Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unfair splitting of dinner bill by couple

279 replies

NazMedusa · 16/01/2023 04:00

Went for dinner for a friend's birthday who we hadn't seen for a while and who had come all the way down from another city. This friend has had a rough year so we were treating her to dinner.

Male friend at the last minute asked if he could bring his wife along as she really wanted to join us. Fine but a bit annoying as she's not really a part of this friendship group that we'd formed 15 years ago at work but we've spent enough time with her as he has a habit of bringing her along to everything. So four of us (who once worked together) plus this wife.

The couple ordered extra starters, sides and alcoholic drinks. He made a comment a couple of times that "we'll pay extra for our bits". Myself, other friend and birthday girl don't drink so had a soft drink each and one starter and one main.

The bill came to £170. Our food and drinks came to around £25 each for the non-drinkers. The couple spent the rest. Male friend and his wife took it upon themselves to work the bill out and spent at least 5 mins doing it. As the birthday girl is close friends with the three of us (not the wife), I expected him to split her part between the three of us, and then split the rest of the bill according to what we roughly ordered. Instead he said that myself and the other non-drinking friend owed £48 each, and he paid £74. So he paid only £26 extra when he was supposed to be paying for 2 adults (himself and his wife) plus the non-drinking birthday girl (who's food and drink came to £25 and should have been split three ways).

Isn't this unfair? I feel like we also paid towards his uninvited wife. We paid it without saying anything as didn't want to make things awkward, especially in front of birthday girl. But how should I deal with things next time this happens??

For a bit more context: I am currently on an extended mat leave so no income. And him and his wife are top earners and earn more than any of us.

OP posts:
Badger1970 · 17/01/2023 20:43

You can't say anything now, it would just look petty. But next time, I'd be prepared and when you all sit down at the table, ask how you're splitting the bill as you can't afford to pay for anyone other than yourself.

GingerNutMe · 17/01/2023 20:42

It doesn't sound right but then he's not paying double what you pay as his wife wouldn't be paying part of the guests meal. Who has the receipt, work it out from there and if he has underpaid drop him a message, or better still speak to him, and say they worked it out wrong.

nettie434 · 17/01/2023 20:41

Instead he said that myself and the other non-drinking friend owed £48 each, and he paid £74.

I aam trying to understand how how two people who didn't have alcohol pay more per head than the couple who had extra sides and drinks. I also don't see why his wife didn't contribute to the birthday girl's meal when it wasn't a huge amount split between 4 given that she was coming along to to the meal but I know you weren't expecting that so this is just my gripe!

I really understand you not wanting to make a big thing of it when the birthday girl was present. Next time I would suggest asking to pay separately. That way the service charge is divided fairly too. I had an awful experience at a group meal once when some people left early, leaving cash for their contribution. It was only when we got the bill that I realised that nobody had included the service charge and I ended up paying a ridiculous amount to avoid embarrassing the host who did not earn enough to pay extra. It wasn't the fault of the restaurant - it was quite clear they included service. It was just that the people leaving early probably weren't great at maths.

ComfortablyDazed · 17/01/2023 20:37

123boom · 17/01/2023 20:05

I found your op incredibly rude about bringing his wife. That’s more of an issue in my mind.

This is so bizarre.

It’s a group of ex-work colleagues. None of them were bringing partners. It was to celebrate one of their birthdays.

You don’t always have to bring your partner along to every social occasion. Or at least, if you do, know that there will be people in your group inwardly eye-rolling.

katepilar · 17/01/2023 20:36

Sorry you were not in a position to question him.

What I will never understand is why is it such a problem with paying for whatevery you had when in a group in the UK. Dont understand why the standard is to split the whole bill by number of people /plus fuff about who had/hadnt alcohol to try to make it fairer/, its such a bizzare concept to me.

Mandyjack · 17/01/2023 20:31

If you still have the receipt work out what they had and ask him to pay for it and split it between the rest of you or next time state that the invite is for him only and if you think the share is unfair speak up. I usually prefer or pay for what I've had at a restaurant as I don't drink and find the people that eat and drink the most are always the ones who wants to share the cost

xsquared · 17/01/2023 20:24

LadyOfTheFliessssss · 17/01/2023 20:12

It's embarrassing when you're with someone trying to calculate what they spent to the last penny.

Tbh, I've been annoyed more by people doing that than having to pay a bit extra because someone's skipped out. It just seems super stingy to me.

I don't think people are necessarily working out anything to the last penny just because they know how much their meal comes to. How many items does anyone order for themselves that adding up a few numbers becomes embarrassing?

If there is a huge discrepancy in what they think their share comes to, then it's not unreasonable to question it.

It's not super stingy to not want to subsidise items that others have had and you haven't. OP was treating birthday girl, not male friend and his wife.

Reclaimtheoutdoors · 17/01/2023 20:24

I don’t think the OP is being rude at all re. Wife.

It’s weird to me if he presumably know the others don’t bring their partners except for the occasions they specifically have family meet ups, and yet keeps bringing his wife.

None of my friends bring their partners along unless we were all part of the same friendship group and are friends with their partners too eg. uni friends.

I’d hate for my friends to do that and would think it was a bit pathetic really !

Also if the person who you are celebrating is single and they’re having a small dinner it can make it awkward for them. You expect intimate gatherings to just include your good friends, not their partners. It’s a bit different if it’s more like a big “more the merrier” kind of party but this sounds like a gathering of 4 or 5 before the wife jumped in.

Elsiebear90 · 17/01/2023 20:23

Yeah it’s not fair, but it might have been genuine error, you should have pointed it out at the time because if you raise it now it’s making it into a much bigger deal, don’t end a 15 year friendship over a tenner.

FuzzyDonkey · 17/01/2023 20:21

BadNomad · 16/01/2023 06:05

Did your £48 include a tip? I wonder if he built that into his calculation.

20% of £170 is £34 = £6.80 per person.
That takes your £25 meal up to £31.80.
Then splitting the birthday girl's meal between 3 is an additional £10.60.
So you should have paid around £42.40
Which isn't far off.
He would have paid £75 plus tip.

I'm guessing you're American. It is definitely not normal to tip 20% in the UK. Tips are only given for great service (definitely not expected like in the US) and even then at a rate of around 10-12.5%.

opencheese · 17/01/2023 20:17

Are you sure your share should have been £25?

You had a starter, main, presumably a drink? Where did you go? That's cheap!

LadyOfTheFliessssss · 17/01/2023 20:12

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 17/01/2023 19:06

Yep. After much CFery done to me I make sure I know what I've ordered and pay only that (plus share of the birthday girl's, if appropriate). If people want to take the piss they aren't going to do it to me. Why is it embarrassing to only pay for what you've consumed? Otherwise it just enables the CFs to get away with it.

It's embarrassing when you're with someone trying to calculate what they spent to the last penny.

Tbh, I've been annoyed more by people doing that than having to pay a bit extra because someone's skipped out. It just seems super stingy to me.

Yb23487643 · 17/01/2023 20:07

ComfortablyDazed · 17/01/2023 17:34

I’d agree with you if it was friends, but it’s a group of ex-work colleagues.

And he was the only one bringing his wife along.

Sometimes it is actually socially appropriate to come alone and leave your partner at home.

Yeah this is what I would do in this situation & it’s clearly what the other two did.
You don’t need to be in eachothers pockets when married and reeks of control by the wife. Probs the vibes the friends are getting too.

123boom · 17/01/2023 20:05

I found your op incredibly rude about bringing his wife. That’s more of an issue in my mind.

Name5 · 17/01/2023 19:57

@ThereIbledit the lady tried it again two months later when she invited her daughter to lunch with us. She asked the waiter to spilt the bill, I said no I'll pay for mine. I haven't seen her since! I think she invited her daughter in case I suggested she pay something towards the birthday lunch. She is happy to spend £80 on jeans and has never been to Aldi. Cheeky mare. The beauty of no longer drinking means I am quite vocal now.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 17/01/2023 19:56

I always take my fiancé to things

What a saddo.

Hi20 · 17/01/2023 19:13

something similar when I first started at my work when I was younger went out for a meal and there was talk from a few cf colleagues who was stating that they was getting expensive meals/drinks because they knew older members of staff would split the meal price by numbers of people at the meal, I made it very clear that I was paying for what I had and no extra (unless special occasion) so as soon as we went in to restaurant I stated can we have separate bills please.

Morgysmum · 17/01/2023 19:11

It is frustrating when this happens. At my gran mother's 80th birthday. We had a meal at a posh restaurant.
My mum was sat on a table with her husband, plus some other family members. My mum doesn't drink, my dad only had a couple of beers, which he brought from the bar, so paid for. The others on the table ordered bottles of wine, none of which my parents drunk.
As it was expensive, they only ordered a main course, and I think pudding. Choosing the cheapest options. However when the bill came, it split between all on the table, even though my parents said they would pay for there meal, some towards, grandparents meal. So they ended up paying for food they didn't eat, plus wine they didn't drink.
That's the last time the had a family meal, for my grans 90th, they had a buffet.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 17/01/2023 19:06

Yep. After much CFery done to me I make sure I know what I've ordered and pay only that (plus share of the birthday girl's, if appropriate). If people want to take the piss they aren't going to do it to me. Why is it embarrassing to only pay for what you've consumed? Otherwise it just enables the CFs to get away with it.

Reigateforever · 17/01/2023 19:02

Oh yes I often have this problem, two couples and me and my round comes after the two men, never do their wives pay a round. Or even food, turns to pay at the restaurant over a weekend.

FluffyFlower · 17/01/2023 18:59

It happens all the time. You either say something right there at the time the bill arrives or never and just accept these things happen in a social situation. Next time let everyone pay for what they are/drank, even if it means sorting out the bill for 20 minutes!

ThereIbledit · 17/01/2023 18:58

@FancyFran What the fuck, why didn't you tell those people to damn well pay for their own?? There is no way in hell I'd be paying for somebody else's £100 worth of stuff!

anon666 · 17/01/2023 18:56

Yanbu

That's really puzzling. I'd have felt ripped off too. They sound like a delight. 🙄

ThereIbledit · 17/01/2023 18:54

"We paid it without saying anything as didn't want to make things awkward"

Ultimately the long and the short of it is that you let this happen, and to avoid it happening again in the future you need to get more okay with feeling uncomfortable and letting others feel uncomfortable. It's good to practice having boundaries because you need them not just with friends but with work and definitely with your child!

"Oi Geoff you cheeky sod mine came to £25 plus my contribution to birthday girl's, which does not equal 48 quid!"

"That doesn't seem right, let me see the bill. [sees the bill]". My food and drink was £25 and I'll chuck in a tenner towards birthday girl's and a tip. Here's the cash, I'm off to the loo while you work it out again (taking cash including a little change to group meals is always useful) /I'll go to the bar and pay mine on my card and leave you to recalculate the rest"

[Text message] Hey Geoff I'm still puzzled how my food and drink + contribution to birthday girl's came to £48. by my reckoning it should have been just over £30. You still got the receipt?"

DrLecter · 17/01/2023 18:48

YANBU, OP.

But to the person who wrote:

Everyone I know would expect to bring their spouse to a social event with people of the opposite gender.

... I can't even imagine what it's like to live in your world!