Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to keep separate finances from my husband for this reason?

116 replies

Account1 · 15/01/2023 12:41

AIBU to want to keep separate finances from my husband due to DSC.

Basically I don't want to join finances completely with my husband because I don't want to be responsible for paying for DSC.

At the moment we have a joint account for bills, a joint savings account and then separate accounts for everything else. My wages get paid into my separate account and I transfer an amount to cover half bills into the joint account along with some savings into the other but I keep the rest of the money in my separate. My husband does the same but I expect him to cover whatever DSC need (or he wants to get them) via his own disposable income. So any clothes they need, school trips, uniform, treats, extras or whatever, he'd buy via his own bank. I don't want some family "pot" where we just pay for everything jointly.

My reasoning for this is basically for a couple of reasons, firstly DSC are getting older and thus increasingly expensive, wanting designer clothes and shoes, spends, phones, money into savings for them etc etc. And also the fact I think my husband spends too much on them sometimes. They seem to get whatever they ask for and I wouldn't be happy funding that partly myself. When I've mentioned to DH in the past that I think he can go a bit OTT with spending on them he's told me it's not my business what he spends on his children which is fair enough but then I don't want my money getting involved then if I don't have a say.

At the moment basically it's a case of as long as he pays his half of the bills and the costs for our joint child then if he wants to spend all his disposable buying DSC stuff then that's fine but I won't be bailing him out to do so. It worries me that if it was in one pot it would just seem like more money he'd have to spend on them.

He thinks we should have one family pot which all the kids phones, savings, clothes, uniform, trips etc.. come out of, I think we should stay separate and then spend our disposable however we choose.

OP posts:
FredWinnie · 15/01/2023 15:05

funinthesun19 · 15/01/2023 14:29

Everyone saying “what if it was a man”…

I can’t explain why, but there is a very big difference between being in a relationship with the RP (mostly the mums), and a relationship with the NRP (mostly the dads). Women should keep their money safe when in an NRP dynamic.

The way I see it is that women have been exploited by men for centuries. Women have been exploited for physical labour, financial gain, and for sex

Men were permitted to be acquisitive through various laws, some of which were only finally repealed in my lifetime

So even now, some women who are partners with a (male) parent may find themselves in a position where their personal security and agency feels under threat, by the old systems and laws that still resonate now

"Women should want to pay for his kids"
"Women are naturally nurturing. Anything else is just selfish"
"they're kids, FFS"
Ad infinitum

OP please stick to your guns.
You'll be doing his DC a great service by presenting yourself as a strong role model - demonstrating that women's wants and needs do not have to be subsumed into their husbands'

caringcarer · 15/01/2023 15:04

I think the set up have now saves lots of potential friction. If it was one shared joint pot you would get annoyed if he bought his DC lots of designer clothes or high end phones and. As long as he wants to treat his children so extravagantly he pays himself. You are being fair as you say you don't mind the odd treat or holiday from joint account. Surely their mother should be paying for school lunches on days they are sleeping at her house and go halves with your DH on large ticket items like new high end phones. He needs to be speaking to his ex about having a joint account they both pay into to provide for their DC.

Gymnopedie · 15/01/2023 14:52

It sounds like he has more disposable income than he's making out but he chooses to spend it on whatever his DC decide they want, therefore he has less to spend on himself. That's his choice but it's still disposable income.

Agree OP, keep things the way they are.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 15/01/2023 14:47

I’d definitely keep my finances separate

Simonjt · 15/01/2023 14:41

We have one joint child and one that legally is just mine.

All of our earnings go into a joint account, everything is paid for from this account including anything related to both children. We both take out the same amount of money per month and put it in our personal accounts for spending on anything we like, grown up pocket money.

No matter how you as a couple decide to provide for the children, you both need the same disposable income/fun money, so in a split finances situation you will need to contribute more to even things up if he has less disposable income.

Dacadactyl · 15/01/2023 14:31

HandbagsnGladrags · 15/01/2023 14:27

@Dacadactyl yeah...I suspect you'd be the one on here complaining about the SM overstepped boundaries.

Why do people comment on stuff they know nothing about? 🙄

I've never been cheated on or abused but I can give sensible advice on here to those who have.

Just cos you don't like what I'm saying doesn't mean I can't comment because of a lack of personal experience.

Mars27 · 15/01/2023 14:30

His children, his money, simple as. Yanbu, definitely.

funinthesun19 · 15/01/2023 14:29

Everyone saying “what if it was a man”…

I can’t explain why, but there is a very big difference between being in a relationship with the RP (mostly the mums), and a relationship with the NRP (mostly the dads). Women should keep their money safe when in an NRP dynamic.

Dacadactyl · 15/01/2023 14:29

Account1 · 15/01/2023 14:25

Yes but you don't get to say treat and pay for my kids as if their your own but it's none of your business what I spend on them. Okay it's none of my business, so pay for it yourself.

And yes my DSC have another parent who pays half for all of these things so I don't see why I need to. To me, outside of the occasional treat and household bills, my DSC are the financial responsibility of their parents, so if they need uniform or spends or whatever else, it should come from their mum and dad, not me, DH and their mum.

In your first paragraph you make a fair point.

I see what you're saying in your 2nd paragraph but what if the kids mum died, would you step into the breach then if needs be? Just curious.

HandbagsnGladrags · 15/01/2023 14:27

@Dacadactyl yeah...I suspect you'd be the one on here complaining about the SM overstepped boundaries.

Why do people comment on stuff they know nothing about? 🙄

PeekAtYou · 15/01/2023 14:27

yanbu

He can't suggest joint money but not agree to budgets on spending like luxuries for dsc. We all know that joint money will mean that he will spend your money on dsc too.

Account1 · 15/01/2023 14:25

Yes but you don't get to say treat and pay for my kids as if their your own but it's none of your business what I spend on them. Okay it's none of my business, so pay for it yourself.

And yes my DSC have another parent who pays half for all of these things so I don't see why I need to. To me, outside of the occasional treat and household bills, my DSC are the financial responsibility of their parents, so if they need uniform or spends or whatever else, it should come from their mum and dad, not me, DH and their mum.

OP posts:
Dacadactyl · 15/01/2023 14:23

HandbagsnGladrags · 15/01/2023 14:19

@Dacadactyl I take it you're not a step parent. There's a whole world of difference between a man putting his kids first, and a woman taking on someone else's kids 'as her own' because she happened to marry their father. Would you want some other woman taking on your kids as her own? I certainly wouldn't.

No I'm not a step parent. Wouldn't be remotely interested in a man with children already (unless he was a young widower)

If (God forbid) my children were ever in a 2 house situation, I would certainly want their step mum to treat them as her own. Why wouldn't you? What if I died while my kids were young? I wouldn't want their step mum to be all stand-offish with them. I'd want her to love them too. And if she couldn't do that, I would say she has no business being with a man who has kids.

Lcb123 · 15/01/2023 14:22

your current arrangement seems best. You didn’t mention but assume the DSC have another parent who also supports them financially? In which case, no reason you should

funinthesun19 · 15/01/2023 14:21

Account1 · 15/01/2023 12:52

I think he currently doesn't have much disposable for himself in comparison to me. But then I think well... I don't have as many children to pay for so?

Exactly. He has more children than you, so he has more to pay for. It’s kind of how it works!

You’re doing the right thing by keeping your money separate.

HandbagsnGladrags · 15/01/2023 14:19

@Dacadactyl I take it you're not a step parent. There's a whole world of difference between a man putting his kids first, and a woman taking on someone else's kids 'as her own' because she happened to marry their father. Would you want some other woman taking on your kids as her own? I certainly wouldn't.

SonnySideDown · 15/01/2023 14:16

And this is the way my DH wants it. He treats my DD as his own. Which is more than her biological father has ever done.

Dacadactyl · 15/01/2023 14:16

HandbagsnGladrags · 15/01/2023 14:11

Bullshit.

You don't have to like it, but it's what I think.

I mean, any decent bloke worth having is gonna put his kids above you.

SonnySideDown · 15/01/2023 14:16

It's not that I expected DH to pay for DD. Its that our finances are joined, so things that she needs comes out of that one pot. As does stuff for the DC we have together.

We live in a house together, as a family. That's how it is in our house, others do things differently and that's also fine.

But if my DH said I could only spend my own money on my DD and his money could only go on his, nah its not for me. I've been a stepchild, I know how it feels to not be included.

HandbagsnGladrags · 15/01/2023 14:11

Dacadactyl · 15/01/2023 14:06

Not read any posts other than the OP but I think that when you marry a man with kids, you have to be prepared to take his kids on as your own. If you're not prepared for everything that entails then don't go near men with kids from previous relationships.

Bullshit.

AnneLovesGilbert · 15/01/2023 14:06

if he gets his way.

If he pays maintenance does he pay that from his own spending money? Is the 50/50 bills fair because you earn the same amount?

Dacadactyl · 15/01/2023 14:06

Not read any posts other than the OP but I think that when you marry a man with kids, you have to be prepared to take his kids on as your own. If you're not prepared for everything that entails then don't go near men with kids from previous relationships.

AnneLovesGilbert · 15/01/2023 14:05

You’re completely right and he’s being ridiculous. What’s his is his and what’s yours is also his

musingsinmidlife · 15/01/2023 14:05

There are many threads on here where posters argue that disposable income should be balanced and relatively equal. That spouses having different standards of living isn't fair and that a caring, loving spouse will pay more to equalize that balance.

Beamur · 15/01/2023 14:03

his outlook seems to be that what's his is his and what's yours should also be his
Doesn't it just!