Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do people realise there's more housework if you're a SAHP?

165 replies

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 20:54

Just that. I'm not denying the difficulty of juggling work and home responsibilities, but I often see people on here say stuff like "I manage AND hold down a job, so how can you possibly be struggling?"

Being at home all day with small children creates mess. You can get odd things done, but you can't properly clean your house with toddlers and babies around. Especially if they're terrible nappers. I have to clean when the kids are asleep, the same as working parents, and everything is messier than it would be if nobody was home all day.

Now I'm also doing paid work after kids' bedtime the only possible option is having a cleaner. There's literally not time otherwise.

I'm not complaining about my lot in general. I think there's a lot that's harder about juggling nursery runs, commutes, appointments, kids sick days and so on if you are out of the house, but this particular point really bugs me.

OP posts:
ShellsPebbles · 15/01/2023 21:31

People who slag off SAHPs by saying they are full time parents AND go out to work full time make me laugh. They didn’t actually experience that until they were juggling WFH and their kids during the lockdowns - and most complained about it.
Of course there is more work involved. Full time workers leave the mess for their childminders to clear up. One book before bed and making their kids tea doesn’t compare even slightly.

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 21:31

BeGentlePeeps · 15/01/2023 21:24

Bit off the OP topic but I was chatting to a work colleague about this- she has a toddler and I have 7&10yo boys.

The chat was about when and how we got housework done. We both work 4 days/ week- my days are longer (0800-1830) as I am older/ more senior in role and she has trainee protected hours (0900-1700). Much of my midweek day off is spent catching up with admin work tasks I haven’t managed to do during my paid working hours.

My colleague said she quite enjoyed a leisurely Saturday clean with her 18mo old pottering alongside her and ‘helping’ her.

She was horrified when I described the weekend roster with 2 older fairly active sporty boys- playing taxi from 0900 till 1600 from club to club, match to match, swim training etc etc, other kids from village calling in to hangout etc. Plus vast quantities of extra laundry once kids are in uniforms, sports gear, twice weekly swimming kit etc.

Not complaining! It’s a lot of fun. But there is definitely something to be said for being at home and having the opportunity to stick in the extra load of washing/ hang it/ put away etc.

I got a cleaner as soon as it transpired I was not going to be home even on the days not at work. OMG that feeling, one day a week, when you come home and the cleaners have been 😍😍😍 which lasts for about an hour before it’s a shit tip again.

My house was undoubtedly cleaner and tidier when I was on mat leave and home all the time with kids. But I found the Groundhog Day nature of keeping on top of it extremely tedious and much more tiring than a day at work and ‘dropping my expectations of myself’ when it came to housework.

I couldn't do proper cleaning with kids alongside. Not something like a thorough go at the bathrooms. Younger one is terrified of the hoover which doesn't help either.

The things I manage with them are basic food prep, loading and unloading dishwasher, wiping down surfaces. Maybe quickly sweeping up if there's a really urgent mess. Putting on washes and hanging them to dry. Often I'm being screamed at while doing some of this. My one-year-old is going through a phase of wanting to be held all the time, my three-year-old can sometimes do similar almost in competition with her. It's just honestly a lot.

It's not the same as having to get out of the house 5 mornings a week. I think I'd find that stressful, knowing how hard it can be to mobilise some days. But I'm quite enjoying doing some paid work 3 evenings a week, when I have a valid reason not to be thinking about or doing anything domestic.

OP posts:
Wavescrashingonthebeach · 15/01/2023 21:30

I got a cleaner as soon as it transpired I was not going to be home even on the days not at work. OMG that feeling, one day a week, when you come home and the cleaners have been 😍😍😍 which lasts for about an hour before it’s a shit tip again.

This is what I'm craving! I only work part time so trying to use the fact I'm a single Mum and training for a new career as an excuse for one to come now and then.

Summersolargirl · 15/01/2023 21:29

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 21:23

My three-year-old is at nursery a couple of days now, and the days when she's not home there's less to clean up in the evening than other days. I can also get bit more done with just the baby, despite the fact she'll only nap in the pram.

I'm not trying to say my life is harder than that of working parents. I think it has its own challenges, but I've chosen it precisely because I see the advantages. I just think it's obvious that somewhere gets dirtier if a couple of tiny hooligans are creating havoc all day vs if they only have a couple of hours there.

It's definitely easier for me to keep on top of laundry as I can do several loads in a day if there's a backlog.

Surely you can do laundry with the kids in the house and awake? Unless you’re washing by hand?

you can put clothes in the machine and also fold and pile,laundry with kids around, it is not a task one needs to be left alone for?

DuplicateUserName · 15/01/2023 21:28

I was a SAHM for 12 years and I'm going to be honest, I thought a bit like you at the time OP.

I'd 'list' things like wiping up food after the kids ate their lunch amongst other things, but I feel a bit embarrassed now looking back as it takes minutes doesn't it really?

Looking back I loved those days and wouldn't have swapped them for the world, but I got a bit lazy and the less I did, the less I wanted to do if I'm 100% honest.

I work better under pressure but when I was at home, there was no-one to put me under any.

Just enjoy your time at home, ignore others and what they do, and don't forget to make sure your husband pitches in during some of his time at home.

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 15/01/2023 21:27

The parents saying their child creates a mess an hour in the morning and an hour after nursery. Add another 8 hours of mess-making opportunity and honestly it's like a bomb has gone off haha. I feel like atlas pushing the stone up the hill only for it to roll back down.
There's definitely more laundry, rubbish to take out, and dishes to be done. I used to have most of my meals in the office using their plates and their dishwasher, I'd only ever need to wash the big pan I'd cooked in and my tupperware went in the work dishwasher too.
And there does tend to be more messy play as you are constantly thinking of something new to do with them.
There's pros and cons of both and imo it's not a competition. Parenting is hard work for all of us. But the best things in life are hard work and I love my son more than life itself.
I am tempted to treat myself to a cleaner now and then though. Imagine taking DS out for the day and coming home to a nice shiny clean home. Does this mean I'm old now I dream of this over new shoes?!

BeGentlePeeps · 15/01/2023 21:24

Bit off the OP topic but I was chatting to a work colleague about this- she has a toddler and I have 7&10yo boys.

The chat was about when and how we got housework done. We both work 4 days/ week- my days are longer (0800-1830) as I am older/ more senior in role and she has trainee protected hours (0900-1700). Much of my midweek day off is spent catching up with admin work tasks I haven’t managed to do during my paid working hours.

My colleague said she quite enjoyed a leisurely Saturday clean with her 18mo old pottering alongside her and ‘helping’ her.

She was horrified when I described the weekend roster with 2 older fairly active sporty boys- playing taxi from 0900 till 1600 from club to club, match to match, swim training etc etc, other kids from village calling in to hangout etc. Plus vast quantities of extra laundry once kids are in uniforms, sports gear, twice weekly swimming kit etc.

Not complaining! It’s a lot of fun. But there is definitely something to be said for being at home and having the opportunity to stick in the extra load of washing/ hang it/ put away etc.

I got a cleaner as soon as it transpired I was not going to be home even on the days not at work. OMG that feeling, one day a week, when you come home and the cleaners have been 😍😍😍 which lasts for about an hour before it’s a shit tip again.

My house was undoubtedly cleaner and tidier when I was on mat leave and home all the time with kids. But I found the Groundhog Day nature of keeping on top of it extremely tedious and much more tiring than a day at work and ‘dropping my expectations of myself’ when it came to housework.

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 21:23

My three-year-old is at nursery a couple of days now, and the days when she's not home there's less to clean up in the evening than other days. I can also get bit more done with just the baby, despite the fact she'll only nap in the pram.

I'm not trying to say my life is harder than that of working parents. I think it has its own challenges, but I've chosen it precisely because I see the advantages. I just think it's obvious that somewhere gets dirtier if a couple of tiny hooligans are creating havoc all day vs if they only have a couple of hours there.

It's definitely easier for me to keep on top of laundry as I can do several loads in a day if there's a backlog.

OP posts:
My2pence2day · 15/01/2023 21:20

Why can't these ever just be discussions? I genuinely like to hear other perspectives on things. Why does it always have to be an argument, and someone has to be on a 'side' where one side is better than another? I don't get it 😪

Waspsnbees · 15/01/2023 21:19

it depends on how many kids and how long they're in childcare. my eldest was up and out in the mornings, childcare from 8:30-5:30, home, dinner, bath, little play, bed. no time for mess!
whereas if kids are home longer they'll make more mess.
but no, nowhere near as much mess as 4 kids home all day. especially when there's a baby/small child who doesn't allow for cleaning constantly.

Babyclb · 15/01/2023 21:17

I find it much easier to have a tidy house on a weekend compared to a working day even if I’m parenting alone, so for me it would be easier to keep the house tidy if I was a sahm. That’s not going to be universal but it seems like it’s not an uncommon view.
I also had so much more time to clean during maternity leaves and the house was a lot more organised.

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 21:17

sst1234 · 15/01/2023 21:13

Why are SAHP so insecure? OP’s tone is so defensive and odd. You always get these threads accusing working parents of calling SAHP names. In reality, I’ve never seen or heard any working parent do this. The lady doth protest too much.

I don't want to point to the specific thing that triggered this post and make it a thread about a thread, but it's a sentiment I've seen repeatedly. I'm defensive because of some of the hostility on here!

OP posts:
Spendonsend · 15/01/2023 21:16

I suppose I found it messier because nursery did activities and did the food with my children on nursery days wheras at home days I did activities and food with them. You dont need to paint, cook or make dens etc if they do all that at nursery but if there isnt anyone else doing that sort of thing, its quite nice to - even if its a choice.

Yesthatismychildsigh · 15/01/2023 21:16

😂 oh come on. I don’t know why you’re trying to justify your choices.

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 21:15

DistantSkye · 15/01/2023 21:12

I don't think being a sahm is lazy! But I don't necessarily think it's "more housework". You mention being able to get those odd things done here and there - that's exactly the type of thing you can't get done when you're working out of the home. So popping on a load of laundry, spending 15 mins putting dishes away, hoovering, getting dinner ready... Those are exactly the kind of things you can do during the day when at home with kids (or at least I can, I know everyone's different) - when I'm at work I can't, and it gets done before or after work.

Yeah, that's absolutely a benefit. I recognise the advantages to my situation. I'm doing it because I see advantages.

I spend my evenings doing cleaning though. Now I also work from home 10 hours a week, and I've had to get a cleaner because literally I would not be able to do everything otherwise. Unless I spend no time with my husband at the weekend and just left him to look after the kids solo. When we've been out all day as a family on a Saturday, I have significantly less house stuff to do that evening. Floors aren't so grim. Kitchen hasn't been used as much etc.

OP posts:
Babyclb · 15/01/2023 21:14

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 21:08

My point isn't that it's harder than working out of the home. It's that everyone saying some version of "I manage the housework AND work full time, so how can you lazy bitches be drowning" isn't comparing like with like.

I mean I’ve never seen a single person say that, but I do agree with the sentiment at least that “drowning in housework” is not the default of a SAHP. It’s quite extreme imo, so maybe you have particularly difficult kids, or
you just get overwhelmed more easily than others or you aren’t organised at small tasks.
Being at home with a baby and a toddler probably creates about 20% more ‘housework’ but you have about 60% more waking hours available than someone who works full time.

It sounds like reading SAHP/working parent posts cause too much anxiety for you and just cause negative feelings so probably better to just avoid them.

Sucessinthenewyear · 15/01/2023 21:13

I’m a sahm now. Yes, I agree there is more housework now but it’s so much easier than when working with a child.

sst1234 · 15/01/2023 21:13

Why are SAHP so insecure? OP’s tone is so defensive and odd. You always get these threads accusing working parents of calling SAHP names. In reality, I’ve never seen or heard any working parent do this. The lady doth protest too much.

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 21:13

Maybe I do more messy stuff with my kids than some of you? I don't really know how you keep them entertained a full day without going to the park in all weathers, getting the play dough out and so on. I'm not above using screens but that wouldn't work with my younger one.

OP posts:
DistantSkye · 15/01/2023 21:12

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 21:08

My point isn't that it's harder than working out of the home. It's that everyone saying some version of "I manage the housework AND work full time, so how can you lazy bitches be drowning" isn't comparing like with like.

I don't think being a sahm is lazy! But I don't necessarily think it's "more housework". You mention being able to get those odd things done here and there - that's exactly the type of thing you can't get done when you're working out of the home. So popping on a load of laundry, spending 15 mins putting dishes away, hoovering, getting dinner ready... Those are exactly the kind of things you can do during the day when at home with kids (or at least I can, I know everyone's different) - when I'm at work I can't, and it gets done before or after work.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 15/01/2023 21:12

Possibly my lack of standards are showing but I never found it hard. By the time the kids were 2, they got roped into helping because if they could tidy up at toddler groups...they could do it at home! Being out a lot helped as well. Both mine dropped naps by 13 months and dc2 would only nap on me anyway prior to that but I could still do everything that didn't involve heavy chemical use with her in a sling.

KickHimInTheCrotch · 15/01/2023 21:11

There's a bit more general tidying and washing up but everything else is the same: shopping, laundry, house admin, cooking, making beds, cleaning the toilet.

So, overall, I disagree.

lieselotte · 15/01/2023 21:11

No, people don't realise that because there isn't.

There may be more kids mess ie toys strewn over the floor. That isn't housework though, and I used to make sure one lot of toys were tidied up before the next lot came out.

I WFH and it doesn't create more mess other than the odd extra cup or plate. Hardly "housework".

Mamaneedsadrink · 15/01/2023 21:09

My friends have been telling me how much easier they are finding working. I'm so tired, I can't imagine having to parent and have a job (unless maybe it was a job that required no thinking). Although, you get a mental break which is probably the biggie, plus if childcare provides meals that's less meals to make (and mess to clean up). Not sure if I'm ready to take the plunge and go back to work just yet though, I still think it would be harder overall. Especially when your children are sick

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 21:08

My point isn't that it's harder than working out of the home. It's that everyone saying some version of "I manage the housework AND work full time, so how can you lazy bitches be drowning" isn't comparing like with like.

OP posts: