Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you pay for this?

139 replies

Lockerlocker · 15/01/2023 12:02

Received a phone call from DS16s school last week to say him and another child had been involved in an incident where they had both kicked a locker, they have viewed the CCTV to confirm it was them. He explained DS would be excluded and we would be billed for the locker as they had damaged it. As there was two boys involved they bill would be halved. Fair enough. Makes sense we are billed for the locker.

Friday, I receive an email followed by the letter in the post yesterday to say that the single locker can’t be replaced so we have to pay for the column of lockers, adding that the lockers are on show in the corridor and it ruins the atheistic and the locker is now not functional. So I’m still sort of in agreement. The cost of the four lockers is £156.06 so our bill is £79.03.

Then I open the photo they have sent me (picture 1), the bottom locker is already clearly without a door (there is no suggestion that my DS was involved in this). I show my DS the photo, he states that it doesn’t look like the picture at all and that the girl is still using the locker. He said several of lockers have dents in and they have not been replaced. He has then sent me photos of the block showing the dinted lockers and the locker now.

I think I should only be charged for the broken locker and at a push 3 out of 4 lockers.

Not to drip feed, not sure it’s relevant, it’s an alternate provision. DS has an ASD & ADHD diagnosis. However I don’t believe he was having a melt down at the time of the incident.

Would you pay for this?
Would you pay for this?
Would you pay for this?
OP posts:
Tamarindtree · 15/01/2023 14:18

It shouldn’t matter to you what it costs because the right thing to do would be making your son pay by taking money from either his pocket money or savings to pay for it.

Mydogatemypurse · 15/01/2023 14:18

Just pay it

TidyDancer · 15/01/2023 14:18

@NumberTheory have you quoted the wrong person or maybe misread my post? I think you're agreeing with me (unless I've misunderstood your post!).

NumberTheory · 15/01/2023 14:15

TidyDancer · 15/01/2023 13:09

I was thinking a third would be fair the whole way through reading this. Your DS clearly needs to pay (more as a deterrent for future than anything else) but it needs to be fair and reasonable. Since he didn't cause all the damage but all the damage is being rectified, it's more appropriate for him to pay a reduced bill.

Why is it fair and reasonable for him to pay more than the damage he caused?

He’s being punished already. Getting the locker fixed is not supposed to be a fine on top of that.

Quveas · 15/01/2023 14:13

picklemewalnuts · 15/01/2023 12:11

I think OP's irritation is that the damaged locker isn't the only damage and therefore needing to be fixed. It's just a bit more damage to an already grotty unit.

They are taking the opportunity to upgrade the lockers at OP expense.

No. They are taking the opportunity to replace a row of lockers that have some wear and tear because a yob deliberately kicked one in. The previous condition doesn't excuse the behaviour.

SequinsandStilettos · 15/01/2023 14:08

It should be paid for.
Had this conversation on Friday with our caretaker.
Pupils have deliberately damaged the toilets again, obvs no CCTV there.
The cost is horrendous £££
They might not be so ready to sabotage if they know there are direct consequences.

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 15/01/2023 13:57

ShakespearesBlister · 15/01/2023 13:55

How do you know the one with no door isn't the one your son broke?

Because they sent the OP a picture of locker 'A31'.

Jedsnewstar · 15/01/2023 13:57

picklemewalnuts · 15/01/2023 12:11

I think OP's irritation is that the damaged locker isn't the only damage and therefore needing to be fixed. It's just a bit more damage to an already grotty unit.

They are taking the opportunity to upgrade the lockers at OP expense.

This. I agree with paying for damage but they are clearly taking the piss.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 15/01/2023 13:56

Tontostitis · 15/01/2023 13:14

Ffs pay it I can't believe people arguing about 'betterment ' and discounts are for real. Vandalism has consequences and £79 is cheap for what's he's done.

It's my job. I write check out reports for residential lettings.

My most (in)sincere apologies for applying my own perspective to OPs issue.

ShakespearesBlister · 15/01/2023 13:55

How do you know the one with no door isn't the one your son broke?

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 15/01/2023 13:53

One of the lockers - not in the OP's column - has been scribbled on, and on another the insert for putting a label on has fallen off. You'd think if the school were that bothered about the 'aesthetic' of their lockers, they'd have addressed those two very easy fixes that are spoiling it.

iklboo · 15/01/2023 13:48

op was going to pay, until she realised there was previous damage. Personally they could remove the locker door as they have done for the bottom one

Hardly very secure for the girl whose locker it is. Or doesn't she matter in this scenario?

Maybe the school didn’t know who broke the door, and didn’t have the money to replace it. Or it was accidentally broken?

They have CCTV footage of OP's son & another boy kicking it in

Bridgeth29 · 15/01/2023 13:47

I would be pissed off, but wouldn't want to ruin my relationship with the school and would want to show responsibility as a role model to my DS so would just pay. Then DS would need to do chores to pay me the money back in kind.

AhNowTed · 15/01/2023 13:44

Carry on making excuses for your son and this won't be the last time you'll pay out for his behaviour.

You're not doing him any favours here OP.

Sotellmethisandnomore · 15/01/2023 13:41

123woop · 15/01/2023 13:35

I am absolutely with you OP. Not a chance in hell I'd be paying and I don't know any other school that makes parents pay for damage done whether by accident or on purpose. Are they not insured?!

Absolutely mortified for you.

BitOutOfPractice · 15/01/2023 13:40

Please please don’t compound the embarrassment by quibbling op! If you can afford to pay it, just pay it.

gelatogina · 15/01/2023 13:37

123woop · 15/01/2023 13:35

I am absolutely with you OP. Not a chance in hell I'd be paying and I don't know any other school that makes parents pay for damage done whether by accident or on purpose. Are they not insured?!

No wonder so many boys grow up into men with no respect for other people or their possessions. And thinking that violence has no consequences.

we are really are doomed.

123woop · 15/01/2023 13:35

I am absolutely with you OP. Not a chance in hell I'd be paying and I don't know any other school that makes parents pay for damage done whether by accident or on purpose. Are they not insured?!

Sotellmethisandnomore · 15/01/2023 13:34

Pay up and stop embarrassing yourself, has your son's vandalism not embarrassed you enough?

Limesodas · 15/01/2023 13:33

If this went to court you’d be in the right since they’re looking for betterment, I’d be offering 1/3 in your shoes.

Tangled123 · 15/01/2023 13:32

Lockerlocker · 15/01/2023 13:02

Why didn’t they replace the lockers when the bottom one had no door?

It’s possible that the school had enough lockers for students without the original broken one but not now and/or two they consider one broken locker out of 4 not worth replacing, but it is worth replacing the column when 2 or more are broken.

I do think it’s slightly irrelevant though, the school is entitled to compensation for their damaged property (whether it’s a third or half). I think your time would be better spent dealing with your son who thinks it’s acceptable to kick in girls’ lockers. I would be more concerned over what that is about.

Tinkerbyebye · 15/01/2023 13:30

Have any of you actually read the post?

op was going to pay, until she realised there was previous damage. Personally they could remove the locker door as they have done for the bottom one

i would contact the school, and tell them there was obviously previous damage and you are not paying for that, and offer £50

honeylulu · 15/01/2023 13:29

@EVHead that wouldn't give the claimant the right to get a third party who'd caused later, separate damage to also cover the cost of the previous damage. That would be unequitable.

EVHead · 15/01/2023 13:25

Maybe the school didn’t know who broke the door, and didn’t have the money to replace it. Or it was accidentally broken?

honeylulu · 15/01/2023 13:21

Ffs pay it I can't believe people arguing about 'betterment ' and discounts are for real.

Because the law states that for the claimant to claim for the whole cost and end up in a better position would equate to unjust enrichment. FFS yourself.