Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Net contributor or Burden on the state?

166 replies

Whyareblokesonhere · 15/01/2023 21:29

Am I being unreasonable to think that the vast majority of us don't believe we are 'burdens' on public money.

I earn reasonable money, around £65k per year, I assumed that would make me a net contributor, after all I seem to be paying tax left right and center, however whilst it's not actually an easy calculation, I realised today that I'm most likely a burden, mostly due to have several children.

Not a big user of anything medical aside from birth but that must skew things significantly. Two car household and household income of around £80k.

So very likely that I'm actually a burden, changes my perspective somewhat.

So AIBU to think most of us assume incorrectly that we are net contributors?

Also interested as to whether you think you are or aren't? Obviously MN is the land of ultra wealthy as we all know so not a scientific study by any stretch!

OP posts:
LatteToday · 15/01/2023 23:08

@DonutsAreNotLunch MPs being a big burden? Is that because of their big expenses? Which actually pay for their staff? So- probably 5 peoples wages?

my DH is an MP. Yes he earns £84k. And pays his taxes. As so I. He gave up a better paid job to do this. To try and make peoples lives better. So now, he has a lower income than he had, and lives away from home for 4 days a week.

overall we’re probably a burden because we use the NHS, and kids at state schools.
if we went private (to reduce that state burden) you’d shout at us for not using the state provision.

Snugglemonkey · 15/01/2023 23:04

I thought of myself and dp as contributors for years. Then we had a child with health issues that involved a highly monitored pregnancy, a very specialist delivery, a stay in NICU and special care, minor surgeries and a host of other interventions up until a major surgery. I dread to think what that cost, but he is totally grand now. Then we had a second DC. We do use a private school, but ai think given the enormous cost of my PFB, we are probably not the contributors I always imagined anymore.

Thesonglastslonger · 15/01/2023 23:03

cakeorwine · 15/01/2023 22:13

Without "the burdens", the "net contributors" wouldn't be able to earn what they earn. Society itself may not function.

We are all connected. Society would certainly notice a lack of people who were "burdens!

This. The question makes me very uncomfortable because society relies on a huge amount of work being done for free especially by middle aged women doing unpaid carer work, volunteering and fundraising so state schools can function, etc.

My grandad worked for 30 years then drew a state pension for 40+ years. Was he a burden? Or did fighting in the war cancel that out somehow?

Palmface · 15/01/2023 23:01

Surely having 2 dc isn't a burden though as it's replacing you and your partner, and they will contribute to the economy and pay taxes etc? Id see it as any more than 2dc is a burden (I have 3 dc so not judging others). My rationale for my demographic irresponsibility is that my dc and I are highly educated and earn a lot, so don't receive any childcare subsidies etc (we're in Australia), and they'll hopefully do the same. I'm generally left leaning but this makes me sound decidedly tory..

EezyOozy · 15/01/2023 22:59

I imagine we break even:

household income of 100k

lucky enough that have never claimed benefits or UC/child benefit

1 car

but

2 children, 1 c-section which probably cost the NHS a lot.

Both kids at state school

husband has a couple of minor health issues managed by medication (NHS)

DonutsAreNotLunch · 15/01/2023 22:59

I’m a massive burden. Single parent with 3 kids, claim benefits ( also work 30+ hours a week). One of my kids has long term health issue that has probably cost the NHS a fair bit over the years.
I’m pretty sure that my family is less of a financial burden than an MP though.

N00bz · 15/01/2023 22:56

Fairly sure I’m a net contributor. High household income, no children, private healthcare and dental etc., lucky to not have ever needed any form of benefits (so far).

PinkPlantCase · 15/01/2023 22:56

I’m not sure if children make you more of a burden. The country needs the population to reproduce and make the next generation of tax payers. If there aren’t enough young people to pay for the old people it all falls apart.

I know some countries like Hungary are really encouraging families to have more children. IIRC if a woman has 4 or more children she is exempt from paying income tax there for the rest of her life. So that must work out for them as a huge net contribution in making more citizens!

Believeitornot · 15/01/2023 22:56

Donkeyotey · 15/01/2023 22:49

I am a net contributor. I pay well into six figures in income tax every year, have private healthcare for the whole family and my DC are at private school. I have a pathological loathing of the idea of being dependent on anyone - including the state.

It’s weird to me. We all benefit from state funded things - some may be less obvious than others.

Believeitornot · 15/01/2023 22:55

The idea of being a burden or not is absurd.

This is our country, we are all citizens and we are worth more than our salaries.

For a start, too many people are massively underpaid and too many have hoarded a shit ton of cash. On that basis alone, I dispute the “net burden” argument.

userthrowaway · 15/01/2023 22:54

Definitely net contributor, I paid £65k in tax and NI in the last tax year.

I have private healthcare (including GP) and couldn't have kids so no births, free nursery hours or schooling to come out of the pot for me

Kokapetl · 15/01/2023 22:52

I'm not sure children's education should be taken into account as being part of the parent's calculation for burden vs contributor. Surely this would be part of each child's own calculation? If you look at it year by year, most people are probably burdens when in education, contributors while working then burdens again once retired. The whole life calculation would be more telling, I expect.

I work part time and so am not a high earner any more so am probably not a net contributor at the moment. However, I don't get any benefits, haven't needed any medical treatment recently and do pay tax. I suppose I'm using funded facilities like parks, libraries and museums though.

WinterFoxes · 15/01/2023 22:50

Paid tax on a small income for thirty years.
In that time I've had 2 DC delivered and cared for by NHS and educated free for 7 years in state schools.

So even though I'm pretty healthy and have only ever needed basic stuff from GP, I think overall so far I'm a burden, though DC might end up rich and paying the state back.

Donkeyotey · 15/01/2023 22:49

I am a net contributor. I pay well into six figures in income tax every year, have private healthcare for the whole family and my DC are at private school. I have a pathological loathing of the idea of being dependent on anyone - including the state.

EmmatheStageRat · 15/01/2023 22:47

I used to be a big contributor but then I became an adoptive parent. My elder DD is blind and has autism and ADHD, among other disabilities. My younger DD has just been diagnosed with autism and ADHD. I am a registered carer for my elder daughter but I am also responsible for looking after my very elderly mother who is housebound and has zero mobility. Honestly, I would rather go to work. Oh, and I am saving the State a huge amount of money as it costs circa £4K a week to keep a child in care.

PriOn1 · 15/01/2023 22:44

Even if money is the only factor under consideration, direct tax is not the only contribution. You also contribute through VAT, for example.

I had a conversation with a friend a while back, on a related topic. We don’t live in the UK, but there will be some crossover.

She had heard it on the news that men contributed more than women, but GP that is only true if you consider money to be the only contribution you can make to society l

My ex has contributed far more money than I have, but I’ve raised three children, who will be the ones working and supporting my generation when we get old.

The population in the country I live in is gradually aging and there are fewer children being born. The government here recognizes that parents make a huge contribution to the country and therefore help them financially, much more than in the UK.

Do you look after any aging relatives? You’re saving the state money if you help an elderly patient leave hospital so they’re not blocking beds.

Rainallnight · 15/01/2023 22:42

JaninaDuszejko · 15/01/2023 22:07

And 'burden' is the wrong word. It benefits all of us to have a system where we have minimum standards of living, free education and a healthcare service.

This, times a million. And it’s of benefit to the country to have a population that’s supported and healthy.

And there are other ways to be a burden to society than using services. Landlords who keep their mouldy flats in a state of disrepair, causing ill health to their tenants. Business who don’t pay enough for their staff to live on. And so on

But to go along with the thought experiment, I’ll say that we adopted our DC, so while having kids is ‘burdensome’, we’ve in fact saved the state hundreds of thousands in direct costs of foster care till they’re of age and the indirect costs of the generally poor outcomes for care leavers.

Bubblebubblebah · 15/01/2023 22:42

I am bit confused. I thought this is about financial overal contribution. Afaik most people are not net contributors over their lifetime.
It's nothing to do with being good or bad person. That's whole different debate about being positive contribution to society, not treasury.

Maverickess · 15/01/2023 22:38

I think financially, I definitely fall into the 'burden' camp, though in other ways I've probably 'paid in' more than those who pay in tax a month what I earn - and some of them wouldn't be able to do those jobs and earn that money if it weren't for me (and so many others) doing my (former) job.

But you're only worth anything if it's to do with money, until there's no one left to do the low paying but essential to society work and the important people who pay in more financially suddenly realise that there's no one to look after granny and they'll have to do it themselves and forgo the large salary and kudos that goes with it.

I'm so sick of people who contribute so much in human terms being written off as burdens because their contribution isn't considered financial enough and everything has to be about money and scroungers.

Phrenologistsfinger · 15/01/2023 22:37

Contributor - DP on highest tax rate and I am on high, no kids, barely use NHS (any treatment/diagnosis for autoimmune illness/tests/meds/IVF/therapy all private, rarely use A&E or GP and I miscarry at home mostly).

watchfulwishes · 15/01/2023 22:37

Lozzybear · 15/01/2023 22:35

@thatshowirolllandchips it costs the state £7k a year to educate a child. Based on an income of 45k, your annual tax won’t even cover educating both of your children:

This only takes into account direct taxation. A family generates work for teachers, carers, more shopping etc. This then generates contributions from those people.

TrodOnLegoAgain · 15/01/2023 22:36

Contributor. However it’s worth bearing in mind how things change as one ages- one can be a significant contributor while working but receive a great deal as a pensioner (especially healthcare- many people receive very little before retirement age but a great deal in the last years of life). Better to think less in terms of “them and us” and more in terms of “us now and us in future”.

Lozzybear · 15/01/2023 22:35

@thatshowirolllandchips it costs the state £7k a year to educate a child. Based on an income of 45k, your annual tax won’t even cover educating both of your children:

Georgeskitchen · 15/01/2023 22:35

I would say I was a contributor. 4 children. Worked mostly full time for 44 years.
No serious illnesses, moderate NHS user and I have also raised 4 people who are now taxpayers themselves 😀😀

watchfulwishes · 15/01/2023 22:35

Stepuptowardsinfinity · 15/01/2023 22:17

I'm definitely a net contributor. Paid hundreds of thousands in tax over the years, no kids, rarely used the NHS, never claimed any benefits etc. Bit frustrating really when I see how much everyone else takes.

This attitude is strange. Reduces all of human life to just money. Very empty approach.