Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gender recognition reform blocked

233 replies

hadntbeen · 16/01/2023 22:29

Scottish Secretary Alister Jack has made an order under section 35 of the Scotland Act 1998, preventing the Scottish Parliament’s Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill from proceeding to Royal Assent.
Thank god 🙏🏻 I am an SNP supporter but this is one bill I was wholeheartedly against. I'm glad and relieved this decision was made.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
smileladiesplease · 17/01/2023 00:47

Sedatelpixie

I wish I could do they too. Brilliant idea

smileladiesplease · 17/01/2023 00:45

I think sturgeon knew sunak would do this so the bill won't stand but dhe can blame Westminster and still get approval from the trans minority bullies

Thank god though

Abitofalark · 17/01/2023 00:34

Thank goodness. I am so relieved that the government has acted to protect us. It would have been wrong not to invoke the provision in the Scotland Act for just this type of case. The Scottish government is always pushing to extend its devolved powers and has achieved some changes since the original devolution agreement but something had to be done to stop this particular madness affecting us in the rest of the UK.

And it's not the first time the government has intervened. Remember 2021 when Johnson was PM he successfully took a case to the Supreme Court over two Scottish bills that went beyond the legislative powers of the Scottish parliament. Must have been sweet considering the constant goading and insults she threw his way.

She is a power-mad fanatic still goading the UK government. Fanaticism can make one blinkered and stupid but I doubt that she actually believes the rubbish she comes out with to 'justify' ignoring the safeguarding of women and girls re single sex provision.
More likely deeply cynical and politically motivated.

Scrumbleton · 17/01/2023 00:30

"It's not anti-trans at all, it's about defending women's rights to safe spaces. I'm not anti-men -my best friend is a man- but there is a reason why they are not allowed into women's prisons, shelters, changing rooms and sports. Making self ID law, meant that any man can enter any women's space without even having to pretend to be trans"

Also agree with this

SedatePixie · 17/01/2023 00:24

When the BBC broke this wonderful news-and it is wonderful news-they chose to illustrate it with a picture of young women holding aloft placards declaring Trans Rights.

I have been enjoying the memes on the royalty board and I only wish I knew how to create one.

If I knew how, it would involve pasting turkey heads on the bodies of these young women and, above them, a declaration saying, 'Voting for Christmas!'

RosaCaramella · 17/01/2023 00:18

Pleasegodgotosleep · 16/01/2023 23:37

@RosaCaramella

I dont think women and girls are at risk from trans people. I think they could well be at risk from predators taking advantage of self id reforms to claim to be trans and access formerly safe spaces.

As I understand it, the new birth certificate obtained through self ID would give legal proof of gender identity for the people who need it for various official purposes.

There is nothing to stop predatory / dangerous males from passing themselves off as females right now and going into female only spaces. Having been attacked and threatened by males 19 times by the age of 20, I’m certain that violent, aggressive men don’t need to pretend to be women to do so.

LexMitior · 17/01/2023 00:08

I think given the political cynicism of it, it's damn good thing that there is some mechanism to prevent the rest of the UK having its rights under the Equalties Act affected by the SNP.

That is actually what they have done. Ignore their little domestic dance for their supporters- the SNP were happy to affect the rights of women across the UK because of this bill.

I can understand the desire for independence- but this, this is not okay. Should it represent majority opinion in Scotland and it is vital then declare independence and do it then. Otherwise, unprintable thoughts about the SNP and their support.

PeekAtYou · 17/01/2023 00:04

BuwchGochGota · 16/01/2023 22:39

Regardless of anyone's views on trans issues, I think it sets a dangerous precedent that Westminster can overrule the devolved governments.

It affects the other nations too so it's fair that Westminster can block it.

IlooklikeRonnieCorbett · 17/01/2023 00:03

VestaTilley · 16/01/2023 23:23

Yes yes yes!!! Bloody brilliant news!! Best thing the Tories have ever done. Self ID is a predators dream.

The cynic in new thinks Sturgeon did this whole thing on purpose, to provoke the Tories in to blocking it, and then using it to drive support for independence. But I’m just glad finally someone has stuck up for women and children!

This. Sturgeon doesn’t care about trans issues. She knew they’d block it. She’s power mad.

hadntbeen · 17/01/2023 00:01

@scratchedbymycat because this was the plan all along. The SNP don't truly want this bill to be passed, they know it is an awful idea, they knew it would be blocked. This will now give them yet another example of how Scotland doesn't have any freedom and is being controlled by Westminster in order to push their narrative that Scotland must insist on another referendum. Although, I don't think she quite anticipated how just the mention of the GRR could intact alienate a big percentage of her supporters.

OP posts:
ClareBlue · 17/01/2023 00:00

GreenEmeraldSea · 16/01/2023 22:34

Mumsnet and its pathological hate of trans people...........but the SNP are lovely and magical ..........

Also - wear masks everyone!

Show one post on here that indicates a pathological hatred of trans people. Just the one will do.

BMW6 · 16/01/2023 23:55

GreenEmeraldSea · 16/01/2023 22:34

Mumsnet and its pathological hate of trans people...........but the SNP are lovely and magical ..........

Also - wear masks everyone!

Show a single link where people express hatred for transpeople. Just ONE.

scratchedbymycat · 16/01/2023 23:54

hadntbeen · 16/01/2023 23:48

@scratchedbymycat the gender recognition reform would never have been proposed if we'd of gotten independence in 2014, trust me.

What makes you say that?

LexMitior · 16/01/2023 23:54

I think you have to get past this issue on independence- these laws are really being passed by numpties. That is frightening to me. The only oversight is the UK Government.

This law is wrong for many reasons. I accept that Scotland may want self ID. But really, it is scary how it has been done. I also can't live with the SNP infringing my rights even though I don't even live there.

radrado · 16/01/2023 23:52

@RosaCaramella
What is a trans person anyway? Stonewall include cross dressers in their definition. So doing it for sexual kicks. We do not want them in womens spaces thank you. Stop being so naive.

and yes I know plenty young vulnerable trans FTM through my work. Not who we’re talking about here though. Although I worry about them following a path that’s hard to get off and this Act does not help.

scratchedbymycat · 16/01/2023 23:51

@RosaCaramella

When I first started looking into this years ago I wondered whether there was anything to be worried about too. I started a spreadsheet where I logged sex offenders that were identified in the media, and who were trans and in the UK. I got to 37 awful examples (they usually are when they make the media) and stopped a couple of years ago because it got so disheartening. I still see cases all the time and wonder how many I'd have logged if I had kept it up.

There's also been a sudden 84% increase in female paedophiles ... 🧐 In the news this week. Weird that .... 👃 🐀

This is not to say all trans women are rapists or paedophiles.

Similarly, not all men are rapists or child abusers.

If the fact that most trans women are not violent is a reason to allow ALL TW into women's spaces, then, logically, the same courtesy should be extended to ALL men.

It's not about trans women: it's about male violence against women and children. I don't know a single man who is violent to women, but that doesn't mean I think men don't present a threat to women and children. It's about the significant minority who have a devastating impact on women and girls. It's about women and girls deserving to be protected from them.

Quincythequince · 16/01/2023 23:49

LexMitior · 16/01/2023 23:45

Some of the things the SNP do are so wrong in UK constitutional law that you assume they are done deliberately. Scottish lawyers and the lawyers who draft for the Scottish Government are not stupid people yet these laws are.

Therefore when a draft law can never survive, and a drafting lawyer would know. The advisers would know. The only purpose is political.

Completely agree.

This will be used to stoke anti-English rhetoric, despite the fact that she has moved way out of her lane on this one.

hadntbeen · 16/01/2023 23:48

@scratchedbymycat the gender recognition reform would never have been proposed if we'd of gotten independence in 2014, trust me.

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 16/01/2023 23:48

LoveCillian · 16/01/2023 23:33

I am not a fan of NS but did think she was a strong advocate for women,until this Act

She is not a strong advocate for women at all.

Look back a little further at her chequered career re supporting. She is not, and has never been an ally of women.

LexMitior · 16/01/2023 23:45

Some of the things the SNP do are so wrong in UK constitutional law that you assume they are done deliberately. Scottish lawyers and the lawyers who draft for the Scottish Government are not stupid people yet these laws are.

Therefore when a draft law can never survive, and a drafting lawyer would know. The advisers would know. The only purpose is political.

EmmaEmerald · 16/01/2023 23:42

Lex to provoke what? If they don't mean it, I don't understand the endgame.

LexMitior · 16/01/2023 23:40

The SNP presumably did this for the headlines.

They won't win any judicial review. I assume it's like the independence bill, clearly wrong in law, so it's done to provoke.

Pleased really as I don't want this terrible law to apply on a proxy basis in England. Scotland can be independent and then do it.

EmmaEmerald · 16/01/2023 23:40

FOJN "I met my first transperson before most of the blue hairs screaming transphobe were even born. I took time off work to look after my friend post op, what horrible person I am."

same re my trans contacts. They feel quite upset about a lot of this, they went through so much pain and suffering to transition, and now it's become an issue of self ID - bewildering and strange.

FOJN · 16/01/2023 23:38

How many people who express an opinion (judgement) on this actually know any trans people? The legislation was brought about to lessen the terrible toll that trying to be accepted for who they are takes on trans people - especially young people who are one of the highest groups to take their own lives.

Dear god stop being so melodramatic.

I met my first transperson before most of the blue hairs screaming transphobe were even born. I took time off work to look after my friend post op, what horrible person I am.

Can you tell me how a new birth certificate increases trans acceptance? All other documentation can be changed without a GRC. Do you carry your birth certificate around with you?

Please stop using widely debunked suicide stats for young trans people, it's harmful.

Trans acceptance would be a non issue if the activists speaking on behalf of trans people weren't so intent on forcing the rest of us to deny reality.

scratchedbymycat · 16/01/2023 23:37

hadntbeen · 16/01/2023 23:27

@scratchedbymycat I am yes, I think it'd be difficult to find a party in which you support every single one of their policies. The majority of policies set out by the SNP I agree with and I do want independence. However, the gender reform recognition bill was one I strongly disagreed with and am glad it's not going ahead. But that doesn't change my views on the SNP as a whole. Should we get independence (unlikely) then I would perhaps look at other party policies at that time. At the moment, my main aim is independence and so they shall get my vote. They've also done loads for me personally as a student and as a single mum so I really can't complain.

Yes, but this is a very very big issue involving the rights of 50% of the population. Massive issue. I was hoping, for the sake of my daughter, that this would be a zero tolerance issue for SNP women.

I am very aware that if we'd achieved Independence in 2014, women and children would be in a devastating position right now. For me, my daughter's rights and her safety is more important than anything in the world. It dismays me that women and girls rights could come second to anything. I could never choose to risk that, even if there was a high political price to pay on an issue dear to me (like independence is to you).

Swipe left for the next trending thread