Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want my husband to lose some weight …

80 replies

Kay286 · 15/01/2023 17:31

My husband is overweight , it’s crept on gradually starting during lockdown and is a fair few stone (3-4) overweight.
He’s tall so can carry it ok. I completely love him to bits and am totally attracted to him it does not affect our sex life at all.
He carry it all around his belly and chest and recently at the drs was told his cholesterol is elevated (he’s under 40 )
I know it bothers him also, he won’t swim with our kids on holidays etc and he won’t feel comfortable taking his top off (we don’t speak about this but I know this is the reason)
I’ve tried to support him in the past by not buying too much snack things in and cook healthy meals etc . He bought an exercise bike but that now sits gathering dust.
He has a gym membership and when he goes I’m encouraging. But he will go for 2 weeks then stop.
Ive helped him with calorie counting and how I maintain my weight (I’m under 9 stone and I’m pretty sure he weighs over double what I do but I’m short and he is tall!) but it’s only lasts a week or 2.
Im pretty sure he eats (sneaks ?) food. Recently I found a whole packet of after eights gone from Xmas that were unopened - in one sitting ? I know it wasnt me or the kids . Sweeties and crisps are his downfall.
he recently got invited to a formal event last minute but couldn’t attend as his trousers didn’t fit , every time he’s had an event he has to go buy bigger clothes. He was visably upset they were too small again.
sometimes when he is sitting on the sofa his belly hangs out which isn’t nice to look at 🙈
I just don’t know how to help him… is he just going to continue getting bigger and bigger ?
Am I being awful ? Maybe - like I say I am attracted to him but obviously I would prefer him to lose a few stone and I know he would too ! I have tried talking to him but he is VERY sensitive about it … obviously because he knows he is overweight! So can I do nothing and just have to wait until he does it for himself ??

OP posts:
theGooHasGone · 15/01/2023 20:59

Tripofalifetime343 · 15/01/2023 20:29

I really don’t think that this is a good idea.

You have to be in a good space mentally to lose weight. It isn’t really about food; it’s about the stresses or habits that are causing him to over-eat in the first place.

Please don’t add another stress to him. He knows very well what he has to do.

You're absolutely right, of course, and I realise that I was only able to lose all the weight I have in the past year because I was finally happy with my situation and in a place where it was easier for me to do.

With that said, different people are motivated by different things and while all this guy's needs are still being met, the idea of it actually being a problem is less likely to sink in. I guess I wonder whether he'd be as tolerant if OP had put on 3-4 stone is all.

Kay286 · 15/01/2023 20:59

@Natty13 Awww the last part you wrote is lovely thank you and so true :) the losing weight is really I want him to be healthy and be around with him for a long time ! It’s not making me love or attracted to him any less it’s not for vain reasons (although yes he looks better a bit lighter ) but also because I know it’s making him unhappy too :(

thank you , yes I think I really need to focus on the health side and it is worrying at this young age for raised cholesterol I will try to address this with him.

OP posts:
BigFatLiar · 15/01/2023 20:55

OH has never been slim but he's well built and muscular. He became very ill and had a lot of dietary issues. While he was ill and recovering he put on a lot of weight (lots). He'll never get better but his diet is better. He goes to SW and had lost 5st so far. He does sometimes put on again because he falls off the wagon so to speak. Diets work but when you stop the weight goes on so it needs to be a lifestyle change. He's accepted that every now and then he'll put on again as he likes pies etc (big downfall is bread, he'd live on bacon rolls and sandwiches). If he does have a break he just draws a line under it and starts again.

Only your husband can lose the weight, you can be supportive but it's down to him.

What did OH find helpful, not buying biscuits, crisps etc (for a while we did click and collect so simply didn't put things in the basket). Keeping a note of what you'd eaten (and being honest about it) it was an eye opener (even for me) of all the little bits and pieces that find their way into your mouth.
He actually enjoys cooking so he cooks lots of healthy meals, downside is he doesn't bake any more unless the gc are coming.

We're also a lot more sedentary than we should be which doesn't help.

If you're younger have a look at the couch to 5k program (think that's what it is), several of the SW people have done this to upbtheir exercise.

In the end its really down to him and it'll only work if he takes it on ads a change in lifestyle (which is basically what you had during lockdown that caused the issue).

Kay286 · 15/01/2023 20:53

@Daleksatemyshed Yes that’s what I’m thinking too ! I’m actually like how can he not be losing weight ! I generally cook dinner which are around 500/600 calories mark. Sometimes he doesn’t have breakfast and will have a cheese or sausage sandwich and a nutrigrain etc for lunch (not healthy but again combined not huge calories for a day. ) with his weight he probably is around 2500/3000 to maintain so I’m guessing there might be a lot of snacking I don’t see.
at the same time I also see on weekends eating a lots of treats, sweets , crisps , bread and butter , junk which he is not hiding !
Then he is getting upset he trousers don’t fit …

OP posts:
Natty13 · 15/01/2023 20:49

Kay286 · 15/01/2023 17:54

No I could never be that blunt and hurtful. Besides it’s not really true. I love him so much it doesn’t affect my attraction to him.

Tell him this then. Wait until he next suggests a takeaway or asks for extra bacon in his full English and tell him you're worred about his health. High cholesterol under 40 is a huge marker for heart disease/heart attacks in men and you're scared because he is the love of your life. You love him too much to lose him and want him to be healthy so you have many many more years together.

It's obvious to this stranger in the internet how much you love him, it will be obvious to him too so as long as it comes across as concern for his health it shouldn't hurt him.

eatdrinkandbemerry · 15/01/2023 20:47

I'd sit him down tell him you still find him attractive but your worried about his health. Tell him you can help if he wants to lose weight.
It needs to be said whether he wants to hear it or not but it can be done sensitively x

Kay286 · 15/01/2023 20:44

@Tripofalifetime343 i think this is probably very true. I’ve tried before and it didn’t help at all.
Now no matter how much I want to him to lose some, I also don’t want to put all this pressure and make him feel shit about his weight and nag him espec when he has a pretty stressful job.
I think from reading all the replies I probably can’t really do much he has to want to do it for himself

OP posts:
Kay286 · 15/01/2023 20:40

@pompei8309 when I tried to tackle it a few years ago … I was maybe too direct and it really annoyed him, he said it wasn’t helpful and he will do it on his own (without me nagging about it I guess ) So now he will not really discuss it if I even say something related to his weight he shuts the conversation down.
when he found out his cholesterol was up I started trying to say oh what the the dr say about it …. And his reply was he didn’t even make a big deal just moderate a bit … so don’t try and use that as an angle I know where you’re going with this and that’s it end of conversation

OP posts:
anaconda1831 · 15/01/2023 20:31

perhaps you should tell him that its worrying you and you’re worried that he needs to get it under control while hes still got his health and is relatively young

that’s not harsh but might motivate him - of he wont be motivated to do it fir himself he might be to do it for your peace of mins

Kay286 · 15/01/2023 20:31

@DrinkFeckArseBrick I can have that conversation, when he first started gaining during lockdown I was fairly direct and said we both really need to watch our weight and what we are eating (me really I didn’t need to lose but wanted to eat better as lockdown was ordering takeaways out of boredom) he kept snacking and I really tried to push the healthy eating and he just told me to stop he said it wasn’t helping and there was enough to worry about than gaining a bit of weight.
fast-forward 2 years and ge has gain a lot and he definitely knows it’s an issue but I try to be a lot more gently because I think I really annoyed him when I spoke before.
I have also mentioned the health side of things and we are pushing 40 so need to be more health conscious about cardiovascular risk factors.
His weight bothers him I know it does he has started trying just before Christmas , he even ordered a salad in a restaurant ! But he just doesn’t follow through , he went to the gym but it lasted 2 weeks.

OP posts:
pompei8309 · 15/01/2023 20:31

Kay286 · 15/01/2023 17:47

That’s so tough isn’t it if it’s actually affecting your marriage so much :( thankfully I am not there yet. It’s just so frustrating because I know it and he knows it and I’m know it’s bothering him so it’s like just lose it then and tell me how and I’ll help in whatever way I can - but it doesn’t last ! The health is also a concern espec the raised cholesterol- I was hoping the dr would have a stern talk about being healthy and apparently all he said was just moderate a bit !
Then he proceeded to eat , full English , dolly mixutures , millionaire shortbread 🤦‍♀️

So if he knows and you know what’s stopping you from having a frank discussion? why can’t you tell him exactly what you wrote on your initial post? why you keep going around the bush instead of tackling the situation head on?

Daleksatemyshed · 15/01/2023 20:30

Sorry @Kay286 I obviously got confused.
I do wonder if the person who said your DH has a binge eating disorder is on to something _ if you eat the same meals and you're less than 9 stone then he must be eating an awful lot between meals. I really do think you need to have a proper talk, no need to be unkind, just straight talking. Surely if you are close you should be able to talk about this?

Tripofalifetime343 · 15/01/2023 20:29

theGooHasGone · 15/01/2023 19:59

Also just to state the bleeding obvious - if he did actually think that you don't find him attractive any more because of his weight, it would probably be a pretty big motivator towards him wanting to sort himself out. People ultimately get lazy because they can, and if he's still getting everything he wants (meals, home life, sex etc) while being able to snack as much as he likes then he doesn't have any real motivation to change. It doesn't sound like he's really feeling the physical symptoms of being overweight yet.

Of course you don't need to be harsh about it, but as others have said if you can find a photo of him when he was looking great and tell him how sexy you found him and how much you enjoyed x thing you did together then it's likely to have more of an impact. It doesn't have to be nagging or concern, just a friendly observation that it doesn't go unnoticed. Men often aren't backwards in coming forwards when their wives gain enough weight for them to be less attractive - I think it's only fair that the same is true in reverse.

I really don’t think that this is a good idea.

You have to be in a good space mentally to lose weight. It isn’t really about food; it’s about the stresses or habits that are causing him to over-eat in the first place.

Please don’t add another stress to him. He knows very well what he has to do.

flabbygoldfish · 15/01/2023 20:25

Does he have a birthday coming up soon? If so could you get him some PT sessions? Some do
lifestyle guidance as well and send reminders for step count etc. it might be easier for him to talk about with a third party.

Kay286 · 15/01/2023 20:24

@theGooHasGone haha yes I have thought about this but it feels so mean.
I flit between that’s it but I’m just going to say I’m not interested in sex until you lose some weight etc to thinking that incredibly harsh of me and the I almost makes excuse for him like he got a stressful job , he works hard he’s a great dad and I should ease up on him !

OP posts:
Kay286 · 15/01/2023 20:21

@Daleksatemyshed i think it was someone else who posted their husband said it all men are meant to be slim :)

OP posts:
Kay286 · 15/01/2023 20:19

@Oblahdeeoblahdoe Honestly I really don’t think he would ! I actually think he’s quite insecure about his body and I just don’t think he would go to a group like that (even though everyone is there for the same thing !)

OP posts:
Kay286 · 15/01/2023 20:07

@Straycatblue yes we try and get out on weekends and have long walks we have a dog so we do ! This is what also leads me to think he may be secretly eating and snacking a lot that I don’t see. As we eat dinners the same fairly healthy home cooked meals, most of the time (we do eat out and have takeaways but I also do ) I’m fairly small 8st 11. So if we’re eating the same dinners etc and I’m staying the same and he is 18stone and not losing when we do the walking etc he is definitely snacking on lots !

OP posts:
theGooHasGone · 15/01/2023 19:59

Also just to state the bleeding obvious - if he did actually think that you don't find him attractive any more because of his weight, it would probably be a pretty big motivator towards him wanting to sort himself out. People ultimately get lazy because they can, and if he's still getting everything he wants (meals, home life, sex etc) while being able to snack as much as he likes then he doesn't have any real motivation to change. It doesn't sound like he's really feeling the physical symptoms of being overweight yet.

Of course you don't need to be harsh about it, but as others have said if you can find a photo of him when he was looking great and tell him how sexy you found him and how much you enjoyed x thing you did together then it's likely to have more of an impact. It doesn't have to be nagging or concern, just a friendly observation that it doesn't go unnoticed. Men often aren't backwards in coming forwards when their wives gain enough weight for them to be less attractive - I think it's only fair that the same is true in reverse.

Straycatblue · 15/01/2023 19:54

It's sounds possibly like it may have progressed into a binge eating disorder territory (recognised eating disorder) with him hiding wrappers & eating whole boxes after 8s in one setting. Alot of health boards have eating disorder assistance teams that inc binge eating that may be useful for him but the problem is like anyone with an addiction/disorder is getting them to accept they need help

Another thing you can try that might help can you go walking with him ie something you can do together - huge long walks to get him moving & expending more calories?

theGooHasGone · 15/01/2023 19:49

Kay286 · 15/01/2023 18:28

@theGooHasGone agree ! I think it’s definitely the snacking ! I find so many hidden wrappers in his pockets (when doing the washing) bags , office desk etc. its tricky because he really does not like fruit of any sort.
he wouldnt eat raw carrots either but he doesn’t mind a nice salad.
I think 🤔 need to just get more salad stuff in and less snack stuff I guess.
I think deep down I know he has to make the decision to do it on his own I just really wish it was sooner rather than later. He has done it before about 10 years ago he lost 3 stone he was really into cycling and was cycling 20 miles at a time ! In fact if anything he looked too slim for his height 🙈 just hoping he can do it again.

@Kay286 Raw carrots by themselves would be a lot, but dipping them in some low fat hummus is a delicious snack. Apples are really inoffensive as far as fruits go (can always get one of those apple corers if he doesn't like peeling or biting into them) and satsumas are also delicious - but if he's absolutely determined that he doesn't like fruit and won't eat it then it'll be a little trickier. Anything that's not chocolate/calorie dense but is still satisfying to eat is a big improvement. It's important to have hobbies and things to distract from wanting to snack all the time too - a lot of it happens due to sheer boredom.

I did find that MyFitnessPal helped a bit initially as it forced me to look at how many calories I was actually consuming during the day. If you have an Apple Watch/Fitbit or similar it also gives you credit for any exercise you do - I've tried my best to have a reward system where I feel fine about having a snack if I've done my 30-40 minutes on the elliptical that day. I don't use MyFitnessPal any more but sometimes it can open your eyes about exactly how many calories are in the things you eat and how little energy you're actually using if you don't exercise.

My personal motivation for weight loss came for a few reasons - I was a little concerned about heart disease as I was getting older (family history) plus the potential for diabetes with the amount of sugar I was eating. Stairs were becoming a little trickier, I was out of breath doing garden work, my clothes didn't look good and I just felt like life was passing me by as a fat person. I didn't want to go another year being flabby and hating the way I looked in the mirror. It really does have to come from within - but if he can do things for 2-3 weeks it can start to become a habit.

H2bow · 15/01/2023 19:46

It's a shame it affects family things, perhaps approach it from that angle? He knows he's overweight, he won't lose it until he wants to for himself and its not easy, but similarly its hard when someone you love is basically self harming isn't it.

theGooHasGone · 15/01/2023 19:41

Daleksatemyshed · 15/01/2023 19:11

The remark about some men not being made to be slim is a bit telling @Kay286 . Women feel a lot more social pressure to lose weight than men because we're supposed to stay attractive for them ( or so we're told) but men do have this idea that women will love them for them and their size is irrelevant. It's probably never twigged with him that you might be turned off by his weight especially since you obviously care for him and can't bring yourself to be ukind by saying anything.
If you really can't find a way to say "You're getting too big, you need to slim down a bit" then I don't think you can make any progress. Could you find some old photos and point out gently how slim and fancible he used to be?

As a sweeping statement, men are usually more "visually" stimulated than women so as you say there's often a societal expectation that women stay slim, whereas many women say "oh I like him because he's really smart and he makes me laugh" about their partners, rather than the attraction being mostly based on their physical attributes.

These are vast generalisations of course and not always true, but this is part of why the "dad bod" is definitely seen as something that's more socially acceptable. There's a limit, of course - dad bod doesn't mean a big belly hanging over his trousers, slobby fat arms etc. There is a lot of focus in men's media about keeping trim too, but it tends to be in the context of sport or "gains" in the gym 🙄

This is the reason for my previous statement that men (in general) have to want to lose weight for themselves - society doesn't try to push/shame them into doing it the same way it seems to with women.

tinytemper66 · 15/01/2023 19:40

My husband had a heat attack and was only then he changed his life strike. He lost 3 stone and changed his lifestyle.

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 15/01/2023 19:36

I posted earlier about men being successful on Weight Watchers or Slimming World - do you not think he would be interested in them?

Swipe left for the next trending thread