Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you have “big bones”?

218 replies

SippeeCup · 17/01/2023 18:36

I’m very depressed about my body. I’m not fat, I actually have a very low body fat percentage but I have a huge skeleton. I’m 5ft 6 so not overly tall but I struggle with fitting into women’s things and it’s making me so depressed. Watches are so tight o have to buy men’s straps. Rings and bracelets I have made on Etsy because shop ones don’t fit me. The wide fit shoe section never have shoes that are actually wide enough for my feet. Hats are always too small. I have to size up in clothes to fit my shoulders and rib cage and pelvis but they hang off my everywhere else. It makes me feel very ugly. I was wondering if anyone else has this issue and can maybe share where they buys things like shoes and jewellery etc?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
LavenderHillMob · 18/01/2023 11:10

Doh Human skeletons obviously do come in all shapes & sizes! I know my anatomy, even if I can't proof read!

LavenderHillMob · 18/01/2023 11:09

I thought cremation ashes included the coffin?

There was an interesting AMA on here a few years ago and I think the OP explained that fatter bodies burn better than skinny ones. I don't remember anything about the bones though.

PP are correct that big boned is sometimes used as a euphemism for fat, it doesn't mean that human skeletons come in a range of sizes. I'm a shortie with a large rib cage, big wrists and shoulders and ginormous knees. Even if my BMI was 18 I still wouldn't look dainty.

LowbrowVictoriana · 18/01/2023 10:54

Ifailed · 18/01/2023 10:46

I knew someone who worked in a crematorium, they told me no matter what size a body was, the amount of 'ash' (the remains of the bones) were pretty much the same, with men's being slightly heavier than women.

I don't know about that, but surely it's to do with proportion? As I said above, people of the same sex and height don't necessarily have the same size of feet and hands, so other things will be different sizes too; and my head, feet, shoulders, hands and hips are all bigger/wider than my daughter's, even though she's 3 inches taller.

pocketvenuss · 18/01/2023 10:51

People getting all up in arms about about BMI and body fat vs big bones. They are not the same thing. You can have big bones and be underweight and you can have small bones and be carrying excess body fat.

The point is, someone with a bigger broader frame will be bigger with the same body fat % than someone with a small frame.

A 5'5" small framed slim person with 18% body fat may fit a size 6/8 jacket. A 5'5" large boned broad slim person with 18% body fat may never get below a size 10 because the bones in their shoulder are of a width that means they will never fit into a 6-8.

Bones don't equal body fat or BMIS. Bones do affect your overall size.

Yarrawonga · 18/01/2023 10:50

menswear accommodates a wide range of builds and often suits someone with more muscle/broad shoulders etc

From years accompanying my husband clothes shopping, I’m not sure that this is true. He is tall with broad shoulders and really struggles to find off the peg clothes that fit properly. If they fit on the shoulders, there is usually far too much excess material flapping around his waist, or they aren’t long enough, or both.

HeavyHeidi · 18/01/2023 10:48

You’re either fat because you eat too much/ don’t move enough or you’re not. There’s no such thing as ‘big bones’.

I'm not fat, I'm still big boned though. How hard is it to understand really? When my hip bone is jutting out and not covered by any fat, but it is still wide, what exactly is it then?

Ifailed · 18/01/2023 10:46

I knew someone who worked in a crematorium, they told me no matter what size a body was, the amount of 'ash' (the remains of the bones) were pretty much the same, with men's being slightly heavier than women.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 18/01/2023 10:44

I have a big bellybone l think!

waterlego · 18/01/2023 10:44

To those who think big-boned is a euphemism for overweight, here is a photo of me. I call myself big-boned on account of my wide ribs, big head, big feet and wrists. I’m heavier than I look. Am I using ‘big-boned’ as a euphemism for overweight?

(I do have a head, I’ve just not included it to preserve some anonymity)

Do you have “big bones”?
Jimboscott0115 · 18/01/2023 10:43

I know it's more common in men but yep I'm definitely in this category. Lowish body fat % and in good nick generally, but always very high on BMI based on pure size, not helped by the gym which I enjoy too much to stop.

I do find women's sizing to be crap though, so sympathise OP, menswear accommodates a wide range of builds and often suits someone with more muscle/broad shoulders etc but know from the women in my life that this simply isn't true for their clothes which is ridiculous.

pocketvenuss · 18/01/2023 10:42

Weddi · 18/01/2023 09:51

I don’t know what big boned actually means tbh. You’re either fat because you eat too much/ don’t move enough or you’re not. There’s no such thing as ‘big bones’. Bones are just the structure beneath the fat. I accept people have different body types for sure, some are naturally slimmer than others but in terms of BMI, the bone structure is irrelevant. If your BMI is high it’s mostly because you’re fat (sometimes very muscly but for most this isn’t the case).

Why are you discussing body fat? This is a discussion about bones not fat. Doesn't surprise me that you got confused as you admit to not understanding what big bones are. Big bones is not difficult to understand. The clue is in the name. Some people have bigger bones than others. You don't need to turn it into a discussion about fat

Mango101 · 18/01/2023 10:40

PrincessHoneysuckle · 17/01/2023 19:26

Less than 20%of women have larger than average body frames I've just googled it.Can vary by height too

i think it's 50% :)

Oakbeam · 18/01/2023 10:32

Big boned is sometimes used as a polite or deluded way to describe overweight people, I agree - but that isn’t what the genuinely big boned posters here are discussing!

I remember Billy Connolly’s response to someone overweight claiming that they were jut big boned…

”Aye, and your belly bone is enormous!”

CockSpadget · 18/01/2023 10:26

@pocketvenuss ah, apologies, you were trying to prove they are different 🤦‍♀️

CockSpadget · 18/01/2023 10:24

pocketvenuss · 18/01/2023 09:24

This dude for eg. Bones didn't change

But he doesn’t look like his bones have changed? He looks like he’s built a shit tonne of muscle mass. That analogy does not in any way prove that everyone’s skeletons are the same.

waterlego · 18/01/2023 10:16

I have big/heavy bones despite being a short-arse. I’m 5ft 3, wrist measurement is nearly 7”, size 6.5 feet, big rib cage and quite wide, square shoulders. Narrow hips though so I have an inverted triangle shape despite having small boobs.

People tend to be surprised if I tell them my weight as they expect me to be about 8 stone but I’m considerably heavier than that!

I have low body fat. BMI is in the healthy range but towards the upper end. I don’t worry about it and I don’t weigh myself as a matter of course because I can see with my eyes that I am muscular and not carrying very much fat. My daughter is a similar height to me but about two stones lighter because she has a tiny frame. Little feet, little hands and wrists, slender and willowy and not much muscle, while I am stocky and sturdy.

I don’t have the same problems with clothes as the OP has, except hats, which are usually too small for me.

NoFlashingLightsPlease · 18/01/2023 10:12

Confession: haven’t RTFT.

Caitlin Moran is very good on this. In ‘How to be a Woman’ she reminded us that, before the fashion industry took hold, women would have their clothes made for them. So first of all everything would fit. Secondly I suppose (but obviously don’t know for sure) you could embrace a trend and go full-on or exaggerate it, or play it down. Far more often you’d be wearing clothes,fabrics and colours that actually suited, rather than what you could find on the rails. You’d have far fewer clothes.

Also OP have you read much about the Kibbe technique? It outlines dressing not only for your frame but also your attitude.
From your photos your physical type reminds me of a young Isobella Rossellini. Considered very beautiful. She oozed confidence. But the polar opposite of someone like, say, Ariadne Grande, or Mia Farrow, or Tilda Swindon. A teeny bit like Charlize Theron though. Who is strong-looking, imho.

Yeahrightthen · 18/01/2023 10:11

Weddi · 18/01/2023 09:51

I don’t know what big boned actually means tbh. You’re either fat because you eat too much/ don’t move enough or you’re not. There’s no such thing as ‘big bones’. Bones are just the structure beneath the fat. I accept people have different body types for sure, some are naturally slimmer than others but in terms of BMI, the bone structure is irrelevant. If your BMI is high it’s mostly because you’re fat (sometimes very muscly but for most this isn’t the case).

Sorry but you really don’t know what you’re talking about!

Do you not think bone density/frame is a thing? And different body shapes? Put a 5”2” woman with small hands/feet/wrists etc weighing 10 stone next to a 5”9” woman weighing 10 stone with big hands/feet/wrists next to one another - the smaller one is much more likely to look “fat” don’t you agree? But the taller one is still “big-boned” although they’ll look skinnier - what you weigh doesn’t change your general shape or hand/feet/wrist size and the length of your body and limbs!

Big boned is sometimes used as a polite or deluded way to describe overweight people, I agree - but that isn’t what the genuinely big boned posters here are discussing!

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 18/01/2023 10:06

People are always surprised that at a dress size 22 I wear a 36 back bra. All my weight is in my belly and chin <eyeroll>

As a teen, I was part of a trio of friends - we were all the same height but had such vastly different body shapes we couldn’t share clothes! None of us were overweight - I was the hourglass, E was the typical slender willow, A had the legs that went on forever.

Bodies are different and I don’t know why so many people seem to struggle to understand that your skeleton might hold a part in that?!

Stravaig · 18/01/2023 10:05

My wrists are 5¼" 13 cm, palm circumference and hand length are both 17cm. I'm 5'6" 168cm tall, not at all elfin!

Aprilx · 18/01/2023 10:03

SavoirFlair · 17/01/2023 19:01

What is “big bones?”

like, I am not trolling here or trying to poke someone. I’m genuinely trying to understand what this means considering our bones are covered with flesh and skin.

Could I ask, forget body fat percentages - do you have a BMI and target weight which you’ve felt happy at?

do you know your dress size, and is it one you can sometimes find things you feel good in?

It means your frame, e.g. the width of your shoulders would be quite an indicator of your frame size.

OP, I have big bones, I have been all kind of weights from very underweight to overweight but my frame obviously stays the same and for example I don’t think I would ever fit into a size 8 no matter how little fat I had on my body.

I have never had a problem with my bone size to the extent that you mention though.

xogossipgirlxo · 18/01/2023 10:02

I have big rib cage, but I think it's because I have big boobs? At least this is what I like to blame. When I was on wedding dress fitting, I needed to have my dress adjusted around my ribs and tailor said "it happens during pregnancy". I'm only pregnant now with baby no.1 , 2 years after the wedding 😬

JodiePants · 18/01/2023 10:01

My sister and I wear the same size clothes and are the same height. She definitely has big bones though. She has no fat on her, toned. I have a small frame but am very flabby.

Andywarholswig · 18/01/2023 09:58

@CockSpadget shoes are a pita - it has got better but put it this way, we never go shopping in the high street as everything we buy comes from specialist shoe shops and tall retailers (DH 6’5 and size 13 feet)

One of my daughters is much smaller boned that the other, my eldest has broad shoulders and hips and is more solid - she is very powerful. She loves it. My younger DD is much slighter all over, still has big hands and feet but her shoulders are significantly narrower and hips too - she does however have the family bum - we are all blessed in the big round bum department.

I bothered to measure my wrist this morning, which are noticeably bony - 7 inches exactly.

I have to say there are some seriously hard of thinking on this thread…

@SippeeCup if it helps, I think you you look very proportional. I had always felt very self conscious growing up (my mum certainly didn’t help) but as I’ve got older i feel comfortable being strong, and taking my space and actually i like my body now. I have made peace with it, which I think is important for my girls, they’ve never heard me anything but positives about being more robustly buildt that the average UK woman. They seem to be taking it in their stride, despite all of their friends being absolutely tiny (objectively)

Beenheresomanytimesbefore · 18/01/2023 09:57

Yes I know what you mean. I’m only 5ft but Broad shouldered, big hipped etc. I always weight more than people expect, even at my slimmest when I was a size 8-10 I was right at the top end of the BMI acceptable range. My daughter comments that girls in her dance class might look the same size but some are much harder to lift than others. I put it down to body composition and frame.