Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gender recognition reform blocked

233 replies

hadntbeen · 16/01/2023 22:29

Scottish Secretary Alister Jack has made an order under section 35 of the Scotland Act 1998, preventing the Scottish Parliament’s Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill from proceeding to Royal Assent.
Thank god 🙏🏻 I am an SNP supporter but this is one bill I was wholeheartedly against. I'm glad and relieved this decision was made.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
LexMitior · 18/01/2023 14:37

@maddy68 - you are a copper bottomed idiot. If you want to be an independent Scot you've got to be cleverer than that

smileladiesplease · 18/01/2023 14:36

James o Brian is an Incredibly rich little tit mouse who is clearly afraid of strong women. He's on a par with Sadiq khan the equally useless mayor.

bellinisurge · 18/01/2023 13:56

It's not the English government. Don't be childish. Or ignorant. Doesn't help your position.

ArabellaScott · 18/01/2023 13:48

Regardless of whether you think this bill should or should not go ahead. It is totally outrageous that the English government have overruled the Scottish parliament.

The problem was the Scottish Government attempting to overrule the UK government.

And of course, the UK government is democratically elected by the whole of the UK, including Scottish people. It's not the 'English government'.

Thelnebriati · 18/01/2023 13:38

Regardless of whether you think this bill should or should not go ahead. It is totally outrageous that the English government have overruled the Scottish parliament.

Its outrageous that the Scottish government thought they could introduce such a damaging piece of legislation and expect to not be overruled, especially since it would affect us in England was well.
Its almost as if they knew it would be overruled and went ahead anyway, just so they could complain about how badly they are being treated. The SNP have treated people as political footballs. They should know better than to play fast and loose with human rights, it never ends well.

Helleofabore · 18/01/2023 13:30

It was a rather enlightening interview that Starmer gave on Sunday and I think anyone who has a superficial grasp of this issue would not have probably noticed.

Starmer, a Human rights barrister, was saying there is an issue with the EA and this proposed Scottish law.

It really cannot be clearer.

Just typing the words 'this will not impact the EA' on the first page of a document, doesn't mean that it will not impact the EA. It is remarkable how far society has come that people actually believe that just saying something over and over means that it is material reality.

I noticed yesterday many MPs holding up the briefing document and repeating the words 'flimsy'? The hypocrisy was rather staggering actually.

PoochPalace · 18/01/2023 13:17

maddy68 · 18/01/2023 10:06

Regardless of whether you think this bill should or should not go ahead. It is totally outrageous that the English government have overruled the Scottish parliament.

Ever strengthening the need for independence

It is the only time Westminster have used article 35 or whatever number it is and is because Nicola Sturgeon has attempted to enact something in law that affects the rest of the UK - without consultation with the rest of the UK.

Thon · 18/01/2023 13:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It’s incredibly boring to throw words like ‘transphobic’ and ‘bigot’ about when you have no idea what you're talking about. You can’t don’t provide any examples to back up this claim.

You just said you agreed with me then backtrack and say if I fail to see transphobic comments on MN then ergo I am transphobic and a bigot🤣

Take yourself off mate.

Beowulfa · 18/01/2023 13:11

TheaBrandt · 18/01/2023 13:02

What I have found chilling and depressing over the last few days is the disdain disgust and anger directed at women who dare to push back about men in women’s spaces. A red headed male mp and James o Brian both scoffing and incredulous about women voicing their fears about sharing enclosed spaces where they are undressing with men. No respect at all.

Acknowledging that women and girls would like some male-free spaces means acknowledging that males are potentially dangerous. A lot of men really don't like to hear this. I think it offends the beardy woke bros' socially liberal ideals to be classed like this.

Funnily enough, I don't get offended by having to be DBS checked for a volunteering commitment with vulnerable adults and children.

TheaBrandt · 18/01/2023 13:02

What I have found chilling and depressing over the last few days is the disdain disgust and anger directed at women who dare to push back about men in women’s spaces. A red headed male mp and James o Brian both scoffing and incredulous about women voicing their fears about sharing enclosed spaces where they are undressing with men. No respect at all.

FrostyFifi · 18/01/2023 13:01

I think if you're going to call someone a bigot, which is arguably personal abuse and against site rules, you need to be able to back that up with some evidence.

IWineAndDontDine · 18/01/2023 13:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Cam22 · 18/01/2023 12:49

Good. This tail wagging the dog nonsense has to be stopped.

Brefugee · 18/01/2023 12:14

I'm not going against the GFA, but we were talking about Scotland and I'm not going into the rest of the UK on this conversation about this one instance of the Westminster government challenging the Scottish parliament.

RichardBarrister · 18/01/2023 11:53

Nicolas ‘triumphant outrage’ face on tv last night suggests that she has achieved her aim. She has settled on the trans issue knowing its conflict with the outcome of the public consultation done by the WESC (despite the best efforts of Caroline Nokes to push through self id here).

I don’t believe she genuinely cares about the lives of trans people and they have just become handy leverage.

I’d be very interested to know the answer to Douglas Ross’s question about why it had to be pushed through in an unprecedented manner before Christmas. They argue that the legislation was years in the making but even so, the final stages were rushed through at a gallop. The significant number of amendments reflected the lack of consensus on the law - never a good thing.

They still haven’t defined basic but key terms either. I think at one point Shona Robison refused to answer a question for a key definition and essentially said that they courts would deal with it. How can the courts deal with it if the law isn’t defined?

DownNative · 18/01/2023 11:48

And Holyrood is a Parliament. Not an Assembly . 🤷‍♂️

DownNative · 18/01/2023 11:47

Brefugee · 18/01/2023 11:42

Then you're in breach of the Belfast Agreement aka Good Friday Agreement which states that Northern Ireland is an INTEGRAL part of the UK.

at the risk of derailing: that's not the point i was trying to make. The situation of the NI assembly isn't (afaik) the same as the Scottish Assembly. And we're talking about Scotland.

I am well (and painfully aware) of what the Good Friday Agreement does.

  1. you're trying to create an unnecessary distinction between the four different regions of the UK in the context of devolution. It doesn't fly since all parts are integral - it's literally not a United Kingdom without them all.

  2. this thread isn't just about Scotland. It's also about the rest of the UK, hence the UK Government stepping in to block the Holyrood GRR bill.

Brefugee · 18/01/2023 11:42

Then you're in breach of the Belfast Agreement aka Good Friday Agreement which states that Northern Ireland is an INTEGRAL part of the UK.

at the risk of derailing: that's not the point i was trying to make. The situation of the NI assembly isn't (afaik) the same as the Scottish Assembly. And we're talking about Scotland.

I am well (and painfully aware) of what the Good Friday Agreement does.

Thon · 18/01/2023 11:41

IWineAndDontDine · 17/01/2023 20:32

Seriously? Are you that narrow minded you can't acknowledge there's plenty of transphobia on this site? Amongst some of the reasonable arguments for sure. But it's clearly there. If you are so caught up in your opinions you can't see when it goes to far then that's on you

There is no “pathological hatred” to use your words. And I would also argue there is no “transphobia”. That may be your own narrow perception of what a group of women who want to protect single-sex spaces believe, but I have news for you. You are wrong.

This is about safeguarding and the protection of long fought for sex-based rights. Protecting the rights of women and girls is not “pathological hatred” or “transphobia”.

I feel sorry for you that you can’t see that through your Transblinkers

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 18/01/2023 11:35

Is she being really really sly here?

From the interviews she's done she seems to have completely thrown her weight behind it so I don't know how she could completely change her mind if she did win an IndyRef. I could even see it being used by people opposing an independent Scotland. I think she's playing quite a dangerous game .

talkingmorenonsense · 18/01/2023 11:30

GreenEmeraldSea · 16/01/2023 22:34

Mumsnet and its pathological hate of trans people...........but the SNP are lovely and magical ..........

Also - wear masks everyone!

Gender dysphoria is very complicated and affects many in different ways. Most posters on Mumsnet have concerns with the rights of women to have have safe places. The two things are separate.

DownNative · 18/01/2023 11:29

Brefugee · 18/01/2023 11:18

And Northern Ireland since the UK is made up of four regions.
Not three!

Northern Ireland is different which is why i left it out. Although in the case of abortion law, as i remember, they had to be forced to accept that Westminster could overrule them.

I think that devolved parliaments will only work if they are all on the same footing, so that NI isn't different. I also think that for the sake of understanding the separation of Westminster from Holyrood and the others, there really ought to be an English parliament too. To make it very clear that Westminster does not equal England. And I'd want it in Sheffield (or at least not London) because it's fairly central.

Then you're in breach of the Belfast Agreement aka Good Friday Agreement which states that Northern Ireland is an INTEGRAL part of the UK.

In the context of devolution, Northern Ireland's Assembly is not especially different. Indeed, Northern Ireland was the first devolution experiment in the UK and for its first 50 years you could argue it was different.

Now? Not so as devolution is in two other parts with almost the same rules.

The other devolved administration in the UK is....London.

But every piece of devolved administration and legislation has ALWAYS been subject to Westminster. What's new is the SNP trying to take on Provisional Sinn Féin and Provisional IRA's arguments to make out Westminster is meddling. Even turning a General Election into a de facto referendum won't work - didn't actually work in 1918 and cannot work in 2023 in the context of international law.

In their desperation to get into the history books, the SNP has turned towards trying to provoke as many constitutional fights as possible with the UK Government. That shows a lack of confidence in their strategy.

If they had confidence and truly believed the demographics will deliver independence at some unknown point in the future.....they wouldn't be trying to cause fights with our Sovereign Government which islegally as wellas democratically in the right. 🤷‍♂️

Brefugee · 18/01/2023 11:27

I wonder if NS is playing a really sharp game here? IIRC from other posters/threads the GRC wasn't in the SNP manifesto but they have gone into it at the behest of their coalition partner (Greens)?
So maybe NS really isn't behind it at all, and has done this and gone in all guns blazing because she knows it's not within Holyrood's remit and Westminster will get their way?
But the net result will be a win at Indyref2?
Is she being really really sly here?

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 18/01/2023 11:23

I think this will backfire on NS. The publicity this bill is generating just results in it being scrutinised more closely, and people are wondering why on earth a government would pass such a terribly drafted piece of legislation which is so unpopular with the public. It makes the Scottish government look incompetent. Which it is.

Well yes. NS seems to see this as a 'Gotcha' and a case for Indyref2 but presumably in an independent Scotland it would become law. Lots of women avoid political parties like Labour because of their support for self ID and TWAW so presumably a lot of women will avoid voting SNP because of the issue. Especially with so much light being shone on the batshittery of it all.

Hankunamatata · 18/01/2023 11:22

Thank god its blocked. If you have a penis regardless of gender or sex you don't belong on a female only space.

Swipe left for the next trending thread