Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gender recognition reform blocked

233 replies

hadntbeen · 16/01/2023 22:29

Scottish Secretary Alister Jack has made an order under section 35 of the Scotland Act 1998, preventing the Scottish Parliament’s Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill from proceeding to Royal Assent.
Thank god 🙏🏻 I am an SNP supporter but this is one bill I was wholeheartedly against. I'm glad and relieved this decision was made.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Abitofalark · 17/01/2023 11:14

LexMitior · 17/01/2023 01:10

@Abitofalark - I don't think you can give Boris Johnson the credit! Those cases had been listed and prepped a while before he came in. And of course he had his bottom handed to him by the Supreme Court over prerogation.

Anyway, Sturgeon is constantly looking for the button. She doesn't have powers to legislate, she knows that.

This situation will persist as long as the SNP dominate Holyrood. They like shouting people down. But whatever their perfect Scotland is, it's not anywhere I like the look of.

Rubbish. I don't even know why you are posting this. The Scots parliament passed the Bills in March 2021 and as I said the Johnson government referred them to the Supreme Court.

Eleganz · 17/01/2023 10:44

I think both sides have been spoiling for this fight. The SNP refused to entertain amendments that would have improved compatibility with the Equalities Act and the Tories refused the option of sending this to the courts. It really has very little to do with the actual content of the bill (beyond it being in a grey area between reserved and devolved powers).

purpledalmation · 17/01/2023 10:43

How many people who express an opinion (judgement) on this actually know any trans people?

I'm anti this legislation and have a dear friend (male to female) who has transitioned and is a happy lovely person. Now married to a woman. I don't understand how it works but I don't judge. She wouldn't consider entering women only spaces.

purpledalmation · 17/01/2023 10:40

BuwchGochGota · 16/01/2023 22:39

Regardless of anyone's views on trans issues, I think it sets a dangerous precedent that Westminster can overrule the devolved governments.

I think this is the first time every since devolution and many many pieces of Scottish only legislation have gone through unopposed. This affects all of the UK therefore it is unacceptable under wider laws.

Nicola will milk it though. Maybe that was why it was pushed through despite so much opposition

Rainbowshit · 17/01/2023 10:30

@clutchingatpearls I have serious doubts about Maggie Chapman's ability to make any connections between anything ever. She's absolutely off her head and needs to be well away from where adult decisions are being made.

Brefugee · 17/01/2023 10:27

How many people who express an opinion (judgement) on this actually know any trans people?

that's not actually the 'gotcha' you think it is, btw. So few people know anyone who is trans because they are really a tiny minority.

A minority who deserve to be treated with sympathy and compassion and understanding. But not a minority who get to ride roughshod over other groups.

Where rights of various groups stand in conflict, a 3rd way is required. which is off topic for this discussion so I'll leave it there.

DownNative · 17/01/2023 10:26

BuwchGochGota · 16/01/2023 22:39

Regardless of anyone's views on trans issues, I think it sets a dangerous precedent that Westminster can overrule the devolved governments.

Rubbish.

The UK is a UNITARY SOVEREIGN STATE and Westminster has always been the Supreme Legislator.

Holyrood, Stormont and Cardiff Bay are NOT equal to Westminster as they're very much constrained in power.

Westminster is not constrained in Domestic Constitutional Law.

It's all in the Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales Acts. All above board and very democratic.

You might have a point if the UK was a FEDERATION like the USA, but we're not. We still have central government with very limited powers decentralised.

Unlike Holyrood vis a vis the independence stuff, Westminster is NOT acting outwith it's powers.

People in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland all voted for very limited local government with ultimate power residing in a central Westminster Parliament. It's democratic.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 17/01/2023 10:24

How many people who express an opinion (judgement) on this actually know any trans people?

I do! Just a few quite well. Some for many years, others younger and very dear to me. And these days you'd be bound at least to encounter some trans people if you have anything to do with young people e.g. for your work.

The legislation was brought about to lessen the terrible toll that trying to be accepted for who they are takes on trans people

Yes I am sure it that was the intention. With an innocence that would be charming if it wasn't so dangerous. And then it became policy and a commitment and so it became necessary to stick fingers in ears and say "La La La" when anyone else tried to point out that there were serious downsides.

especially young people who are one of the highest groups to take their own lives.

Young people, perhaps, not especially due to being trans though. That's misinformation.

it wasn’t discussed widely in the press or on social media as far as I am aware

Well no it wasn't, so naive views like yours were not corrected by widespread public discussion or by reliable information.

so I would also question the assertions that the Scottish public didn’t want the bill.

That's hard to say. The bill is pig in a poke, the public don't know all the effects it will have, no-one really knows for sure. The Scottish government has said contradictory things about what legal effects it will have, so we don't know.

I wish the Scottish Govt had listened to women's advocates, and also taken more seriously the evidence about physical and psychological dangers to children and young people instead of using the "just like Section 28" trope. But the Scottish govt didn't take it seriously. Calling on the UK govt to stop it feels like stopping a bully by calling on a bigger bully!

kinkytoes · 17/01/2023 10:21

I don't know any trans people but I know plenty of men and that's enough for me to oppose this bill tyvm.

I think NS has done us all a favour by blowing this issue out of the bylines and into the mainstream narrative. Thank you Nic!

Brefugee · 17/01/2023 09:46

I’m certain that violent, aggressive men don’t need to pretend to be women to do so

nobody has ever said that violent, aggressive men need these new laws to be able to harm women.
Rapists gotta rape.

However, it makes it so much easier for a bloke to just walk into, say, a gym changing room and not be challenged because they literally cannot be challenged. And anyone who does challenge them, even with a polite "this is the ladies" might realistically be prosecuted.

I personally don't think women are at risk from a genuine, honest-to-god trans woman. I do think women are at risk from men who have now been handed the ability to access women's areas on a plate. There is no need to even put on a dress, shave, or adapt in any way to indicate that you "are a woman"

clutchingatpearls · 17/01/2023 09:41

Rainbowshit · 16/01/2023 22:51

I'm delighted although slightly nervous about the knock on impact on scexit.

Have you all seen that deranged lunatic Maggie Chapman say she doesn't know what sex she is and that 6 year olds should be able to choose to change their legal sex? That's what we're dealing with in Scotland.

Wonder whether she's capable of making the connection:
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-north-east-orkney-shetland-64223032

Imicola · 17/01/2023 09:40

BuwchGochGota · 16/01/2023 22:39

Regardless of anyone's views on trans issues, I think it sets a dangerous precedent that Westminster can overrule the devolved governments.

I think it would make a more dangerous precedent to allow the devolved administration to create new laws that have far reaching consequences outside of their competency. Regardless of the topic within this legislation, to say that there is no impact of the Equality Act, and no consequences for non-devolved matters is totally disingenuous. This whole legislative process by the SG has been flawed from the outset.

Zebedee55 · 17/01/2023 09:38

Good. Hope Sunak manages to stop this. Even Starmer agreed that age 16 was too young for all this.

Sturgron is just using this to push her independence agenda.🙄

Sorefootouch · 17/01/2023 09:36

I think this will backfire on NS. The publicity this bill is generating just results in it being scrutinised more closely, and people are wondering why on earth a government would pass such a terribly drafted piece of legislation which is so unpopular with the public. It makes the Scottish government look incompetent. Which it is.

RichardBarrister · 17/01/2023 09:32

In answer to a previous poster’s question, I know several trans people. Thankfully the ones born male understand that sex is not the same as gender and happily use facilities set aside for men.

Another one is now disabled from taking cross sex hormones, left his family and is extremely depressed.

There are also a couple of young female transitioners and I’m not sure how they are right now - they’ve gone very quiet.

It seems like Nicola has decided to throw trans people as well as women under the bus in pursuit of Independence. The lobbyists have tried very hard to keep this all under the radar for years and get the law changed before we all realised what was going on like they did in Ireland.

They nearly succeeded under Theresa May who was pushing for the UK to adopt self id but thankfully some people in government are still advocating for women and children’s needs and at least attempting to balance them with the requirements of trans people.

We have found that when people understand the implications of self id legislation, they are far less supportive. This huge row means that greater public awareness and therefore ultimately more resistance to self id.

We have been sleepwalking into this for years with many organisations quietly introducing self id policies for toilets, changing rooms, schools, hospitals etc. The GRR will cement those policies and prevent the companies that do understand the need to maintain single sex spaces and services.

We know that women and girls are already being harmed directly as a result of self id policies - sexually assaulted and peeped at in Primark, mixed sex changing villages, raped in hospitals and prisons etc.

Why would anyone bring in a law that makes all that more likely and makes it easier for men to prey on women?

Flapjackquack · 17/01/2023 09:30

@StuntNun - I think it’s covered in the Northern Ireland Act 1998 but don’t quote me on it. Odd it’s devolved in NI but not everywhere else, I guess due to the specific religious divisions present in NI and not as present in the rest of the UK.

OneTC · 17/01/2023 09:29

Pretty sure this was what wee Jimmy was after but it's a risky issue to be the one to cause the split I reckon.

StuntNun · 17/01/2023 09:26

Does anyone know why Alister Jack's statement only mentions Great Britain? What is the equivalent of the Equality Act in Northern Ireland that means they wouldn't be affected by the GRR?

ClaphamSouth · 17/01/2023 09:24

No one asked me my opinion on the bill and it wasn’t discussed widely in the press or on social media as far as I am aware so I would also question the assertions that the Scottish public didn’t want the bill.

It's very interesting to hear you say this, RosaCaramella, because Scottish Government insisted that this was the most scrutinised piece of legislation they'd put forward, and had been the subject of multiple public consultations, although it's true those consultations didn't actually include listening to many of the concerns raised by women, as noted by Reem Alsalem, the UN's Special Rapporteur on Violence Against Women and Girls: www.thetimes.co.uk/article/bc237744-7ff0-11ed-ab78-11b70ed96428?shareToken=c0957e4d2cd99ee6635e9e027b6ca3bb

Perhaps ScotGov didn't publicise it as well as they claim to have done.

There were several polls conducted as the legislation went through the Scottish parliament which showed low public support for it, for example this YouGov one: https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/plh4depnh8/TimesScottGender221209.pdf

LexMitior · 17/01/2023 09:22

There is a degree of real confusion about what that Scottish Government can do. They certainly don't have the power to do this - all the power it has ever had can be taken away by Westminster. All of them.

This has always been the case. Devolved government only has the power given to it. If it treads on a reserved matter like the Equality Act, then that law will be invalid.

There is no precedent. Just the constitution of the UK and it's law.

Mirabai · 17/01/2023 09:14

Flapjackquack · 17/01/2023 08:49

I think Sturgeon is sincerely supportive of anything that will boost her chances at the next referendum. I am not anti Scotland leaving the union, I just think Sturgeon is someone who will do absolutely anything to be the person who took Scotland out of the Union like BJ and Brexit.

And this is likely to fuck that up. I think she genuinely thought it was the right progressive move to appeal to the younger population, but she misread women on this - failed to heed women’s opposition.

scratchedbymycat · 17/01/2023 09:10

@Sorefootouch

The Scottish Greens are batshit bonkers, which is criminal considering the climate emergency we are currently facing.

My husband announced he was going to vote Green and it provoked a row of massive proportions. I couldn't believe he'd throw my daughter and I under the bus like that. I told him it would be like supporting an apartheid party if the two of us were black. He hadn't even thought about it at all.

I really hope the Westminster involvement shines a light on who these parties are and how far they'll go to achieve things.

In the end, DH decided that the environment was such a pressing issue it rendered the need for a ' Green Party ' obsolete - ironically. Environment was now mainstream politics too. I wonder if this might be why the Green Party are scrabbling around in different issue areas.

Sorefootouch · 17/01/2023 09:00

scratchedbymycat · 17/01/2023 08:50

I think everything the SNP do has one eye on how it can rule Westminster. But if this was its sole intention - as you suggest - then women and children are pawns / collateral damage . And that's despicable and unforgivable.

Further, the SNP have a track record for ill conceived laws that are harmful to women and children - the named person, hate crime stand out .

Are you suggesting that if we vote for Independence, that all this will melt away and we'll have a wonderful country with good laws? That this isn't the real SNP?

Or is it possible that if we vote for Independence our lives will be in the hands of people who impose bad controlling laws on its populace?

Sometimes the simplest answer is the most obvious one. I think the SNP did this because they did a deal with the greens. I think it's populate among many of the SNP MSPs as well. I think they thought it would look progressive and modern and edgy and appeal to the youth. And above all, I think they thought they could impose it on dissenters because they believe they can get away with absolutely anything because they have a core group who only care about 'independence'.

You seem nice, but supporters like you are part of the problem here. It's Trump's 5th Avenue analogy. And that is utterly terrifying for the rest of us.

100% agree. The only reason they raised this was to appear edgy and it would please the Green Party who they are coalition with.

The Scottish Greens are batshit bonkers, which is criminal considering the climate emergency we are currently facing.

HermioneWeasley · 17/01/2023 08:57

@RosaCaramella what are your thoughts on the serial rapist demanding a move to a women’s prison because he meets the new GRR criteria?

are the women in prison protected by having a single sex space or not?

scratchedbymycat · 17/01/2023 08:56

I’m certain that violent, aggressive men don’t need to pretend to be women to do so

@RosaCaramella: Explain to me why we have sex-segregated spaces at all then? Why not dispense with them all together?