Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do people realise there's more housework if you're a SAHP?

165 replies

CantPreventSpring · 15/01/2023 20:54

Just that. I'm not denying the difficulty of juggling work and home responsibilities, but I often see people on here say stuff like "I manage AND hold down a job, so how can you possibly be struggling?"

Being at home all day with small children creates mess. You can get odd things done, but you can't properly clean your house with toddlers and babies around. Especially if they're terrible nappers. I have to clean when the kids are asleep, the same as working parents, and everything is messier than it would be if nobody was home all day.

Now I'm also doing paid work after kids' bedtime the only possible option is having a cleaner. There's literally not time otherwise.

I'm not complaining about my lot in general. I think there's a lot that's harder about juggling nursery runs, commutes, appointments, kids sick days and so on if you are out of the house, but this particular point really bugs me.

OP posts:
gemloving · 15/01/2023 23:12

@Roundabout78 it's gives you time to do chores you wouldn't be able to otherwise + no commuting time!

Itisbetter · 15/01/2023 23:10

What nonsense. How many hours a week do you have the cleaner for @CantPreventSpring

Roundabout78 · 15/01/2023 23:10

@gemloving working from home is a whole other ball game 😂 can’t comment because I’ve never done it.

gemloving · 15/01/2023 23:06

@Roundabout78 a lot of people work from home now, so yes they can!
@EezyOozy I couldn't agree more. Mine are 1&3 and working is so much easier and I work in a high pressure environment. My appraisal not once scared as me as I've always exceeded at what I do professionally. I have not always felt like this as mother, I felt like I failed so many more times than I did at work.

Rachaelrachael · 15/01/2023 23:05

I hear you OP. For me it's the never ending cycle of snacks/meal times - crumbs everywhere, spillages, constant kitchen cleaning, stickers EVERYWHERE, playdough bits, greasy finger marks on every glass surface 😂
I have 2 mornings per week when they're both in nursery and it makes such a difference!

Roundabout78 · 15/01/2023 23:05

Also, screens (iPads and smart phones) weren’t a thing when mine were little. We certainly didn’t have them and they weren’t common, any way. We played with play dough, moon sand, paints. Went on walks and made collages from leaves sticks etc. made dens and tents in the living room. Baked and cooked.
so I don’t buy the argument that it’s easier because of screens either:

Roundabout78 · 15/01/2023 23:02

DontMakeMeShushYou · 15/01/2023 21:00

Apart from a bit more tidying up of toys, what else is there that creates more housework?

This. I was a SAHM until my youngest started school. The house was always clean and tidy, i don’t see the big deal. Tidy toys when they’ve finished with them, wash dishes as they’re used. It’s much harder being a working mum imo. Can’t Chuck clothes in the washer through the day or run a hoover round as the kids are eating lunch.

EezyOozy · 15/01/2023 23:02

There is no appraisals, no objectives to complete, no targets to meet, no one to tell you that you are doing a rubbish job and need to go on a performance improvement plan.

I disagree totally. I work now (my kids are 3 and 5) and I find it so much easier. (And I don’t have a particularly easy job).

and much less child related tidying to do in the evenings. (Although laundry etc are the same).

FindingMeno · 15/01/2023 23:01

Mine were looked after in my home when I was at work, so I came home to a mess.

SnowAndFrostOutside · 15/01/2023 22:58

@EezyOozy i had done two lots of maternity leave. Once with a baby and a second time with toddler and baby. It’s much easier than working. There is no appraisals, no objectives to complete, no targets to meet, no one to tell you that you are doing a rubbish job and need to go on a performance improvement plan.

I remember spending a lot of time going out to groups and watching sky (first maternity) and Netflix (second maternity). It take an hour at most to clean the house,

gemloving · 15/01/2023 22:58

@SnowAndFrostOutside you work from
home with no kids at home from 9-03:30 right?

When we're work from home without our toddlers at home, it's so easy to put a washing on, mop the floor in my lunch break etc.

WFH when kids in school most day + they're obviously older as in school, this cannot be compared to being at home all day with two young toddlers.

Hobbitfeet32 · 15/01/2023 22:53

so Presumably the husbands of all the SAHMs could manage easily then if there wasn’t a SAHP in the family. It would be a doddle for the men to finish work and then pick up all the housework as there would hardly be any for them to do?

EezyOozy · 15/01/2023 22:46

@SnowAndFrostOutside not all sahps have school ages children that are out most of the day. Toddlers at home all day create a huge amount of mess ! Especially if there’s more than one of them.

SnowAndFrostOutside · 15/01/2023 22:42

YABU because both DH and I work full time. DH WFH every day and I am only in the office 4 days a week. I don’t know what point you are trying to make other than you are at home more? Many of us WFH and we are at home just as much if not more. We also have two school aged children and no external childcare.

EezyOozy · 15/01/2023 22:39

i always acknowledged that mothers who work jobs have it much harder in every way, that’s just a fact.

it’s not a fact at all.

I work and have one in nursery and one at school. My life is a lot easier than it was when I was a SAHM, which was extremely intense.

gemloving · 15/01/2023 22:39

@toocold54 I completely disagree with you - sorry.

StarsSand · 15/01/2023 22:38

I agree with you OP.

I work but have had my children home with a nanny and DH works from home.

The house never catches a break. There is never time to clean it and people are constantly in it messing it up, creating dishes, spilling things, pulling out toys.

On the rare occasion the children go to the grandparents for a day, I can actually make some progress.

We have a cleaner, could not work unless I outsourced things like this as I just don't have the opportunity clean it unless we waste half the weekend with the children out having fun with DH while I mop the floors.

DontMakeMeShushYou · 15/01/2023 22:37

To all those parents with small children who say they have mountains of mess and toys to clear up of an evening. Do yourselves and your children a favour and start tidying up as you go along. Finished with something? It gets tidied away before you start on the next thing. It's a really good habit to get into early on.

TrainspottingWelsh · 15/01/2023 22:36

@CantPreventSpring I was a single parent when dd was little, so my weekend experience didn’t involve 2 adults juggling a toddler and the washing up. I didn’t know any different so rather than striking me it was hard I just thought some people had it extremely easy.
Comparing different situations is pretty pointless though, I also had horses but in comparison to a sahp to a child with complex disability, my life was relaxing. Ditto if I compare with a single parent working pt but in poverty. You can only really compare with your own situation with or without going to work.

gemloving · 15/01/2023 22:36

@CantPreventSpring You're doing great. Don't listen. If you need a pep talk, message me! I find it strange when people tell me how well they manage or managed. I would too with 1 to be honest. It's like the work quadrupled when baby number 2 arrived.

I'd love to see them 1 day in my house. They also fight like cats and dogs. I work 9-5. I used to work 8-7. It's an agreement I have with my wonderful boss but I am just very lucky. I'm not very senior yet but I didn't give myself enough time for my career and I just prioritise my family now and am completely happy to not be promoted but do a good job if that makes sense. I had my first in my 20s, most women in my industry have their children mid to late 30s, they often establish their careers before but yes, they all have nannies. My boss also had a nanny when hers were younger. My husband is wonderful and has a very flexible job which helps. Take the pressure off though, honestly.

What you do is mentally draining and hard graft, lonely, can be mind numbing but you're actually watching your children grow which is beyond special. It was never meant to be easy but challenging but haven't we learned so much since they arrived? X

EezyOozy · 15/01/2023 22:36

So yes you have more time to make mess, but you also have more time to clean it up.

not necessarily true

EezyOozy · 15/01/2023 22:34

You’re totally correct op.

I was a stay at home mum to a 1
and 2 year old during the worst bits of
the covid pandemic restrictions.

I had to entertain them all day. Every day.
no garden.

toys, playdoh, sensory play, meals,
snacks, all the toys tipped out of baskets constantly, shoes taken off the shoe rack, not being able to take my eyes off them for a minute to even load the dishwasher (I’m serious) …. They’re 3 and 5 now and I’m working , but at the weekends the house is SO MUCH MESSIER than it is Mon-fri. Craft stuff everywhere , train sets, Lego, Playdoh , baking, dressing up clothes,
food prep for three meals a day for everyone.*

Small children at home all day create a huge amount of mess and due to running around like a blue arsed fly after them much of the work needs to be done into the night (like a working parent).

I still have loads to do in the evenings , but less tidying up when they’ve not been home all day.

*yes, we do go out.

paintitallover · 15/01/2023 22:32

I'll never forget the mounds of toys and Lego I had to clear up every night. Often several times!

toocold54 · 15/01/2023 22:32

YABU

My home has never been so clean than when we were in lockdown and I was wfh FT too.

Same as the weekends.
I will get it spotless and then it gets gradually messier during the week.

When people get home they cook and eat their food as well as have messy play etc - all of which need tidying away afterwards, which they tend to do right away.

This is the exact same as a SAHP - they may have lunch at home which others wouldn’t but they’d just spend 5 mins clearing away afterwards.

The reason why a home with a SAHP is more tidy is because they can put a wash on it the morning and hoover during the day and clean more regularly than someone who works FT.

What you are saying would be true if someone who works FT didn’t ever come home but they only have 1 less meal a day at home and the DCs will be just as messy, wear the same amount of clothes, take the same amount of showers etc.

So yes you have more time to make mess, but you also have more time to clean it up.

Thepeopleversuswork · 15/01/2023 22:31

ShellsPebbles · 15/01/2023 21:31

People who slag off SAHPs by saying they are full time parents AND go out to work full time make me laugh. They didn’t actually experience that until they were juggling WFH and their kids during the lockdowns - and most complained about it.
Of course there is more work involved. Full time workers leave the mess for their childminders to clear up. One book before bed and making their kids tea doesn’t compare even slightly.

There’s only one person so far doing any “slagging off” on this thread and it’s you @ShellsPebbles.

Plus you clearly know Jack all about what working parents’ lives are like (and clearly judge them for it.) This was actually a rare interesting, courteous and reasonable discussion about stay at home parenting. Thanks for making it a bigoted race to the bottom.

Swipe left for the next trending thread