Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cleaner adding half an hour each time

138 replies

DinoHat · 17/01/2023 15:53

I have had the same cleaner for over two years, always liked her and she worked so hard initially I have always paid her more than she charged. So she charges £12 p/h and I pay her £15 p/h.
Recommended her to friends when she was starting out - she got around 7 houses from me.

I used to rely on her to tell me how many hours she’d done but noticed lately she is missing bits off, like not cleaning a couple of rooms just tidying them - a few times she’d say she was in a rush today so I accepted that for what it was. Missed her last week and thought that was odd as I’d not been out long and she used to take 3-4 hours. I have CCTV and saw she was at my house 2 hours 11 minutes. That’s pulling on and off the drive so not necessarily working, but to be fair I paid her for 2 hours 20 mins. She text back and said she’d done half an hour longer. Which I know isn’t true.

Same this week - she was here an hour, my DH was home and of course we have CCTV and she added an extra half an hour when she told me- if she’d have asked for fuel money I’d have given it to her. Although was expecting a 3 hour clean. (She had missed bits).

This is obviously intentional - if she wanted to increase her rates I’d accept that. But AIBU to be pissed off shes lying? I thought we got along but feel she’s taking the mick out of my generosity.

OP posts:
Greyhave · 17/01/2023 17:44

One of our old cleaners was like this. Took twice as long to clean house as it should have taken and I frequently caught her out when I came home early and she wasn’t there.

We kept her on because she did a fairly good job and was a lot cheaper than the alternatives. In the end I caught her stealing twice. First time I gave her the benefit of the doubt, second time it was obvious it was her so I sacked her next time she came round.

we now pay a company twice as much but at least they are honest and do a good job.

oohokay · 17/01/2023 17:44

DinoHat · 17/01/2023 16:12

It’s not really odd - I told her that I appreciate she works fast and decided she was better value at £15 p/h than someone who can’t get it done in 3-4 hours but charges the same. I’ve had cleaners who can’t get to all the room in that time so when she started I wanted to keep hold of her, as by contrast to the others she was much better.

She has a set list of tasks that we agreed at the outset. But occasionally I’ll ask her to do adhoc bits. I don’t think that’s especially unusual?

There's no excuse at all for being dishonest, especially for something as cut and dry as time worked/billed.

But I think this is the reason. So for example, my flat in london is tiny and I've told cleaners "oh I just want XYZ quickly done in an hour, and I don't need it perfect at all". It's definitely possible if you work quickly (not at a madcap pace, just quickly) but every single cleaner has told me "no, we need 2-3 hours for this size". Meaning 2-3x the pay. So there's clearly an industry standard wage/reasonable speed.

Perhaps she was desperate for the job at first and agreed to a wage below industry standard. I say wage because for example you're paying her £45-60 for a much larger set of tasks than other cleaners who also charge £45-60. I think she's taking the mick because she now thinks you are/were taking the mick.

Again not berating or shaming you in any way, or morally justifying her behaviour. Just providing a possible explanation from my POV as a freelancer who often faces this dilemma! I've often had to man up and renegotiate prior rates which no longer work, but sometimes when that's not possible / new factors emerge, I do cut corners, but never to the point of outright deception.

drpet49 · 17/01/2023 17:42

highlyrecommendit · 17/01/2023 15:56

Get rid of her. This happened to me too. Find a new cleaner.
Never pay anybody more than they charge. I used to do it all the time but they don't see it as kindness, they see it as a weakness. And you, as someone to take the piss out of.

Couldn’t have put it better myself.

BeenPurple · 17/01/2023 17:37

Ask her to confirm the times she started and stopped the last twice, and then you can let her go with no notice period for breaking the contract/theft/deceiving. As a previous poster said, once the trust is gone it’s gone.

inloveandmarried · 17/01/2023 17:37

I agree that once the trust has gone it's difficult.

Could you get a ring doorbell? Then it's obvious her entry and exit times are logged?

But I think if you've got to this stage you are best asking around for recommendations for another cleaner.

Katekeeprunning · 17/01/2023 17:36

My father had a saying:

'he who steals my time, steals my money'

and I think this fits very well in with your situation.

2bazookas · 17/01/2023 17:36

Doesn't she know you have CCTV?

If she doesn't, perhaps let it drop into conversation.

" If you find a ginger cat on the doorstep mewing to get in, don't let him. It's a stray; our camera has picked him up twice."

Wobblytrees · 17/01/2023 17:34

We had this and told a friend she was going to next. Did the same to them so was basically stealing from pretty much everyone she worked for. I’d been really nice to her too. Told her we no longer needed a cleaner, didn’t give a reason. The trust had gone. Later on I also found out that her son had been doing some of our cleans without our knowledge.

Saintasaurus · 17/01/2023 17:33

Our neighbours have two cleaners once a week in the morning, for two hours. They are always sitting by the kitchen table talking to each other. I always wonder how much cleaning they do..

AngelDelightUK · 17/01/2023 17:26

Could you say something like your camera doorbell alerted you to when she arrived/left, and you’re wondering if it’s faulty because it doesn’t tie in with the timings she’s said. Just to call her bluff a bit and you aren’t then accusing her

Roselilly36 · 17/01/2023 17:24

Let her go, the trust has gone.

whatswrongwithdh · 17/01/2023 17:22

DinoHat · 17/01/2023 16:00

Thing is she knows all this stuff needs doing - she’s been doing my house over two years! I don’t want to have to remind her. We have basics that she always does and then I will text with extras like cleaning the fridge or occasionally the ovens - always if she has time and I’ll always pay her if it takes longer.

I feel she’s intentionally ripping me off, which is what annoys me the most.

I would go with SugarTits suggestion. Of course she knows it. It's a way giving her a chance to change and saying pack it in and do what we agreed without backing her into a corner.

YourGazeHitsTheSideOfMyFace · 17/01/2023 17:21

I wouldn’t trust someone who was willing to defraud me with a key to my house.

Time for a change, OP, and don’t feel badly about it. She’s betrayed your trust and kindness.

Chooksnroses · 17/01/2023 17:14

As an ex cleaner who was always meticulous about my cleaning and my timing, this makes me very angry. I'm at the age now where I would like someone to help me with my cleaning, but stories like yours really put me off. You should definitely find someone else, and you should tell her why.

GlassBunion · 17/01/2023 17:14

It sounds to me like she's got more clients than she can cope with and is shaving time from you and adding it to the next client. She'll be quids in as she is, in effect, getting paid travel time.

StarPup · 17/01/2023 17:13

My cleaner often leaves 10 - 20 mins before her paid 2 hrs are up. She recently told me she couldn’t clean all our house in 2 hrs and needed more time… another half an hour… because we’d had an extension. I told her to do what she can in 2 hrs and she still leaves early.

She comes at a slightly different time each week and probably thinks I don’t notice.

The only thing stopping me properly confronting this is she’s a damn good cleaner and works very fast.

I feel your pain!

Pumpmonkey · 17/01/2023 17:07

Im a freelance cleaner with just one client. I have a list of cleaning jobs that we agreed and my client will sometimes ask me to do extras. She understands that this might sometimes mean I can’t do everything on that list but we communicate weekly and she lets me know what needs priority. It can take more or less time per week depending on how dirty/messy the place is. I take a pic when i arrive and one when I leave of each room so that we both have a record of whats been done. I frequently give them a little bit of extra time if I haven't quite finished and occasionally leave a little early if I have…but ii’m careful to log hours so they know i’m being fair.

I agree good cleaners are really hard to find. Ive worked alongside some really lazy people.

If it were me I’d maybe sit and chat with her and ask if there are any other pressures on her time which mean she is finding it hard to stay longer and then renegotiate if she needs to spend less time. If you do this and she is still taking the piss then let her go.

CharlieBoo · 17/01/2023 17:03

I run a cleaning business. Totally unacceptable.. she’s taking the piss. Call her out on it, and remind her that you require 3 hours each week and for x y and z to be done. Or you can just bin her off and find someone else. Plenty of cleaners out there x

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 17/01/2023 17:03

Namechangedforthisonetoday · 17/01/2023 16:32

Do not tell her you’ve been checking her timings on CCTV. There are laws for employers around the use of this. I’m not completely au fait with them currently, but I know one example was that the cctv could only be checked where the employer believed a crime had been committed.

OP isn't an employer.

pilates · 17/01/2023 16:58

I think it is hard to continue a working relationship when the trust has gone. It leaves a bad taste.

BloodAndFire · 17/01/2023 16:57

Kapalika · 17/01/2023 16:54

Nobody is irreplaceable. Doesn’t matter what job you do, and that includes the PM.

I don't think that, after the past year, anyone thinks the PM is irreplaceable Grin

Kapalika · 17/01/2023 16:54

Nobody is irreplaceable. Doesn’t matter what job you do, and that includes the PM.

Arniesleftleg · 17/01/2023 16:49

I give my clients time slots. Generally they all have 2 hours unless they specifically request more/have larger houses. I manage to get a lot done in two hours.

Her hours shouldn't be changing when she sees fit. She should give you a time, say three hours and do what she can in the three hours. If she's doing this to you I'd be intrigued as to what she's doing when she's inside too.

BCxx · 17/01/2023 16:47

I’ve got a similar thing but im paying for 2 and a half hours and it isn’t a list of set jobs, just basically as much of my house as she can get done - which could take you double that time if you were to do everything. She’s constantly leaving early. One day my dad met her in Tesco when she was supposed to be cleaning my house for another 20 minutes. I told myself I couldn’t sack her coming up to Christmas, couldn’t do it at Christmas and now I’m like I can’t do it in January but I think I’m going to text and tell her I no longer need her in February. We really can’t afford to be paying someone who isn’t even doing the job they’re paid for

SpeckledlyHen · 17/01/2023 16:43

Nad28 · 17/01/2023 16:02

Once the trust has gone, it’s gone.

This.

I had a cleaner and for the most part I was working from home so I was there when she cleaned. However, I got a new job and was out every time she cleaned. What she didn't know was the place where I worked was a mile from home and because of the nature of the job I was often driving round the local area and often drove past my house.

I noticed on more than one occasion her car was not there on the morning she was due to clean. She always came the same time every week, 10.00am and stayed for 3 hours. I could see as I drove past she started at 11 and left by 12 latest. I also just had that feeling she hadn't done anything, or rather had just run the hoover round a few rooms and wiped over the sink and put some bleach down the loo (30 mins max).

I sacked her and was really upset over it. I had befriended her and bought her and her kids xmas presents etc, I could not get over the fact that she lied to me. Even if she had been there say 2.5 hours instead of 3 I would have still paid her for 3 hours but to be there less than an hour and not attempt to do anything was a right slap in the face.