Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dogs capable of sending us to hospital/the morgue need to be banned

305 replies

SplishSplashIWasTakingABath · 16/01/2023 11:51

Yet another serious dog attack.

uknip.co.uk/Breaking/News/breaking/woman-rushed-to-hospital-after-attack-by-dog-in-the-street/?fbclid=IwAR3bVa7T5KdsbfMlHZqg8CjSCFIkSVJtGYjB8iAZJ5_2C2Rv4tomNMO1ask

YANBU - ban these dogs (bully breeds, huskies, Dobermans etc)
YABU - aw, poor pibbles, must have been provoked

OP posts:
HoneyIshrunkthe · 16/01/2023 14:48

I was walking in the park today and met a man with a huge Staffordshire Bull Terrior.
He was massive!
The owner told me he was 70kg and is a rescue he believes was abused before.
He then, in the next sentence, told me how his young daughters paint the dogs nails but the dog wont let him lift his paw at all…………….
Just waiting on the news 🙄🙄🙄🙄

WineDup · 16/01/2023 14:47

JustFrustrated · 16/01/2023 14:44

For hundreds, if not thousands of years, we have had dogs.

It's quite appalling people think that it's okay to murder a full breed of animal...to protect humans.

And then others wonder why we have a climate crisis? The human greed is why.

I don't like dogs. I don't like them around me. Or in restaurants or shops or anywhere else.

I've been chased and attacked by a dog.

I STILL disagree with banning breeds entirely.

One, I don’t support banning breeds.

Two, banning breeds doesn’t mean “murdering” dogs - sterilising them should do the trick

Three, none of these things has anything to do with climate change.

We may have had dogs in general for thousands of years, but the mere existence of different dog breeds is purely down to humans selectively breeding dogs with particular characteristics.

ArtixLynx · 16/01/2023 14:47

i'd push for legal requirements for all dogs to be leashed/muzzled in public before banning certain breeds because owners can't handle them.

I say that as an owner of a rescue greyhound that HAD to legally be muzzled/leashed on walks as it had been a coursing dog and was at risk of attacking small dogs/cats.

LakieLady · 16/01/2023 14:46

kitsuneghost · 16/01/2023 13:39

Don't see anyone walking their cows and pigs at the local park.
Only on private land.

Good point though maybe keeping your dogs on private land would be a good option if you need a dog.

A lot of private land has public rights of way running through it. Some farmland is now "access land" under the Countryside & Rights of Way Act, and anyone can enter it.

I've been chased across a field by curious cows when crossing grazing land more times than I can remember and am quite wary of cows as a result

Many years ago, we were walking in Cumbria and came across an ambulance in a farmyard, and 2 paramedics attending to a walker. We heard later that he'd been crushed against a wall in the yard by the cows who were being brought in for milking. He had a couple of broken ribs.

A few people are killed by cattle every year in the UK, and a farmer was prosecuted by the HSE approx a year ago. He got a suspended prison sentence, iirc.

KLM2023 · 16/01/2023 14:45

What do people mean by the term ‘bully breeds’? There are multiple different bulldog breeds and they are not all the same. You can’t lump an XL bully into the same category as a French or English bulldog for example. Calling for all ‘bully breeds’ to be banned is not dissimilar to calling for all dogs with pointy ears to be banned. It’s nonsense.

NapoliTutti · 16/01/2023 14:44

I have a fairly large dog (pointer) who is the gentlest dog ever, known for their affection and love. Just because he is large doesn’t mean he is dangerous. I will add however that certain dangerous breed types that are banned roam the streets usually attached by a chain to someone i wouldn’t trust with a potato gun, and that needs to be clamped down on.
so I partially agree with you…. But only in regards to recognised under UK law dangerous dog breeds.
Dobermans are NOT a problem dog.

JustFrustrated · 16/01/2023 14:44

WineDup · 16/01/2023 14:39

Dog breeds only exist because of humans.

For hundreds, if not thousands of years, we have had dogs.

It's quite appalling people think that it's okay to murder a full breed of animal...to protect humans.

And then others wonder why we have a climate crisis? The human greed is why.

I don't like dogs. I don't like them around me. Or in restaurants or shops or anywhere else.

I've been chased and attacked by a dog.

I STILL disagree with banning breeds entirely.

Ladyincrimson · 16/01/2023 14:43

It’s like saying a human killed somebody so we best start putting all humans to sleep. A Caucasian English human killed another human so we best wipe them all out because they’re all bad.

TBF I can think of a few humans I’d like to permanently muzzle 😉

DoubleShotEspresso · 16/01/2023 14:42

Apologies for typos !

Justcallmebebes · 16/01/2023 14:42

Clymene · 16/01/2023 12:00

You know that the dog walker woman was attacked by a group of dogs including a cockerpoo and a couple of dachshund don't you?

I think this is another one being reported on today. Woman in her home

DoubleShotEspresso · 16/01/2023 14:42

fitzwilliamdarcy · 16/01/2023 14:04

@DoubleShotEspresso Because your analogy doesn’t work. Kitchen knives aren’t banned; hunting knives, machetes are banned. Guns are either banned outright or for some types only obtainable under a licence. Or in other words, not all knives and guns are treated equally under the law.

Where knives and guns are banned it’s because of their fundamental nature (not how they’re used). You can’t own a handgun or machete if you promise to undergo training in how to use it. They’re banned outright.

So why hasn’t the knife ban worked? Partly because there are plenty of knives whose nature isn’t inherently dangerous and so they aren’t caught by it eg. pen knives, kitchen knives. They’re still dangerous knives but we can’t ban all knives, as that’s not proportionate. The same is true with dogs like labradors and sausage dogs - capable of causing damage and in fact statistically more likely to do, but they don’t have a fundamentally dangerous nature. It’s about how they’re used.

To truly enforce your suggestion, you’d have to ban all dogs (and maybe all knives, actually - they’re worse than dogs!) on the basis that they’re all on the same level as handguns. And given that dogs are alive and far more widely owned than handguns, this is quite complex. This is why the debate “rumbles on”, not because everyone else is stupid and only you see the light.

If course kitchen knives are not banned.
But you'd be pretty stupid to take one for a walk right?

We have to start somewhere with this and the fluffy notion that these digs are all perfectly harmless & it's all the wrong type of owners holds no water.

This keeps happening.

So yes absolutely ban XL bullies and any similar breeds that follow.

IcallitVera · 16/01/2023 14:41

So anything bigger than a chihuahua then?

And horses. Also cars and any kind of vehicle really.

And bacteria those fuckers should be banned, they kill thousands of people a week.

Get a grip. We're not the only species on the planet.

StalkedByASpider · 16/01/2023 14:41

InTheFutilityRoomEatingBiscuits · 16/01/2023 14:34

A hamster caused a friend of mine to be hospitalised on IV antibiotics.

I needed antibiotics after my son bit me. My hand was puffy, swollen and disgusting.

In retrospect I should have made up a story about fighting off a giant dog. Dammit.

FictionalCharacter · 16/01/2023 14:41

I’m not voting when the choices are “ban them” or “poor pibbles”, whatever that means. A reasoned debate can’t be had unless you accept that it’s more complex than that.

laidbacklife · 16/01/2023 14:39

It’s the owners generally. And normally it’s irresponsible male owners who are the problem. Someone earlier in the thread suggested banning men and I think it’s probably the most sensible solution 😂

WineDup · 16/01/2023 14:39

JustFrustrated · 16/01/2023 14:28

So overtime you'd make a breed extinct because of humans?

I feel like we already know this isn't good or right.

Dog breeds only exist because of humans.

mollynolly · 16/01/2023 14:39

My mistake, it was a leonburger. I knew it was a big dog with a funny name.

mollynolly · 16/01/2023 14:38

I think one of the dogs in the walker attack was a malinois, which hasn't yet been caught as it ran off after the attack. A malinois could definitely kill a person. But I agree that the issue was too many dogs. I would feel very nervous with more than three, personally, but an experienced dog walker should limit the amount of dogs they walk at a time for supervision purposes alone.

GelPens1 · 16/01/2023 14:37

Clymene · 16/01/2023 12:00

You know that the dog walker woman was attacked by a group of dogs including a cockerpoo and a couple of dachshund don't you?

Interesting that you didn’t mention she had an 11 stone leonberger too. I could fend off 2 dachshunds. A leonberger would kill me because they are huge beasts.

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11637121/amp/11st-Leonberger-walked-dog-walker-mauled-death-appeared-BBC-badly-behaved-puppies.html

MarshaBradyo · 16/01/2023 14:35

Yanbu that link and all the other incidents are very concerning

InTheFutilityRoomEatingBiscuits · 16/01/2023 14:34

A hamster caused a friend of mine to be hospitalised on IV antibiotics.

mollynolly · 16/01/2023 14:33

I always worry when Facebook tries to push those House of Asher videos on me because the guy in them is often out on his own with a pack of 20-30 dogs, many with bite histories. He's an accident waiting to happen.

StalkedByASpider · 16/01/2023 14:31

I think there absolutely is a problem with certain breeds. I think it's probably a combination of ownership and genetics. Yes, all dogs can bite but I think a) there's a difference between a bite and a full-blown attack and b) most adults would stand a chance with the majority of dogs - not with these highly muscled breeds.

Lots of PP have made really good points and as a dog-lover, it's hard to find the right solution. But maybe the first step should be to bring in licensing - but only for the breeds that could be dangerous? So not just the Bully breeds, but also Rotties, Doberman, huskies, GSD, Akitas etc. Basically if you want a strong and powerful dog, you need to have a license.

Having so few dogs requiring licences should make it easier to enforce and eventually will cut down on the dickhead owners. It's the fatal and dangerous attacks that we need to focus attention on rather than this "all dogs bite" attitude which distracts from the clear problem.

SoftSheen · 16/01/2023 14:30

YANBU. All dogs can bite but an untrained, poorly socialised Jack Russell is unlikely to kill someone, whereas an untrained, poorly socialised 'XL Bully' could, and they sometimes do.

Some dogs are bred to do a particular job, and are usually happiest if doing that job, or something equivalent e.g. Malinois, Border Collie, Husky. Other dogs are bred simply to be family pets, ideally with good health and temperament. It isn't clear to me how something like an XL Bully is going to be well suited to being either a working dog or a pet, so should they really be bred at all?

BashfulClam · 16/01/2023 14:29

All dogs are unpredictable,my friend was scarred for life by a Golden retriever. I’d never ban them as they are lively 95% of the time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread