Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To put up with him to see kids 100% time

183 replies

Nevisonspad · 17/01/2023 01:24

NC, been around a while. Looking for some support/advice please.

Been with husband over 20 years, married for 10. 2 DC, 8 and 5. Since children came along, he’s been increasingly emotionally abusive. Big cycles where he doesn’t speak to me for many weeks other than to shout that I’m a vile and nasty person. I used to argue but now I barely engage. No trigger, no rationale, he just goes into a mood and it lasts like this for weeks. I try to minimise the impact on the kids by staying cheerful and eventually he comes out of it and we’re ‘normal’ for a while, then he starts calling me a nasty piece of work again. Kids seem happy enough though I know it will have an effect on them and I hate that this demonstrates a ‘relationship’ to them. He only shouts this stuff at me, not at the kids.

No affairs or anything that I know of on either side. He’s had some big stresses in his family over the years whereas my family is tight-knit. His dad was a serial adulterer and alcoholic but they kept up appearances until his parents eventually divorced quite recently. ‘D’H hasn’t I think dealt with this, puts his dad on a pedestal and claims I have a problematic relationship with my family, which I don’t. He doesn’t have an alcohol problem and apart from all the shit he gives me is otherwise a good dad.

The years go by and at least a third of the year he isn’t speaking to me. Obviously I would have left him years ago, but I don’t want to see the kids only half the time, which is what would happen I think if I divorce him. I know it’s crap for the kids to see him shouting at me but most of the time it’s the silent treatment and I try to minimise it to the kids by just saying dad is grumpy again. (I know the silent treatment they see him giving me is also damaging, but it seems better than constant blazing rows). I’m financially ok, work full-time.

My plan is to leave when my younger one leaves home, and until then put up with it in order to see the kids 100% of the time rather than 50/50. Once they have flown the nest there is nothing keeping me here, as he knows. The ‘down’ bit of the cycle where he ignores me and shouts at me has grown longer over the years so that it makes up a bigger proportion of the year, but otherwise it hasn’t gotten worse - nothing physical.

I have a sense of humour and I’m not depressed. I’m busy with work and kids and have family and some friends, though never enough time to see friends. My closest friend knows the situation and agrees with my plan to put up with him until the youngest leaves home, then leave. I don’t act as a doormat around my ‘D’H, I avoid him as much as possible when he’s abusive.

My AIBU is can I put up with him for the next 13 years (say) to see the kids 100% of time? I’ve gotten very close to leaving at points, even engaged a solicitor, but I can’t bring myself to do anything which means I can’t live with the kids 100% of the time. On mumsnet I see lots of people saying LTB under many scenarios. I’m not physically abused, and I’m strong enough and with enough family and friend support that his emotional abuse doesn’t hurt me other than for me to think what an entitled pillock he is to impinge his moods on my and my children’s lives like this. I think there must be lots of people on mumsnet who have made this same bargain with themselves - put up with crap from their ‘D’H so as to live with their kids 100% time. Or is it somehow impossible to do so and everyone ends up leaving before the kids have left home?

Obviously he could leave me, in which case the choice is made for me. I don’t hate him, and I’m happy in myself, but the love I had for him has really ebbed away and I imagine myself single when the kids have flown. Posting now as yet again we’re 3 weeks into a ‘down’ cycle (started just after a genuinely happy Christmas) and I’m fed up with him impinging his moods on me and the kids. We’ve been to counselling, didn’t change anything.

Thanks for reading this.

AIBU - leave him, even if it means kids shared 50/50

YANBU - it’s not really getting worse, even if it is crap, so it’s reasonable to stay to see the kids 100% time.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pinkfondu · 04/02/2023 13:33

For me, it meant I could give them some time away from him. Teach them the tools to deal with it.

rubberduckiee · 30/01/2023 21:24

Maybe OP you subconsciously believe a fake "socially perfect" family is better for the kids than a real smaller family? I would suggest giving them a real family where they can feel safe and belonged and authentic. Depending on which one you give them, that sense of either insecurity or security carries permanently into friendships and romantic relationships.

It's actually hugely damaging for them to smile, laugh, act like oblivious/innocent kids and play the part – whether to keep the overall peace, whether it's because they're copying Mum, or whether it's because they realise from Dad's Jeckyll and Hyde behaviour (horrid to Mum then nice to kids) that one day they may lose favour with Dad too. They might be doing that now to some extent, and certainly will as they grow up, much sooner than you think way before their young teens. I speak from experience. Kids see a lot and adapt prettily.

DarkShade · 30/01/2023 15:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I hope that this is a troll. Are you really suggesting that when men abuse women, it's the woman's fault for not "giving" the man sex or for talking too much?? Why the fuck is it the woman's job to "feed" a man? Even with outdated sexist stereotypes, I thought the man was suppposed to be the one bringing home the bacon.... And you're actually suggesting that this is always the case? If you are verbally abusing your wife for not "giving" you sex, you are problem.

OP, I don't know what the answer is, I'm in a similar situation but the child is much younger and the behaviour of DP much less frquent, so it's a real dilemma. I also think people are too quick to minimise the effects of being shipped from post to post, of living in much poorer households, of step parents and half siblings being thrown into the mix. Also, it's true that when we have children, we should prioritise them, but why is it always the women who are expected to be matryrs? Giving up half your time with your kids, when so much time already is spent with them at school, is such a big ask. Of course you want to make sure it's the right decision for them before you do something that will be awful for you.

Momof3kidsand3cats · 29/01/2023 16:07

He will almost certainly start on the kids as they get older. They will say/do something "just like their mother" or not up to his standards and he will abuse them as well as you.
He most likely will not want 50/50. My ex threatened it to hurt me, he never actually wanted it.

3487642l · 29/01/2023 05:29

Nevisonspad · 18/01/2023 08:53

Thanks for the responses. I can see the view is strongly that the children are being negatively affected now (which I know). What I’ve been doing is weighing up the effect on them of staying, with the assumption this does not get worse (fully aware it may well get worse), vs only seeing the kids half the time. Some posters were very quick to jump down my throat at this, assuming I’m only thinking of myself. The kids want me 100% of the time, and they are upset when I am not with them and they are just with their dad. He would want 50% - yes we have talked about this - and he does 50% the childcare (none of the life admin, as is typical, so it’s not a true 50%, but a 50% as a court would see it I think), and I think he would genuinely want half the time with them - partly because he does want to be with them, and partly to make sure I don’t ‘win’. I know over time he might back off, but initially I’m confident he would want and get them 50% time.

Seeing me 50% time isn’t what the kids would want now, and they might well get that sense of abandonment that one poster spoke about. They are very clingy with me. Many posters were quick to call me selfish - and some called me worse, which frankly felt a bit unnecessarily abusive. The kids if we split will likely have half the time with their dad, which isn’t what they want. There’s no guarantee he gets happier when we split, so they might have to spend half the time with a grump, where I can’t protect them if he starts taking it out on them.

Therefore I’m currently still conflicted. If they are with him 50% time I can’t protect them as I can if I stay, as if he starts taking his moods out on them when he can’t on me, there’s nothing I can do if we’re living apart. If we’re living together and he does this I can go to the police and protect them from him. At the moment it wouldn’t be seen as emotional abuse of them, so he would have them 50%. Yes the kids can choose aged 11/12 or so, but they’re a long way off that yet. I’m not therefore as clear as most people seem to be that leaving them to him half the time is the obvious best path and that not to have done so already makes me abusive. Neither option is good.

I can really relate to your awful dilemma @Nevisonspad .

After knowing for a few years my ex was abusive I left when my youngest was 7 which felt old enough to cope with the separation from me, and I knew the older siblings would support the youngest. It was/is awful, and there is no good solution when a parent emotionally abuses their entire family. After a couple of years separated with 50/50 I can see my children are happier because my home is safe and they see me being myself, even though the post-separation abuse continues and they have to deal with him still. But they also see me modeling healthy relationships in our home, so they can see the difference between dad's house and mum's house.

I highly recommend a woman named Torna Pitman of Talking Wise who has helped me greatly with how to deal with my ex and support my children. In situations like ours, the children need language that does not put down their dad but is clear that his behaviour isn't ok.

rubberduckiee · 29/01/2023 03:35

While I have every sympathy for you and understand your motivations, I got very upset on behalf of your kids while reading this post. While you may not feel you're being abused, you have a part to play in emotionally abusing your kids. I know this sounds harsh, obviously he's the main abuser, but you are also enabling abuse by proxy, in terms of the kind of environment they grow up in – permanent survival mode for their developing brains, even if they're not being directly targeted.

Plus also, the crucial messages they absorb. Your kids will take decades to – or very possibly never ever – learn that silent treatment and emotional abuse is not something they should ever put up with themselves. No matter what you tell them, actions speak louder than words.

I'm someone who grew up with this – not to me – as a norm in my childhood, had lots of exposure and literacy to emotional intelligence/abuse theories growing up, and yet never really put the dots together. My own relationship choices were really poor at best and abusive at worst – I just wrote all kinds of disrespectful and shitty behaviour off as okay and exceptions. That was what I was most comfortable with.

At worse, your kids go on to make the same kind of extreme choice you did, or worse. At best, they learn to ignore red flags, have no idea about the existence of green flags like respect and affection (or rather think it is always mixed up with toxic elements in the same package), and go for less than ideal partners below what they deserve.

harrassedmumto3 · 29/01/2023 03:28

With kindness and respect, your plan to stay is bonkers ... and also a tiny bit selfish. You can't put yourself or your kids through this for the next 10+ years (probably longer, with the cost of living these days). He has no respect for you - and, I'm guessing women in general - and this must be so damaging for them to see (more than you think, anyway).
I'm sorry for your situation and wish you well Flowers

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/01/2023 02:36

You know what @Sith12 just get divorced if you dislike your wife. I'm on DH2 and he's a vast improvement.

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/01/2023 02:35

Men only get "gumpy & not talking petty" with 3 things.

You might. But thankfully the men in my life are fully rounded humans with complex inner lives. And they don't believe that women not acting as support-bots is the worst thing.

Internalised misandry if you ask me.

YetiTeri · 29/01/2023 02:30

@sith12

  1. Sex is not something women 'give' they 'have' it. It's meant to be enjoyable for women too.
  2. Men are perfectly capable of feeding themselves. Women are not a restaurant.
  3. Why did you not mention listening in there? Women are not school children, they don't have to 'shut up'
Sith12 · 28/01/2023 23:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TiredMomOf3 · 27/01/2023 21:51

Why did you ask if you aren't even going to take the advice given?

After reading this, I still think you need to leave. If you have a son, your DH is teaching him to abuse women. He is watching. He is listening. If you have a daughter, you are teaching her that if a ma abuses you, suck it up and deal with it.

Your children are watching you and learning from you. Do you want your children be in this same scenario!? What would you want your daughter to do in this scenario!? Would you tell her "suck it up and stay"!? For real, you are setting a TERRIBLE EXAMPLE FOR YOUR CHILDREN.

TiredMomOf3 · 27/01/2023 21:47

Don't put up with this. My father is an alcoholic and mentally abusive. He said extremely mean things to us growing up. My sister and I both struggled with anorexia and bulimia as kids because of his words of calling us fat. My sister was a cutter as a teen because of my dad's horrible demeanor towards us. I still struggle with body acceptance and anorexia. I'm in my 30's.

My mother was depressed growing up. She worked all the time but he took the $. She said all the time she wished she had not married him. I spent most of my life consoling her till my late 20's when I got tired of being there for her when she was depressed and having her stay with my father and not stop the abuse to her and us.

I don't talk to my parents anymore. I have them blocked on everything. I feel bad for my mom, but I'm not going to stick around with that crappy human being of a father.

So, if you truly care about your children's mental health, LEAVE. Who cares if it's 50/50. If 100% equals abuse, your just letting your children know that it's ok to be abused. You should set the example on what is NOT ok and LEAVE.

TiredMomOf3 · 27/01/2023 21:41

Don't put up with this. My father is an alcoholic and mentally abusive. He said extremely mean things to us growi

Blufelt · 27/01/2023 21:40

It’s not about you seeing the kids 100%. What you have to consider is he will get partial custody, possibly as much as 50%. Then he’ll be abusive to your kids and you won’t be there to protect them.

MandieM · 27/01/2023 21:37

Your husband learned how to be an adult man from his father who was a terrible example. Staying with him for your convenience & playing the martyr is teaching your children not only that you think daddies behavior is acceptable but feel free to go ahead & emulate him. Just lather, rinse, repeat the cycle of abuse onto your grandchildren, again just to reiterate here, because your are too confrontation adverse to give your children the safe & healthy childhood they deserve. Look at your husband, look at your kids & can you accept them growing up to be just like him? Can you accept the blame for never teaching them his behavior was unacceptable? Accept the anger at you for letting them watch Daddy abuse Mummy? You aren't sucking it up for them, you are bunking off for yourself.

mandlerparr · 23/01/2023 18:46

If he really is a good dad and otherwise fine, then the next time he does this, walk right up to him (not too close, just talking distance) and tell him that you are not his whipping post or punching bag to take his bad mood out on. Tell him that he needs to go to therapy. Also tell him that you are open to couples counseling, but that he needs to go see someone to discuss his feelings with.
Unfortunately, this is a thing that some men do when they want to end the marriage, but don't have the will to do it themselves. They try and force you into being so miserable that you file and then they get to cry foul to all the people you know about how you broke up the marriage.

wordler · 20/01/2023 19:07

I think you should reassess the situation as soon as your youngest is 10. By that point, they will both have a lot more agency than they do now - and will be able to advocate for themselves more than at their current ages. The older child will probably have a phone by then and they will both have started to have more independence outside the home with friends as well so won't be 100% with you in the house anyway.

That gives you five years to get all your ducks in a row. It's a much nearer deadline than waiting till the youngest is 18, so will help you be more resilient about dealing with the current situation. And it's a long enough time for you to make serious plans and start saving up some money etc.

With a shorter deadline and getting ready for it you will also be more prepared as well if things do escalate at home and you suddenly had to split sooner.

Volhhg · 20/01/2023 18:46

Hazelbrazil · 19/01/2023 20:14

We are in a massive experiment at the moment. We don't know whether today's kids 50:50 in situations like this will say it was much better as with each parent the tension disappeared and we had fun or will say I spent every other week miserable and scared/bored

Yes exactly this, It was relatively rare for my generation to go and have 50/50 when I was young and experiencing this. All the posters on here saying they had to go through therapy and had poor self esteem from living with both parents who were not in a happy relationship. Guess what so did I! I definitely had abandonment issues with my mum who had to let us go to ours dad's. Neither then moved on to healthy relationships so I still didn't get a good role model. My dad's next relationship was worse in fact. Sometimes there's no good options when you have a dad like this and I can't blame the op for keeping the situation under her control. All situations are different and only you know what is best for your children right now op.

Hazelbrazil · 19/01/2023 20:14

Hazelbrazil · 18/01/2023 19:01

By the time they are aged 10/11 the children get a say and if it was50:50 they would be older to be able to ring you if needed. Also will be less clingy by that point. Less time to wait than 18.

We are in a massive experiment at the moment. We don't know whether today's kids 50:50 in situations like this will say it was much better as with each parent the tension disappeared and we had fun or will say I spent every other week miserable and scared/bored

FlorencenotRatchet · 18/01/2023 20:26

Op
You say that your children want you 100% of the time. Have you thought that this may be a reaction to the atmosphere in the house already rubbing off on them.
Sometimes we make decisions when we are in situations that feel right. It's only when we are removed we can see how damaging they are.

buckeejit · 18/01/2023 19:56

That sucks. I know you don't want to hear it but you should leave. Don't distress yourself with worrying what might happen IF you leave. Look at things now. What you know now is that the children are suffering & the situation is not good for anyone. Think of the opportunity of you & dc having breathing space.

Hazelbrazil · 18/01/2023 19:01

By the time they are aged 10/11 the children get a say and if it was50:50 they would be older to be able to ring you if needed. Also will be less clingy by that point. Less time to wait than 18.

Orangesare · 18/01/2023 18:37

If you have a large enough garden you can have a static caravan or garden room (with kitchenette, bathroom heating etc) fairly easily. Would he go to his new space to be grumpy so the house is calm and there’s not atmosphere and the kids are happy because you are there all the time but they can see dad pretty much as normal as well.
when they are old enough to decide how much time they want to spend with him you can then split

bakewellbride · 18/01/2023 18:37

Leave him now. I grew up with this and trust me it was hell. Do the right thing.