Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do people realise there's more housework if you're a SAHP?

165 replies

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 20:54

Just that. I'm not denying the difficulty of juggling work and home responsibilities, but I often see people on here say stuff like "I manage AND hold down a job, so how can you possibly be struggling?"

Being at home all day with small children creates mess. You can get odd things done, but you can't properly clean your house with toddlers and babies around. Especially if they're terrible nappers. I have to clean when the kids are asleep, the same as working parents, and everything is messier than it would be if nobody was home all day.

Now I'm also doing paid work after kids' bedtime the only possible option is having a cleaner. There's literally not time otherwise.

I'm not complaining about my lot in general. I think there's a lot that's harder about juggling nursery runs, commutes, appointments, kids sick days and so on if you are out of the house, but this particular point really bugs me.

OP posts:
Eyerollcentral · 15/01/2023 22:30

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 21:08

My point isn't that it's harder than working out of the home. It's that everyone saying some version of "I manage the housework AND work full time, so how can you lazy bitches be drowning" isn't comparing like with like.

Sorry, it definitely is not more difficult than working out of the home for most people. Most people I know have very busy, very stressful jobs and usually work over their contracted hours and at home. Plus at work you have to work with others including those you might not like, you might have a difficult boss or staff to manage or both and you don’t get to choose these people or what work you bother doing or not. I’m not saying being at home is easy, it’s not. But unless you have a very easy job with amazing colleagues, for most people being at work is much harder

MysteryBelle · 15/01/2023 22:22

It’s always harder for the woman who works a job and also has to do all the other tasks. Logic.

I stayed at home with mine and of course house will get a bit messier because you’re home using it but I always acknowledged that mothers who work jobs have it much harder in every way, that’s just a fact.

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 22:21

gemloving · 15/01/2023 22:17

I have a 3 year old and 1 year old.

If people aren't in it, they won't remember what it's like. It also depends on how many you have. I found it easy when I had one.

It's a crazy mad house in my house now with 2. I work 4 days a week. My house is clean and tidy on those 4 days, the other 3 it gets SO messy. I don't prioritise tidying though, I love and enjoy my kids and we have such a great time together. I tidy in the evening + kids help taking dishes away but I feel you.

Huge respect to SAHMs, I know I wouldn't manage & I work for an investment bank - very high pressure but it's all completely different, you just can't compare it.

Thank you! It makes me feel like I'm missing some magic strategy everyone else knows when people claim it doesn't generate any extra mess.

I couldn't manage your life. The one investment banker with kids I know has two nannies for two kids, one of whom is also in school. We've been on holiday with him and he doesn't seem to stop working.

OP posts:
Testng123 · 15/01/2023 22:20

UANBU. A bathroom used only a couple of time a day is going to stay a lot cleaner than a bathroom used umpteen times a day. Buying breakfast on the way to work, eating lunch out (or even dinner)...all that work and mess - shopping for food, emptying the bin, wiping down counters etc - is done outside of the house, often by other people e.g. office cleaner, deli staff etc.

I miss it 😪

gemloving · 15/01/2023 22:17

I have a 3 year old and 1 year old.

If people aren't in it, they won't remember what it's like. It also depends on how many you have. I found it easy when I had one.

It's a crazy mad house in my house now with 2. I work 4 days a week. My house is clean and tidy on those 4 days, the other 3 it gets SO messy. I don't prioritise tidying though, I love and enjoy my kids and we have such a great time together. I tidy in the evening + kids help taking dishes away but I feel you.

Huge respect to SAHMs, I know I wouldn't manage & I work for an investment bank - very high pressure but it's all completely different, you just can't compare it.

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 22:14

TrainspottingWelsh · 15/01/2023 22:09

I think some people forget that working parents have days off and annual leave, so we’re perfectly aware of exactly how much extra mess there is when you’re not out at work. And also aware that it’s kind of irrelevant in comparison to also fitting in a day of work on top of it.

It depends, though. On Saturdays we normally do some nice family activity of visit out of the house. Sunday is generally church and then the park as a family. It's weekdays that the real chaos happens in my house.

Even when we're at home all day, two adults means one can kind the kids while the other actually does the dishes immediately rather than adding them to the long list of things that need dealing with when the kids are asleep. It's a different experience.

I literally don't know how single parents manage whether they do paid work or not. It's crazy to me that there's a cultural stereotype of 'lazy' single mothers 'sitting at home' as if it's an easy life.

OP posts:
caoraich · 15/01/2023 22:12

I work full time over 4 days a week. The 5th day at home doing childcare is an absolute breeze in comparison. We tidy up as we go along, my kid can be left for 2 mins while I put on a load of washing and will e.g. do playdough while I fold it. I call it my breathing space day!

Plenty of FT workers don't do 9-5 5 days a week

LemonDrizzles · 15/01/2023 22:12

2 mornings a week, we introduced going to breakfast club. This somehow manages to reduce 1 1/2 hr of cleaning/house work each day (bowls need hand washing, have to wait to change their clothes due to possible spillage, ask the rinsing out of yoghurt pots, wiping down table, sweeping up spillage, mopping, and on and on)

....

So absolutely yes, staying at home just creates more more more housework.

Just more!

Hattie72 · 15/01/2023 22:12

Mat leaves not may leaves

Hattie72 · 15/01/2023 22:12

I have always worked full time, but have been at home during 3 May leaves. Being at home is a walk in the park compared to working for me personally, just extremely boring. Being a SAHM is not hard work at all in my opinion.

Boshi · 15/01/2023 22:11

Yes of course there is more housework. There is obviously more time to deal with it as you are at home but yes there is more stuff to do to keep the house clean, especially when you have little ones. When my dc were little and in nursery the house just stayed as it was apart from a few dishes in the kitchen but when the littlies were home they made a mess in every room we were in 😄

Mumto32022 · 15/01/2023 22:11

I work full time plus then have my kids every waking hour when I’m home. I still have all the house work to do with less hours.
mum not saying being a stay at home parent is easy by any means (I was one for three years and yes it was constant and relentless ) but you do have more ‘time’ to do bits of house work even if it’s five mins here and there (I used to try and get up earlier than my kids to do house work) but now I’m out of the house working for 40- 50 hours a week and still have to make tea wash up/ put the washer on/ sort the washing out and try and find time to clean the bathrooms etc… relentless and exhausting and there’s not enough time in the day / week to do anything else but work / clean/ feed the kids and try and ‘enjoy’ motherhood.

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 22:09

RewildingAmbridge · 15/01/2023 22:06

I work full time so does DH, you seem to think people who work ft only do 9-5 Monday to Friday leaning the house empty and the child at nursery. DS is at home 5 days a week, and that's not always with us, so I'm quite often greeted by a nerd when I open the front door, that I wouldn't dream of asking grandparents to tidy/clean.
Having said that you couldn't pay me enough to be a SAHM!

If you've got grandparents looking after them at home and not doing anything other than look after them, that's obviously different again. I guess you could spend money you save on childcare on more help though 😁

I think if we had grandparents who were local and willing I'd work a bit more myself. Not full-time but more.

OP posts:
TrainspottingWelsh · 15/01/2023 22:09

I think some people forget that working parents have days off and annual leave, so we’re perfectly aware of exactly how much extra mess there is when you’re not out at work. And also aware that it’s kind of irrelevant in comparison to also fitting in a day of work on top of it.

Summerfun54321 · 15/01/2023 22:08

It's that everyone saying some version of "I manage the housework AND work full time, so how can you lazy bitches be drowning"

You need new friends if anyone is saying that to you. I have friends that work and other SAHP friends and everyone is honest that their house is a shit hole and that having young kids is hard.

TheMoth · 15/01/2023 22:07

Having taught all the way through the hard years, I got to do both, sort of.

There was more mess when I was off, but I had more time to sort it.

Working meant everyone out by 730, breakfast bowls in the sink and the house full of morning chaos.
Home by 6, then a couple of hours for tea, seeing kids and clearing up. The bulk of the housework got shunted to weekends. I spent about 10 years permanently exhausted, even though dh and i split everything. But I have been training the kids to do their bit as they've got older.

Spendonsend · 15/01/2023 22:07

I thought op was saying it was messier rather than harder.

RewildingAmbridge · 15/01/2023 22:06

I work full time so does DH, you seem to think people who work ft only do 9-5 Monday to Friday leaning the house empty and the child at nursery. DS is at home 5 days a week, and that's not always with us, so I'm quite often greeted by a nerd when I open the front door, that I wouldn't dream of asking grandparents to tidy/clean.
Having said that you couldn't pay me enough to be a SAHM!

1AngelicFruitCake · 15/01/2023 22:02

Being at home you can set your own agenda, fit jobs in. Working all day then switching back into mum mode and finding the energy to do the tidying and cleaning that need doing is hard.

Lockedinforwinter · 15/01/2023 22:02

I don't understand the constant need to compare working parents and SAHP. It is just not possible as there are too many variables. It depends on what job, what hours, how stressful, ages and personalities of DC, health issues of DC or parents, what family support there is, how much money is available, etc etc. It is just not as simple as saying working parents have it harder, or vice versa. Every single family situation is unique, so comparing them because of one factor (working or not) is ludicrous.

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 22:01

RandomCatGenerator · 15/01/2023 21:57

Lordy, has someone said that?

Youre always going to get The Guilt. I get riled when posters use the whole ‘why don’t you stay at home, why did you go back to work, why did you even have kids if you aren’t going to raise them’. Looks like you get it from the other ‘side’ of ‘you must be so lazy not bothering to work’.

You can’t win as a working age mother of young kids.

You're right, you can't win.

I think the suggestion that using childcare means you aren't raising your own kids is despicable fwiw.

OP posts:
CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 21:57

DistantSkye · 15/01/2023 21:46

@CantPreventSpring
There's advantages and disadvantages to all situations, you're right... And I definitely find even having those little moments to do food prep, laundry, changing sheets during the day quite helpful (and why I only work part time!) And having read your update about doing tasks and having the kids screaming in the background - I do see how that feels like more work because its just so draining, and frustrating trying to get things done and deal with unhappy small kids!

Thank you! All I want is that recognition that it's not a day of chilling on the sofa and calmly hanging up a few bits of laundry. I don't know why I care about strangers opinions but I read a couple of posts today that really irked me.

Working full-time with small children seems tough. I think my husband's career benefits from me not working. He can easily go abroad when necessary, can work late without needing to worry about nursery pick ups and never has to take time off for (relentless!) child illnesses. if both of you are working there's a whole set of new challenges.

On the other hand, shouldering the full financial burden is tricky. My 10 evening hours are helping us a lot.

OP posts:
RandomCatGenerator · 15/01/2023 21:57

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 21:08

My point isn't that it's harder than working out of the home. It's that everyone saying some version of "I manage the housework AND work full time, so how can you lazy bitches be drowning" isn't comparing like with like.

Lordy, has someone said that?

Youre always going to get The Guilt. I get riled when posters use the whole ‘why don’t you stay at home, why did you go back to work, why did you even have kids if you aren’t going to raise them’. Looks like you get it from the other ‘side’ of ‘you must be so lazy not bothering to work’.

You can’t win as a working age mother of young kids.

DistantSkye · 15/01/2023 21:53

DontMakeMeShushYou · 15/01/2023 21:45

I don't think you've thought this argument through. Parents who WORKED from home whilst simultaneously looking after their pre-schoolers during lockdown were doing TWO jobs simultaneously during those 8 hours. They weren't just working in the office for those 8 hours, or just working in childcare for those 8 hours, or just looking after their own kids. They were working in the (home) office at the same time as doing childcare. It was in no way comparable to being an SAHP which, unless I've misunderstood, is what you're trying to suggest.

Hahaha. The extra work during covid wasn't from having to hoover round my kids. It was from trying to do my job from the kitchen table whilst breastfeeding a 1 year old and teaching a 4 year old phonics!

Posting this as I read your final update - adjusting to 2 is hard! Especially as your youngest gets more mobile and you have to balance the needs of both. It's normal to feel frazzled at times and you don't need to justify feeling overwhelmed. Being at home with kids can be hard, working can be hard. We shouldn't be making it into a competition 😊

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 21:50

DontMakeMeShushYou · 15/01/2023 21:45

I don't think you've thought this argument through. Parents who WORKED from home whilst simultaneously looking after their pre-schoolers during lockdown were doing TWO jobs simultaneously during those 8 hours. They weren't just working in the office for those 8 hours, or just working in childcare for those 8 hours, or just looking after their own kids. They were working in the (home) office at the same time as doing childcare. It was in no way comparable to being an SAHP which, unless I've misunderstood, is what you're trying to suggest.

I'm saying it was a nightmare for any of you who had to do that because, as you say, it's two jobs. The domestic and childcare stuff was a second job on top of your existing job.

OP posts: