Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just got engaged, wedding in two years too soon?

364 replies

Littlemoon31 · 15/01/2023 22:18

Hi hope you can help me here?

My DP proposed to me on Wednesday whilst away on holiday. Whole family informed, social media post, all smiles and happy. Gorgeous proposal which isn't like him as he isn't romantic.

We came back from our holiday on Saturday morning. We had an amazing time whilst away.

Lots of questions from family about plans, dates etc. I have already asked my bridesmaids. Noted a provisional date and written a guest list.

Tonight has been only opportunity to talk with my DP about my idea to get married in two years.

He has said no and that it is too soon, we should just enjoy the engagement, not drank the champagne that my parents bought us as a celebration gift and that he hasn't even unpacked yet.

Also said I have no patience and it's one of my annoying qualities and that I rush into everything including asking to be his girlfriend (10 years ago) and buying a house (3 years ago.) No children, 2 cats, he is 38 and I am 37.

He is very chilled out person and not emotional at all. Seen him cry 3 times in 10 years. I am the opposite that is why we work.

However I am upset??? What do I do?

OP posts:
lborgia · 16/01/2023 07:39

The way you write implies that you both would've got married much sooner if life hadn't been so difficult.

That being the case, and your mum being unwell, it would be reasonable to expect to get married within 6 months, whilst you've got a good window to enjoy it.

I also grew up thinking the engagement was just the name of the bit where you organise the the wedding.

I'm also not sure how your got to 37 not realising how difficult TTC can be. If you have fertility issues, you simply don't have time to faff about. Doesn't matter if everyone knows tons of people having babies from late 30s onwards, it is statistically far more likely to take a long time/mcs/ needing ivf/ not work out.

He needs to recognise that he's been thinking about this for a while, you've only just found out.

Those seriously unpleasant remarks (including the idea that you rushed him into a relationship 10 years ago) are either seriously controlling, or he thought the proposal would buy him more time. I honestly can't see a positive spin.

Don't be a martyr to the sunk cost fallacy either. If he responds well to a proper conversation, and apologises properly, crack on. If he gets defensive, prevaricates, or brings up more ways in which you don't do life right, do yourself a favour and look at your options.

TestingTestingWonTooFree · 16/01/2023 07:38

It’s not unreasonable to want a couple of weeks to enjoy the cards, champagne and congratulations before getting stuck into planning. He may not realise how complex/time consuming wedding planning can be. I agree with other posters that I’d aim for an early wedding and then TTC. Especially as your mum is ill.

SleeplessInEngland · 16/01/2023 07:22

When I read the title I thought it’d be the op who’d suggested that long, bit a dh who wanted to edit even longer than that.

More info is needed. What date does he envisage if not two years?

ThomasinaLivesHere · 16/01/2023 07:19

If I were you I’d be planning a wedding for a few months away not years. I was in similar situation to you and prioritised children but then the wedding and honeymoon weren’t what they would have been if we’d done that first. If you have babies, toddlers or young children the logistics become more difficult. It’s not to say it can’t be nice etc. And they do look cute in wedding clothes. But for example our honeymoon was just three nights as we couldn’t be away so long from our child.

Welshgirl10 · 16/01/2023 07:17

I got engaged two months ago after being together 11 years, and we are planning to get married at the end of next year so around 2 years. I have done a rough plan of numbers as we are starting to look at venues, but haven't asked any bridesmaids or anything yet.

I think two years is normal these days, and gives you time to plan and enjoy the engagement. None of my friends were married within 6 months of engagement.

I'm early 30's for context

UseOfWeapons · 16/01/2023 07:15

My 1st husband proposed in the July, we started living together in August, married in December. We’d known each other for 8 years. Initially, we planning our wedding for the following year, but as we were arranging it ourselves, we brought it forward. We had 60 to the church, and 100 in the evening, and all the food, buffet, cars, etc., were done by friends and family. The only thing that were done by professionals, were the photos, and the icing of the wedding cake, which my mum made. It was all we could afford, but it was lovely. I wore my mum’s wedding dress, my ex hired a suit. The important thing for us was that we loved each other and wanted to be married. 2years sounds like a lot of time to delay. Sounds like your OH doesn’t want to get married.

DaphneBlue · 16/01/2023 07:12

DH proposed after three days and we were married as soon as was physically possible afterwards (3 months), but I realise we're unusual! However two years is a long engagement already and I'd have serious concerns about someone who wanted to make it longer still. ExH and I were engaged for five years before he reluctantly agreed to start wedding preps - we separated within a year and he said me 'rushing him into marriage' was one of the reasons he behaved the way he did (which is another thread entirely!).

Tubs11 · 16/01/2023 07:05

I'd postpone any baby plans until after you're married tbh. Don't know your financial background or future plans, but plenty of stores on Mumsnet about partners changing their mind and leaving partner financially stranded with kids.

Sorry to take the shine of the celebrations but that's the cold reality and your gut feel is telling you it isn't right otherwise you wouldn't have posted on MN

gogohmm · 16/01/2023 07:03

2 years is long, a few months would be more normal

Justalittlebitduckling · 16/01/2023 06:59

Two years is perfectly reasonable for getting married after getting engaged. Why did he propose if he doesn’t want to get married? How many years does he think will be reasonable? Are you planning on having children together?

Shemovesshemoves21 · 16/01/2023 06:56

To play devil's advocate here. It sounds like you've both been through the mill given your mums illness, you not being well, renovating a house and being made redundant 4 times. You drew up a guest list etc 4 days after being engaged and it may well be that he's just wanting to enjoy this time with family at the moment and start planning in a few weeks time. You say he's known for having quirks and is fairly chilled out, it wouldn't be a complete shock for him to bumble along at a slower pace than you'd like. As you've said, he's picked a church he'd like to marry in which is a good sign (and an important part of planning a wedding!). Perhaps don't sway immediately into the territory of "he doesn't want to marry me" because he's not throwing himself head first into planning 4 days after getting engaged. Have a conversation with him and be honest about how you feel, but you must try and see it from his perspective too.

AWaferThinMint · 16/01/2023 06:55

We were married ten months after he proposed. Two years is a long wait. As a PP said, being engaged is literally being in the state of preparing for a wedding. If you're not wedding planning it has no meaning.

TeenDivided · 16/01/2023 06:42

2 years seems a very long time to plan a wedding unless you have to save up massively.
If it were me I'd be aiming for this September, but otherwise Spring '24.

That said, you writing provisional guest lists, inviting bridesmaids all without discussion seems a bit precipitous.

littlelid · 16/01/2023 06:36

PurBal · 16/01/2023 06:27

IMO engagement is a stepping stone not a status in itself. You’re neither single or married and it’s a weird half way place to be. I didn’t like being engaged at all because of this. 2 years sounds pretty long (we had 6 months) but I think it’s fairly usual if you have your heart set on a particular venue. Why did your FI propose if he doesn’t want to get married?

I agree. You shouldn't get engaged unless you'd get married

houseargh · 16/01/2023 06:31

Two years is more than enough time. Sounds like he wanted to get engaged (or thought he ought to) but doesn't currently want to get married. Maybe he's hoping he'll change his mind in future but sounds like you need to have a serious conversation about the basis of your relationship and commitment level

PurBal · 16/01/2023 06:27

IMO engagement is a stepping stone not a status in itself. You’re neither single or married and it’s a weird half way place to be. I didn’t like being engaged at all because of this. 2 years sounds pretty long (we had 6 months) but I think it’s fairly usual if you have your heart set on a particular venue. Why did your FI propose if he doesn’t want to get married?

ohfook · 16/01/2023 06:11

Frabbits · 15/01/2023 22:26

2 years is a reasonable length of time to take from engagement to wedding but if you are already drawing up guest lists (for crying out loud) having got engaged less than a week ago then it's very likely he has a point about enjoying the engagement to some extent. Are you sure you haven't prematurely gone a bit mental about it all?

My dh presented me with a wedding planner Filofax thing the second I said yes! We were making plans that afternoon. Surely part of enjoying the engagement is thinking about the wedding and your marriage?

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 16/01/2023 05:53

If you want a particular venue/time of the year etc then 2 years may be necessary but it’s definitely not a short engagement. Being engaged is about planning a wedding so if you are not planning a wedding yet what is there to enjoy/what’s different than before.

Blueberry40 · 16/01/2023 05:45

Just to offer a different perspective. My (now DH) proposed after 2 years of seeing each other when we were both mid thirties. He did exactly what your DP did to the point where he wouldn’t discuss wedding plans at all and said he just wanted to enjoy being engaged. Any attempt I made to plan a wedding was thwarted and eventually I just gave up and accepted we would never marry. I felt it was a huge red flag but stayed in the relationship because I love him. We finally got married last year (very small wedding) after 8 years together.

I realise in hindsight that he had nerves about being the centre of attention and was hugely concerned about the cost of a big wedding-he’s a cautious person and it became this massive hurdle that just stressed him out every time he thought about it. It was never lack of commitment to me but an aversion to weddings in general- the planning, the cost, the awkward decisions about who to invite, the general hugeness of the day. I made the mistake of assuming he wanted the same big wedding that I did, not stopping to consider that it might just all feel too much for him.

If your DP is similar could you have something very small soon that didn’t feel too overwhelming to legally bind you and then plan a large blessing over a longer period of time? Maybe he would be more receptive to that. Would also be safer for you if you’re planning a family together.

Sweetener12 · 16/01/2023 05:43

Eh, I personally think that 2 years is fine and it's enough time to properly plan a wedding, it's about average, not exactly too long or too soon, but the way your FH speaks to you about your excitement is conserning. Life is too short to not drink a champagne gifted to celebrate or not make silly funny smartshow 3d engagement videos with your photos. How is that even wrong when you really do have something to celebrate and be happy about? Maybe he's just overwhelmed, hence the reaction, but I wouldn't appreciate it.

JudgeRudy · 16/01/2023 05:41

Sounds like you 2 have very different expectations. I'd be hurt and annoyed at his response. If he had been lighthearted and said Wow babe, slow down that's OK, but he didn't. He basically said its not happening anytime soon.
For me personally I would view a proposal as someone asking to get married. The engagement is simply the state of being engaged to be married. In my eyes if you're engaged you've said you're willing and ready to marry ut have the logistics of sorting z wedding first.
If he's not ready to commit to a date/plan I'd be inclined to say OK, forget the engagement, ask me again when you're ready.
Surely you've been together long enough to be as sure as you'll ever be. Is it possible he just got carried away in the heat of the moment and is back tracking?

ShippingNews · 16/01/2023 05:36

You are planning a small wedding - two years seems incredibly long to me, for a small event like this. DH and I had 20 day / 40 evening and we planned the whole thing in one month .

You've been together for 10 years already , and your biological clock is ticking pretty fast now , so if you want children it's time to get cracking on that. Personally I'd go for a little registry office wedding, a party for 40 , and then go home and make babies. Your DP will string this out until it's too late .

BigHeadBertha · 16/01/2023 05:33

Two years seems excessive to me for a small wedding. When someone proposes, it's reasonable to assume that means it's time to start planning the wedding. If he doesn't want to get married until the far off future then why on earth did he propose?

Also, at 37 years old, your fertility has already taken a sharp decline. I would definitely not wait to start trying if you want babies. Good luck.

escapingthecity · 16/01/2023 05:27

Being engaged is a temporary status, not an end destination. A wedding takes as long to plan as you give it. Two years is a long engagement.

Eyerollcentral · 16/01/2023 05:24

Littlemoon31 · 16/01/2023 05:22

Thank you so much.

The house is fine now. Still needs lots doing but it's liveable. It's on hold for few more years.

I will try talk to figure. Good stuck up.

Best of luck and congrats!