Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you pay for this?

139 replies

Lockerlocker · 15/01/2023 12:02

Received a phone call from DS16s school last week to say him and another child had been involved in an incident where they had both kicked a locker, they have viewed the CCTV to confirm it was them. He explained DS would be excluded and we would be billed for the locker as they had damaged it. As there was two boys involved they bill would be halved. Fair enough. Makes sense we are billed for the locker.

Friday, I receive an email followed by the letter in the post yesterday to say that the single locker can’t be replaced so we have to pay for the column of lockers, adding that the lockers are on show in the corridor and it ruins the atheistic and the locker is now not functional. So I’m still sort of in agreement. The cost of the four lockers is £156.06 so our bill is £79.03.

Then I open the photo they have sent me (picture 1), the bottom locker is already clearly without a door (there is no suggestion that my DS was involved in this). I show my DS the photo, he states that it doesn’t look like the picture at all and that the girl is still using the locker. He said several of lockers have dents in and they have not been replaced. He has then sent me photos of the block showing the dinted lockers and the locker now.

I think I should only be charged for the broken locker and at a push 3 out of 4 lockers.

Not to drip feed, not sure it’s relevant, it’s an alternate provision. DS has an ASD & ADHD diagnosis. However I don’t believe he was having a melt down at the time of the incident.

Would you pay for this?
Would you pay for this?
Would you pay for this?
OP posts:
Whinge · 15/01/2023 13:20

Your ds still kicked the door so even if they had replaced it you would need to pay the same amount of money to replace it anyway due to the deliberate damage your son caused

This is a good point.

2chocolateoranges · 15/01/2023 13:15

Lockerlocker · 15/01/2023 13:02

Why didn’t they replace the lockers when the bottom one had no door?

Your ds still kicked the door so even if they had replaced it you would need to pay the same amount of money to replace it anyway due to the deliberate damage your son caused,

the bottom one may have been damaged accidentally, your sons damage was deliberate .

Tontostitis · 15/01/2023 13:14

Ffs pay it I can't believe people arguing about 'betterment ' and discounts are for real. Vandalism has consequences and £79 is cheap for what's he's done.

Georgeskitchen · 15/01/2023 13:12

MrsSkylerWhite · 15/01/2023 13:01

Georgeskitchen · Today 12:33
Just pay for the damaged door. School tried to make me pay for a full wall to replastered when my son hit the wall with his hand and a small piece of plaster roughly 3"×3" fell off the wall. I told them very clearly and concisely where to shove it

They didn't bother me again 😉“

That apple didn’t fall far from the tree.

The school was due for demolition so in my view the apple fell in a perfect location 🤣

harrassedmumto3 · 15/01/2023 13:11

Pay up.

TidyDancer · 15/01/2023 13:09

I was thinking a third would be fair the whole way through reading this. Your DS clearly needs to pay (more as a deterrent for future than anything else) but it needs to be fair and reasonable. Since he didn't cause all the damage but all the damage is being rectified, it's more appropriate for him to pay a reduced bill.

DanielRicciardosSmile · 15/01/2023 13:08

I wonder why whoever broke the bottom locker (and dented/graffitied the other lockers) wasn't made to pay for a column of lockers.

Lockerlocker · 15/01/2023 13:06

SD1978 · 15/01/2023 12:21

Given there is already damage, and the column needs to be replaced due to the already damaged door on the bottom, I would be offering 1/3, other parent pay 1/3 and school pay 1/3. Surely they would have been planning to replace anyway? Your son absolutely needs to take responsibility for his vandalism, but school also should be partially responsible for the whole column

A third is a good shout actually.

OP posts:
Emmamoo89 · 15/01/2023 13:02

You need to pay it

Lockerlocker · 15/01/2023 13:02

Suprima · 15/01/2023 12:15

The consequence of the damage done to one locker means that 4 need to be bought.

Why should school budgets suffer because your son vandalised them?

That money will have to come from somewhere.

Why didn’t they replace the lockers when the bottom one had no door?

OP posts:
Lockerlocker · 15/01/2023 13:02

saveforthat · 15/01/2023 12:14

If your son gets pocket money or has savings, he should pay. If not he should do extra chores to compensate you for paying.

Yes he absolutely will be, but I’m not sure he should also be paying for the one that already had no door. If the looks of the lockers are so important, why were they not replaced when that one was broken?

OP posts:
custardbear · 15/01/2023 13:01

I think he needs a harsh lesson about actions and consequences. Don't be wading in with them or fair nonsense, he's wilfully vandalised something, he needs to stop this behaviour and be chastised appropriately - making excuses for him just breeds criminals with their parents making excuses for them

MrsSkylerWhite · 15/01/2023 13:01

Georgeskitchen · Today 12:33
Just pay for the damaged door. School tried to make me pay for a full wall to replastered when my son hit the wall with his hand and a small piece of plaster roughly 3"×3" fell off the wall. I told them very clearly and concisely where to shove it

They didn't bother me again 😉“

That apple didn’t fall far from the tree.

Lockerlocker · 15/01/2023 13:00

picklemewalnuts · 15/01/2023 12:11

I think OP's irritation is that the damaged locker isn't the only damage and therefore needing to be fixed. It's just a bit more damage to an already grotty unit.

They are taking the opportunity to upgrade the lockers at OP expense.

Yes exactly this

OP posts:
SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 15/01/2023 12:59

That locker now can't be locked and is jutting out so will hurt someone if they walked into/fell into it.

You should pay for the locker replacement and absolutely bollock you son for acting like a little thug

Newlifestartingatlast · 15/01/2023 12:59

I’d certainly be querying if they’d intended to replace the block anyway given the bottom locker is not fit for purpose . Ask them had they already planned on replacing? I think say you’ll go halves on 75% of costs , but given aesthetics and use were already damaged they’d have to have replaced them already or accepted the crap situation

whilst I don’t think they’re being greedy, it certainly seems they’re going to benefit from getting someone else to pay for a previously useless and unsightly locker.

honeylulu · 15/01/2023 12:58

I agree there should be a discounted element to reflect the fact that the column of lockers already had some damage (which spoiled the aesthetic) so if the school gets the full cost of a brand new column of lockers, they are getting a windfall.

I'm a lawyer specialising in subrogated property damage claims for insurers. In this instance the property insurer would likely pay out for the new column (if that was cheaper than reinstating the new damage) but with a discount on the full cost due to betterment i e the school would be getting something better/newer than before the incident damage occurred. A civil claim to recover the loss against the tortfeasor (wrongdoer) would be on the same basis. At law the claimant is only entitled to be restored to the same position as it would have been but for the wrong that has been committed, not a better position.

TLDR: Paying one third seems very reasonable as the school is not entitled to gain a windfall, legally or morally.

I agree your son should be held to account. If he has funds he should pay or at least make a fair contribution. If no funds he should recompense you in some other way (chores etc).

GimmeBiscuits · 15/01/2023 12:56

SD1978 · 15/01/2023 12:21

Given there is already damage, and the column needs to be replaced due to the already damaged door on the bottom, I would be offering 1/3, other parent pay 1/3 and school pay 1/3. Surely they would have been planning to replace anyway? Your son absolutely needs to take responsibility for his vandalism, but school also should be partially responsible for the whole column

I agree. Nobody is disputing that he caused damage. The issue is that there was already damage before this incident. Therefore OP should not be picking up the cost of an existing problem.

NumberTheory · 15/01/2023 12:56

It is unreasonable for the school to expect an older locker to be compensated for at new locker prices. And particularly unreasonable to expect an only partially functioning set of lockers to be replaced by a brand new, fully functioning one.

The school are trying it on.

I agree your son needs to be responsible for the cost of damage, but many on this thread seem to think he should suck up whatever the school ask for as some sort of additional punishment. That’s not reasonable. He’s being punished (the exclusion) he should compensate the school for the actual damage he’s caused, not be a source of school beautification.

I would respond saying that compensation needs to be limited to the damage done and shouldn’t be a source of improvement for the school and so you are only prepared to pay the initial agreed amount for half of one locker.

Dutch1e · 15/01/2023 12:52

If you want to replace like with like see if you can find a second-hand column of lockers and deliver it to the school. If that ends up being a huge hassle then I'd just pay the new price as someone has to spend time & energy on this.

SamphiretheTervosaurReturneth · 15/01/2023 12:50

picklemewalnuts · 15/01/2023 12:11

I think OP's irritation is that the damaged locker isn't the only damage and therefore needing to be fixed. It's just a bit more damage to an already grotty unit.

They are taking the opportunity to upgrade the lockers at OP expense.

And that's a valuable lesson for her DS to learn!

Don't deliberately damage someone else's property, you don't know what the full consequences will be,

@Lockerlocker Write back and say that they are seeking 'betterment' rather than recompense. You have no problem replacing the one your DS and his mate damaged and the ones that are perfectly useable but now need to be replaced, as part of the column. But the one that was already damaged, has no door, was not affected by their actions and you don't believe it is in any way fair or moral to expect them/you to pay for the damage caused by someone else.

£156/4 = £39 per locker

x3 = £117

Divided by 2 = £58.50

WinterFoxes · 15/01/2023 12:48

I think he should pay for it, not you. You can 'pay' him minimum wage to do gardening and DIY jobs around the house if you like, for 8 hours, to cover the cost.

If you really want, you could argue that due to existing damage in other lockers in the block, you are willing to pay one third, the other boy's family pay a third and the school pays the last third. But they could say no.

The point is - it was wilful damage and he really needs to learn that is not OK and it has tiresome consequences for him. So do make him earn the money and pay you back in some form.

LindaEllen · 15/01/2023 12:44

SD1978 · 15/01/2023 12:21

Given there is already damage, and the column needs to be replaced due to the already damaged door on the bottom, I would be offering 1/3, other parent pay 1/3 and school pay 1/3. Surely they would have been planning to replace anyway? Your son absolutely needs to take responsibility for his vandalism, but school also should be partially responsible for the whole column

This.

I agree that your son and the other boy need to see consequences (and I would be taking it out of his money, or making him earn it if he didn't have it) but at the same time I would be annoyed that he was also having to pay for damage that they didn't cause. It's funny how the school are suddenly concerned with wanting to replace the lockers, when clearly the bottom one hasn't been functional since before your son damaged the other one.

1/3 each for each of the boys and the school. That's fair. ALL parties need to take responsibility, including the school who should have got the other locker repaired previously.

LimeCheesecake · 15/01/2023 12:43

Can I check which bit is the issue - you said that DS said the photo didn’t look right - is there a suggestion this isn’t the locker he kicked?

or is it that they’ve made a point that the location of the lockers means it has to be replaced due to needing to look nice, yet it was already damaged so either a) they were already planned to replace it or b) they were happy to leave it damaged in view when there wasn’t someone to pay for a new one?

if it’s the wrong locker - you need to ask for the correct photo. If it’s that it was already damaged and due to be replaced anyway, then agree expecting you and the other boys family to pay for the lot is a bit excessive.

I would question if other doors have been damaged by other children, why is the cost of replacement not being split between them all?

StubbleAndSqueak · 15/01/2023 12:40

I think him paying for all of it is a small price to pay for learning a big lesson
serves him right