Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Net contributor or Burden on the state?

166 replies

Whyareblokesonhere · 15/01/2023 21:29

Am I being unreasonable to think that the vast majority of us don't believe we are 'burdens' on public money.

I earn reasonable money, around £65k per year, I assumed that would make me a net contributor, after all I seem to be paying tax left right and center, however whilst it's not actually an easy calculation, I realised today that I'm most likely a burden, mostly due to have several children.

Not a big user of anything medical aside from birth but that must skew things significantly. Two car household and household income of around £80k.

So very likely that I'm actually a burden, changes my perspective somewhat.

So AIBU to think most of us assume incorrectly that we are net contributors?

Also interested as to whether you think you are or aren't? Obviously MN is the land of ultra wealthy as we all know so not a scientific study by any stretch!

OP posts:
nutbrownhare15 · 16/01/2023 12:30

There are ways to contribute to society beyond finances

fitzwilliamdarcy · 16/01/2023 11:34

I’m not sure where I stand. Higher rate tax payer for over half my working life, no kids, both of which would indicate that I’m a contributor. Never claimed any benefits either. However, I nearly died and had a significant surgery on the NHS so maybe not.

I agree that having kids is determinative in most cases though.

LavenderHillMob · 16/01/2023 11:18

Having worked in the public sector - this complicates the calculation. Do you include the incomes of those paid by the state out of taxes? And do you count the taxes of those paid out of taxes?

Or do you look at an expenditure approach and agree that spending contributes to the economy?

I personally believe in the social contract of taxation and would prefer to pay more for better services and a safety net.

SparklyLeprechaun · 16/01/2023 11:00

Net contributor, probably. High income, no benefits, kids in private school, private healthcare, although we have been to A&E a few times and have an NHS GP (which we see maybe once a year), and the kids have free NHS dental treatment (so far only used for checkups). 2 x childbirth on the NHS.

AmeliaEarhart · 16/01/2023 10:43

Ha! I once got called a “Tory moron” on here for pointing out that there were such things as net contributors and net beneficiaries. It was years ago and I’m still sore about it! I’ve never voted Tory in my life, I was just pointing our that higher rate tax payers were paying for their own child benefit (back when there was such a thing for that group).

Anyway, “burden” is obviously a very emotive word, but technically that’s what I am as an individual. As a household, we’re not.

pattihews · 16/01/2023 10:42

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/01/2023 10:13

I am a net contributor. I pay well into six figures in income tax every year, have private healthcare for the whole family and my DC are at private school. I have a pathological loathing of the idea of being dependent on anyone - including the state

Don't use roads?
Don't use energy?
Don't use water?
Don't use supermarkets?
Build and service your own car?
Produce your own fuel?

Of course you're dependent on people, hundreds if not thousands of them.

That poster means she's not financially dependent on the state, which is what we're discussing here — finances. She pays for water, she pays for energy, she pays for her supermarket shop etc. She isn't depending on the state or others to pick up the tab.

WinterFoxes · 16/01/2023 10:31

QueenOfHiraeth · 15/01/2023 23:50

There was a really interesting talk by David Willetts, ex-minister, a while ago about baby boomers. In that he said that an average person, on average pay, with average life, currently crosses from net contributor to net recipient around the age of 70.
I caught part of a debate on the radio earlier. Apparently one of the founders of Obamacare has suggested that he would not, personally, want medical treatment after age 75 as it is generally extending life, but in poor health and low quality of life. As a boomer myself, fortunately in good health so far, I do wonder if we need a mature discussion about this as I don't see how the younger generations can keep paying out more and more

I agree. We need this conversation. Both my parents were hauled back from the brink of death in their seventies , only to limp along for another ten years (dad) at a massive cost to the NHS in constant pain, losing all friends as he could no longer socialise, while my mum has declined into dementia and is now in a care home at 1.5k a week, bored and lonely and confused.

I have made it very clear to DC that if any serious illness befalls me after 70, I don;t want to be cured, just palliative care. It's caring for the elderly boomers into their 90s that has brought the NHS to its knees.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/01/2023 10:13

I am a net contributor. I pay well into six figures in income tax every year, have private healthcare for the whole family and my DC are at private school. I have a pathological loathing of the idea of being dependent on anyone - including the state

Don't use roads?
Don't use energy?
Don't use water?
Don't use supermarkets?
Build and service your own car?
Produce your own fuel?

Of course you're dependent on people, hundreds if not thousands of them.

Donkeyotey · 16/01/2023 10:13

QueenOfHiraeth · 15/01/2023 23:50

There was a really interesting talk by David Willetts, ex-minister, a while ago about baby boomers. In that he said that an average person, on average pay, with average life, currently crosses from net contributor to net recipient around the age of 70.
I caught part of a debate on the radio earlier. Apparently one of the founders of Obamacare has suggested that he would not, personally, want medical treatment after age 75 as it is generally extending life, but in poor health and low quality of life. As a boomer myself, fortunately in good health so far, I do wonder if we need a mature discussion about this as I don't see how the younger generations can keep paying out more and more

I agree 100%.

LemonTT · 16/01/2023 10:10

RandomCatGenerator · 15/01/2023 22:06

Ooh do you have a source? That sounds really interesting.

It’s is obviously ridiculous. There is no way that with income tax, road tax, VAT, NI and every other form of tax that this would be right.

Curledupwithagoodbook · 16/01/2023 10:03

OneHundredOtters · 15/01/2023 21:45

I read the other day the the Baby boomers will on average contribute £60000 over their lifetimes and receive benefits of 1.2m. Gen Z is looking to be the other way round (adjusted for inflation)

I don't think those figures are correct.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 16/01/2023 09:12

Bit frustrating really when I see how much everyone else takes

So sorry that us 'burdens' are having the cheek to use your NHS. Ask the govt nicely, they might give you your own burden free hospital.

Whyareblokesonhere · 16/01/2023 08:58

totally agree there is no need to feel guilty, whilst I wouldn't wish illness on anyone this is surely the positive side of our system

OP posts:
RandomCatGenerator · 16/01/2023 07:54

CoorieInByTheFire · 16/01/2023 01:29

Burden.

I’ve been ill all my life and could only work a short while as an adult. I’ve cost the NHS so much and I feel very guilty about it a lot. I’ve also lived longer than expected so that’s added to the amount I’ve cost. I don’t feel like I’ve been able to give back or contribute much at all really.

Don’t feel guilty - it isn’t your fault you were ill 💐

SleeplessInEngland · 16/01/2023 07:53

Depends. Arguably having children is (potentially) contributing to future tax bases so some economists might see that as a net benefit within reason.

Myotherpetisamouse · 16/01/2023 07:51

AlmostAJillSandwich · 16/01/2023 02:22

Burden, and hate it! Triggered with severe OCD aged 5, that got worse as i got older. By 15 i ws completely housebound, had to drop out of school, and have been on disability since my 16th birthday. Throw in developing depression and PTSD, i've never been well enough to work. With the few scraped GCSE passes i got, and no work history, even if i was magically well tomorrow, i'd struggle to get offered a job.

Isn’t there a link between strep throat and OCD? I’m sure I read something to that effect a few years ago.

stepstepstep · 16/01/2023 06:39

The taxes you pay are only part of your contribution though, there are all sort of work that are unpaid (caring particularly) that saves the state money.

Also don’t forget that if you work, your labour allows you employer to generate wealth (some of which is taxed) and grows the economy as a whole.

The point of taxes is to pool risk and benefit, none of us know if we might fall on hard times & need the state to protect us. Also it’s hard to measure the benefit of public services, for example roads. Education has a personal benefit & an economic one (an educated workforce).

TLDR: looking at your status on a cash-based net basis doesn’t make any sense, that’s not how public finances work!

Throwncrumbs · 16/01/2023 05:58

OneHundredOtters · 15/01/2023 21:45

I read the other day the the Baby boomers will on average contribute £60000 over their lifetimes and receive benefits of 1.2m. Gen Z is looking to be the other way round (adjusted for inflation)

One day your kids will be paying for you, with inflation going up you will be more of a burden than any baby boomer ever will!

thatshowirolllandchips · 16/01/2023 05:57

Lozzybear · 15/01/2023 22:35

@thatshowirolllandchips it costs the state £7k a year to educate a child. Based on an income of 45k, your annual tax won’t even cover educating both of your children:

Hah shows what I know then! Neither in school yet so maybe currently around zero? Or maybe I'm kidding myself completely. It's easy to think that if you're not on benefits you must be contributing but clearly there's much more to it than that.

GoldCherub · 16/01/2023 02:49

A person can’t be valued on what they contribute in taxes or what they rely on to live or be healthy the scope is too narrow and meaningless.

AlmostAJillSandwich · 16/01/2023 02:23

I can only hope donating my organs when my time comes, makes up somewhat,.

AlmostAJillSandwich · 16/01/2023 02:22

Burden, and hate it! Triggered with severe OCD aged 5, that got worse as i got older. By 15 i ws completely housebound, had to drop out of school, and have been on disability since my 16th birthday. Throw in developing depression and PTSD, i've never been well enough to work. With the few scraped GCSE passes i got, and no work history, even if i was magically well tomorrow, i'd struggle to get offered a job.

DdraigGoch · 16/01/2023 02:13

I earn about £50k (so just below the 40p threshold) and have no kids. My only contact with the NHS is covid boosters. I ride a bike so while I don't pay fuel duty etc. I'm also not wearing out the roads. I'd imagine that I'm roughly even with the state on an annual basis.

That said, surely my education is something that the state has paid for, how long will it take to effectively repay that investment back to the state in tax? At some point I will draw a state pension and incur other costs relating to old age. How much will I need to pay the state now so that it can afford to look after me then? Yes I know that it doesn't really work like that, I'm paying for the last generation, and the next generation will pay for me but it's an interesting philosophical quandary.

So I think that nearly everyone will be a net burden over the whole course of their lives, and that because there won't be enough contributors to match this the entire Ponzi scheme will collapse eventually.

ArcticSkewer · 16/01/2023 01:43

The state needs people to exist. I see my children as part of my contribution rather than a burden. In other European states I would get tax benefits for having a few of them. It'll happen here as well eventually - the replacement rate isn't high enough and immigration brings its own problems.

Then I put my own education rather than that of my children as part of my cost.

So, op, I would be more optimistic in your shoes.

The general calculation is around £50k pp I think to tip into net contributor.

For the nhs we all usually do quite well and are net contributors until the last two years of life, when the NHS ends up throwing money at keeping us going.

There is a lot of research available on all this. It's interesting.

CoorieInByTheFire · 16/01/2023 01:29

Burden.

I’ve been ill all my life and could only work a short while as an adult. I’ve cost the NHS so much and I feel very guilty about it a lot. I’ve also lived longer than expected so that’s added to the amount I’ve cost. I don’t feel like I’ve been able to give back or contribute much at all really.