Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shook up by death of someone I don't know

133 replies

Greengables4 · 16/01/2023 14:00

I knew who she was, she dated a guy I used to chat to a bit. I'd seen her on social media but didn't know her in person, though she had one or two mutual friends. She was pretty and seemed popular with a loving family. She lived in my area.
She committed suicide a few days ago and was only in her early 20s. I find it so heartbreaking, even if I didn't know her. It's really got me down for some reason, I like many others cannot comprehend why, but I suppose only the people who take their own lives know why, they have their reasons.
Does anybody else ever feel like this if they didn't know the person? I felt the same after Caroline Flack, chilled to the bone

OP posts:
Lovemydoggiesomuch · 16/01/2023 18:51

I agree with @Move22 . OP I really do understand.Any young death is truly tragic and I personally know people who made very serious attempts at ending their own life and sadly 3-4 who did take their own life .

IncompleteSenten · 16/01/2023 18:43

I don't, but everyone is different and I'm sorry you are feeling upset. 💐

AngieBolen · 16/01/2023 18:39

I think suicide shows us that people who might seem happy are actually desperately desperate. It makes us think about whether or not we could have helped prevent their death. It's always such a sad situation. I have friends whose parents have taken their own lives, but I can only imagine how I would feel if a friends child took their own life. I think it would shake me to the core as it's a concern I have with one of my own DC.

I totally understand how you feel as you do OP. I think suicide is such a complicated thing it's not surprising you can't make sense of your emotions right now.

The last time DH told me to shut the fuck up was when his cousin took her own life and didn't have a Catholic funeral. I said it was probably because she took her own life. We got no further in talking about it. As I said, suicide is always awful, always causes a pain to those left behind, and those taking their own life know this, yet also know their pain is even greater. Sad

I don't mean to offend anyone with this post, it's just my personal view.

QueefQueen80s · 16/01/2023 18:33

It would be weirder to not be saddened by it.. this is a very normal human response.
I felt the same when a young mum hung herself a few years ago, knew of her but never met her.. two beautiful girls 2 and 4, seemed like a wonderful mum, load of loving family around her. So tragic but sometimes we can't find a reason, and that feels scary. Only she knew why.

Surplus2requirements · 16/01/2023 18:17

I think suicide, especially of a young person without obvious reason can effect any number of people no matter how tenuous their connection.

On some level it's a dark unspoken fear that we could lose someone close to us and its difficult for it to be pushed into our awareness.

I have been attending bereaved by suicide support groups for 4 years now and can attest many bereaved by suicide find the phrase 'committed suicide' very difficult to hear, not all, it doesn't bother me much now but it's a phrase I would never use myself. Especially not to someone else grieving.

I don't see it as policing language but helping to spread awareness of how to talk about suicide and to those grieving.

It's an emotional minefield that can be triggered by almost anything, so much so that many stop trying and avoid people desperately in need of support, and those that need support isolating themselves.

There's no harm in pointing out what can unintentionally be heard as an accusation of sin and criminality

PinkSyCo · 16/01/2023 18:07

Yes hearing that someone has taken their own lives always affects me badly. I think that’s partly because I lost a family member to suicide, but I just think that it’s a particularly tragic end to a life because that person must have been suffering in silence for so long. 😞

Greenisthecalmestcolour · 16/01/2023 18:06

Suicide is a deeply horrible thing, for some people it is distant, and unexamined it does little harm, but the closer it gets to you and touches your life the more disturbing it is. You are being human by reacting to it as you have OP.

I have been affected by suicide in my family, and I naturally say committed suicide, (although I try not to). I know the history that suicide was once considered a sin or a crime but that's not what I think of when I use it. It hasn't been a sin or a crime in my lifetime so why would I? I think more of committed as it is relevant to marriage or the way people commit to something. It makes me think that the action was considered, they committed to it and strangely I find peace in that. For what it's worth.

10HailMarys · 16/01/2023 18:05

I don't think it's unreasonable to feel sad upon hearing of someone's death, however they died or whoever they were.

I do, however, have an extremely low tolerance of people who essentially just have to get in on the act of grieving/emoting to feel included somehow. When I was a teenager a pupil at my school, the younger sister of one of my classmates, died in particularly shocking circumstances, and random people who didn't know her kept turning up leaving flowers at the school gates, which the family actually just found intrusive and distasteful. As my classmate said many years later, 'I completely understand that people were shocked and sad about what happened and that it might really prey on someone's mind after reading it in the news, but when they started turning up and leaving teddy bears and messages that said 'Goodnight princess' for [name] when they hadn't even known she existed until they heard about their death, it turned into grief tourism and we just wanted them to fuck off.'

Maytodecember · 16/01/2023 18:04

Your reaction is normal. It isn’t “just” the death of this young person , you imagine how her family feel, how it would feel if it was someone closer to you, the utter sadness of a young over son feeling driven to suicide. It’s all part of your empathy.
It will take time to process what has happened and if you feel overwhelmed or very affected in the next weeks make sure you speak to someone. You can always call Cruse or The Samaritans. Look after yourself.

Change2banon · 16/01/2023 18:03

OP, I think you may be referring to a lovely young lady known to me - her case is tragic.

Any suicide case is tragic. I’m fed up of hearing on TV, media etc about ‘talk to others’ ‘talk more’ ‘there’s so much support out there for MH’ … the cold stark reality is NO THERE’S NOT! Politicians and professionals keep insisting things are good (re help/support) … well get in the real world, open your eyes … it’s NOT TRUE. Young people are bring horrifically let down by the system! Heads should roll in many cases .. but nothing will happen, nothing will change. 😡

oohokay · 16/01/2023 17:59

As if they took their own life because they knew they were guilty. At least, that's how I felt the local press and public narrative went around the person I loved.

oohokay · 16/01/2023 17:55

@GonnaGetGoingReturns (Please note I'm not arguing, just having a conversation out of interest... If this is offensive or upsetting or splitting hairs, my apologies, and please ignore it.)

Perhaps it also depends on the circumstances of death? Everyone with mental health issues will feel deep shame and self-loathing. But in some cases, society itself will have decided this person has done something outwardly shameful (even before they died).

Some examples are being publicly victim blamed (eg for sexual abuse, especially if there are big institutions, legal cases, etc involved), or bankruptcy (common in the region I used to live after a historic economic crisis). "Committed suicide" is almost like a verdict/ confirmation of their guilt and wrongdoing. I know it's just words but yeah...

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 16/01/2023 17:45

Back to OP. Of course it’s natural to feel upset by this person’s death and the manner in which she died, as it is upsetting, especially when a young woman, who seemingly from external appearances has everything to live for, is obviously battling some internal upsetting issues, and sadly hasn’t been able to get the necessary support from her family and friends or mental health professionals or suicide charities (Samaritans).

I can’t say I’ve heard of a suicide of someone I didn’t know (I might’ve forgotten) as most people I know who did die in this way, I knew as eg friends or a girlfriend of my brother. A few people recently and over lockdown I’ve seen have died on social media (Facebook/Instagram school friends/acquaintances) then yes, I have been really upset as these people have died either before 50 or on 50 and that’s no age to die either. A few of them it was addictions/drink problems too. People rarely say the real reason online (naturally) unless they know them well, and that’s understandable too.

Supersimkin2 · 16/01/2023 17:44

YANBU OP, it’s horrible for you.

Who’s ‘we’? @Move22 Not in the UK are you; just to let you know, it’s not considered respectful to hijack a grief thread with fringe terminology attacks.

watchfulwishes · 16/01/2023 17:38

@Greengables4 I think one of the reasons some deaths by suicide shock is because they are people who appear to be living the type of life we think should make them 'happy', or a life that is similar to ours. This is frightening because it means it could be us one day, or someone we love.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 16/01/2023 17:37

SallyCinnamon12 · 16/01/2023 14:46

So unspeakably tired of the constant policing of language these days.

Such time and energy would be more usefully directed into doing something about the underlying causes of suicide.

I agree with you. My best friend just weeks before her 33rd birthday killed herself. I’m not about to split hairs with which correct term to use.

All I can say is that suicide, for the victim and their friends and family is one of the most terrible and misunderstood ways to die. When the person doesn’t leave a note (as is often the case) you’re also often wondering, why. Even though deep down, you do know the reasons why.

I heard my ex colleague (a bitch and a bully) criticising a close friend and client of our boss, saying how selfish he was to end his own life, yet I’m sure this man hadn’t exactly wanted to gas himself with the exhaust pipe from his own or his parents’ car. This same ex colleague used to tell me, almost with glee, how her DM had witnessed with her grandson, a jumper at the nearest train station, and what it had looked like (I won’t describe it here).

ThanksItHasPockets · 16/01/2023 17:36

HeavenIsAHalfpipe · 16/01/2023 17:23

What are WE supposed to say then? Confused I 'get' saying someone has commit suicide is jarring for some, because (as some posters have said,) it harks back to the days when suicide was a criminal offence/a sin.

But what on earth is wrong with 'they took their own life?'

As I said @Move22 what are people meant to say then?! Confused

You’ve misread the post you quoted. It specifically cites ‘took their own life’ as an option.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 16/01/2023 17:34

MyDogStoodOnABee · 16/01/2023 14:43

Who is we? I haven’t had the memo

It's one of the fundamentals taught in Mental Health First Aid qualifications as part of the desire to reduce stigma and make mental health something that's OK to speak about, to ask people about and to encourage people to help and be helped, rather than suffer in silence and shame.

watchfulwishes · 16/01/2023 17:34

HeavenIsAHalfpipe · 16/01/2023 17:23

What are WE supposed to say then? Confused I 'get' saying someone has commit suicide is jarring for some, because (as some posters have said,) it harks back to the days when suicide was a criminal offence/a sin.

But what on earth is wrong with 'they took their own life?'

As I said @Move22 what are people meant to say then?! Confused

Confused The suggestion is you say 'they took their own life' or 'died by suicide' rather than 'committed suicide'. It is the word 'committed' that is the issue as it harks back to when committing suicide was deemed an immoral action akin to committing murder.

moonmoon123 · 16/01/2023 17:32

Greengables4 · 16/01/2023 14:00

I knew who she was, she dated a guy I used to chat to a bit. I'd seen her on social media but didn't know her in person, though she had one or two mutual friends. She was pretty and seemed popular with a loving family. She lived in my area.
She committed suicide a few days ago and was only in her early 20s. I find it so heartbreaking, even if I didn't know her. It's really got me down for some reason, I like many others cannot comprehend why, but I suppose only the people who take their own lives know why, they have their reasons.
Does anybody else ever feel like this if they didn't know the person? I felt the same after Caroline Flack, chilled to the bone

I had this girl on my Facebook. i feel so bad for her two best friends

HeavenIsAHalfpipe · 16/01/2023 17:30

HeavenIsAHalfpipe · 16/01/2023 17:29

@Greengables4 YANBU to feel sad and shook up about this young woman's death. The death of anyone is sad, but the younger they are, the worse it is. Flowers Someone taking their own life in their 20s is dreadful... it's bad at any age, but if they are in their 20s, it's so sad. Sad

Sadly, I have known about 7 people who took their own life over the past 20 years. 3 of them were in their 20s. 2 in their early 40s, and 2 in their 50s. 5 women, 2 men. Despite the stats I have read about more men taking their own life than women - I have known more women. Don't know of anyone who has taken their own life after the age of 55 oddly.

Sorry, I have know 7 people who took their own life, not about 7 people. Actually 7.

watchfulwishes · 16/01/2023 17:29

DismantledKing · 16/01/2023 14:21

This is what you’ve taken from the thread? A chance to police the language used?

Informing is not 'policing'. I agree with what @Move22 said.

HeavenIsAHalfpipe · 16/01/2023 17:29

@Greengables4 YANBU to feel sad and shook up about this young woman's death. The death of anyone is sad, but the younger they are, the worse it is. Flowers Someone taking their own life in their 20s is dreadful... it's bad at any age, but if they are in their 20s, it's so sad. Sad

Sadly, I have known about 7 people who took their own life over the past 20 years. 3 of them were in their 20s. 2 in their early 40s, and 2 in their 50s. 5 women, 2 men. Despite the stats I have read about more men taking their own life than women - I have known more women. Don't know of anyone who has taken their own life after the age of 55 oddly.

54isanopendoor · 16/01/2023 17:27

oohokay · 16/01/2023 16:28

I'm not usually one for sensitivity, but I know someone who took their own life and I can totally understand on a visceral emotional level.

"Committed suicide" sounds like she did something wrong and taints her last actions on this earth... Which is especially awful as the wrongdoing was inflicted upon her (sexual abuse by an institutionally powerful male and the societal response to that).

The above may sound dramatic, but I genuinely believe you'll only understand if you know someone who died by suicide.

If someone who knew her personally used the term while grieving, I wouldn't even comment, but on a random conversation (especially online) like this it's fine to spread a bit of awareness.

I agree.
It's not an offence anymore.
But it IS a tragedy.
OP YANBU to feel upset at that happening to someone.
I can think of a few folk over the years, some I've known a wee bit, most I haven't
There 'but for the grace of god etc' could go any of us in the wrong circs.

HeavenIsAHalfpipe · 16/01/2023 17:23

Move22 · 16/01/2023 14:20

Please use the term died by suicide.
or
took their own life

we don’t say committed suicide any longer that is an awful term in itself. Thanks all.

What are WE supposed to say then? Confused I 'get' saying someone has commit suicide is jarring for some, because (as some posters have said,) it harks back to the days when suicide was a criminal offence/a sin.

But what on earth is wrong with 'they took their own life?'

As I said @Move22 what are people meant to say then?! Confused