Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anyone have positive experience with lodgers ?

36 replies

Cinammonroll · 17/01/2023 10:55

My partner is interested in us taking one to save money, which I agree would be helpful.
I think I'm just worried as I really like my own space. Don't want to go back to essentially flat sharing, it really depends, there's some nice people I've lived with in the past and who you can bump into in the kitchen and have a nice chat with etc.
My partner says we could all cook together and share groceries etc.
Honestly I just like my own space, I like coming in from work and relaxing and being on my own.
I'm just introverted and quiet.
Has anybody got successful experience of it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JimDixon · 19/01/2023 12:29

I think in some circumstances it's fine to exclude the lodger from the lounge. When I was in my mid-20s, I lodged with a couple in their 50s. I could never have imagined hanging out with them in the lounge of an evening while they watched TV, or thinking I could force them from that room.

Similarly now I have a lodger myself, in a flat, I've found that giving lounge access causes problems. Since my lodgers are typically half my age, it's hard to find someone I can genuinely share a room with! So either they will take the room over (sometimes in a confidently friendly way, but still!), or they will be scared to come in / not want to have to spend that much time talking to me anyway. So, it's easier just not to include that room. There's still no shortage of takers - though I'm in London....

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 19/01/2023 12:27

KettrickenSmiled · 17/01/2023 11:18

My partner says we could all cook together and share groceries etc.

Beware your partner conjuring an imaginary Dream Lodger who won't live up to his naive expectations. They are there to rent a room & facilities off you, not become your partner's new best friend. They might now want to share cooking & groceries. They might expect you to work to a rota about who can be in the kitchen at specific times - & they'd be well within their rights to do so.

How keen are you on going along with this, & how much extra money does it actually mean you could save?

That bit sounded more like he wants to move in a mate, a girlfriend, etc. As though home life with OP is boring.

JimDixon · 19/01/2023 12:26

VincaBlue · 19/01/2023 01:00

Does your dh want a male or female lodger?

Because if female, LTB!!!

VincaBlue · 19/01/2023 01:00

Does your dh want a male or female lodger?

whytesnow · 19/01/2023 00:31

I have one just now she's amazing she doesn't use any of my things very clean and paying my mortgage while am coming out of debt

Itsonlyagame · 19/01/2023 00:19

I had 3 lodgers over the years. All men, all fantastic lodgers. 2 were Monday to Friday, one was full time. Honestly had no issues whatsoever with any of them. I advertised on spare room and went very much by gut instinct.

LastOfTheChristmasWine · 19/01/2023 00:06

I've currently got a lodger, and have had several previously (and before that I house-shared, which I never hated).

Firstly, big fat NO to sharing meals. I can guarantee that you will have different tastes, skill levels, budgets and dinner times to the lodger. It's a recipe for disaster (pun intended). Each cook your own meals. I make it a rule that the lodger has to provide anything of theirs that needs washing up after each use (pans, cutlery etc) but we share other things (toaster, kettle, etc.) as it avoids conflict. Lodger gets their own shelf in the fridge and freezer. Don't try and ban the lodger from the lounge as a PP suggested - no one wants to be made to feel unwelcome, and it's not going to store up goodwill.

It is a bit like flat-sharing BUT there's a very different power dynamic, as you essentially have the upper hand. I try to treat my lodgers as equally as possible, but there is always a power imbalance. One of the reasons for this is that they are excluded occupiers, not tenants, and have very few rights - if it's not working out you can give 'reasonable notice' (a month, normally) and end the arrangement.

To dip your toes in the water, consider having your first lodger as someone who only needs a room short term, for a month or two. It will allow you to see how you feel about it, without having to feel guilty about evicting someone if it doesn't work out, as there is a natural end date. Some people prefer to have a string of short-term lodgers as they never get their feet under the table, as it were, though the disadvantage of short-term lodgers is that they're often coming straight from their usual hometown (I even picked one up from the airport once) so you don't get to meet them beforehand.

www.spareroom.co.uk is the main site for finding a lodger; the nice thing about it is that you can browse the adverts that potential lodgers write about themselves and get an idea of what's out there.

If you do decide to advertise your spare room, my advice would be to be super upfront about everything. If that puts some people off, that's fine, those are the people you want to put off. Things like any planned building work, your cat with an attitude problem, your need for daytime quiet because you work nightshifts, your passion for yodelling... put it in. You may get lucky and find a vet nurse who works the 9-5 and has a passion for music (or is profoundly deaf...)

WinterFoxes · 18/01/2023 22:44

TrickyD · 18/01/2023 10:21

My friend would say she had a very positive experience with her lodger. He was here from the far east studying construction at our local college.
We often tease them about how exactly lodger became lover. They have been happily married for forty years.

Probably the OP should not rely on this happening to her, what with a DH on the scene.

I know three men who started out as lodgers and ended up marrying their landladies!

Cherry85 · 18/01/2023 22:41

Depending on how big the rooms are you could rent a room as a bedsit? So they don't have use of other parts of the house but have a bed / sofa / mini kitchen in one room.

Also - if you have a room with an ensuite, give them this and you use main bathroom. Keeps them totally contained.

TrickyD · 18/01/2023 10:21

My friend would say she had a very positive experience with her lodger. He was here from the far east studying construction at our local college.
We often tease them about how exactly lodger became lover. They have been happily married for forty years.

Probably the OP should not rely on this happening to her, what with a DH on the scene.

SummaLuvin · 18/01/2023 09:56

my brother-in-law was a lodger for around 2-3 months, he could not have been more conscientious and respectful, and even so I found him wearing after a time. I think once you are used to your own space and routines it becomes very difficult to live with someone who you otherwise wouldn't really choose.

Bagsundermyeyestoday · 18/01/2023 09:50

Coffeeandchocs · 17/01/2023 11:05

Has your partner ever shared living space before? His idea of having a lodger seems very romanticised from the mention of sharing groceries and cooking meals together. You may do this with a flat mate you’ve chosen to share with who was already a friend, but a lodger I wouldn’t be expecting that of them. Especially because you two are a couple, it isn’t the easiest dynamic compared to say three friends sharing a property.

A Monday -Friday set up could potentially work.

Agree. If anything you'd want to keep food separate. Is there some other way to save/make money?

JudgeRudy · 18/01/2023 08:44

If you like your own space and value your privacy then a lodger isn't for you. Personally I'd rather work a couple of evenings in the chippie or cab driving.
It's an odd thing to bring up given what you've said. You're not in a bigger financial mess than you realise are you?

Aphrathestorm · 18/01/2023 08:32

You dp is confusing lodgers and flatmates/couples.

You don't share groceries/meals.

Ime lodgers are great as you don't pay tax on their rent. It's free money!

The only thing I'd 'share' is loo roll which you calculate into their rent.

I'd expect them to have and wash their own towels, have their own fridge/freezer and kitchen cupboards with their own crockery/cutlery/utensils.

I think it's easier to get a cleaner so there's not resentment about things like cooker mess.

If they have a big room I'd keep the living room out of bounds for them do that's still your space in the evenings.

If you can give them an en-suite, even better.

thelionthewitchtheaudacityofTHISbitch · 17/01/2023 22:31

When I bought my 1st flat (late 80's London) I needed a lodger to help pay the mortgage. My 1st lovely lady 10 years older than me - stayed a few months before buying her own flat. We are still friends to this day despite being very different. My flat had a tiny kitchen (literally gallery), shared bathroom and a shared living room/dining room. We were both professionals so worked long hours - that probably helped! When she moved out, someone else from the firm moved in. Male on secondment from overseas. He was different - I am chuckling now at the TV memory. I had finally bought a TV (small 14 in Sony triniton) - it was delivered when I was out shopping with my mum - we came home to find him in front of the TV literally 3 inches in front. It was all set up and must have taken him all afternoon to manually tune in!! He was a star at a party I held - made home made baklava - god it was good. Took him all day in the kitchen and I am not sure we ever got all of the sugar strands clean! He was lovely - friends went to stay with him years later when they were travelling around Egypt. He was a partner by then. I was perhaps less enamoured by all the porn material that he "forgot" to take with him when he moved out. Different time, different culture. It can be really good, but I was single, so were they, no kids, no pets, and very few expectations. (Apart from the Persian kittens I looked after for a week - didnt know my new lodger was fur-phobic!)

Luana1 · 17/01/2023 22:15

We've had lodgers in the past, all apart from one were fine. I think the key thing is to find someone who just needs it temporarily like for few months or up a year, you don't really want a lodger to see your house as their permanent home as I think that's when conflicts and power struggles can arise. I am a bit baffled by your partner's attitude though, especially knowing how much you value your own space - sounds like he is looking to be part of a thruple!

ColdHandsHotHead · 17/01/2023 22:13

Your OH needs to give his head a wobble. I've been a lodger myself, and I've had a lodger. It means essentially having a second household under your roof, and someone who is paying to be there, what's more. You're not all going to skip off down the path of life together. A lodger will have their own likes, dislikes and foibles.

richmondmum1 · 17/01/2023 21:19

You do not want to be cooking together and sharing groceries. That might put some potential lodgers off too. If you do it keep your lives separate. Much easier all round. But obviously be civil and curteous.

Ohgodthepain · 17/01/2023 20:43

I've had many , many lodgers over the years - don't do it . As nice as some may be , it's very difficult to live alongside a stranger and if you get a shocker , it's a nightmare.

MeridaBrave · 17/01/2023 20:40

We have a lodger currently. And it’s totally fine. However that’s only because she had the attic bedroom which has its own bathroom and kitchenette. She also likes taking our dog for extra walks. Not sure I would do if no kitchenette in attic.

Bonjovispyjamas · 17/01/2023 12:08

If you're an introvert and like you're own space, then you'll probably hate it, so I wouldn't in your position. I've been a lodger when I was younger, but I was very considerate, stayed in my room, only used kitchen, washing machine etc when I knew they didn't need to, but not all lodgers are like that.

CohenTree · 17/01/2023 12:03

Having once been a lodger, I would say never again!
I was supposed to be sharing a small house with one other lodger but the couple that owned the house would also appear every weekend, fill up the fridge with their food so there was no space for anything else, take drugs, put the radio on full blast very early in the morning... etc.
The husband was a particular gem and would do things like switch off the lights in the room where I was studying, or if I was listening to music in the sitting room he would come in and put the telly on full blast without saying a word.
They had their own bathroom but when he needed to wash an oily car engine, of course he did it in the bathtub I shared with the other lodger. And then left it filthy!
I don't know what his problem was but I soon cleared out of that place. It was a shame as the wife was quite nice and had previously been a friend of mine from college.

Iliveditwizbit · 17/01/2023 11:57

Just make sure YOU choose the lodger op.

BumbleBee92 · 17/01/2023 11:50

Agree that a Monday Friday lodger is a good idea. If they have their own home to go back to you might be less likely to end up with someone you eg can’t evict if you run into problems and it will also give you downtime. Professionals wanting this kind of let may also be in the house less at evenings and bank holidays etc. There is a website specialising in this sort of arrangement.

Squamata · 17/01/2023 11:46

Quite often universities look for host families who could take in an overseas student - short term, probably not in that much, might be interesting, easy to back out of if you don't like it!

Or language schools that look to place short-term students.

Swipe left for the next trending thread