compared to some other families. But it included violence for every misdemeanour. We never answered back. We weren’t allowed to laugh in the house. We weren’t allowed to accidentally wake a sleeping parent up. If we didn’t finish our dinner we got sent to the garden and the plates thrown at our heads. Ss seemed to be non existent back then. My mum lost her temper at my sister and threw her across the room resulting in a broken arm. My brother had a fractured eye socket from my mum shoving him over when he was in the bath. I had perforated ear drums from being slapped around the head. They didn’t hide what had happened, just no one gave a shite. And I’m only in my 30’s so it’s not like this was 60 years ago.

ThatsGoingToHurt · 17/01/2023 21:11

My mum was a SAHM but both me and my brother went to nursery school every morning. I remember my nan picking me up and giving me a jam doughnut. My husband all went to nursery for afternoons and his mum was a SAHM. It was free which is why we were sent! It was acceptable as it gave wives more time to do housework and at it gave kids the chance to let of some steam!

ancientgran · 17/01/2023 21:09

I had my first in 1971, no washing machine, no tumble dryer, no fridge, no central heating, no freezer, no car, no disposables, no money. I didn't find it very easy.

MybabyH · 17/01/2023 21:08

My gran (passed away last year -early 90s) sadly told me she wished she cuddled her babies more often. One of her biggest life regrets - not cuddling her babies when they were tiny.

Back in her days they had a strict routine of putting the babies out in the pram for fresh air at the bottom of the garden whilst she got on with the housework. Her lads weren't allowed to many cuddles otherwise it'd make them "soft" according to her HV. When they could toddle they went out to play with the kids on the street - looked after by the neighbours eldest daughter. She told me that the same neighbours daughter took her then four week old into school with her - so the class could use the baby (my uncle) for home economics - learn how to bathe, dress, make a bottle - the neighbours daughter dropped him back off in his pram after school. My.gran thought it was great as she caught up on washing all the bedding. I cant imagine that now.

She absolutely loved holding and cuddling her great grandbabies. I'm very grateful to be parenting now however I am sad that my kids won't experience the same freedoms I and my parents and grandparents experienced in their childhood.

MilkyYay · 17/01/2023 21:07

The balance (imo) has now tipped the other way with pressure on parents to do everything right, meet every need immediately. So I think parenting has got harder bc of the social norms.

I dunno I'd go one further, i think a lot of parents try to meet their child's every want as well as need. Its both impossible and unreasonable as children's wants regularly conflict with their needs "I want to never go to bed! I want to live on rice cakes! I want to never brush my teeth!".

A lot of people i know seem to spend so much time pleading and cajoling and coaxing their kids to comply. I am a bit impatient. You are the parent, act like it!.

LindorDoubleChoc · 17/01/2023 21:07

I would accept that parenting in the 60s/70s whatever we're talking about here was more slack and damaging IF we didn't have the current wave of terrible mental health in young people born from the 90s onwards. Why is this? Why are young adults and children more depressed than ever before?

ThatsGoingToHurt · 17/01/2023 21:06

I was a child in the 80’s. I remember all my for Ed started walking to school by themselves or with brothers and sisters aged 7 or 8.

I very rarely remember being take to the park to play. Once I was 10 I was allowed to take my 7 year old brother with me.

There was occasionally trips to the seaside or the countryside. I was never take to the theatre, or a museum. That’s what school was for. I begged my mum to let me go to Brownies and she finally signed me up after 2 years of nagging.

Evenings were just watching tv. Weekend we’re going to the supermarket with parents, or being take to where they wanted to go. If my dad wanted to got to the pub as a family for the afternoon we would be expected to sit in the lounge and chat quietly whilst bored out of skulls for hours whilst the adults chatted and drank. If we were lucky it would be a pub with a beer garden where at least we could run around.

sunshinesupermum · 17/01/2023 21:05

When I was a child (in the 50s and 60s) I was left to my own devices most of the time because both my parents worked full-time. I had no living grandparents or relatives who lived nearby but did have friends with who I spent much of my spare time when I wasn't at school or at the library.

I walked to and from school on my own from the age of six and was a latchkey kid. I didn't know any other children who had accidents (and died). Although living in town, there were far fewer cars around. We walked or took the bus when we went out anywhere until my father could afford to buy a car. We didn't have a washing machine but my mother did have a mangle to wring water out of the clothes before hanging them to dry!

Dad was of the generation that thought children should be seen and not heard. But he was a very gentle and kind man himself. My mother sometimes gave me a slap but most kids got one at some time or another. Not saying that was right but it's how it was.

When my own children were young in the 1980s I also worked full time but had help with looking after them and stayed home myself after a few years. My ex-husband was strict. It was still the norm then for children to fit in with their parents and not the other way around as it seems to be nowadays, although it was starting to change; family life began to be more child-centric at the end of the last century and is even more so now as I see with my grandchildren. I do not offer advice on their upbringing! That's the domain of DD and her husband.

I think things are more difficult for parents in the 21st century, mainly because there is so much confusing information out there and everyone has an opinion. The internet causes as much damage as it does good, I think. I'm glad my childbearing years are long past!

knittingaddict · 17/01/2023 21:04

Having children in the 80's I think it was easier then. The does and don'ts of parenting seem much more prescriptive now.

I'm not saying it was better for the babies, but it was easier for the parents.

MilkyYay · 17/01/2023 21:03

My kids are only 3 &6, we run on a routine like this (except i fed on demand the first 3 or 4 months i think) and it has always seemed simpler to me. I think most (not all) children thrive on predictable routines and are happier and more settled when they know whats coming.

My kids never whine for tv all day. They know full well its only ever gone on for 20 mins after tea because thats how it's always been.

They are good at bedtime because they know the drill. I didn't do extinction cry it out, no, but i did sleep train gradually so by about 9/10 months both were just put down awake. The youngest was a worse sleeper than the eldest but we mostly avoided letting bad habits creep in.

They are happy, confident kids who sleep well and get along really well. I think im perceived as quite strict/inflexible by other mums but it's what works for us.

AbreathofFrenchair · 17/01/2023 21:03

Forgooodnesssakenow · 17/01/2023 20:49

You sound wonderful and warm, I'm sure your children remember that time with you fondly.

Imagine wanting to hold, bond with and nurture the child you made 😱 what lunatics we mums are nowadays

Why are you trying to make out she isnt a warm and wonderful Mom and that her children wont remember that time fondly?

What compelled you to say such wicked things? Your own Mom guilt? A bad upbringing by your own parents?

If you were confident and secure in your own parenting style, you definitely wouldn't be attempting to tear apart another person's way of parenting.

Trying being a bit kinder, it won't kill you

smileladiesplease · 17/01/2023 21:00

Whatever era women bore the brunt and were always judged on parenting so no nothing has changed!

My mantra do your best and fuck off judgy world 😂😂

SomethingOriginal2 · 17/01/2023 20:59

Well if what MIL says counts you just ignored your kids until they stopped bothering you / crying and then it was easy. She even told me about when the midwife told her off for feeding her newborn thickened milk and ignoring them all night and she said "and I told her I need that bloody sleep" i was just like "yeah you're not allowed to do that anymore" her babies slept through almost immediately because what choice did they have.

Her kids spent all day outside because they weren't allowed in.

I don't think parenting (for the most part- my mum tells a very different story of her dad but he was retired.) was even actually parenting back then. There was no concern for the welfare, happiness, future of the children, just the parents convenience.

Obviously not everyone but from what people I know in their 50s tell of their parents and people in their 80s tell of their own parenting

Testng123 · 17/01/2023 20:57

They didn't seem to worry about their children as much....when I think about what we got up to, playing in rivers, on train tracks (once!), cycling for miles...I would be terrified if mine where doing the same.

We are the other extreme now though.

WandaWonder · 17/01/2023 20:56

I do think there are good and bad from each generation, but everyone and everything these days needs a label and nothing gets done without deep over thinking of every aspect of parenting

But people can actually parent they way they want, if you want to parent by social media, what the neighbours think, what is said on MN or other places like parenting books what you read in the media or your friends say then that is your choice, I do get annoyed with the contast 'I am so being judged'

Sure there was some issues people have mentioned on here that happened in the past but I like the fact they just got on with it and didn't have endless angst

I grew up with caring parents who also let us get on with it, they helped us and were there for us when we needed then but they did not hover over us all day everyday and I have done with my own child

AbreathofFrenchair · 17/01/2023 20:53

germanbight · 17/01/2023 19:46

My beloved grandma, who lived on a small farm and really ran it alone, always used to tut at toddlers/small children who were being naughty out and about and always told me that when she had her children it was all much simpler— especially in the baby phase.

Apparently routine kept all 4 children perfect from baby-hood. Baby fed every three hours until it slept through, all children off for an afternoon nap after dinner and bedtime a prompt 7:30 until they were 10. She always used to say that now parents adapt to fit the baby in their lives, but when she was having children they had to adapt to her life.

I just don’t see how it could’ve run on clockwork like that. Was it really that much easier? Just a case of endless CIO?

It probably was in the sense that children then had a parent, usually a Mom, at home full time and because household chores needed doing, the child sometimes had to be bored or wait for something while things were done.

There were also more communities, if you like, where other people at home, looked out for others children and also kept them in line where and when needed.

Now, we have all this technology to make our lives easier yet more and more people are struggling with basic parenting that doesnt have an app to solve it, we shut off from our neighbours, we effectively isolate ourselves and keep families at a distance and think asking for help means you've failed.

You only have to read some posts on here where people hate their neighbours for using their back gardens and refuse to answer the door after dark or refuse to talk to their neighbours to solve small disputes

Georgeskitchen · 17/01/2023 20:52

Depending how old yoir gran is, it wouldn't be that easy. No automatic washing machines, dishwashers, labour saving gadgets etc. On the other hand it would be "children should be seen and not heard "
They knew their place. Nobody needed a bath/shower every night. Wash day on a Monday come rain or shine. There was no expectation to entertain the kids constantly, spending money on expensive trips out every weekend.
I'm 62 and we had a camping holiday every year and that was it apart from a few trips to the cinema
and an annual visit to the local funfair. New toys/gifts at Xmas and birthday only.

PermanentTemporary · 17/01/2023 20:52

God no, I'd a million times rather bring up a child now than back in the day.

Epidurals hadn't really got to rural Hertfordshire, to start with. My mum had no washing machine, no telly (they did have a radio) and nappies were all rinsed soaked boiled and handwashed (she was quite well off in fact so at least bedding went to the laundry). No central heating until we were a lot older. She grew large amounts of our food and obviously cooked most of it from scratch, making the leftovers last (her particular pet hate was cleaning the mincing machine). Any cakes, biscuits or pastry we had were handmade. I think people forget the amount of time prepping actual garden produce takes- digging it out, scraping off mud, cutting out the weevils and rotten bits, picking over, deseeding. We kept hens which is quite a job but meant we had eggs. Children's clothes weren't widely available in any variety and were very expensive, so she sewed and knitted most of our clothes, with an endless mending pile of darning and patching and restitching to do. She liked gardening but it was fairly relentless.

It's all very idyllic sounding, and undoubtedly a healthier and more environmentally sustainable life, but bloody hell it was hard work.