Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you pay for this?

139 replies

Lockerlocker · 15/01/2023 12:02

Received a phone call from DS16s school last week to say him and another child had been involved in an incident where they had both kicked a locker, they have viewed the CCTV to confirm it was them. He explained DS would be excluded and we would be billed for the locker as they had damaged it. As there was two boys involved they bill would be halved. Fair enough. Makes sense we are billed for the locker.

Friday, I receive an email followed by the letter in the post yesterday to say that the single locker can’t be replaced so we have to pay for the column of lockers, adding that the lockers are on show in the corridor and it ruins the atheistic and the locker is now not functional. So I’m still sort of in agreement. The cost of the four lockers is £156.06 so our bill is £79.03.

Then I open the photo they have sent me (picture 1), the bottom locker is already clearly without a door (there is no suggestion that my DS was involved in this). I show my DS the photo, he states that it doesn’t look like the picture at all and that the girl is still using the locker. He said several of lockers have dents in and they have not been replaced. He has then sent me photos of the block showing the dinted lockers and the locker now.

I think I should only be charged for the broken locker and at a push 3 out of 4 lockers.

Not to drip feed, not sure it’s relevant, it’s an alternate provision. DS has an ASD & ADHD diagnosis. However I don’t believe he was having a melt down at the time of the incident.

Would you pay for this?
Would you pay for this?
Would you pay for this?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SequinsandStilettos · 15/01/2023 22:00

Surely the compromise is the school pay 25% for the already broken locker, and you and the other parent split the other 75%, so 37.5% each. As there was nothing wrong with those 3 and they didn't need to be replaced until the boys vandalised the girl's locker. This would amount to £58.52 each rather than £79. Having said that, I'm not sure it's worth quibbling over £20. I'd be mortified if my DS had done this.

Go with this if you want to look petty

NumberTheory · 15/01/2023 21:48

Tryingtokeepgoing · 15/01/2023 21:29

He’s not. They can only be replaced in a full bank. If they’d fixed the one at the bottom last week he’d still be paying for the full bank, because he’d have damaged it since. Schools have no cash; is it fair that yobbish behaviour means there’s less to spend on actual education?

And to the poster who said they wouldn’t pay and the school should be insured, can you imagine the excess, never mind the premium, for accidental (and this wasn’t an accident) damage to school premises?

They hadn’t fixed the one at the bottom last week, though. So he didn’t damage a four locker bank. If he had damaged a new, fully working locker bank then expecting him to replace it with a new fully working locker bank would be more reasonable (though probably not what a court would rule if it they were asked). He didn’t. So it really isn’t.

Agree with you re: the ridiculous insurance comments, though.

iklboo · 15/01/2023 21:36

I spoke to them today and she feels the same as me, she was totally expecting to pay for the lockers but after seeing the photos she feels we are being take advantage of.

Maybe it'll make your sons think twice about deliberately damaging property then. This isn't harsh treatment after an accident. They wilfully kicked in a girl's locker for Christ knows why what reason. Make the sons pay so they learn properly about consequences. They're 16 not 10.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 15/01/2023 21:29

NumberTheory · 15/01/2023 14:15

Why is it fair and reasonable for him to pay more than the damage he caused?

He’s being punished already. Getting the locker fixed is not supposed to be a fine on top of that.

He’s not. They can only be replaced in a full bank. If they’d fixed the one at the bottom last week he’d still be paying for the full bank, because he’d have damaged it since. Schools have no cash; is it fair that yobbish behaviour means there’s less to spend on actual education?

And to the poster who said they wouldn’t pay and the school should be insured, can you imagine the excess, never mind the premium, for accidental (and this wasn’t an accident) damage to school premises?

diddl · 15/01/2023 21:14

Lockerlocker · 15/01/2023 20:52

I spoke to them today and she feels the same as me, she was totally expecting to pay for the lockers but after seeing the photos she feels we are being take advantage of.

Well I guess that's the price you pay for having sons that deliberately damage property.

The whole unit needs replacing for the sake of the door that they decided to kick.

RewildingAmbridge · 15/01/2023 21:09

Surely the compromise is the school pay 25% for the already broken locker, and you and the other parent split the other 75%, so 37.5% each. As there was nothing wrong with those 3 and they didn't need to be replaced until the boys vandalised the girl's locker. This would amount to £58.52 each rather than £79. Having said that, I'm not sure it's worth quibbling over £20. I'd be mortified if my DS had done this.

Lockerlocker · 15/01/2023 20:52

MugginsOverEre · 15/01/2023 20:49

@Lockerlocker what does the other parent think? Have you spoken to them?

I spoke to them today and she feels the same as me, she was totally expecting to pay for the lockers but after seeing the photos she feels we are being take advantage of.

OP posts:
MugginsOverEre · 15/01/2023 20:49

@Lockerlocker what does the other parent think? Have you spoken to them?

Lockerlocker · 15/01/2023 20:46

You can also see from photo 2 that they have bent the door back into place and the locked has continued to be used by the girl. This however isn’t the point, I get that.

OP posts:
Lockerlocker · 15/01/2023 20:44

Pjmaskmummy · 15/01/2023 15:00

If the other lockers were in good condition and the only damaged one was the one your son damaged then I'd agree with the school however in this situation I think you should pay a percentage of the cost for the whole unit.

Yes I completely agreed until I saw the photo of the already damaged one.

OP posts:
Lockerlocker · 15/01/2023 20:33

diddl · 15/01/2023 17:42

I think that this would be me also.

Was it just a random locker that he kicked?

Hopefully no element of bully towards the girl whose locker it is/was.

I thought that lockers in schools were a pretty rare thing now.

Shame that they're not appreciated when they do have them!

No they have confirmed it was a random locker and they are sure there is no link to the girl in either a bullying form or her upsetting my DS. I asked this straight away when they called to tell me what had happened.

OP posts:
caringcarer · 15/01/2023 18:13

Your son needs to understand if he purposely damages the property of others the consequences are he ends up with a bill for damage. You should pay his half and take it out of his allowance or pocket money until he repays the debt. My adult son has ADHD and knows he is impetuous but also knows if he damages others property he pays to replace.

diddl · 15/01/2023 17:42

PinkSyCo · 15/01/2023 17:30

You might have a point OP, though I would be so embarrassed about my son’s behaviour that I would just quietly pay up.

I think that this would be me also.

Was it just a random locker that he kicked?

Hopefully no element of bully towards the girl whose locker it is/was.

I thought that lockers in schools were a pretty rare thing now.

Shame that they're not appreciated when they do have them!

PinkSyCo · 15/01/2023 17:30

You might have a point OP, though I would be so embarrassed about my son’s behaviour that I would just quietly pay up.

orbitalcrisis · 15/01/2023 17:24

The school are entitled to a like for like replacement and a sincere apology from your son, maybe a bit of litter picking and sweeping around the school. I would send them a link to the many second hand lockers for sale on Ebay and a cheque for half the cost. £12.50 seems to cover it. I would even offer to go and collect the locker, it's only fair.

SinnerBoy · 15/01/2023 16:47

Ledwood85

Worst analogy I've ever read on here 😂

Headlights, bonnets and alloys are completely separate items from the bumper. You would have been better off describing having to replace a cracked bumper that already had chips and scratches on it. The school is looking to replace part of something that comes as one item.

My point was that there was quite a lot of damage to other parts of the unit, which was pre-existing. The school say that the OP's boy is responsible for it no longer being aesthetically pleasing, even though he's not responsible for the other damaged areas.

And they've bent it back into shape, so that it can be used again.

WhatDoYouWantNow · 15/01/2023 16:34

Just pay it. Stop it out of your son's pocket money, or get him to do jobs in the garden, for no reward.

Technonan · 15/01/2023 16:32

Good grief. How to teach your son that vandalism is OK. He damaged the locker. You should pay for the replacement set. It's hardly a fortune.

maddiemookins16mum · 15/01/2023 16:31

No, you shouldn’t pay. Your Son should.

Ledwood85 · 15/01/2023 16:30

If you bumped someone's car and they needed a bumper replaced, for £300 and they told you to pay £2,000, as the aesthetics were ruined; the alloys were wrecked, the bonnet dented and the headlight broken - not by you, nobody would be telling you to comply.

Worst analogy I've ever read on here 😂

Headlights, bonnets and alloys are completely separate items from the bumper.
You would have been better off describing having to replace a cracked bumper that already had chips and scratches on it.

The school is looking to replace part of something that comes as one item.

They don't have the resources/time/tools to repair the existing, and why should they? They didn't damage it.
They don't have the time to try and hunt down the same model from decades ago and only replace the broken part.
Used ones are not available.
They can only buy new from a pre-approved supplier.
Claiming on insurance and raising premiums based on non-accidental misbehaviour and making everyone else pay? Give it a rest.

The only solution is to replace the entire thing with a new one.

Completely incidental that it means it'll also replace some wear and tear that was already in place.

Don't like it having to pay for pre-existing wear?
Don't go around kicking in lockers. Pretty simple situation to avoid.

Daffodilis · 15/01/2023 16:19

Just pay it. The school have better things to do than sorting this sort of stuff out. Maybe you should do something about your violent thug of a son before you end up paying court fines for him. You are being ridiculous

mumda · 15/01/2023 16:18

Do they not have caretakers any more?

That'd be back in shape in about 5 minutes.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 15/01/2023 16:01

Just pay up and expect your son to 'work off' the cost somehow. End of.

LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus · 15/01/2023 15:59

I would actually want the bill and to make my son pay, so he learns from it. Never mind the previous condition of the locker, he shouldn't have damaged it further. Do we want him to damage something newer looking and then only be billed for that? I see you are making pay, which is a good lesson.

Tamarindtree · 15/01/2023 15:59

How frightening for anyone working at the school and other pupils to witness your son and his friend behave so aggressively.

The quicker you pay up the sooner you can put it behind you and move on.

Quibbling over the condition of the lockers is really poor form.