Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Net contributor or Burden on the state?

166 replies

Whyareblokesonhere · 15/01/2023 21:29

Am I being unreasonable to think that the vast majority of us don't believe we are 'burdens' on public money.

I earn reasonable money, around £65k per year, I assumed that would make me a net contributor, after all I seem to be paying tax left right and center, however whilst it's not actually an easy calculation, I realised today that I'm most likely a burden, mostly due to have several children.

Not a big user of anything medical aside from birth but that must skew things significantly. Two car household and household income of around £80k.

So very likely that I'm actually a burden, changes my perspective somewhat.

So AIBU to think most of us assume incorrectly that we are net contributors?

Also interested as to whether you think you are or aren't? Obviously MN is the land of ultra wealthy as we all know so not a scientific study by any stretch!

OP posts:
pattihews · 16/01/2023 14:45

SleepingStandingUp · 16/01/2023 14:19

Anything to back up your claim that 1 in to to 1 in 5 people do nothing but cause disruption I n school, ruin their neighbours lives, live off petty or worse crime and then spawn another generation who follow their path? I'd be interested in the research.

This also ignores the fact that many of us who work and pay taxes are also good citizens, do voluntary work and look after elderly parents etc.

Dogsandbabies · 16/01/2023 14:41

Interesting thread OP!

I am calculating I am a contributor. Didn't grow up here so never used services including education here. Earn well at 85k. I do have 3 children using most services but also using private medical services.

Would be interesting to consider their output too in this. I am hoping that they will one day contribute a lot and therefore lead to a net contribution overall.

Sirius3030 · 16/01/2023 14:27

HundredMilesAnHour · 15/01/2023 22:04

I imagine that I'm a net contributor. Higher/top rate taxpayer for years, no children, private healthcare (including GP) for years. Occasional car use (mostly I walk).

Don’t kid yourself. Much of the governments revenue comes from corporation tax etc which then gets distributed through various routes to its citizenry. You have been using the nations assets and infrastructure for years. When you retire you will be even more dependent on the state. (As in, if there was no state, could you survive?).
The same goes for most, if not all, of us.

SleepingStandingUp · 16/01/2023 14:19

JoonT · 16/01/2023 13:56

You could cost the state money, but give back in other ways. For example, you could raise three children on benefits, but do a superb job. You could raise them to be polite, civilized, and hard-working. You could teach them to treat others with respect, value art and beauty, give something back to society, and so on. If those kids all go on to study physics and engineering and biochemistry at Cambridge, and then stay in the UK, where they work in cutting-edge labs, generating loads of money for the UK economy, etc, you'd be a net contributor.

In fact, even your general conduct matters. So you could be on benefits, never work and produce no children. But, you might be kind and polite to your neighbors, thus helping to raise the general quality of life in your area (albeit in a very small way). Or you might look after your sister's kids every day so she can go and work for an engineering firm that makes and sells stuff to China. You might care for your elderly mother, so she doesn't burden the NHS. Even taking care of your own health contributes to society. A health freak will live longer and get fewer chronic illnesses, and so won't burden the hospitals.

The problem is the large minority who really are a drain. Around 10 to 20% of the population do nothing but harm. They disrupt lessons at school, holding other kids back. They ruin their neighbour's lives, causing them stress and insomnia and affecting their ability to work and raise their own kids. They drift into petty crime or become addicts (or both). Then they produce another generation exactly like themselves, and the whole nightmare continues. And the worst thing of all is that it's always the worst people, the most violent and uncivilized, who have the most kids. No one knows what to do with them. Both the left and the right have utterly failed. Nothing works. Unless you are prepared to stop them having kids, you just have to live with it and pray they never move next door.

Anything to back up your claim that 1 in to to 1 in 5 people do nothing but cause disruption I n school, ruin their neighbours lives, live off petty or worse crime and then spawn another generation who follow their path? I'd be interested in the research.

SleepingStandingUp · 16/01/2023 14:17

Stepuptowardsinfinity · 16/01/2023 14:09

You know nothing about my life. Actually I have a very low income job now though I didn't years ago. I also have a voluntary position at a health company so contribute that way as well. I live very simply, not asking anything from anyone. I have health issues to do with mental health and fatigue but nothing the NHS can help with. I had a scholarship to a private school so the government hasn't even paid for that.

Please don't assume I'm sitting here from the lofty position of a high salary because that's not the truth.

If you're on a very low income job then you're not a net contributor. You have access to the NHS and the basic cost of your access even if you don't use it beyond being born. You use bins and roads and pavements, walk though public parks etc. And honestly unless someone is exceptionally wealthy you can't assume your lifetime will even out as a contributor because you have no idea what you'll need tomorrow or in your old age.

So yes. If you're complaining about how unfair it is you don't get to take more from the system rather than say a specific complaint that the NHS won't help you with your health needs, then I'll stick to taking umbrage at your complaints about people like me using up your tax payments

nonevernotever · 16/01/2023 14:10

I'm also not convinced by a PPs suggestion that 10-20% of the population do nothing but harm.! No figures to hand, but I would be astonished if it was anything like that high.

Stepuptowardsinfinity · 16/01/2023 14:09

SleepingStandingUp · 16/01/2023 13:05

Frustrating that you have a well paid job, that you aren't disabled to a level where you cannot work, that you aren't called upon to be a carer for someone meaning you can't work, that you haven't by no fault of your own ended up losing your job, your home etc? You're right, your life sounds so hard. I recommend quitting an getting a job as a TA perhaps or a carer. Then you too can be a burden on the state and live happily ever after.

You know nothing about my life. Actually I have a very low income job now though I didn't years ago. I also have a voluntary position at a health company so contribute that way as well. I live very simply, not asking anything from anyone. I have health issues to do with mental health and fatigue but nothing the NHS can help with. I had a scholarship to a private school so the government hasn't even paid for that.

Please don't assume I'm sitting here from the lofty position of a high salary because that's not the truth.

nonevernotever · 16/01/2023 14:07

Not rtft so apologies if this has already been said, but I don't honestly see how such a complex calculation could be readily done. And how do you decide what counts? Does my NHS (and complicated) birth accrue to my account or my mother's / father's? Or both?Presumably my education counts towards mine. As a civil servant, and therefore paid for from the public purse does my salary count as part of what I get from the state, or can I offset my labour against that? Does it make a difference if I buy the majority of my non-essential purchases overseas so contributing differently to UK coffers? And what about the people who pay cash in hand to tradesmen?

Isleoftights · 16/01/2023 14:02

JoonT
The problem is the large minority who really are a drain. Around 10 to 20% of the population do nothing but harm.

So true.

Isleoftights · 16/01/2023 13:59

7.7 million of the 12.5 million State pensioners in the UK pay income tax - but an additional two million more will pay income tax by April 2026, as tax thresholds are frozen until then. So by April 2026, approximately two-thirds of pensioners will pay some income tax.

JoonT · 16/01/2023 13:56

You could cost the state money, but give back in other ways. For example, you could raise three children on benefits, but do a superb job. You could raise them to be polite, civilized, and hard-working. You could teach them to treat others with respect, value art and beauty, give something back to society, and so on. If those kids all go on to study physics and engineering and biochemistry at Cambridge, and then stay in the UK, where they work in cutting-edge labs, generating loads of money for the UK economy, etc, you'd be a net contributor.

In fact, even your general conduct matters. So you could be on benefits, never work and produce no children. But, you might be kind and polite to your neighbors, thus helping to raise the general quality of life in your area (albeit in a very small way). Or you might look after your sister's kids every day so she can go and work for an engineering firm that makes and sells stuff to China. You might care for your elderly mother, so she doesn't burden the NHS. Even taking care of your own health contributes to society. A health freak will live longer and get fewer chronic illnesses, and so won't burden the hospitals.

The problem is the large minority who really are a drain. Around 10 to 20% of the population do nothing but harm. They disrupt lessons at school, holding other kids back. They ruin their neighbour's lives, causing them stress and insomnia and affecting their ability to work and raise their own kids. They drift into petty crime or become addicts (or both). Then they produce another generation exactly like themselves, and the whole nightmare continues. And the worst thing of all is that it's always the worst people, the most violent and uncivilized, who have the most kids. No one knows what to do with them. Both the left and the right have utterly failed. Nothing works. Unless you are prepared to stop them having kids, you just have to live with it and pray they never move next door.

Isleoftights · 16/01/2023 13:51

Yes, includes people of pensionable age - pensioners, like anyone else are liable to pay income tax.

Teder · 16/01/2023 13:42

Isleoftights · 16/01/2023 13:11

The top 1% of earners pay 28% of all income tax.
The top 5% of earners pay 48% of all income tax.
37% of UK adults pay no income tax.

Does the 37% include people of pensionable age?

Isleoftights · 16/01/2023 13:11

The top 1% of earners pay 28% of all income tax.
The top 5% of earners pay 48% of all income tax.
37% of UK adults pay no income tax.

SleepingStandingUp · 16/01/2023 13:05

Stepuptowardsinfinity · 15/01/2023 22:17

I'm definitely a net contributor. Paid hundreds of thousands in tax over the years, no kids, rarely used the NHS, never claimed any benefits etc. Bit frustrating really when I see how much everyone else takes.

Frustrating that you have a well paid job, that you aren't disabled to a level where you cannot work, that you aren't called upon to be a carer for someone meaning you can't work, that you haven't by no fault of your own ended up losing your job, your home etc? You're right, your life sounds so hard. I recommend quitting an getting a job as a TA perhaps or a carer. Then you too can be a burden on the state and live happily ever after.

Marchmount · 16/01/2023 13:03

Totally agree @WinterFoxes. My grandfather was brought back from the brink when he was in his 80s due to agressive medical treatment. He went on to live for another few years in constant pain and struggling for breath. My whole family is in agreement that we don’t want that for us.

Beezknees · 16/01/2023 12:58

I'm definitely not a net contributer, but I don't think of myself as a burden on the state, I work full time and am economically active.

SleepingStandingUp · 16/01/2023 12:57

pattihews · 16/01/2023 12:35

Would you elaborate? All I can think of is volunteering and if you can volunteer you can work.

I volunteer now four weekends a year. One in March, one in April, one in May, one in October. Also do some online meetings once a month. And some extra work around that mainly over the summer but it's a few hours here and there deadlines but on my timescales. If you can find me a job where I can do those hours and get paid, sign me up!!

Believeitornot · 16/01/2023 12:49

pattihews · 16/01/2023 12:35

Would you elaborate? All I can think of is volunteering and if you can volunteer you can work.

Because there’s a naive assumption that lower paid people are paid a fair wage.

They absolutely are not. So any questions about burden are bullshit.

MilkyYay · 16/01/2023 12:46

But agree with pp, tax contribution is not the only one. Some key workers are hugely underpaid, plenty of private sector workers overpaid.

SleepingStandingUp · 16/01/2023 12:45

Wallywobbles · 15/01/2023 22:03

How do you work out what to include? Costs etc. Is there a calculator somewhere (and if not, why not?).

Surely more, why would you want one?

DS earns 30k, I don't work. Two pregnancies but twins so get tax credits for all 3, dla for DS, carers for me, 18 months of hospitalizations and operations for DS and continues medical support altho down to a few hospital visits a year.

Would it help you if I flagellate myself on the alter of state burden? Would it help you if I told my son he's essentially the reason we're such a burden as I worked before him? Perhaps some sort of badge so you know who we are?

MilkyYay · 16/01/2023 12:45

Yup. Ive got a mate who goes on and on about how much she contributes (about 5k a year in tax). She has no clue of the huge extent to which very high earners contribute.

QuertyGirl · 16/01/2023 12:42

This is far too simplistic to mean anything.

nutbrownhare15 · 16/01/2023 12:40

The NHS consultant upthread. Nurses on relatively low wages who according to this calculation would be seen as a 'burden' when in fact they are performing an essential service keeping people alive (and working if you want to put it in those terms). People who are supporting their friends and families emotionally. Legions of unpaid carers of disabled people and children. Teachers educating the next generation. I'm just saying you can't put whether someone is a 'burden' in solely financial terms as people contribute to society through the work (often unpaid) they do and the relationships they maintain.

pattihews · 16/01/2023 12:35

nutbrownhare15 · 16/01/2023 12:30

There are ways to contribute to society beyond finances

Would you elaborate? All I can think of is volunteering and if you can volunteer you can work.