Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Net contributor or Burden on the state?

166 replies

Whyareblokesonhere · 15/01/2023 21:29

Am I being unreasonable to think that the vast majority of us don't believe we are 'burdens' on public money.

I earn reasonable money, around £65k per year, I assumed that would make me a net contributor, after all I seem to be paying tax left right and center, however whilst it's not actually an easy calculation, I realised today that I'm most likely a burden, mostly due to have several children.

Not a big user of anything medical aside from birth but that must skew things significantly. Two car household and household income of around £80k.

So very likely that I'm actually a burden, changes my perspective somewhat.

So AIBU to think most of us assume incorrectly that we are net contributors?

Also interested as to whether you think you are or aren't? Obviously MN is the land of ultra wealthy as we all know so not a scientific study by any stretch!

OP posts:
pattihews · 16/01/2023 01:20

QueenOfHiraeth · 15/01/2023 23:50

There was a really interesting talk by David Willetts, ex-minister, a while ago about baby boomers. In that he said that an average person, on average pay, with average life, currently crosses from net contributor to net recipient around the age of 70.
I caught part of a debate on the radio earlier. Apparently one of the founders of Obamacare has suggested that he would not, personally, want medical treatment after age 75 as it is generally extending life, but in poor health and low quality of life. As a boomer myself, fortunately in good health so far, I do wonder if we need a mature discussion about this as I don't see how the younger generations can keep paying out more and more

Yes, I read that too and I agree. I've recently learned that someone in their 90s, with advanced dementia, has been in hospital after a fall for a month because a suitable care home can't be found. I also have a friend who, after a catastrophic accident caused massive physical injuries and brain damage, has been kept alive for 12 years so far, at £200k a year, and will probably live for another 25 years. She should have been allowed to die the day the accident happened, but the medical establishment viewed her as a challenge and decided to throw everything they could at the situation to keep her alive. The US company that built the care facility in which she now exists has built several more similar facilities here in the UK since she was injured.

pattihews · 16/01/2023 01:04

Oh, forgot to add that I consider it a privilege to pay tax. I think me and Polly Toynbee are the only ones.

pattihews · 16/01/2023 01:01

JaninaDuszejko · 15/01/2023 22:04

Isn't the cut off between 'burden' and 'net contributor' around about the 40% tax limit? There will be variations around that, mainly around healthcare and children in education but that's probably a reasonable cut off. And children are only in school for 13 years but parents are paying tax for 40 plus years.

I've read a couple of articles recently that put the cost of educating a child at state school at something like £60-65k from infants to sixth form, so the more children you have, the more burden you have. Each baby costs somewhere between £7-11k, more if there are serious complications.

I'm childfree and have been fortunate enough not to have made many calls on the NHS. I've worked so far for 43 years and paid tax every year. Higher rate for about 15 years. I'm semi-retired now: working part time and living off one of my private pension plans. I'll retire at 66 and will continue to be a tax payer. I've paid fairly large sums out in Stamp Duty and CGT over the years. Never received any benefits. I think at the moment I'm probably about even, but presumably at some point during my retirement I'll become a burden.

Aria999 · 16/01/2023 00:59

DH is a net contributor (I am just a burden on him 🤣) but we are in the US so options to be a burden are somewhat limited.

(Relatively modest) private school, private nursery, no such thing as public healthcare so employer insurance which we also pay $$$ for, we live in a too big house which seemed like a good idea at the time so pay a ton of property tax.

No, we can't really afford it.

OneHundredOtters · 16/01/2023 00:56

@Demonto sorry it should be £600000.

OneHundredOtters · 16/01/2023 00:54

@RandomCatGenerator it was definitely an article in the Times about why millennials aren't getting more right wing as they age but I can't for the life of me find it now.

pattihews · 16/01/2023 00:46

OneHundredOtters · 15/01/2023 21:45

I read the other day the the Baby boomers will on average contribute £60000 over their lifetimes and receive benefits of 1.2m. Gen Z is looking to be the other way round (adjusted for inflation)

Could you link whatever it was you read?

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 16/01/2023 00:38

Net contributor - additional rate tax payer, children educated privately and we have private healthcare. Like others I think financial contribution is only one element of contributing to society, I significant number of the so called burdens will be providing unpaid care and doing jobs that are necessary for the functioning of society.

Whyareblokesonhere · 16/01/2023 00:29

Sorry I posted then disappeared (dealing with poorly child).

Appreciate 'Burden' sounds very negative but it was the word used in articles I was reading and assume there is a specific reason for this.

Also yes I just mean financial which has minimal reflection on someone's overall contribution to society.

Personally I wish there was another way, of politics, of society, but don't have the answers, I'd just love something more equal, for all.

Thanks for the replies, I'm finding it fascinating reading the articulate, conversational posts.

And for clarity, against this financial measure I'm absolutely classing myself as a 'burden' which has just made me reflect on even more reasons I should be grateful for all I do have in life

OP posts:
Kaibashira · 16/01/2023 00:11

This is a joke / troll post, right?
This isn't how normal people think right?

PatrickBasedman · 16/01/2023 00:06

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

notangelinajolie · 15/01/2023 23:59

No clue how it’s worked out but would think I am a burden. I don’t work, SAHM & HW , don’t pay tax or NI and have been treated in A&E a few times which resulted in a few lengthy stays in hospital. Also had three babies on the NHS. Take medication for life.
DH probably a burden too. He works full time and has for over 40 years but has never earned much, certainly not enough to pay much tax. He has also been in hospital for heart surgery.
Both of us approaching 60. Neither of us claim benefits but I doubt that offsets much.

Myotherpetisamouse · 15/01/2023 23:58

I think most of the tax is raised by the top few percent and the theory is that if you tax them too much they’ll have the resources and the means to move elsewhere?

QueenOfHiraeth · 15/01/2023 23:50

There was a really interesting talk by David Willetts, ex-minister, a while ago about baby boomers. In that he said that an average person, on average pay, with average life, currently crosses from net contributor to net recipient around the age of 70.
I caught part of a debate on the radio earlier. Apparently one of the founders of Obamacare has suggested that he would not, personally, want medical treatment after age 75 as it is generally extending life, but in poor health and low quality of life. As a boomer myself, fortunately in good health so far, I do wonder if we need a mature discussion about this as I don't see how the younger generations can keep paying out more and more

Starseeking · 15/01/2023 23:39

I've been a higher earner since 2006, additional rate since 2016, never claimed any income benefits, or lived in a council or social house, I live in a mortgaged hone.

Had 2 DC in the last 7 years, both with non-surgical births, went home on day 2 and same day. Wasn't entitled to 30 hours due to salary level, both DC went to a private nursery. One DC has additional needs which they receive DLA for, however the annual DLA received is probably a quarter of my monthly net pay. DC is at a specialist school, which would obviously increase the amount I take from the system.

However, overall, given everything above, I believe I would be a net contributor.

sst1234 · 15/01/2023 23:37

cakeorwine · 15/01/2023 23:27

Your world must be a sad place to live in

It’s called reality. You know the one where there is a thing called the economy. And productivity. And finances. And GDP. Not resources produced by unicorns.

cakeorwine · 15/01/2023 23:27

sst1234 · 15/01/2023 23:23

That’s what people like to think. Net beneficiaries are not adding anything to the system other than being vessels for recycling other people money. If they didn’t exist, the system would find another way to move money around the economy. And productivity would be higher as cheap labour would be replaced by automation.

Your world must be a sad place to live in

sst1234 · 15/01/2023 23:27

The worrying thing is that the number of net contributors is shrinking. As is the number of wealthy people in this country. What we are starting to be left with is the more and more net recipients, fighting over less and less of other people’s contribution. It’s what happens when you take more and more from net contributors without them getting anything in return.

sst1234 · 15/01/2023 23:23

cakeorwine · 15/01/2023 22:13

Without "the burdens", the "net contributors" wouldn't be able to earn what they earn. Society itself may not function.

We are all connected. Society would certainly notice a lack of people who were "burdens!

That’s what people like to think. Net beneficiaries are not adding anything to the system other than being vessels for recycling other people money. If they didn’t exist, the system would find another way to move money around the economy. And productivity would be higher as cheap labour would be replaced by automation.

Nimbostratus100 · 15/01/2023 23:21

But its not just financial, is it, taking on caring roles in the family, doing voluntry work, looking after your health, supporting British charities and businesses etc it would be very difficult to calculate the worth of some of this

ThreeFeetTall · 15/01/2023 23:19

I would imagine most individuals are 'burdens' but that's fine, tax is also collected from businesses and other transactions. It doesn't mean those that are contributors are supporting all the others!

KimberleyClark · 15/01/2023 23:17

Surely having 2 dc isn't a burden though as it's replacing you and your partner, and they will contribute to the economy and pay taxes etc?

what if they emigrate?

I have no children. Never been a high earner. Took early retirement after 40 years of paying tax, but not yet claiming state pension. Use NHS for routine stuff and my thyroid. Burden probably.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 15/01/2023 23:16

I don’t like the word “burden” here. Makes it sound unwanted or an imposition.

As a society we have agreed to pool resources to benefit the whole and as such we all have a right (but perhaps not a need) to receive support from that pool. It’s actually beautiful that we do this, and I think we should do it even more.

Nobody is a burden.

caringcarer · 15/01/2023 23:13

I don't think I used to be a burden. I had 3 DC and got child benefit but never claimed any other benefits ever and always worked full time and paid tax and DH too. Now I have poor health so several prescriptions which I get free as have thyroid problems and mobility issues, and although I still work full time self employed I now claim PIP. I wish I did not have too and had better health. My dh cares for me but as he still works full time he does not claim Carers allowance. We will be selling a btl house in April and will be paying a lot of Capital Gains Tax.

allthegoodusernameshavegone · 15/01/2023 23:11

I think I am a contributor. 40% tax payer most of my working life until 5 years ago, now much lower nhs salary. No children, never been unemployed therefore never claimed any allowance, I use the nhs every three years for a cervical smear and last year I had a drs appointment for hrt, ah that May now make me a burden as I only pay the prescription charge on my patches rather than the total cost whatever that might be. Of course I was educated foc for 14 years but my taxes as an adult should counteract that. I will of course, if I live long enough hopefully get my state pension at 68. I have a private pension that will hopefully let me cut down my working days per week when I’m 55 because quite frankly I am knackered.