Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gender recognition reform blocked

233 replies

hadntbeen · 16/01/2023 22:29

Scottish Secretary Alister Jack has made an order under section 35 of the Scotland Act 1998, preventing the Scottish Parliament’s Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill from proceeding to Royal Assent.
Thank god 🙏🏻 I am an SNP supporter but this is one bill I was wholeheartedly against. I'm glad and relieved this decision was made.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Thon · 17/01/2023 19:47

@IWineAndDontDine if you’ve sobered up maybe you could share a link

radrado · 17/01/2023 18:53

“If” not “when” please God 🙏 @LexMitior as a Scot I am embarrassed at the calibre of some of our politicians.

LexMitior · 17/01/2023 18:43

@RosaCaramella - that is not the point. The point jd that legally, the rest of the UK do not have any obligation to engage with this law.
There is no world where I want the SNP to legislate for me. Once independent Scotland may have these laws if it wishes. On a constitutional basis right now they may not.

The fact that the SNP have got delusional supporters on this does not mean the law is right. Scotland is full of excellent lawyers - I've worked with them, but this is just pigswill politics. If that is the best Scotland has to offer its people then they will need all the luck in the world when independent.

OneTC · 17/01/2023 17:20

bellinisurge · 17/01/2023 13:42

@OneTC Do tell what rights trans people don't have. And, while you are at it, tell us more about this different genetic makeup

I didn't say that they don't have rights. I mean that in an equality for all kind of sense.

As I explained I think there should be proportional third space provision, there should be third categories in sports and honours. Keep women's spaces and competitions and honours for women. If trans people ain't happy using men's facilities or entering into competitions with born men then there should be provision that allows them to compete, in open categories, or in trans specific categories that doesn't fuck with anyone else.

The pretending to be what you're not comment was a shit joke about the inherent transphobia of being trans. I should have said chromosomal but it would still have been a shit joke

lifeturnsonadime · 17/01/2023 15:46

Good.

i also think that NS knew what she was doing, doesn't give a shit about the collateral damage to anyone, in order to force indyref 2.

VickyEadieofThigh · 17/01/2023 15:35

Beancounter1 · 17/01/2023 15:23

The EA is mostly sufficient, but it needs clarification that the word 'sex' means biological sex. There is a petition on this - does someone have the link to post here?

The GRC is a mess, because my understanding is that it conflates sex and gender, and gives people the mistaken impression that they can change sex. It also allows changing of the sex on the birth certificate which should not be permissable.
No-one should get a certificate saying they are the opposite sex, because that is a lie and an impossibility. No-one should need a certificate saying they are of any particular gender, because it doesn't matter. You don't need a gender certificate to change your appearance or pay for surgery.

Single sex exemptions under the EA may be enough (or all that can reasonably be done in this arena) to protect women - but they have to be genuinely single-biological-sex, nothing to do with gender.

And Stonewall, Mermaids and the like need telling to stop giving false information to organisations about single-sex provisions and services.

WifeMotherWorker · 17/01/2023 15:29

Good! The safety of women and girls should never be up for negotiation.

Beancounter1 · 17/01/2023 15:23

AthenaPopodopolous · 17/01/2023 14:48

Yeah Beancounter I understand. I think the existing Equalities Law and gender recognition law are already sufficient to safeguard women. Had a quick read last night but I don’t agree with the Scots gov reducing the age to 16 by I do agree with removing the need for a medical diagnosis.

Id like to hear more from non binary people though on their thoughts of any are on here.

The EA is mostly sufficient, but it needs clarification that the word 'sex' means biological sex. There is a petition on this - does someone have the link to post here?

The GRC is a mess, because my understanding is that it conflates sex and gender, and gives people the mistaken impression that they can change sex. It also allows changing of the sex on the birth certificate which should not be permissable.
No-one should get a certificate saying they are the opposite sex, because that is a lie and an impossibility. No-one should need a certificate saying they are of any particular gender, because it doesn't matter. You don't need a gender certificate to change your appearance or pay for surgery.

Single sex exemptions under the EA may be enough (or all that can reasonably be done in this arena) to protect women - but they have to be genuinely single-biological-sex, nothing to do with gender.

Abitofalark · 17/01/2023 15:10

Flapjackquack · 17/01/2023 09:30

@StuntNun - I think it’s covered in the Northern Ireland Act 1998 but don’t quote me on it. Odd it’s devolved in NI but not everywhere else, I guess due to the specific religious divisions present in NI and not as present in the rest of the UK.

I think you are right. It is the Northern Ireland Act 1998 plus regulations on various strands of discrimination, reflecting NI, UK/ GB and EU anti-discrimination law. Historically, NI law was separate long before devolution, constituted and operating under the Government of Ireland Act 1920 with its own parliament and judicial system. That was repealed by the Northern Ireland Act 1998 which set out NI's status and arrangements for government based on the Belfast Agreement. In that context, it isn't odd that it has its own tailored arrangements reflecting its special circumstances but perhaps one could call it an oddity within the UK.

Brefugee · 17/01/2023 15:06

as i understand it the EA2010 is what is in force and what applies legally. But, some organisations are jumping the gun and taking what is in the Scottish GRC bill as "best practice"?

So if, say, a man (looks like a man in jeans, t-shirt, beard, deep voice) goes into a ladies toilet and someone says "sorry, mate, the men's is over there" what should happen is "oh sorry" and off they go.

But what might happen is "I'm a woman, you can't say that to me transphobe transphobe help help" and some well meaning member of the public hauls in plod who either has words with or arrests the woman who pointed out the mistake. Under EA2010 simply saying "i am a trans woman" doesn't make you a woman under the law. You are still a man, but you are also a trans woman.

if I'm understanding the possible scenarios correctly, most people you ask "do you support TW using women's facilities" think it's someone who looks more like Edna Everage or Debbie Hayton, rather than some bloke who just walked in off a building site.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 17/01/2023 15:01

AthenaPopodopolous · 17/01/2023 14:48

Yeah Beancounter I understand. I think the existing Equalities Law and gender recognition law are already sufficient to safeguard women. Had a quick read last night but I don’t agree with the Scots gov reducing the age to 16 by I do agree with removing the need for a medical diagnosis.

Id like to hear more from non binary people though on their thoughts of any are on here.

Except the existing Equalities Law and gender recognition law clearly don't protect or safeguard women. The evidence of that is more than abundant.

HermioneKipper · 17/01/2023 14:56

I’m no fan of the tories but my god thank heavens there’s some adults at the table who can stop this utter madness.

Sturgeon and cronies are throwing women and children under the bus and for what exactly?

I have to agree, think they’re trying to stoke an anti English rhetoric so she can try and push independence through.

AthenaPopodopolous · 17/01/2023 14:48

Yeah Beancounter I understand. I think the existing Equalities Law and gender recognition law are already sufficient to safeguard women. Had a quick read last night but I don’t agree with the Scots gov reducing the age to 16 by I do agree with removing the need for a medical diagnosis.

Id like to hear more from non binary people though on their thoughts of any are on here.

Beancounter1 · 17/01/2023 14:39

AthenaPopodopolous · 17/01/2023 13:57

I was trying to show a comparison that trans and gay people were formerly criminalised or thought of as having a medical disorder in history. This new bill seeks to do away with non binary people having to get a mental health diagnosis, i,e gender dysphoria.
my point is that is helpful, it’s just their identity and why should they be labelled mentally ill?

I totally get the comparison and point you are trying to make - that what is considered a 'mental illness' changes over time. A century ago women were often considered to be mentally ill if they didn't conform to social expectations.

Perhaps 'being trans' is not a mental illness, just as 'being gay' is not. If an individual believes it is possible for them to change sex, perhaps they are just misinformed and ignorant, not mentally ill.

However, if we do away with the mental illness test, and the long wait, and the 'living as a woman' requirement, if we remove the barriers for the sake of compassion, and say that any trans person can get a GRC with ease - then what happens to women's safeguards? What will stop predatory and abusive men abusing the current GRC facility to enter women's spaces with impunity?

What needs to happen is that the fiction that changing gender = changing sex should be abolished.

I am not bothered about the 'identity' of any non-binary or trans person. I would be happy for anyone to be able to get a 'gender' certificate on demand, proclaiming themselves to be whatever - as long as the whole of society, and the individuals concerned, recognises that this did not change their biological sex. The sex on the birth certificate should not be changed. All relevant official documents for adults could included boxes for 'gender' (as well as sex where essential and relevant) - would that help?

But no-one can change sex. And sex matters. Especially to women.

sanluca · 17/01/2023 14:21

AthenaPopodopolous · 17/01/2023 13:57

I was trying to show a comparison that trans and gay people were formerly criminalised or thought of as having a medical disorder in history. This new bill seeks to do away with non binary people having to get a mental health diagnosis, i,e gender dysphoria.
my point is that is helpful, it’s just their identity and why should they be labelled mentally ill?

Why should your self proclaimed identity give you additional rights others of your class don't have?

And the 'trans is like gay' falls flat: gay people wanted the same rights as others, trans people want priviliges other people don't have.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 17/01/2023 14:08

Do we validate an anorexic girl's opinion that she is fat?

No. So why do we validate a mans belief that he's a woman?

And on the suicide note, any psychologist will tell you not to rise to the 'they will commit suicide' or 'I'll kill myself if you leave me' threat by men. It's emotional manipulation, and it's abusive and it shouldn't be something given in to.

Women are not human shields because a male in a dress will kill himself if he can't access womens change rooms.

JustHereWithMyPopcorn · 17/01/2023 14:07

I'm so pleased to hear this.

FrostyFifi · 17/01/2023 14:06

it’s just their identity and why should they be labelled mentally ill?

I'm all for people wearing what they want and living as they wish without a label of mental illness, certainly.
I draw the line when this includes seeking entry into single sex spaces belonging to the opposite sex.

If you're so distressed by your body thst you require surgeries on healthy body parts, cross-sex hormones and binders, or cannot cope with "misgendering"or anything other than total affirmation then yes you are mentally ill.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 17/01/2023 14:02

RosaCaramella · 17/01/2023 12:46

As a Scottish person living in Scotland with no intention of moving to England or Wales or Northern Ireland, this is my perspective on a piece of legislation brought about by the Scottish government which would have applied in Scotland only.

You do realise that people from other countries with different laws about many aspects of life and behaviour including gender identity self-Id visit England, Wales and Northern Ireland already? Is there evidence of any trans people amongst them causing harm to women and children either in rUK or in their own countries? Is there evidence of people pretending to be trans and using the legislation to harm women and children in countries which already have gender self-id? It is well known that the equality act of 2010 already includes provision for transgender people vis-a-vis the use of single sex changing rooms, toilets and prisons. The proposed GRR would not change that.

I don’t often post on controversial issues but as stated earlier, I’ve seen the devastation of mental health in trans people, young people in particular, due to not being accepted by society. For me, this legislation was about easing their burden. Many here seem to think my outlook naive but I have nothing but compassion for people who struggle with life and there doesn’t appear to be solid evidence backing people’s worst fears about this legislation.

I accept we all have our own views on this.

Is there evidence of any trans people amongst them causing harm to women and children either in rUK or in their own countries? Is there evidence of people pretending to be trans and using the legislation to harm women and children in countries which already have gender self-id?

Yes, there is. Evidence shows trans women offend at a HIGHER RATE than natal males:
fairplayforwomen.com/criminality/
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/seven-sex-attacks-in-womens-jails-by-transgender-convicts-cx9m8zqpg
committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/18973/pdf/
fairplayforwomen.com/unisex-changing-rooms-put-women-in-danger/
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/unisex-changing-rooms-put-women-in-danger-8lwbp8kgk

As to the lies about suicide; trans people have less suicides but perform more offences than natal men. They retain Male Privilege and are the most protected and privileged group in society:
www.transgendertrend.com/the-suicide-myth/
thecritic.co.uk/neither-marginalised-abused-nor-vulnerable/

If trans women are at risk, that is MENS problem to solve. Not womens. Women are not HUMAN SHIELDS for trans women.

AthenaPopodopolous · 17/01/2023 13:57

I was trying to show a comparison that trans and gay people were formerly criminalised or thought of as having a medical disorder in history. This new bill seeks to do away with non binary people having to get a mental health diagnosis, i,e gender dysphoria.
my point is that is helpful, it’s just their identity and why should they be labelled mentally ill?

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 17/01/2023 13:51

AthenaPopodopolous · 17/01/2023 01:08

I think the point of the law was to reduce trauma to trans people as they’d have to be diagnosed with gender dysphasia first.
Effectively being diagnosed with a mental health condition before being allowed by medics to transition…
Gays were labelled mentally Ill in the DSM (psychiatric diagnostic medical manual) as mentally I’ll years ago until the law and medics overturned that.

@AthenaPopodopolous What about the trauma to women? Of having a person with a penis and testicles (which is what self-ID allows) in our spaces? What about WOMENS TRAUMA? Why don't we matter?

The gay analogy is a weak and offensive strawman. Gay people weren't seeking to take any rights away from women. Gay men still use mens facilities. Lesbian women still use womens facilities. They weren't advocating for taking rights away from a group.

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 17/01/2023 13:48

RosaCaramella · 17/01/2023 00:18

As I understand it, the new birth certificate obtained through self ID would give legal proof of gender identity for the people who need it for various official purposes.

There is nothing to stop predatory / dangerous males from passing themselves off as females right now and going into female only spaces. Having been attacked and threatened by males 19 times by the age of 20, I’m certain that violent, aggressive men don’t need to pretend to be women to do so.

The old 'they already do it anyway' trope. Same as 'well they'll take heroine anyway, take crystal meth anyway, murder anyway, so lets decriminalise heroin, meth, murder. In fact lets have no laws.' This, breaks down the social construct and contract that shamed men into staying out of our spaces. This breaks that taboo, and enables it. It gives public acceptance to something that was taboo.

bellinisurge · 17/01/2023 13:47

Does the Carrick care mean all policemen are rapists? No. Does the Katie Dolatowski case mean all transwomen are paedophiles? No. Both cases show you need fully operational safeguarding. Because predators like Carrick and Dolatowski will exploit your good will in order to abuse. Remove the safeguards or lower the safeguarding standards (which the GRR Bill does) and you create opportunities for predators.
How is this difficult?

IAmWomanHearMeRoar1 · 17/01/2023 13:43

RosaCaramella · 16/01/2023 23:27

How many people who express an opinion (judgement) on this actually know any trans people? The legislation was brought about to lessen the terrible toll that trying to be accepted for who they are takes on trans people - especially young people who are one of the highest groups to take their own lives.
I don’t get the argument that girls and women are at risk from trans women. From the news today, women and girls are at much more risk from policeman. And men in general! Trans people are a tiny minority who just want the same right to live their lives as their own selves.
Just don’t get the negative attitude. And no I’m not trans but have seen the devastation that public attitudes and the lack of acceptance have on some trans people.
The legislation was for people living in Scotland so has nothing to do with the rUK. No one asked me my opinion on the bill and it wasn’t discussed widely in the press or on social media as far as I am aware so I would also question the assertions that the Scottish public didn’t want the bill.
Where’s the empathy and compassion for this tiny minority of people?

@RosaCaramella Then you clearly haven't thought it through. There is no toll on trans people. Evidence shows they are the safest and most privileged group there is. WOMEN are the most vulnerable group.

You talk about policeMEN, but forget that trans women are..... MEN. 97% of trans women retain their penis and testicles. So, you are advocating, for MEN, these MEN, to enter womens spaces.

Where is your empathy and compassion for WOMEN???

Btw, you might like to become informed: www.transgendertrend.com/the-suicide-myth/
thecritic.co.uk/neither-marginalised-abused-nor-vulnerable/
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/unisex-changing-rooms-put-women-in-danger-8lwbp8kgk

bellinisurge · 17/01/2023 13:42

@OneTC Do tell what rights trans people don't have. And, while you are at it, tell us more about this different genetic makeup