Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gender recognition reform blocked

233 replies

hadntbeen · 16/01/2023 22:29

Scottish Secretary Alister Jack has made an order under section 35 of the Scotland Act 1998, preventing the Scottish Parliament’s Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill from proceeding to Royal Assent.
Thank god 🙏🏻 I am an SNP supporter but this is one bill I was wholeheartedly against. I'm glad and relieved this decision was made.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
scratchedbymycat · 17/01/2023 08:50

hadntbeen · 17/01/2023 00:01

@scratchedbymycat because this was the plan all along. The SNP don't truly want this bill to be passed, they know it is an awful idea, they knew it would be blocked. This will now give them yet another example of how Scotland doesn't have any freedom and is being controlled by Westminster in order to push their narrative that Scotland must insist on another referendum. Although, I don't think she quite anticipated how just the mention of the GRR could intact alienate a big percentage of her supporters.

I think everything the SNP do has one eye on how it can rule Westminster. But if this was its sole intention - as you suggest - then women and children are pawns / collateral damage . And that's despicable and unforgivable.

Further, the SNP have a track record for ill conceived laws that are harmful to women and children - the named person, hate crime stand out .

Are you suggesting that if we vote for Independence, that all this will melt away and we'll have a wonderful country with good laws? That this isn't the real SNP?

Or is it possible that if we vote for Independence our lives will be in the hands of people who impose bad controlling laws on its populace?

Sometimes the simplest answer is the most obvious one. I think the SNP did this because they did a deal with the greens. I think it's populate among many of the SNP MSPs as well. I think they thought it would look progressive and modern and edgy and appeal to the youth. And above all, I think they thought they could impose it on dissenters because they believe they can get away with absolutely anything because they have a core group who only care about 'independence'.

You seem nice, but supporters like you are part of the problem here. It's Trump's 5th Avenue analogy. And that is utterly terrifying for the rest of us.

Giggorata · 17/01/2023 08:50

Thank goodness that sense prevails.

As for “How many people who express an opinion (judgement) on this actually know any trans people?”, I met the first two trans people I knew around 1971, and even then, the differences between the one with gender dysphoria and the
one with auto gynephilia were obvious, even though we didn't have the terms then.

Flapjackquack · 17/01/2023 08:49

Mirabai · 17/01/2023 08:45

I don’t agree with that, I mean she knew it might get blocked but I think her support is sincere.

I think Sturgeon is sincerely supportive of anything that will boost her chances at the next referendum. I am not anti Scotland leaving the union, I just think Sturgeon is someone who will do absolutely anything to be the person who took Scotland out of the Union like BJ and Brexit.

Mirabai · 17/01/2023 08:45

Flapjackquack · 17/01/2023 08:43

This bill went way too far and I think that was intentional. Sturgeon always knew it would get blocked because it was so far reaching. It’s funny Sturgeon calling out the UK government for using trans people as political pawns when she is doing exactly that. It’s just another argument for independence. If she really cared about trans people the bill would have been much more limited.

I don’t agree with that, I mean she knew it might get blocked but I think her support is sincere.

Flapjackquack · 17/01/2023 08:43

This bill went way too far and I think that was intentional. Sturgeon always knew it would get blocked because it was so far reaching. It’s funny Sturgeon calling out the UK government for using trans people as political pawns when she is doing exactly that. It’s just another argument for independence. If she really cared about trans people the bill would have been much more limited.

NotRightNowNo · 17/01/2023 08:43

I can't understand why some people still think this is about hating trans people.

I don't hate men but I don't want to share a space where I'm vulnerable with them, like a changing room. If anyone can say they're a woman and enter a female safe space then some men will do that to get access . It has already been proven. Why is that so difficult to grasp?

Mirabai · 17/01/2023 08:43

And the worst of it is - if Starmer was in power he wouldn’t be challenging NS on this. The Labour Party is creating the mother of all women problems.

Mirabai · 17/01/2023 08:41

Sturgeon has lost her marbles on this one and failed to listen to women.

Whoever would have thought I’d be supporting a Brexit supporting Tory PM over Sturgeon over an issue. Strange times.

Bluebird1234 · 17/01/2023 08:38

I’m glad blocked. However, it’s Sturgeon trying to stoke division and say that Scotland is oppressed. This was forced through Holyrood and it’s not about trans or women’s rights merely a tool for her.

Roselilly36 · 17/01/2023 08:38

Not a Sunak fan, but at last he has got something right!

Sorefootouch · 17/01/2023 08:37

And as someone with a connection to those drafting this legislation, they knew full well it was deeply flawed, told the government it was deeply flawed but it was pushed ahead anyway.

Sorefootouch · 17/01/2023 08:33

I am just so relieved the UK government has the power to over rule such dangerous, mindbendingly stupid legislation. Could you imagine if Scotland were independent and legislation such as thing had passed?

if anyone has not seen it already, google Tom Swarbrick Maggie Chapman interview. It’s on YouTube. This is the calibre of ‘politician’ we have in Scotland. These are the sort of people legislating. It’s quite frankly terrifying.

Brefugee · 17/01/2023 08:21

Oh God, the old "trans people are evil people with nefarious purposes in mind" trope.

this is tripe. It is not Trans people that anyone is worried about.
It is that dangerous men can now stand up and say "I'm trans" and DO NOTHING AT ALL, not even shave, and enter, under the umbrella of "Trans" any space where women would normally be alone

Nobody is saying trans people will be doing that. As many trans women have pointed out, they have been using women's spaces for years and years and years. So what changed? Well, AGP's for one, using "trans" as a cover up. Trans women should be as up in arms about this as anyone else. Not because it is dangerous for them as such, but because their position is greatly weakened. And we have seen the result: instead of trans women being able to quietly go about their lives as they have been - the whole movement has been dragged into an MRA hate-fest.

Brefugee · 17/01/2023 08:15

Regardless of anyone's views on trans issues, I think it sets a dangerous precedent that Westminster can overrule the devolved governments.

It's not a precedent it was built into the act that created the devolved governments. Some things are devolved and some not.

I think it's unfortunate that it has arrived with this bill, and it will be interesting to see how it affects people's attitudes to Scottish Independence. There will be those who don't care what the bill is about but "how dare England try to block our laws" about this, and others who are concerned about the content of the bill who may be either "how dare they" or "thank goodness"

The fact that we are 4 countries under the banner of one nation isn't even unique. The US and Germany are two examples of federated states where the states have certain devolved powers, but not over every aspect of life. And they are definitely not allowed to enact laws that encroach on the powers of the national government. I haven't really paid that much attention to the bill in Scotland, i do know that for various reasons it is heavily contested in some quarters and highly desired in others. Not necessarily because they are trans/anti-trans (or pro-/anti-woman - depending on your view) but because it is a test of how far the Scottish government can and will go to preserve/extend its autonomy.

From a Scottish citizen's pov, of course, the more autonomy their government has the better (if they support Independence) and the less their government has the better (if they don't). From the UK government pov? it's a hot mess giving some citizens different laws than others. How do we handle having a GRC issued in Scotland when we're in England or Wales? What if someone from England moves to Scotland, 3 months later gets a GRC and subsequently (as planned by them) moves back to England?

Marriages in one state are generally, but not always (as we have seen with same-sex marriage). Marriage is, like a GRC, in essence, a government licence to confirm an action an individual has taken. So how does it work in countries where a GRC isn't recognised at all? or has very different criteria? (i have no idea but could imagine that some states might say you only get a GRC post all surgery, for example, and I'd think that may be a problem for some)

FeinCuroxiVooz · 17/01/2023 08:13

absolutely no hate for trans people from me, but it would have set a very dangerous precedent if the Scottish parliament had been allowed to make legislation that so clearly impacts people in england wales and northern ireland too. this is a matter that can't be fully devolved, and is a correct use of the section 35 powers which appropriately foresaw that a situation could come about where proposed legislation in Scotland could over reach the borders of Scotland and have effects in the rest of the uk.

OxPeg · 17/01/2023 08:04

There is nothing to stop predatory / dangerous males from passing themselves off as females right now and going into female only spaces.

Of course there is - if your ID still reflects your sex observed at birth, you’re not going to find it easy to access a women’s prison, for example. Why make it easier for potential predators (not to be conflated with trans people in general - that’s obviously not what I’m saying) to access women’s safe spaces?

And as another poster said, please stop using widely-debunked suicide stats about trans people - it is extremely harmful.

FrostyFifi · 17/01/2023 08:03

I think the point of the law was to reduce trauma to trans people as they’d have to be diagnosed with gender dysphasia first

So what makes them trans if not gender dysphoria? Should there be zero oversight for starting down a route of drugs and surgery, especially for sixteen year olds?

Faultymain5 · 17/01/2023 07:23

GreenEmeraldSea · 16/01/2023 23:02

Oh God, the old "trans people are evil people with nefarious purposes in mind" trope.

No one said that. This is a lie.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 17/01/2023 07:16

As I understand it, the new birth certificate obtained through self ID would give legal proof of gender identity for the people who need it for various official purposes

What is a 'gender identity' other than sex role stereotypes or feelings? Seriously?
Because unless they come up with an actual meaning for 'gender' and 'gender identity' that has any factual, coherent basis then how can, and why should it be legally protected?

If 'trans' is anything or everything anyone says on any given day then it's meaningless.
If it's a mental health condition of dysphoria, that can be professionally diagnosed, then why does it need legal protection?
No one should be allowed to alter their birth certificate because no one can change sex. 'Gender' isn't sex as we are told by TRA's so no reason to change their sex marker eh?

The issue with the current trans narrative is that they want to force everyone else to go along with the nonsense new religion and language.
Nothing to do with actual transexuals which is who a lot of people naively think this is about because they were already protected in law.

People who claim trans identities ALREADY have the same legal protections as everyone else plus the protection of gender reassignment.

There is nothing to stop predatory / dangerous males from passing themselves off as females right now and going into female only spaces. Having been attacked and threatened by males 19 times by the age of 20, I’m certain that violent, aggressive men don’t need to pretend to be women to do so

Rapist gonna rape so let's make all formally female only spaces mixed sex to accommodate males with poor mental health or a sexual paraphilia.
Who cares if it increases the risk to women and girls.

Thank fuck it's been blocked.

IWineAndDontDine · 17/01/2023 01:41

Thon · 16/01/2023 22:52

No one on here has a pathological hatred of anyone. Wind yer neck in.

😂😂😂 are you sniffing glue

LexMitior · 17/01/2023 01:10

@Abitofalark - I don't think you can give Boris Johnson the credit! Those cases had been listed and prepped a while before he came in. And of course he had his bottom handed to him by the Supreme Court over prerogation.

Anyway, Sturgeon is constantly looking for the button. She doesn't have powers to legislate, she knows that.

This situation will persist as long as the SNP dominate Holyrood. They like shouting people down. But whatever their perfect Scotland is, it's not anywhere I like the look of.

blackpearwhitelilies · 17/01/2023 01:09

BuwchGochGota · 16/01/2023 22:39

Regardless of anyone's views on trans issues, I think it sets a dangerous precedent that Westminster can overrule the devolved governments.

Yes. I agree with this. Extremely ironic that this is from the party whining about the EU trying to rule us.

AthenaPopodopolous · 17/01/2023 01:08

Gender dysphoria… I meant

AthenaPopodopolous · 17/01/2023 01:08

I think the point of the law was to reduce trauma to trans people as they’d have to be diagnosed with gender dysphasia first.
Effectively being diagnosed with a mental health condition before being allowed by medics to transition…
Gays were labelled mentally Ill in the DSM (psychiatric diagnostic medical manual) as mentally I’ll years ago until the law and medics overturned that.

Crispwinterday · 17/01/2023 00:55

GreenEmeraldSea · 16/01/2023 23:02

Oh God, the old "trans people are evil people with nefarious purposes in mind" trope.

You need to reread what. FOJN wrote, because it wasn't that.

The point is that any male could misuse the act to access women and girls' safe spaces.