Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just got engaged, wedding in two years too soon?

364 replies

Littlemoon31 · 15/01/2023 22:18

Hi hope you can help me here?

My DP proposed to me on Wednesday whilst away on holiday. Whole family informed, social media post, all smiles and happy. Gorgeous proposal which isn't like him as he isn't romantic.

We came back from our holiday on Saturday morning. We had an amazing time whilst away.

Lots of questions from family about plans, dates etc. I have already asked my bridesmaids. Noted a provisional date and written a guest list.

Tonight has been only opportunity to talk with my DP about my idea to get married in two years.

He has said no and that it is too soon, we should just enjoy the engagement, not drank the champagne that my parents bought us as a celebration gift and that he hasn't even unpacked yet.

Also said I have no patience and it's one of my annoying qualities and that I rush into everything including asking to be his girlfriend (10 years ago) and buying a house (3 years ago.) No children, 2 cats, he is 38 and I am 37.

He is very chilled out person and not emotional at all. Seen him cry 3 times in 10 years. I am the opposite that is why we work.

However I am upset??? What do I do?

OP posts:
ThomasinaLivesHere · 16/01/2023 14:58

@Littlemoon31 Did you have a talk with him?

Littlemoon31 · 16/01/2023 14:53

MrsHGWells · 16/01/2023 08:53

There’s chilled and also fear of commitment… or preference to spend the money on starting a family? OP you have the patience of a saint .. 10yrs gf and now a drawn out wedding timeline.. heck what is he waiting for … the retirement home wedding package fully catered ? Set a date and work towards

I know I'm devastated. I've taken my ring off.

OP posts:
londonrach · 16/01/2023 14:24

That does sound a long time. I don't know anyone who after got engaged were not married within the year apart from those that got engaged and still not married 10 plus years later and no plan too. What do you want op.

Lcb123 · 16/01/2023 14:20

That would be a concern for me. We got engaged after 10 years together and got married 15 months later - mostly because it was during covid so waited to plan until it was clearer on the restrictions. Would have done sooner without Covid. I think you need to have a discussion about his reasoning? You didn’t mention if it’s money related, perhaps.

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 16/01/2023 14:14

I think he's clearly using it to string you along, sorry. Ten years but another two is too fast? I also reckon that once you have the baby he'll think of baby-related reasons why you shouldn't plan a wedding.

Blondeshavemorefun · 16/01/2023 14:14

Does he want to get married

I’m guessing you have fir a while if have already asked bm and have guest list done already

equally 2yrs is average as obv venue you want is likely to be booked fir least a year

plus need to save to pay for the wedding

when does he want to get married @Littlemoon31

TheGoogleMum · 16/01/2023 14:08

I'd say 2 years is pretty normal, not rushing. I'm basing this on people in late 20s though as that's when most people I know got engaged, it's maybe even a bit of a long engagement for late 30s

budgiegirl · 16/01/2023 13:40

I work in the wedding industry. I'd say 18months to 2 years is a fairly typical length of time to plan a wedding, especially if it's a large one and needs saving for. So I don't agree that 2 years is too short, especially as you've been together for so long. Surely the reason the point of an engagement is that you are ready to get married?

20viona · 16/01/2023 13:38

I think 2 years is about normal. We got married 14 months after getting engaged, I book it 4 weeks after we got engaged.

Hydrangeatea · 16/01/2023 13:34

Christ I'd die of boredom before then!

2 years is a hell of a long time away from an engagement. I am still of the old fashioned view that you get engaged to be married and therefore get married in a reasonable timeslot after the engagement. All the waiting around to get married would do my head in. Getting engaged should mean you set the date for the wedding there and then.

Stravaig · 16/01/2023 13:31

It doesn't matter what anyone and everyone else did. OP wants to marry this man, and for him it's too fast, for her too slow. If they're going to share their lives together, it has to work for both of them. You don't sound very compatible, OP.

ReneBumsWombats · 16/01/2023 13:22

Applesandcarrots · 16/01/2023 13:03

I would think he meant it's too soon after engagement to basically have half planned wedding and just enjoy the moment.

He proposed on Wed and there is already bridal party, date, guest list etc. That's pretty fast.

We got married shortly after engagement but we didn't start planning until few weeks after.

The point of an engagement is to plan the wedding. They've been together ten years already. What "moment" is there to be enjoying by not doing anything?

We were looking at venues the day after he proposed.

mindutopia · 16/01/2023 13:22

We got married 6 months after we got engaged. I think 2 years is quite a long time, though I know in post-COVID times, venues have been hard to find. But the people who I know who tend to wait years to get married are ones who got engaged young 'just for the ring' and aren't entirely sure they are ready for marriage yet.

That said, you are late 30s. You've been together 10 years. You either want to get married or you don't. You have a house together and presumably a mat leave to save money for. You probably don't need to be spending ridiculous amounts of money on a wedding. You can easily get married in 6-12 months if you are planning something on the smaller side. Wedding aside (it's just one day and it goes by really quickly), married life doesn't sound much different than what you're already doing, especially if you are thinking about TTC, so I'd just get married. Focus together on the marriage and not the wedding. If he's not keen on that, that would raise some red flags for me.

Applesandcarrots · 16/01/2023 13:03

I would think he meant it's too soon after engagement to basically have half planned wedding and just enjoy the moment.

He proposed on Wed and there is already bridal party, date, guest list etc. That's pretty fast.

We got married shortly after engagement but we didn't start planning until few weeks after.

ReneBumsWombats · 16/01/2023 12:54

Does he realise re fertility especially if want more than one. Some people are clueless - not realising celebs often use donor eggs, surrogacy etc to have children in their 40s.

Have you ever known a man in his 40s who knew he wanted children and sought out women his age?

JustAnotherManicMomday · 16/01/2023 12:54

Sounds like the proposal was an obligation used as a stalling tactic. His done that so he can delay the marriage for another few years then delay children until its too late. If these are things you want sooner than in the year 2030 then have a serious conversation regarding timescales. If you don't like them leave.

Dixiechickonhols · 16/01/2023 12:39

Hopefully you can discuss and get on same page.
You have more to lose than him if you want a child.
He can faff a few years, then go and have a child with a 29 yr old while you are in 40s and childless.
Does he realise re fertility especially if want more than one. Some people are clueless - not realising celebs often use donor eggs, surrogacy etc to have children in their 40s.
I can’t think of any reason to wait yrs after engagement in your situation unless he doesn’t really want to marry.

Omgwhatthehell · 16/01/2023 10:54

If you’re not planning a huge, expensive wedding, and want children sooner rather than later then why wait?
It’s really unkind of him to criticise you for drawing up a rough guest list. Two years is a pretty standard amount of time to be engaged. You need to start the planning now and need an idea of guest numbers so that you can look at appropriate venues and get them priced up.

DH and I got married just under nine months after getting engaged. Mainly because we’d decided to get married, rather than just get engaged, if that makes sense.
We drew up a guest list straight away. Then did a bit of internet research and contacted venues which would accommodate those numbers to get availability and costs. We realised we could afford to do it, then just cracked on and booked it.
In no way are you jumping the gun.

Ansjovis · 16/01/2023 10:28

If he's difficult to talk to then you really don't want to be a parent with this guy. Babies shine a massive spotlight on any problems in the relationship so his communication issues will impact you more and more.

I think that most people would expect that wedding planning would follow an engagement. The fact that he doesn't is concerning, as if he expected the proposal to buy him some time before he had to make an actual commitment. I would think very carefully about this, dragging an unwilling man up the aisle is not a good idea, regardless of whether said man admits he is unwilling.

TiredButDancing · 16/01/2023 10:16

I have to agree with PP -if you're planning marriage, I wouldn't be having children until you'd done that. Otherwise there will be a million reasons not to do it - you're pregnant, you're breastfeeding, there's a toddler, you're pregnant again etc - and bang, you've been engaged for 5 years, have no financial security and the wedding is off forever.

LadyOfTheCanyon · 16/01/2023 10:08

Put bluntly, most men would be happy not being married. A long term girlfriend with no concrete commitments but someone to ' look after him' suits most men just fine.
Weddings for a lot of men are just an appeasement to keep their partner onside.

Obviously NAMALT but I've been around the block enough ( and had two marriages myself) to think that a lot of weddings are pushed for ( quite rightly, and I include myself in this) by the woman.

The relationship board is full of this kind of thing. It's never 'my Fiancé is so desperate to get married it's driving me nuts'

HappinesDependsOnYou · 16/01/2023 09:54

This may seem unrelated when just engaged but how would the house be divided currently if you split? Is it 50/50? Who is the higher earner of the 2 of you? If you have a baby what's the plan childcare/ return to work? If the house isn't already 50/50, you are the lower earner and you will be making the sacrifices for childcare in going part time or what ever I would have so many alarm bells ringing. The hesitation in a marriage after a decade together and having a baby first may put you in a financially difficult situation should this come to an end. An engagement gives you no legal protection and he shouldn't be hesitating when ge just proposed! It could just be that he is overwhelmed where he hasn't even seen your parents yet and it could all be innocent but be cautious

NatMoz · 16/01/2023 09:51

We had a 15 month engagement. It was just based on what was available with the venue dates wise.

I suggested the year after but my husband said no, he didn't want to wait that long🤣

FellOnMyArseToDay · 16/01/2023 09:51

saraclara · 15/01/2023 23:11

Does he even understand the concept of an engagement?
After ten years, he still thinks a wedding after being together for twelve years is 'too soon'?

We got engaged six months after our first date, and married six months after that. Together for a very happy thirtyodd years, until his far too early death from cancer.

💐 So sorry that happened.

PatientlyWaiting21 · 16/01/2023 09:48

Firstly congratulations, secondly thank goodness you managed to get that social media post out…

I don’t think two years is too soon, but I think he’s right slow down and enjoy the engagement for at least a month or something! This would annoy me too.