Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you pay for this?

139 replies

Lockerlocker · 15/01/2023 12:02

Received a phone call from DS16s school last week to say him and another child had been involved in an incident where they had both kicked a locker, they have viewed the CCTV to confirm it was them. He explained DS would be excluded and we would be billed for the locker as they had damaged it. As there was two boys involved they bill would be halved. Fair enough. Makes sense we are billed for the locker.

Friday, I receive an email followed by the letter in the post yesterday to say that the single locker can’t be replaced so we have to pay for the column of lockers, adding that the lockers are on show in the corridor and it ruins the atheistic and the locker is now not functional. So I’m still sort of in agreement. The cost of the four lockers is £156.06 so our bill is £79.03.

Then I open the photo they have sent me (picture 1), the bottom locker is already clearly without a door (there is no suggestion that my DS was involved in this). I show my DS the photo, he states that it doesn’t look like the picture at all and that the girl is still using the locker. He said several of lockers have dents in and they have not been replaced. He has then sent me photos of the block showing the dinted lockers and the locker now.

I think I should only be charged for the broken locker and at a push 3 out of 4 lockers.

Not to drip feed, not sure it’s relevant, it’s an alternate provision. DS has an ASD & ADHD diagnosis. However I don’t believe he was having a melt down at the time of the incident.

Would you pay for this?
Would you pay for this?
Would you pay for this?
OP posts:
User4775433 · 15/01/2023 12:38

Hmm, it's a bit of an ethical dilemma. Paying for damage that you (your son) was responsible for is an excellent life lesson, however the school talking about the aesthetics of the lockers when there is already aesthetic issues seems a little bit disingenuous of the school and that would be an issue for me tbh. I would probably pay it though. There is still a lesson in there - and physically damaging school property in the manner your son and his friend did is really not on and the punishment could be seen to be replacing all 4 lockers. Which isn't massively unreasonable.

Iceicebabytoocold · 15/01/2023 12:37

Of course the damage should be paid for, by your DS. Lesson learnt for him. I can’t believe you are even questioning this, would you except this vandalism in your own home, I expect not.

Georgeskitchen · 15/01/2023 12:33

Just pay for the damaged door. School tried to make me pay for a full wall to replastered when my son hit the wall with his hand and a small piece of plaster roughly 3"×3" fell off the wall. I told them very clearly and concisely where to shove it
They didn't bother me again 😉

Lkydfju · 15/01/2023 12:32

Also consider that the replacement of these lockers takes time out of the day of staff members when they could be doing things that improve life for students rather than sorting out the damage; their time costs money too

orangegato · 15/01/2023 12:30

Pay it and make the little pay you back. Stop making excuses for him. He learns now as if he did this outside of school it wouldn’t be an option to bail him out and he’d have a criminal record. Stop being soft.

iklboo · 15/01/2023 12:30

Stop minimising his actions. He deliberately kicked in a girl's locker - which, in itself, needs addressing. The fact she still uses it is irrelevant. You pay & then make him pay you back.

IDontCareMatthew · 15/01/2023 12:30

Looks to just be the door that he damaged?

Lkydfju · 15/01/2023 12:28

I think by saying that you’ll only pay some of it misses the point on your DS taking responsibility for what he’s done; school are a bit cheeky and misleading to say that it’s ruins the aesthetic when there’s already a broken and dented one but the lesson for your DS is that he caused damage and he has to be responsible for the entire repair (I hope it’s coming out of his money). The fact the girl can use the locker is not really anything to do with it as why should she have to have a broken locker because of your DS which she has no choice about using.
If he damaged a car door that needed to be replaced would you say you’re only paying part because it was already scratched?
also he’s 16 and if he did that outside of school the police would be called so not sure you can risk thinking that his mum will help him shirk responsibility

VladmirsPoutine · 15/01/2023 12:28

The school have probably passed on the cost to you and other parent to replace the lot but who can blame them tbh.

Blanketpolicy · 15/01/2023 12:27

SD1978 · 15/01/2023 12:21

Given there is already damage, and the column needs to be replaced due to the already damaged door on the bottom, I would be offering 1/3, other parent pay 1/3 and school pay 1/3. Surely they would have been planning to replace anyway? Your son absolutely needs to take responsibility for his vandalism, but school also should be partially responsible for the whole column

Absolutely not.

Perhaps the column didnt need replaced now as they had enough lockers without the one at the bottom?

gelatogina · 15/01/2023 12:27

Your son needs to learn there are consequences to his violent behaviour. What was the reason for kicking in this girls locker?

make him pay it back out of his own money.

Theunamedcat · 15/01/2023 12:26

I think you should pay half the depreciated value as they obviously were not replacing the lockers despite prior damage they are only replacing it now they have someone to pay it for them can't blame them but play fairly

And don't tell ds your negotiations he really doesn't need to know your chalkenging it

also I would like evidence they have actually replaced the lockers

TheHauntedPencilCase · 15/01/2023 12:26

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 15/01/2023 12:12

I'm with you, OP. If the bank of lockers was knackered anyway, you should only be paying the cost of the one your son damaged.

I agree. I think you should be asking to contribute towards 1/4 of the replacement rather than half on the basis it already needed replacement but I probably would just suck it up tbh as the consequences are for your sons benefit.

Blanketpolicy · 15/01/2023 12:24

He needs to pay. It is likely they just never found evidence for the other locker damage and cant afford to replace yet, but that does not negate you being responsibile to replace the column for the locker your ds damaged.

Hope you make him pay for the damage either out of his pocket money /savings or with chores at NMW for his age.

Oysterbabe · 15/01/2023 12:23

I think that is incredibly cheap and I'd pay it and move on.

dudsville · 15/01/2023 12:23

Re the previous damage, your son left the locker in an unsafe way, the previously dented lockers do not look unsafe and unusable.

dudsville · 15/01/2023 12:21

I think the concept underpinning your post OP is an interesting one; does the person who caused wilfull damage to property get a say in what fair reparations amounts to?

SD1978 · 15/01/2023 12:21

Given there is already damage, and the column needs to be replaced due to the already damaged door on the bottom, I would be offering 1/3, other parent pay 1/3 and school pay 1/3. Surely they would have been planning to replace anyway? Your son absolutely needs to take responsibility for his vandalism, but school also should be partially responsible for the whole column

GotAnyGrapez · 15/01/2023 12:21

He broke the locker, of course he needs to pay!

Maybe he needs to be more careful of other peoples property if he doesn't want to be charged. 🤨

Soggydog · 15/01/2023 12:18

But I think regardless let it be a lesson for your son and don't voice if you think.the school unreasonable. Do back them up in front of him as it will teach him responsibility.

Dillydollydingdong · 15/01/2023 12:17

It's not a lot of money anyway, is it? The school was prepared to put up with the previous damage, but the extra damage makes it unfeasible.

MrsSkylerWhite · 15/01/2023 12:17

Of course you must pay. Who else would you expect to?

Soggydog · 15/01/2023 12:17

I'm presuming they have tried hammering it back into shape and can't as it would be dangerous to keep it jutting out like that? If that is the case then fair enough to make you pay for the set that has to be bought. If it will reshape and can be used then maybe overkill to make you pay that.

SunshineAndFizz · 15/01/2023 12:16

Show me the money.

drpet49 · 15/01/2023 12:16

Really? Your son deliberately damaged school property and you are more concerned with the cost.