Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs capable of sending us to hospital/the morgue need to be banned

305 replies

SplishSplashIWasTakingABath · 16/01/2023 11:51

Yet another serious dog attack.

uknip.co.uk/Breaking/News/breaking/woman-rushed-to-hospital-after-attack-by-dog-in-the-street/?fbclid=IwAR3bVa7T5KdsbfMlHZqg8CjSCFIkSVJtGYjB8iAZJ5_2C2Rv4tomNMO1ask

YANBU - ban these dogs (bully breeds, huskies, Dobermans etc)
YABU - aw, poor pibbles, must have been provoked

OP posts:
JustFrustrated · 16/01/2023 14:28

So overtime you'd make a breed extinct because of humans?

I feel like we already know this isn't good or right.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 16/01/2023 14:27

I am very much in the camp of the problem being the owner not the breed.

However, just a quick google shows that the US has has 71 fatal dog attacks since 2020 with 57 of those involving at least one Pit Bull. The UK has had 17 fatal dog attacks in the same period with 0 Pit Bulls involved. (But 7 with XL Bullys.)

We'll never know if banning the breed actually did anything in terms of UK attacks but it is interesting.

anomaly23 · 16/01/2023 14:19

I think all dogs can be aggressive even beloved retrievers and labs, in lots of cases it's the owner but in lots of cases it's the dogs genetic make up.

I think an owner has to be reasonable and understand their dog. If a dogs unfriendly with people and other dogs then muzzle it. I muzzle one of my dogs because while he's lovely at home, he's an absolute horror on walks and hates everyone and everything. This dog has been with us from a pup, went to socialisation/puppy and training classes and we have other dogs in the house but he's just a dick. I love him to bits but he's on a short lead, muzzled and walked when it's quiet. His litter are all the same, 2 have been rehomed and 2 have been put down. I still have mine and 2 others still have theirs.

Suzi888 · 16/01/2023 14:19

Vets will be seriously out of pocket.

BasiliskStare · 16/01/2023 14:19

@Barbbarkbark and and PP . In our local park dog walkers are limited to 3 dogs. 7 is way to many I think . I am an experienced dog owner but no way would I take 7 dogs out by myself. Given we have a young one we take 3 out between 2 people ( border terriers - decently trained ad know us. )
I am so sad to hear this but one young woman with 7 dogs - no it should not have happened but I think Dog walkers ( can't remember if she was being paid ) should not be allowed out with more than 3 - friend of mine is a dog walker and he won't do more than 2. This should be scrutinised I think . & even if not a dog walker as a job - I do think it should be a thing you can't take more dogs out than you can control & the dog owner should be responsible enough not to let their dog be walked with so many others & has to take some responsibility.

AlwaysGinPlease · 16/01/2023 14:17

So sick of the ever increasing amount of dog hater posts. Bore off.

LakieLady · 16/01/2023 14:17

Spiderboy · 16/01/2023 12:04

I feel the same about men sometimes. I read far more news stories about abusive men and murdered women than I do about dogs.

Absolutely.

On another forum, I just suggested that the Met police should become an all-female force, as they seem incapable of not letting men like Couzens and Carrick in to abuse their powers.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 16/01/2023 14:17

Even if you managed to pass a law banning all dogs, you’d have to either define a dog in a watertight way to capture any new crossbreed or species sourced by people desperate to own a dog (whether for nefarious reasons or otherwise), or have a list of breeds that’d need to be constantly updated. If the former you’d need to provide a route for people to either appeal their pet being so categorised or a defence to criminal prosecution on the basis that their pet doesn’t meet the critters to be defined as a dog.

The man hours would be ridiculous, and arguably for very little benefit as by the time an illegal dog comes to light it’s probably already caused the harm.

twistyizzy · 16/01/2023 14:16

kitsuneghost · 16/01/2023 14:15

Sorry, advocate banning that should have been.

And how about a pet dog that works? But only part time? Gundogs only work during shooting season ie august-january. The rest of the year they don't "work" so how would you address that?

kitsuneghost · 16/01/2023 14:15

Sorry, advocate banning that should have been.

kitsuneghost · 16/01/2023 14:14

twistyizzy · 16/01/2023 14:07

Not blindsided at all, just the premise that we ban anything that has the potentil to kill or harm us considering that so many things can do this besides the very rare occurence of dogs. It is a preposterous suggestion hence the ridicule.
Fundamentally it is impossible to do and won't get anywhere. The people who are irresponsible won't suddenly stop, all you will do is push the breeding or training or dangerous dogs further underground and thereby making them more appealing. All breeds of dog have the potential to harm therefore are you seriously suggesting banning ALL dog breeds 🙄?

I would actually advocate private dog ownership for sole purpose of being a pet.
I know that's not going to happen though.

But as I said previously people should not have dogs that are stronger than them. If that dog attacks, the responsible person needs to be able to stop it before it does damage.

LakieLady · 16/01/2023 14:12

Shitzngiggles · 16/01/2023 12:12

It's not the dogs, it's the owners. That's what we should be focusing on.

Absolutely.

If the Am Bulldog was banned, the people who are so inadequate that they need an aggressive dog to look "hard" would just switch to another breed or crossbreed.

Scottishskifun · 16/01/2023 14:08

tulips27 · 16/01/2023 13:32

@Scottishskifun It's poor ownership which is the issue

Look at this list, it is dominated by bulldog breeds:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fatal_dog_attacks_in_the_United_Kingdom

Those numbers are low and if you look at the stats for attending hospital for a dog bite it used to be labradors which had the highest number which definitely isn't a bull breed. Again bull breeds isn't the issue it's the owner and the way they train that dog. If it's seen as a status symbol/defence weapon and trained as such then that increases the liklihood significantly of that happening hence its the owner not the breed!
What that breed is changes with time as well it used to be German shepherd's, then was dobermans, then boxers, mastiffs, staffies, now bulldogs and husky breeds. The thing they all have in common is poor ownership!

A staffing before being used in this was known as the nursing dog as they are really good around children majority of staffing I know lick the death out of people with a wagging tail!

It just shows lack of knowledge of the breeds to simply blame a breed rather then the human training it!

vodkaredbullgirl · 16/01/2023 14:08

Go the whole hog and ban every animal that might bite 🙄

DanePack · 16/01/2023 14:08

@Largethighsbadeyes Great Danes were originally bred around 400 years ago ( they're actually a German breed ) to hunt and bring down wild boar.
That's why they're the only dog breed to have a ' thumb ' which was used to hold down the boar.
That said, they weren't trained to kill the boar, only hold it.
They were bred from mastiff types of dog, they were also used in the 18th century to protect estates and carriages by nobility.
However, over the years this has been bred out of them, hence the gentle giants name.
In over thirty years of breeding them and growing up with them, I can honestly say I've never had a bad tempered one.
That said, what has to be remembered is that dogs, irrespective of their breed are inherently pack animals and will follow the pack in attacking, which is what will have happened in the case of that poor dog walker. One attacked so the rest followed their instinct and attacked too, even the smallest gentle dog.
Irresponsible breeders coupled with irresponsible owners are the problem.
By irresponsible owners I mean the ones who, regardless of breed..
Don't know or are interested in that breed history.
Allow their dog to roam free and mostly not muzzled.
Don't attend training classes.
Don't meet the correct need of the breed they have.
Encourage the dogs bad behaviour by allowing it to ' play bite ' and ' play chase '
Allowing children to tease the dog.
They are just a small example of bad ownership.
Hence my thorough checks and demands on potential owners prior to purchase.

twistyizzy · 16/01/2023 14:07

kitsuneghost · 16/01/2023 14:01

The thread is not about men and cars or anything else. Are people sooo blindsided that they feel the need to deflect rather than have a serious discussion.

Not blindsided at all, just the premise that we ban anything that has the potentil to kill or harm us considering that so many things can do this besides the very rare occurence of dogs. It is a preposterous suggestion hence the ridicule.
Fundamentally it is impossible to do and won't get anywhere. The people who are irresponsible won't suddenly stop, all you will do is push the breeding or training or dangerous dogs further underground and thereby making them more appealing. All breeds of dog have the potential to harm therefore are you seriously suggesting banning ALL dog breeds 🙄?

feelingsareweird · 16/01/2023 14:07

Sooo you would ban most guide dogs, sniffer dogs, some sheep dogs? As they're all often medium-large breeds theoretically capable of causing a lot of damage.

Cows are the most objectively dangerous animal in the uk.

I think what we need is better education, both in dog body language and in statistics and risk in this country tbh... and since we can't even keep our education system on an even keel I'm not sure how you think we have the resources to police dog ownership!!

SoupDragon · 16/01/2023 14:07

MooseBreath · 16/01/2023 12:06

The man who owned the dog in that article has been charged with "grievous bodily harm with intent". To me, that says that this was a purposeful attack and the dog (presumably a status dog) is not at fault. Properly punish offenders like this twat, don't ban dogs when 99% of them don't cause any problems.

This.

Ladyincrimson · 16/01/2023 14:07

And are we including mixed breeds too? That’s an awful lot of dogs to pts 🙄

Ladyincrimson · 16/01/2023 14:06

So huskies, dobermans, German shepherds, bull breeds, Akitas, Rottweilers, malamutes, mastiffs, Great Danes, newfoundlands, st Bernards, English and Irish wolfhounds, douge de bordeux, shar pei, antalonian shepherd, Leonbergers… Have I missed any out OP?

Fivebyfive2 · 16/01/2023 14:05

Someone I know is selling puppies on FB, a litter from their female dog. They're advertised as "pocket bully" which according to Google is a cross between a bully and a patterdale terrier. It's absolute bollocks, if you scroll further down their page you see them bragging about breeding their female bully type dog with an absolutely massive American XL bully. Click on that dog owners page and he's exactly "the type" people associate with status dogs. But idiots are snapping them up without any real info or there being any regulations.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 16/01/2023 14:04

@DoubleShotEspresso Because your analogy doesn’t work. Kitchen knives aren’t banned; hunting knives, machetes are banned. Guns are either banned outright or for some types only obtainable under a licence. Or in other words, not all knives and guns are treated equally under the law.

Where knives and guns are banned it’s because of their fundamental nature (not how they’re used). You can’t own a handgun or machete if you promise to undergo training in how to use it. They’re banned outright.

So why hasn’t the knife ban worked? Partly because there are plenty of knives whose nature isn’t inherently dangerous and so they aren’t caught by it eg. pen knives, kitchen knives. They’re still dangerous knives but we can’t ban all knives, as that’s not proportionate. The same is true with dogs like labradors and sausage dogs - capable of causing damage and in fact statistically more likely to do, but they don’t have a fundamentally dangerous nature. It’s about how they’re used.

To truly enforce your suggestion, you’d have to ban all dogs (and maybe all knives, actually - they’re worse than dogs!) on the basis that they’re all on the same level as handguns. And given that dogs are alive and far more widely owned than handguns, this is quite complex. This is why the debate “rumbles on”, not because everyone else is stupid and only you see the light.

Lakeyloo · 16/01/2023 14:02

HaveYouSeenNancy · 16/01/2023 12:36

I agree, there was another thread recently about an XL Bully and someone posted the statistics of fatal attacks in the UK. American Bully and Cane Corso are still extremely rare here, yet responsible for about half of the fatal dog attacks. I don't think there were any lab/spaniel/dachshund on the list, and a Jack Russell had attacked a baby.

I would attempt to help someone being attacked by a small dog, but I'm just not sure about larger dogs, and I'm not confident that a large muscular dog could be reined in and held back by the person holding the lead. I love dogs, and I'm sure that most of the bully breeds have a lovely nature (I've known two beautiful Staffie bitches), but the XL and Cane Corso genuinely frighten me. They are just too powerful to be stopped attacking if they want to.

This is the exact point I was going to make. Bearing in mind that the amount of XL Bullies and Cane Corso in this country is probably extremely low at the moment compared to the number of labs/spaniels/collies etc etc, the percentage of fatalities or serious injuries caused by them is terrifying. Everyone who owns one insists that they are loyal and amazing pets, but that's half the issue.... their instinct to protect their environment and their "pack" . It often seems to be someone visiting who is attacked first. I know of someone who lives in a tiny 2 bed flat with their young child and an XL Bully. They have just "acquired" a cane corso puppy (cropped tail and ears 😥)Never owned dogs before. I doubt very much these animals are insured and i know for a fact they might get a short walk every now and again. It's a horrible accident waiting to happen. It isn't the dogs fault, but how can anyone and everyone be allowed to own these kind of dogs ? What's to stop this person keeping 4 or 5 in this environment ? Something definitely needs to be done but making laws and insisting on licencing doesn't stop the kind of people who are attracted to these breeds. (Apologies to those who are responsible and manage these breeds well)

Staffielove23 · 16/01/2023 14:01

You’ll have to ban labradors, German Shepards, golden retrievers, etc too as they are also big animals and capable of causing serious damage.

Suzi888 · 16/01/2023 14:01

“Then we ban ALL breeds that are strong enough to seriously hurt us.”

What a ridiculous comment.

Swipe left for the next trending thread