Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gender recognition reform blocked

233 replies

hadntbeen · 16/01/2023 22:29

Scottish Secretary Alister Jack has made an order under section 35 of the Scotland Act 1998, preventing the Scottish Parliament’s Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill from proceeding to Royal Assent.
Thank god 🙏🏻 I am an SNP supporter but this is one bill I was wholeheartedly against. I'm glad and relieved this decision was made.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
bellinisurge · 17/01/2023 13:41

The GRR Bill would change the operation of a UK law. Last time I checked, I didn't get to vote for a Scottish MSP - what with not living there. They have no right to mess with a reserved issue. Equality is a reserved issue.
Regardless of what I think about GRR Bill, it affects Uk law.
So the government was right to refuse to put it forward for consent

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 17/01/2023 13:38

GreenEmeraldSea · 16/01/2023 23:02

Oh God, the old "trans people are evil people with nefarious purposes in mind" trope.

@GreenEmeraldSea See, this just proves you don't get it. It's about MEN. Not 'trans people'.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 17/01/2023 13:36

GreenEmeraldSea · 16/01/2023 22:34

Mumsnet and its pathological hate of trans people...........but the SNP are lovely and magical ..........

Also - wear masks everyone!

Yes, advocating for womens safety is 'hating trans people'. Wow. You really are brainwashed.

OneTC · 17/01/2023 13:29

I fully support equal rights for trans people. They should have proportional provision, they should have sporting category provided, they should not fear discrimination and have legal protections, just like everyone else. Trans should be a proud status, not something people are so ashamed to be that they have to pretend to be of a different genetic makeup

StellaAndCrow · 17/01/2023 13:25

Thank you to all the posters with info about suicide statistics, confirms what I was thinking - that there are a lot of groups at risk of suicide e.g. care leavers, the elderly, disabled, people with chronic pain, people with ASD, eating disorders, as well as people who are trans or have gender dysphoria.

I haven't seen anything to suggest that getting a GRC reduces suicide risk. I have seen stats that surgical and hormonal transition doesn't reduce suicide risk.

And there does seem to be a crossover between trans and some personality disorders, which also have increased suicide risk (e.g. emotionally unstable personality disorder, previously known as borderline PD)

Abitofalark · 17/01/2023 13:22

StuntNun · 17/01/2023 09:26

Does anyone know why Alister Jack's statement only mentions Great Britain? What is the equivalent of the Equality Act in Northern Ireland that means they wouldn't be affected by the GRR?

Northern Ireland operates under the Northern Ireland Act 1998, implementing the Belfast Agreement. Discrimination and equality are devolved ('transferred') matters, not reserved to the UK government as they are in Great Britain. NI is responsible for its own legislation on equality and has its own separate Equality Commission for Northern Ireland (ECNI). The EHRC is GB only. The Equality Act is mostly a GB Act.

StellaAndCrow · 17/01/2023 13:20

It would be fine if it was about Transwomen people being more easily recognised/protected AS TRANSWOMEN - but it's not, it's about transwomen (men) being recognised as women.

Mirabai · 17/01/2023 13:18

Quite. There’s co-morbidity with ASD and anorexia for example - and anorexia has the highest suicide rate for all mental illness.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 17/01/2023 13:10

Thanks @Beancounter1

@RosaCaramella I did not mean to accuse you of spreading misinformation; I meant only that you had been misinformed if you thought that there was some super-high risk of suicide for trans young people.

Nowadays many trans young people belong to multiple high risk groups, also having other mental health issues which are not simply the effect of being trans. So these studies need to be taken carefully and not over interpreted to mean there is something unusually dangerous about being trans that overwhelms all other considerations. There isn't.

Brefugee · 17/01/2023 13:03

I think there are lots of groups who are at high risk for suicide, and as pp mentioned some of them (a lot?) are post OP trans people.

So the position shouldn't be "who can i deprive of help to serve these people?" but "how can we best use our resources to help as many as possible?" Every life is as valid as another, IMO.

So what we need is more therapy places, more therapists and overall more help. And in the meantime? we have to triage and some people miss out. It is a tragic fact of our current situation.

Mirabai · 17/01/2023 12:59

It’s worth noting that trans are suicide risk post transition as well as pre.

scratchedbymycat · 17/01/2023 12:58

Brefugee · 17/01/2023 12:56

For the record there have been people on this thread disputing that trans youngsters are at high risk of self harm and suicide hence my reply with links.

to be fair they aren't. They are contesting your claim that they are the AT MOST risk.

This.

Beancounter1 · 17/01/2023 12:56

RosaCaramella · 17/01/2023 12:53

The evidence is there for people who care to see. I will not be drawn into making personal comments to individuals
who have a different view from me.

For the record there have been people on this thread disputing that trans youngsters are at high risk of self harm and suicide hence my reply with links.

I’m not interested in point scoring. Good day to you.

Nor am I interested in point-scoring. The issues are far, far too serious for that.

Matters of legislation and public policy are always best decided with lots of logic and clear thinking, unclouded by emotion.

scratchedbymycat · 17/01/2023 12:56

To evidence this you would need links to suicide risk statistics for ALL groups of people, including e.g. young straight men, pensioners in chronic pain, etc. etc.

... girls suffering from anorexia, ASD children, those suffering from depression, survivors of child sexual abuse, bullying etc etc

Brefugee · 17/01/2023 12:56

For the record there have been people on this thread disputing that trans youngsters are at high risk of self harm and suicide hence my reply with links.

to be fair they aren't. They are contesting your claim that they are the AT MOST risk.

Brefugee · 17/01/2023 12:55

but the evidence isn't - all people are asking for are good reliable statistics.

You seem concerned about trans teens, and that is good. Someone needs to be concerned about them beyond just "living your best life, have a mastectomy" affirmation, but serious good therapy and support in their transition.

But you have zero compassion for anyone else. There are many many more women who are going to be affected by this than the trans teens. Because there are many more women to start with. So have some compassion for all and don't blindly follow a badly thought out, bill. Do some critical and logical thinking

RosaCaramella · 17/01/2023 12:53

Beancounter1 · 17/01/2023 12:47

@RosaCaramella Your links are all about the risks of trans YP taking their own lives. It is not in dispute that this group of people are at high risk.

The questions is: are trans YP "one of the highest groups to take their own lives"? as you assert. To evidence this you would need links to suicide risk statistics for ALL groups of people, including e.g. young straight men, pensioners in chronic pain, etc. etc. Then we could see how trans YP compare to other groups and whether they are "one of the highest groups".

You need clearer thinking and better logic.

The evidence is there for people who care to see. I will not be drawn into making personal comments to individuals
who have a different view from me.

For the record there have been people on this thread disputing that trans youngsters are at high risk of self harm and suicide hence my reply with links.

I’m not interested in point scoring. Good day to you.

Brefugee · 17/01/2023 12:52

I don’t often post on controversial issues but as stated earlier, I’ve seen the devastation of mental health in trans people, young people in particular, due to not being accepted by society.

and the devastation and mental health issues caused to female victims of opportunist men who take advantage of this badly thought out legislation? don't matter right, especially if they are now self-excluding from therapy etc because they don't feature in the statistics.

Getting a GRC in 3 months does ZIP to help a currently frantic trans teen. What would help them is good therapy.

Beancounter1 · 17/01/2023 12:52

@RosaCaramella
"Is there evidence of people pretending to be trans and using the legislation to harm women and children in countries which already have gender self-id?"

Have a look at the 'It will never happen' thread.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/3348290-It-will-never-happen-resource-thread

Beancounter1 · 17/01/2023 12:47

RosaCaramella · 17/01/2023 12:07

@AmaryllisNightAndDay

especially young people who are one of the highest groups to take their own lives.

“Young people, perhaps, not especially due to being trans though. That's misinformation.”

Do not accuse me of spreading misinformation. Here are a tiny selection of examples of worldwide research on this topic. I would be interested to see your sources which refute this research.

committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/23299/pdf/

academic.oup.com/jpubhealth/advance-article/doi/10.1093/pubmed/fdab383/6444311

www.thetrevorproject.org/resources/article/facts-about-lgbtq-youth-suicide/

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32345113/

@RosaCaramella Your links are all about the risks of trans YP taking their own lives. It is not in dispute that this group of people are at high risk.

The questions is: are trans YP "one of the highest groups to take their own lives"? as you assert. To evidence this you would need links to suicide risk statistics for ALL groups of people, including e.g. young straight men, pensioners in chronic pain, etc. etc. Then we could see how trans YP compare to other groups and whether they are "one of the highest groups".

You need clearer thinking and better logic.

RosaCaramella · 17/01/2023 12:46

PoochPalace · 17/01/2023 12:14

@RosaCaramella

The legislation was for people living in Scotland so has nothing to do with the UK.

INCORRECT.

As a Scottish person living in Scotland with no intention of moving to England or Wales or Northern Ireland, this is my perspective on a piece of legislation brought about by the Scottish government which would have applied in Scotland only.

You do realise that people from other countries with different laws about many aspects of life and behaviour including gender identity self-Id visit England, Wales and Northern Ireland already? Is there evidence of any trans people amongst them causing harm to women and children either in rUK or in their own countries? Is there evidence of people pretending to be trans and using the legislation to harm women and children in countries which already have gender self-id? It is well known that the equality act of 2010 already includes provision for transgender people vis-a-vis the use of single sex changing rooms, toilets and prisons. The proposed GRR would not change that.

I don’t often post on controversial issues but as stated earlier, I’ve seen the devastation of mental health in trans people, young people in particular, due to not being accepted by society. For me, this legislation was about easing their burden. Many here seem to think my outlook naive but I have nothing but compassion for people who struggle with life and there doesn’t appear to be solid evidence backing people’s worst fears about this legislation.

I accept we all have our own views on this.

SirMingeALot · 17/01/2023 12:22

PoochPalace · 17/01/2023 12:14

@RosaCaramella

The legislation was for people living in Scotland so has nothing to do with the UK.

INCORRECT.

Yeah, this is just wrong. If a person has a particular view about the constitutional issues that's fair enough, but actually find out what they are first.

PoochPalace · 17/01/2023 12:14

@RosaCaramella

The legislation was for people living in Scotland so has nothing to do with the UK.

INCORRECT.

RosaCaramella · 17/01/2023 12:07

@AmaryllisNightAndDay

especially young people who are one of the highest groups to take their own lives.

“Young people, perhaps, not especially due to being trans though. That's misinformation.”

Do not accuse me of spreading misinformation. Here are a tiny selection of examples of worldwide research on this topic. I would be interested to see your sources which refute this research.

committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/23299/pdf/

academic.oup.com/jpubhealth/advance-article/doi/10.1093/pubmed/fdab383/6444311

www.thetrevorproject.org/resources/article/facts-about-lgbtq-youth-suicide/

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32345113/

SedatePixie · 17/01/2023 11:58

Rainbowshit · 17/01/2023 10:30

@clutchingatpearls I have serious doubts about Maggie Chapman's ability to make any connections between anything ever. She's absolutely off her head and needs to be well away from where adult decisions are being made.

Seconded! It is clear that Maggie Chapman is unable to connect any dots UNLESS it is to do with pushing her career and then she is well in front.

Scotland should think about Twat Self Recognition Certificates and begin by giving them to Chapman and Sturgeon. I

Although I think they both know that they are twats and don't care but a certificate would make it nice and legal for them. Then, whenever they open their mouths, they could brandish their TSRC in case anyone was in any doubt.