Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to avoid conflict over homework

41 replies

hydroxyapatite · 16/01/2023 08:43

DS has started secondary. He's in Y7. He is a great student in class, by all accounts, but hates homework and revision. He literally slaps it out or does the bare minimum. He's smart, so it's frustrating.

I have a very strong work ethic, always worked at school, and it does my head in. I want him to do well, to have choices.

We have had several rows about it. He gets upset and moody, DH and I get upset.

Suggestions?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PAFMO · 17/01/2023 07:49

Let him deal with it.
He needs to work out that his work is his responsibility. And that not doing it will have consequences. Presumably you'll be kept abreast of what's going on at parents' evening.
Whenever I get parents telling me about their kids' homework, I tell them that at secondary, all things being equal, they don't even need to know whether there is any or not. Until it's not being done. Then they find out quickly.

redskydelight · 17/01/2023 07:36

GreenEmeraldSea · 16/01/2023 22:02

"Do you really not ask your child if they've had a good day?🙄"

One day, when he is an adult, he'll work out that people who pad their emails and phone calls with all this "how are you?" BS don't care one hoot. I hope that doesn't disappoint him too much.

Also when he is an adult he will need to realise that even though no one cares one hoot it's polite to include some degree of niceties in his conversation. And actually I think the "how are you" in the workplace allows for people to preempt future work with "feeling swamped by work at the moment" type answers.

We don't ask whether DC have had a good day either. That's a closed question and will just get you the answer "yes". But we do ask how their day was (which often just gets the answer "fine" but at least allows for a broader answer) and will home in on specifics ("how are you finding Chapter 3 of English Lit text?").

GreenEmeraldSea · 16/01/2023 22:02

"Do you really not ask your child if they've had a good day?🙄"

One day, when he is an adult, he'll work out that people who pad their emails and phone calls with all this "how are you?" BS don't care one hoot. I hope that doesn't disappoint him too much.

NoSquirrels · 16/01/2023 22:01

Have school raised concerns over his homework? If not, I’d not worry.

Tallulasdancingshoes · 16/01/2023 21:55

To be honest, I wouldn’t battle over it. I’d offer help/support and remind but that’s it. Leave him to it. If it’s not good enough or not done, school will deal with it and he will have to suffer the consequences. Today I’ve made 6 of my top set year 9s re-do their homework because what they handed in was was absolutely dreadful quality - rushed and just awful. If they hand in the same again they will be on after school detention. Maybe he needs to be in a bit of trouble at school to make the penny drop that this is important. Just make sure you support school with any sanctions they put in place.

Mapletreelane · 16/01/2023 21:54

This may be controversial but my belief is that home / the bedroom is their safe space and I don't want them to feel conflicted/stressed at home about school. They have so much going on in their lives home should be the one place they can switch off and not be nagged/given targets/ultimatums.

I try and provide the framework so space, tools, time and support if need be and the it is up to them to learn how to manage themselves.

The school has consequences for poor homework and it is much better for all our state of minds that school inflict the punishments rather than me. It definitely helps lessen conflict in our house.

I did learn this the hard way, I used to have blazing rows with DS1 when he was 13, doors slamming , shouting matches, tears. Once I realised that in his world I was constantly on his back , nagging him it was a light bulb moment and as soon as I backed off and gave him space so much improved.

That said both children are pretty conscientious and motivated, so giving them space may work for them, but not all kids. So much of the success of managing homework depends in the individual child's personality and what works for one child will not work for all.

HaroldeVwilliam · 16/01/2023 21:45

@ChickenDhansak82

Does he need to have a different attitude if he is getting good grades?

Maybe keep screen time for as long as his hw gets good grades and he does in his tests? maybe that's how he works best? Last minute to a deadline?

trythisforsize · 16/01/2023 21:44

As only year 7 perhaps start small and build. So 10 minutes per night, then 15 after half term. When they realise its quite quick and painless hopefully they'll settle into it. Even if my boy (yr8) rushes it I always tell him thehandwritingmusr be neat or he has to do it again. Its slows him down just enough to relax into it a bit more. I also bribe him with chocolate 😉

Theunamedcat · 16/01/2023 21:36

Honestly I let him fail he got a punishment at school and now he does it willingly its not perfect but it's done

hydroxyapatite · 16/01/2023 21:13

We also get involved and do it with him, if he wants. DH is especially good at this. It's more just about the acceptance that homework is now a regular part of school life

OP posts:
PaperMonster · 16/01/2023 21:02

Daughter is Y7 and hating homework. As did I and more often than not I didn’t bother doing it. OH wants her to do it as soon as she comes in, but it’d never get done that way! So we do it the night before it’s due and I sit with her whilst she does it. Because that’s how she likes to do it and how she works best. We’ve just been sitting in bed doing her maths. Works for us, I don’t make a big deal about it.

Shemovesshemoves21 · 16/01/2023 20:49

MargaretThursday · 16/01/2023 16:13

Have you asked him why he hates doing his homework?

If someone asked me why I hate certain things I have to do then they would probably get a rather sarcastic answer along the lines that if they can't work it out for themselves then they can do it for me.
The most likely answer is that he finds it boring and has things he'd rather do. Much like I feel over the washing up or similar.

OP, one of mine worked non-stop on homework, the other two did bare minimum. It's part of who they are.
I found rewards much better than anything else for encouraging homework, because if he doesn't want to do it, then you're not going to make him feel any more positive about doing it by going on about it.

The reason I suggested asking questions is because it reminded me of a friend at school. He was terrible with school work, most thought he wouldn't amount to anything and it turned out that he was incredibly bright and his work wasn't challenging him enough. He now runs his own business in the millions. So yes, I do think there's merit in asking why he doesn't like his homework, which could lead to further conversations and understanding, and therefore how to tackle the issue. Not everyone would have a sarcastic or rude response 🙄

hydroxyapatite · 16/01/2023 18:49

Thanks all.

Food for thought. Have to do something to make it constructive and pleasant (even when hard) or next few years will be hell

OP posts:
ElfandSafety101 · 16/01/2023 17:36

Remove the conflict.

As long as their results and overall grades aren’t suffering I’d not push homework if it’s causing this much drama, if they get consequences for not completing it then they can deal with those at school.

Sometimes kids need to feel consequences to understand them.

RudsyFarmer · 16/01/2023 17:36

It works for us but horses for courses 👍

LlynTegid · 16/01/2023 17:35

I'm with you over reward for completion.

redskydelight · 16/01/2023 17:32

RudsyFarmer · 16/01/2023 16:56

Id be firm about homework = earning screen time.

Having a phone/Xbox etc is a privilege not a requirement. The requirement by law is safe housing, food, access to education etc. Nowhere in the UN convention of rights does it mention game machines or iPhones so they are a privilege earned by following rules and homework falls under rules.

I think this reinforces that doing homework is a chore.

If you're trying to encourage a good work ethic, then someone doing something to get a reward is not the way to go about it.

my suggestion to avoid conflict is to not get involved. Tell him you expect homework to be done to a good standard and back off. Let school deal with it if you aren't. You can't force someone to work if they don't want to.

If your child is a "great student" in Year 7, then he may not need to do much in the way of homework in any case.

LoveMyLawn · 16/01/2023 17:23

@hydroxyapatite I can see that you ran a very tight, stimulating ship for your kids. But I suspect we have different types of kids and households.

I love it when a small snapshot of what I posted gets interpreted that way. Ds2 fought me all the way on homework in primary but we set expectations for secondary because it is more important. Plus in primary he was in the top few children so homework felt like a waste of his time and the teachers agreed but you can't not set it for a handful of students.

In secondary they had a homework slot but tech? Be on it until your eyes bleed. You have earned it. No 1 hour on weekdays, literally be on tech until dinner but you have to be off at X time to set the table, help with dinner prep, dance and sing in the kitchen. Then you can go back on it or choose to watch some TV shows/films with us etc which would qualify as screen time. I think gaming teaches valuable lessons to children with strategy, forward planning, resilience, learning to win and lose and learning to play with your mates. They did do sports and had other things in their lives like board games, chess, cards but gaming was what they wanted and if they apply themselves in school and for homework they can game.

RudsyFarmer · 16/01/2023 16:56

Id be firm about homework = earning screen time.

Having a phone/Xbox etc is a privilege not a requirement. The requirement by law is safe housing, food, access to education etc. Nowhere in the UN convention of rights does it mention game machines or iPhones so they are a privilege earned by following rules and homework falls under rules.

grayhairdontcare · 16/01/2023 16:55

Mine are adults now but homework was their responsibility and if they didn't do it then they got detention.
It soon focused them

MyMachineAndMe · 16/01/2023 16:55

ds has adhd and hates homework. His tablet has worn off by the time he gets home so struggles to concentrate on it. I do not push or force him to do it and simply leave it to him, saying that he's the one who has to go to detention meaning it will take him out of the after school minecraft club.

hydroxyapatite · 16/01/2023 16:52

I think reward, tying it to tech, trying to improve his whole attitude to homework will be key.

I don't want to keep fighting over it. He's wilful, it's hard.

OP posts:
hydroxyapatite · 16/01/2023 16:51

LoveMyLawn · 16/01/2023 16:17

@hydroxyapatite that is what you took from that? I am more interested in all of the day, broken down. Some bits will have been "good" especially for subjects they find interesting, the conversations they had with friends or teachers, some bits will have been "bad" like low level disruption that led to X child being removed and then more homework as they didn't cover enough in class so overall what? Good? Is it a percentage? Part of a lesson can be good and then bad. A good day is hard to quantify overall and so we focus on the ups and downs of a school day instead of setting the expectation that every day at school should be good because what if it isn't? Are they then failing at it?

My children are very happy with this system, willing to talk to us, have discussions. Yes even as teens, no grunting or one syllable words because we talk to them about the things they are learning and it leads to conversations around the dinner table. My youngest is year 12 and both my children did incredibly well academically. I was just trying to be helpful in suggesting setting a homework slot at home just like lots of schools offer a homework club after school to help students do well with their homework.

Honestly, maybe it was the way you originally wrote it but yes, I was pretty blindsided by the comment.

Anyway, onwards.

I can see that a homework slot would be helpful and mixing it up with some of the other ideas here, I think it's something we'll do.

I can see that you ran a very tight, stimulating ship for your kids. But I suspect we have different types of kids and households.

OP posts:
SleeplessInEngland · 16/01/2023 16:50

With homework it's best to work smart, not hard. Do the bare minimum and start giving a shit when it comes to exam revision. If he's good in the class itself the teacher will know.

Lovemydoggiesomuch · 16/01/2023 16:48

I used to chat to my children once after school about homework and then left it entirely up to them . Their schools were state grammar and they were worked hard during the day so am sure this reflected on the relatively low amount of homework.

Swipe left for the next trending thread