Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gender recognition reform blocked

233 replies

hadntbeen · 16/01/2023 22:29

Scottish Secretary Alister Jack has made an order under section 35 of the Scotland Act 1998, preventing the Scottish Parliament’s Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill from proceeding to Royal Assent.
Thank god 🙏🏻 I am an SNP supporter but this is one bill I was wholeheartedly against. I'm glad and relieved this decision was made.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
DownNative · 18/01/2023 11:20

Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland Acts simply states the Westminster Parliament will not normally legislate on devolved issues.

There is NO barrier to them doing so.

To make it worse, most of the SNP MPs voted for Westminster to legislate for abortion in Northern Ireland not too long ago. This behaviour demonstrates the SNP knows its perfectly legal AND democratic for Westminster to step in on any issue in Stormont, Cardiff Bay and.....yes, Holyrood!

Yet they're trying to manipulate the Scottish electorate into thinking it's some kind of democratic outrage. It's not whatsoever!

SNP MP Lisa Cameron feared deselection as she voted against om the basis of hypocrisy and was trolled by SNP Cybernats.

SNP = "Do as I SAY and not as I DO!" 🤥

Brefugee · 18/01/2023 11:18

And Northern Ireland since the UK is made up of four regions.
Not three!

Northern Ireland is different which is why i left it out. Although in the case of abortion law, as i remember, they had to be forced to accept that Westminster could overrule them.

I think that devolved parliaments will only work if they are all on the same footing, so that NI isn't different. I also think that for the sake of understanding the separation of Westminster from Holyrood and the others, there really ought to be an English parliament too. To make it very clear that Westminster does not equal England. And I'd want it in Sheffield (or at least not London) because it's fairly central.

Oopsies · 18/01/2023 11:16

Even Alba?

JanesLittleGirl · 18/01/2023 11:14

maddy68 · 18/01/2023 10:06

Regardless of whether you think this bill should or should not go ahead. It is totally outrageous that the English government have overruled the Scottish parliament.

Ever strengthening the need for independence

There isn't an English government. There is a UK government that comprises MPs representing all parts of the UK.

DownNative · 18/01/2023 11:12

Brefugee · 18/01/2023 10:08

Regardless of whether you think this bill should or should not go ahead. It is totally outrageous that the English government have overruled the Scottish parliament.

no it isn't. It was an obvious decision based on the fact that this legislation will affect England and Wales too.

In Scotland people rightly rail against legislation made in Westminster that covers things in Scotland, and have taken steps (devolved government) to avoid that. England and Wales deserve and must have the same courtesy.

And Northern Ireland since the UK is made up of four regions.

Not three!

Also, Westminster can step in at any time on any issue they see fit because it is only Westminster that is the Supreme Legislator in the UK.

Holyrood, Stormont and Cardiff Bay were never understood by anyone to be of equal status to Westminster. After all, the UK is a unitary sovereign state which has the same position as Germany. I.E. their respective regions and states are not sovereign or, to quote Germany's highest court, "are not masters of the constitution".

SNP refuse to essentially accept this basis of international law in their attempted mission creep. 🤷‍♂️

DownNative · 18/01/2023 11:04

For the very hard of thinking.....🤔

On this issue, democracy IS working as set out in Constitutional Law. No amount of gnashing of teeth or stamping of feet by Scottish Nationalists will change that. By now, we all know how they will distort the actual Constitutional Law to suit themselves. They do a 🤥 often enough to spot them.

Gender recognition reform blocked
Gender recognition reform blocked
Gender recognition reform blocked
DownNative · 18/01/2023 11:00

maddy68 · 18/01/2023 10:06

Regardless of whether you think this bill should or should not go ahead. It is totally outrageous that the English government have overruled the Scottish parliament.

Ever strengthening the need for independence

Willfully and blatantly ignoring the reality of the UK Constitution right there! Even the Scottish Parliament website states that most aspects of the Equality Act is outwith their powers.

SNP push for IndyRef2 slapped down by Supreme Court as beyond their powers.

SNP Named Persons Scheme slapped down by Supreme Court as it was ruled illegal in the form the SNP wanted.

And now this piece of legislation.

It's clear the SNP exist to create confrontation with OUR central government and central Parliament in their push for IndyRef2. SNP clearly do not genuinely care about trans issues as it's a means to an end to create confrontation they hope will lead to IndyRef2.

It won't. The electorate do NOT like the SNP or Holyrood attempting to act illegally and beyond their prescribed powers as they voted for very LIMITED local government in 1998.

@maddy68 you should be ashamed of yourself for trying to portray this as an English v Scottish issue. It patently is NOT.

I'll say it again, Westminster is a BRITISH Parliament and the UK Government is a British Government.

Simple as that.

Brefugee · 18/01/2023 10:55

I have no preference over wether or not Scotland remains part of the union. I'm not Scottish and i don't live in Scotland (or indeed the UK) and I'm merely interested in that I'm British and i live in a federal state with some similar kinds of issues. (Germany)

There will always be issues over the areas of responsiblity (for want of a better phrase) and tensions between the state itself and the different federated states/countries. The German constitution is very clear on which issues a state makes decisions (which only affect that state) such as Education, and other areas in which the state makes decisions (defence, for eg). Our constitution enshrines that (helpfully a written constitution) and has been in operation longer than the devolved parliaments in the UK.

Scottish devolution is enshrined in an act, which is a kind of constitution also outlines exactly what the areas of responsibility are. It is indeed possible that this document needs tweaking, we will see.
But in principle, anything that affects anything outside Scottish borders, is not for them to decide alone. I'm sure there may be outliers and exceptions.

So it is probably about time one thing was challenged, to see how robust the systems and regulations are.

Dotjones · 18/01/2023 10:38

I think the fact that it's taken 25 years for Westminster to veto a Scottish law shows that the system works well. The point of the veto is to prevent the Scottish parliament passing laws over things that are reserved for Westminster and it never having been used until now shows it's unusual for it to be an issue.

That said I'm certain the SNP are currently working out other legislation they can pass that the UK government will also veto because they can use this as a weapon.

FWIW I was pleased Scotland voted to remain in 2014 but it's clear now that it's just a matter of time so they might as well just go independent and be done with it. It'll be interesting/funny seeing them struggle once their UK funds are cut off and how they pay their "divorce bill" to the rest of the UK. Ideally I'd like to see the funds used to build a fucking massive wall along the border and a big army presence to prevent border crossings after independence a bit like they have in Korea.

MingeofDeath · 18/01/2023 10:18

@RosaCaramella

"I’ve seen the devastation of mental health in trans people, young people in particular, due to not being accepted by society."

It's not on the rest of us to affirm someone's identity issues. If a person's mental health is affected by society's perception of them then they need psychological help.

FOJN · 18/01/2023 10:14

We’d also need some way to measure if someone is ‘genuine trans’, but the trans umbrella is so wide that is impossible.

This is the problem with self ID, there is no way to check if someone is "genuine trans" if the only verification required is their say so. Under self ID if you say you are trans, you are.

It also renders the penalties for making a false declaration utterly meaningless. How can you prove someone made a false declaration if the law hasn't defined what "living in your acquired gender" means and all you had to do to obtain a GRC was to say, "I'm trans".

Brefugee · 18/01/2023 10:08

Regardless of whether you think this bill should or should not go ahead. It is totally outrageous that the English government have overruled the Scottish parliament.

no it isn't. It was an obvious decision based on the fact that this legislation will affect England and Wales too.

In Scotland people rightly rail against legislation made in Westminster that covers things in Scotland, and have taken steps (devolved government) to avoid that. England and Wales deserve and must have the same courtesy.

Brefugee · 18/01/2023 10:07

agree, it is a big hot mess that really only benefits the people taking advantage of legislation/modern thinking for nefarious purposes.

But the trans lobby (MRA lobby) have made it so that if you question or comment on one small thing done by one of these folk - you're instantly a terf and perpetrating trans genocide (sigh)

I don't know the answer outside of all forms for recording anything must have space for: biological sex (sex observed at birth) and also Gender.

maddy68 · 18/01/2023 10:06

Regardless of whether you think this bill should or should not go ahead. It is totally outrageous that the English government have overruled the Scottish parliament.

Ever strengthening the need for independence

DontAskIDontKnow · 18/01/2023 10:04

Brefugee · 18/01/2023 07:36

If transwomen aren't more likely to be sex offenders then how do we explain this? Most people I've discussed it with think that self ID presents an attractive loophole for sexual predators who would like to serve their prison time in the female prison estate. I can't see how allowing this is helpful to transpeople in anyway.

that is the same point though. they "identify as transwomen" because that makes it seem as though being trans is the issue. But they aren't and it isn't. They aren't transwomen, they are sexual predators using current thinking/legieslation to get access to vulnerable targets (women).

I don't believe they are genuinely trans, they are sexual predators. But, of course, there is no way of knowing since we must "affirm"

We’d also need some way to measure if someone is ‘genuine trans’, but the trans umbrella is so wide that is impossible.

It seems most people who call us transphobes think there is a genuine trans, and that in that state it is impossible to be a sex offender. When the trans umbrella includes people who cross-dress for erotic purposes (i.e. fetish) it is extraordinarily unlikely that you won’t get a sex offender in there.

DownNative · 18/01/2023 09:31

The facts regarding the legality and democracy of the UK Government blocking this particular Holyrood legislation.

Gender recognition reform blocked
Gender recognition reform blocked
Gender recognition reform blocked
HaroldeVwilliam · 18/01/2023 07:40

Good

Brefugee · 18/01/2023 07:36

If transwomen aren't more likely to be sex offenders then how do we explain this? Most people I've discussed it with think that self ID presents an attractive loophole for sexual predators who would like to serve their prison time in the female prison estate. I can't see how allowing this is helpful to transpeople in anyway.

that is the same point though. they "identify as transwomen" because that makes it seem as though being trans is the issue. But they aren't and it isn't. They aren't transwomen, they are sexual predators using current thinking/legieslation to get access to vulnerable targets (women).

I don't believe they are genuinely trans, they are sexual predators. But, of course, there is no way of knowing since we must "affirm"

FOJN · 17/01/2023 21:44

Cronkywonkycrinkywinky · 17/01/2023 21:32

EGS, you have misunderstood Fojn.

She's not saying that trans people are nefarious, she's saying that this well-meaning but badly-thought-out rule would have been open to exploitation by non-trans nefarious bastards

Thanks Cronky but this willful misrepresentation of the points made is fairly common. I've witnessed an MP in the HoP do exactly the same thing today.

Some clever bugger has crunched the numbers from the UK census with prison stats from the MOJ and found that:

1 in 585 males who identify as transwomen are convicted sex offenders
vs
1 in 2500-3000 men who are convicted sex offenders

If transwomen aren't more likely to be sex offenders then how do we explain this? Most people I've discussed it with think that self ID presents an attractive loophole for sexual predators who would like to serve their prison time in the female prison estate. I can't see how allowing this is helpful to transpeople in anyway.

You have to wonder why someone would try to shut down this conversation when it's so obvious self ID is open to abuse and is already being exploited even though it is not UK law. Are these people who are well aware of the risks but are determined not to be deprived of that loophole to use for themselves?

Cronkywonkycrinkywinky · 17/01/2023 21:32

GreenEmeraldSea · 16/01/2023 23:02

Oh God, the old "trans people are evil people with nefarious purposes in mind" trope.

EGS, you have misunderstood Fojn.

She's not saying that trans people are nefarious, she's saying that this well-meaning but badly-thought-out rule would have been open to exploitation by non-trans nefarious bastards

VinoDino · 17/01/2023 21:21

Seriously? Are you that narrow minded you can't acknowledge there's plenty of transphobia on this site? Amongst some of the reasonable arguments for sure. But it's clearly there. If you are so caught up in your opinions you can't see when it goes to far then that's on you

Post the examples of transphobia. Since there's plenty...

Mirabai · 17/01/2023 21:18

Clear according to who?

IWineAndDontDine · 17/01/2023 20:32

Thon · 17/01/2023 19:47

@IWineAndDontDine if you’ve sobered up maybe you could share a link

Seriously? Are you that narrow minded you can't acknowledge there's plenty of transphobia on this site? Amongst some of the reasonable arguments for sure. But it's clearly there. If you are so caught up in your opinions you can't see when it goes to far then that's on you

Sparklybanana · 17/01/2023 20:06

You can always tell what Sturgeon is thinking because she levels the same arguments against Westminster. They are using this as a political football apparently, even though its clear this exactly the sort of bill she's desperate to push - purely because Westminster has to act, despite it being against the "will of the Scottish people" (but phrased differently as she knows full well its not true on this). It's actually despicable that she's using such a highly contentious/dangerous bill to push through her independence agenda at the expense of women and the trans community who are all just pawns in her fantasy.

ChristinaXYZ · 17/01/2023 20:03

BuwchGochGota · 16/01/2023 22:39

Regardless of anyone's views on trans issues, I think it sets a dangerous precedent that Westminster can overrule the devolved governments.

How? Section 35 is part of a law passed under the Labour Scottish Secretary Donald Dewar, and actually voted for by the SNP. Never been used before in all this time.

Some matters are devolved, some are not. It is fair enough that if the Scottish parliament has passed a law that strays beyond its remit that the UK government should block it. Otherwise everyone else in the UK is subject to laws passed by a Scottish parliament that only Scots get to vote for. How undemocratic is that? How wrong constitutionally is that?

Everyone and anyone has begged the SNP to think again about this including the EHRC. The UK government would be highly irresponsible to let this legislation through when there are constitutional problems with it. Letting this legislation through is the only thing that would be a 'dangerous precedent'.

This is all done thorough a UK parliament where Scots get to vote for their MPs same as the rest of us, and that Scots less than 10 years ago voted to remain part of. This is just democracy working not a "dangerous precedent" ffs.